Resources

In a cell biology laboratory, students determine the duration of each cell cycle phase in onion (Allium cepa) root-tip meristem cells using pulsed thymidine labeling combined with light microscopy. The total cell cycle duration was independently determined to be T=18.0 hoursT = 18.0\text{ hours}. In a microscopic grid count of 800800 total active meristematic cells, the recorded phase distributions are: Interphase =704= 704 cells (of which autoradiographic pulse-labeling identifies 288288 cells actively incorporating [3H][^3\text{H}]-thymidine during DNA replication, with 272272 cells pre-replication and 144144 cells post-replication), Prophase =48= 48 cells, Metaphase =24= 24 cells, Anaphase =16= 16 cells, and Telophase/Cytokinesis =8= 8 cells. (a) Calculate the duration (in hours) of G1G_1, S\text{S}, G2G_2, and active MM phase; (b) Calculate the duration of anaphase alone in minutes.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) tG1=6.12 hourst_{G_1} = 6.12\text{ hours}, tS=6.48 hourst_{\text{S}} = 6.48\text{ hours}, tG2=3.24 hourst_{G_2} = 3.24\text{ hours}, tM=2.16 hourst_{\text{M}} = 2.16\text{ hours}; (b) tAnaphase=21.6 minutest_{\text{Anaphase}} = 21.6\text{ minutes}.

Steps

01

Assigning Cell Counts to Interphase and M Phase Sub-stages

Principle of Cell Cycle Phase Duration Calculation

In an actively growing and asynchronous cell population (such as onion root-tip meristem tissue), cells are distributed randomly throughout the phases of the cell cycle. The proportion of cells observed in any given phase is directly proportional to the fraction of the total cycle time (TT) that a cell spends in that phase: tphase=NphaseNtotal⋅Tt_{\text{phase}} = \frac{N_{\text{phase}}}{N_{\text{total}}} \cdot T where:

  • NphaseN_{\text{phase}} is the number of cells counted in the specific phase,
  • Ntotal=800N_{\text{total}} = 800 is the total number of cells observed,
  • T=18.0 hoursT = 18.0\text{ hours} is the total cell cycle duration.

  1. Interphase sub-phases:

    • G1G_1 (Gap 1) phase: Occurs prior to DNA synthesis (pre-replication):
      NG1=272 cellsN_{G_1} = 272\text{ cells}
    • S\text{S} (Synthesis) phase: Characterized by active DNA replication incorporating [3H]-thymidine[^3\text{H}]\text{-thymidine}:
      NS=288 cellsN_{\text{S}} = 288\text{ cells}
    • G2G_2 (Gap 2) phase: Occurs after DNA synthesis but before mitosis (post-replication):
      NG2=144 cellsN_{G_2} = 144\text{ cells}
  2. Mitosis (M\text{M} phase):

    • Combines Prophase (4848), Metaphase (2424), Anaphase (1616), and Telophase/Cytokinesis (88): NM=48+24+16+8=96 cellsN_{\text{M}} = 48 + 24 + 16 + 8 = 96\text{ cells}

02

Calculate the Duration of G1G_1, S\text{S}, G2G_2, and M\text{M} Phases (in Hours)

Applying the proportional formula to each phase:

  • G1G_1 Phase: tG1=272800⋅18.0 h=0.34⋅18.0 h=6.12 hourst_{G_1} = \frac{272}{800} \cdot 18.0\text{ h} = 0.34 \cdot 18.0\text{ h} = 6.12\text{ hours}
  • S\text{S} Phase: tS=288800⋅18.0 h=0.36⋅18.0 h=6.48 hourst_{\text{S}} = \frac{288}{800} \cdot 18.0\text{ h} = 0.36 \cdot 18.0\text{ h} = 6.48\text{ hours}
  • G2G_2 Phase: tG2=144800⋅18.0 h=0.18⋅18.0 h=3.24 hourst_{G_2} = \frac{144}{800} \cdot 18.0\text{ h} = 0.18 \cdot 18.0\text{ h} = 3.24\text{ hours}
  • M\text{M} Phase: tM=96800⋅18.0 h=0.12⋅18.0 h=2.16 hourst_{\text{M}} = \frac{96}{800} \cdot 18.0\text{ h} = 0.12 \cdot 18.0\text{ h} = 2.16\text{ hours}

(Check: 6.12+6.48+3.24+2.16=18.00 hours6.12 + 6.48 + 3.24 + 2.16 = 18.00\text{ hours})


03

Calculate the Duration of Anaphase (in Minutes)

Anaphase represents NAnaphase=16N_{\text{Anaphase}} = 16 cells out of 800800:

tAnaphase=16800⋅18.0 hours=0.02⋅18.0 hours=0.36 hourst_{\text{Anaphase}} = \frac{16}{800} \cdot 18.0\text{ hours} = 0.02 \cdot 18.0\text{ hours} = 0.36\text{ hours}

Convert hours to minutes (1 hour=60 minutes1\text{ hour} = 60\text{ minutes}):

tAnaphase=0.36⋅60 min=21.6 minutest_{\text{Anaphase}} = 0.36 \cdot 60\text{ min} = 21.6\text{ minutes}

