Resources
Colchicine is an alkaloid that inhibits the polymerization of tubulin, destabilizing the mitotic and meiotic spindle apparatus and arresting cells at the metaphase-to-anaphase transition checkpoint. A diploid plant () with initial DNA content is treated with colchicine. In Population 1, root apical meristem cells undergoing mitosis are arrested at metaphase. In Population 2, microsporocytes undergoing meiosis are arrested at metaphase I. For each arrested cell population, specify: (1) the physical state and spatial arrangement of homologous chromosomes, (2) the total functional centromere/kinetochore count per cell, and (3) the total nuclear DNA mass (in ).
Answer and steps
Final answer
Population 1 (Mitosis): (1) individual replicated chromosomes align independently along the equatorial plate; (2) functional centromeres; (3) DNA. Population 2 (Meiosis I): (1) homologous pairs form bivalents/tetrads aligned along the equatorial plate; (2) functional centromeres (as paired bivalents); (3) DNA.
Steps
Determine the Nuclear DNA Content After S Phase
Before entering either mitosis (Population 1) or meiosis I (Population 2), the diploid cells () complete interphase, which includes the synthesis phase ( phase).
- During phase, DNA replicates completely, doubling the nuclear DNA mass from the initial level ( to ).
- Given initial DNA mass : Because colchicine halts cells at the metaphase-to-anaphase transition, neither cell population has divided or separated its genetic material. Therefore, both populations contain of nuclear DNA.
Analyze Population 1 (Mitotic Metaphase)
- Physical state and spatial arrangement:
- In mitotic prophase, homologous chromosomes do not synapse.
- At metaphase, all replicated chromosomes (each consisting of two sister chromatids joined at the centromere) align independently in a single plane along the equatorial (metaphase) plate.
- Functional centromere count:
- The number of functional centromeres determines the number of individual chromosomes.
- Each of the replicated chromosomes possesses one functional centromere holding two sister chromatids.
- Total functional centromeres = .
- Total nuclear DNA mass:
- .
Analyze Population 2 (Meiotic Metaphase I)
- Physical state and spatial arrangement:
- During prophase I of meiosis, homologous chromosomes pair up via synapsis and undergo crossing over, forming bivalents (tetrads).
- At metaphase I, the homologous pairs (bivalents) align along the equatorial plate, with homologous kinetochores oriented toward opposite spindle poles.
- Functional centromere count:
- Each bivalent is composed of replicated homologous chromosomes.
- Each chromosome maintains its own functional centromere (each bearing sister kinetochores that function as a single unit during meiosis I).
- Total functional centromeres = .
- Total nuclear DNA mass:
- .
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Counting chromatids instead of centromeres: While each cell has chromatids after replication, each replicated chromosome counts as a single chromosome with functional centromere until the sister chromatids separate at anaphase (or anaphase II in meiosis).
- Assuming DNA reduction happens before metaphase I: The reduction in chromosome number and DNA mass does not occur until cytokinesis I finishes; at metaphase I, the cell still retains the full () complement of DNA.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses sister chromatid count with centromere count, incorrectly counting each sister chromatid as possessing an independent centromere before anaphase.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homologous chromosomes are unpaired and scattered randomly due to spindle absence.
- Step 2
Each of the 24 chromosomes has 2 chromatids Centromere count Post-replication DNA mass
CorrectFunctional centromere count ; Total nuclear DNA mass .
You calculated the DNA mass correctly, but each replicated chromosome possesses exactly functional centromere joining its sister chromatids before anaphase. Therefore, the centromere count is , not .
- Step 3
Homologous chromosomes are paired as 12 bivalents and scattered in the cytoplasm.
- Step 4
Each bivalent has 4 chromatids Centromere count Pre-meiotic replication DNA mass
CorrectFunctional centromere count ; Total nuclear DNA mass .
You correctly calculated the DNA mass and chromatid count, but counted chromatids as centromeres. Each bivalent consists of replicated homologous chromosomes, giving functional centromeres per bivalent, or functional centromeres in total.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated that DNA replication doubles the nuclear DNA mass from to in both cell types.
You correctly distinguished that chromosomes remain unpaired in mitosis but synapse into bivalents in meiosis I.
You accurately identified that each replicated chromosome has sister chromatids and each bivalent contains chromatids.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated each individual sister chromatid as possessing its own separate functional centromere prior to anaphase. In metaphase (and metaphase I), sister chromatids remain physically united at a single shared centromere per chromosome; centromeres only divide and double at anaphase (or anaphase II).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Rule for Counting Chromosomes and Centromeres
The number of chromosomes in a cell equals the number of functional centromeres, not the number of chromatids.
Count one centromere per replicated X-shaped chromosome until anaphase physically separates the sister centromeres.
- Centromeres in Meiotic Bivalents
A bivalent (tetrad) consists of homologous chromosomes ( chromatids) and therefore carries functional centromeres.
Multiply the number of bivalents by (not by ) to find the total centromere count in metaphase I.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIn Population 1 (mitotic metaphase), there are replicated chromosomes. Because sister chromatids have not yet separated, each chromosome has functional centromere: .
In Population 2 (meiotic metaphase I), there are bivalents. Each bivalent contains homologous chromosomes, each with its own centromere: .
Population 1: (1) 24 individual replicated chromosomes aligned along equatorial plate; (2) 24 functional centromeres; (3) 12.4 pg DNA. Population 2: (1) 12 homologous pairs as bivalents aligned along equatorial plate; (2) 24 functional centromeres; (3) 12.4 pg DNA.
02 The student treats a meiotic bivalent as having only a single functional centromere rather than two separate homologous centromeres.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Chromosomes are unpaired, duplicated, and scattered without forming a metaphase plate.
- Step 2
24 duplicated chromosomes each have 1 centromere ⟹ Centromere count = 24 ⟹ DNA mass = 2 × 6.2 pg = 12.4 pg
- Step 3
Homologues are paired as bivalents and remain unaligned due to spindle inhibition.
- Step 4
There are 12 bivalents present ⟹ Centromere count = 12 bivalents × 1 = 12
CorrectCentromere count .
Each bivalent consists of two synapsed homologous chromosomes, and each homologue retains its own functional centromere. Multiplying bivalents by gives functional centromeres.
- Step 5
DNA mass = 2 × 6.2 pg = 12.4 pg
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the post-replication nuclear DNA mass as for both cell populations.
You recognized that homologues remain unpaired in mitosis but synapse into bivalents during meiosis I.
You accurately counted functional centromeres in the mitotic population.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated each meiotic bivalent as possessing a single functional centromere rather than two distinct centromeres, one for each replicated homologous chromosome.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Bivalent structure
A bivalent (tetrad) is composed of synapsed homologous chromosomes, containing chromatids and separate centromeres.
Always multiply the number of bivalents by to find the total functional centromere count in meiosis I.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that a bivalent consists of homologous replicated chromosomes held together by chiasmata.
Each individual replicated chromosome possesses centromere holding its sister chromatids.
Multiply the number of bivalents () by the number of centromeres per bivalent (): functional centromeres.
Population 1: (1) individual duplicated chromosomes; (2) functional centromeres; (3) DNA. Population 2: (1) bivalents; (2) functional centromeres; (3) DNA.
03 The student forgets that DNA replicates during interphase before mitosis and meiosis, reporting the unreplicated G1 DNA mass.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Population 1: Chromosomes are unpaired and dispersed throughout the cytoplasm without an equatorial plate. ⟹ Centromere count =
- Step 2
Population 1: DNA mass =
CorrectDNA mass =
You crossed out the correct doubled value () and wrote the mass (). Before entering mitosis, cells undergo S phase in interphase, which duplicates the nuclear DNA from () to (). Because anaphase is blocked by colchicine, no division has occurred, leaving the DNA mass at .
- Step 3
Population 2: Homologous chromosomes form bivalents, scattered due to spindle breakdown. ⟹ Centromere count =
- Step 4
Population 2: DNA mass =
CorrectDNA mass =
You reported instead of . Meiosis is also preceded by premeiotic S phase, which doubles the nuclear DNA mass to (). Reduction in DNA content does not occur until after meiosis I and meiosis II complete cytokinesis.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly distinguished the pairing state between mitosis (unpaired individual chromosomes) and meiosis I ( synapsed bivalents).
You accurately determined that each cell possesses functional centromeres at metaphase, counting one centromere per replicated chromosome.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou initially calculated the correct DNA mass of for Population 1, but second-guessed yourself and crossed it out in favor of the unreplicated value.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked that both mitotic cells and meiotic cells must complete interphase S phase before entering division, meaning chromosomes at metaphase and metaphase I are fully replicated and retain a DNA content until cytokinesis occurs.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Interphase S Phase Rule
Every cell entering mitosis or meiosis I has already completed S phase; DNA mass doubles from to ().
Multiply the DNA mass by when evaluating any stage from through metaphase.
- Centromere vs. Chromatid Counting
Chromosome count equals functional centromere count; replication doubles chromatids and DNA mass, but does not change centromere count until anaphase.
Count one functional centromere per replicated chromosome before anaphase centromere cleavage.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the cell cycle stage: Both Population 1 and Population 2 are arrested at metaphase/metaphase I, well after S phase completion.
Calculate post-replication DNA content: .
Verify cytokinesis status: Colchicine prevents anaphase separation, so neither population has divided its cytoplasm or partitioned DNA.
Population 1 (Mitosis): (1) individual replicated chromosomes; (2) functional centromeres; (3) DNA. Population 2 (Meiosis I): (1) homologous pairs (bivalents); (2) functional centromeres; (3) DNA.
Lock it in
How do you determine the number of chromosomes present in a cell at any stage of division?
Count the number of functional centromeres. One functional centromere equals one chromosome, regardless of whether it has one or two sister chromatids.
Similar question
A diploid mammalian cell has chromosomes and a nuclear DNA content of . During mitotic metaphase, what are the total number of chromatids, functional centromeres, and nuclear DNA mass?
Answer
chromatids, functional centromeres, and of DNA. After S phase, DNA replicates (), producing sister chromatids. Because sister chromatids remain joined at one centromere per chromosome until anaphase, the functional centromere count remains .
In an organism with , microsporocytes are observed at metaphase I and metaphase II of meiosis. For each of these two stages, specify the number of bivalents, total chromosomes, and total functional centromeres in a single cell.
Answer
Metaphase I: bivalents, chromosomes, functional centromeres. Metaphase II: bivalents, chromosomes, functional centromeres. Homologous pairs separate during anaphase I, so each daughter cell entering metaphase II has halved its chromosome and centromere count to .
A chemical blocks the cleavage of cohesin at the centromere, preventing sister chromatid separation, while cytokinesis still proceeds normally. If a diploid cell (, in ) passes through this defective mitosis into two daughter cells, explain why each daughter cell cannot simply be said to have centromeres immediately before division.
Answer
Immediately before division (metaphase), the cell possesses replicated chromosomes with centromeres and chromatids ( DNA). If sister chromatids fail to separate because centromeric cohesin is not cleaved, the centromeres never divide from to ; thus, any physical partitioning will distribute unreplicated centromere units unequally or leave nondisjoined -centromere sets intact.