Common Pitfall: Forgetting to convert units to minutes when requested for an individual sub-stage, or treating total interphase as a single phase instead of resolving the pre-replication, synthesis, and post-replication fractions identified by thymidine labeling.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates phase durations relative to the 704 interphase cells instead of the 800 total dividing cells, overestimating the durations of G1, S, and G2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    G1=272704×18.0 hours=6.95 hours  ⟹  S=288704×18.0 hours=7.36 hours  ⟹  G2=144704×18.0 hours=3.68 hoursG_1 = \frac{272}{704} \times 18.0\text{ hours} = 6.95\text{ hours} \implies \text{S} = \frac{288}{704} \times 18.0\text{ hours} = 7.36\text{ hours} \implies G_2 = \frac{144}{704} \times 18.0\text{ hours} = 3.68\text{ hours}

    Correct

    tG1=272800×18.0 h=6.12 h  ⟹  tS=288800×18.0 h=6.48 h  ⟹  tG2=144800×18.0 h=3.24 ht_{G_1} = \frac{272}{800} \times 18.0\text{ h} = 6.12\text{ h} \implies t_{\text{S}} = \frac{288}{800} \times 18.0\text{ h} = 6.48\text{ h} \implies t_{G_2} = \frac{144}{800} \times 18.0\text{ h} = 3.24\text{ h}

    Because the given cycle time of 18.0 hours18.0\text{ hours} represents the complete cell cycle, the fraction for each phase must be taken relative to the total population of 800800 cells, not just the 704704 interphase cells.

  2. Step 2

    M phase cells=48+24+16+8=96  ⟹  M=96800×18.0 hours=2.16 hours\text{M phase cells} = 48 + 24 + 16 + 8 = 96 \implies \text{M} = \frac{96}{800} \times 18.0\text{ hours} = 2.16\text{ hours}

  3. Step 3

    Anaphase=16800×18.0 hours=0.36 hours  ⟹  0.36×60=21.6 minutes\text{Anaphase} = \frac{16}{800} \times 18.0\text{ hours} = 0.36\text{ hours} \implies 0.36 \times 60 = 21.6\text{ minutes}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the cell counts corresponding to each sub-phase of interphase and mitosis.

You used the total cell count of 800800 cells to calculate the duration of M\text{M} phase and anaphase.

You correctly converted the duration of anaphase from hours to minutes.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect denominator in cell cycle proportion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You matched the sub-phases of interphase (G1G_1, S\text{S}, G2G_2) to the interphase subtotal of 704704 cells rather than the total cell cycle count (800800), while still multiplying by the full cycle duration (18.0 hours18.0\text{ hours}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Reference Population Check
  • tphase=NphaseNtotal×Ttotalt_{\text{phase}} = \frac{N_{\text{phase}}}{N_{\text{total}}} \times T_{\text{total}}

  • Always ensure the denominator matches the total population that corresponds to the total time period TT.

Total Duration Sum Check
  • ∑tphases=Ttotal\sum t_{\text{phases}} = T_{\text{total}}

  • Add your calculated phase durations (6.95+7.36+3.68+2.16=20.15 h≠18.0 h6.95 + 7.36 + 3.68 + 2.16 = 20.15\text{ h} \neq 18.0\text{ h}) to verify that they sum to the total cycle time.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the duration of G1G_1: tG1=272800×18.0 h=0.34×18.0 h=6.12 hourst_{G_1} = \frac{272}{800} \times 18.0\text{ h} = 0.34 \times 18.0\text{ h} = 6.12\text{ hours}.

  2. Compute the duration of S\text{S}: tS=288800×18.0 h=0.36×18.0 h=6.48 hourst_{\text{S}} = \frac{288}{800} \times 18.0\text{ h} = 0.36 \times 18.0\text{ h} = 6.48\text{ hours}.

  3. Compute the duration of G2G_2: tG2=144800×18.0 h=0.18×18.0 h=3.24 hourst_{G_2} = \frac{144}{800} \times 18.0\text{ h} = 0.18 \times 18.0\text{ h} = 3.24\text{ hours}.

Final answer

(a) tG1=6.12 hourst_{G_1} = 6.12\text{ hours}, tS=6.48 hourst_{\text{S}} = 6.48\text{ hours}, tG2=3.24 hourst_{G_2} = 3.24\text{ hours}, tM=2.16 hourst_{\text{M}} = 2.16\text{ hours}; (b) tAnaphase=21.6 minutest_{\text{Anaphase}} = 21.6\text{ minutes}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Re-evaluate whether each given time factor represents the entire cycle (TtotalT_{\text{total}}) or only a specific stage before setting up fractions.

  • Perform a quick sum-check on all calculated phase durations to ensure they equal the total cell cycle time.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to convert the duration of anaphase from hours to minutes in part (b), leaving the final answer in hours.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    G1=(272800)×18.0=6.12 hoursG_1 = \left(\frac{272}{800}\right) \times 18.0 = 6.12\text{ hours}, S=(288800)×18.0=6.48 hours\text{S} = \left(\frac{288}{800}\right) \times 18.0 = 6.48\text{ hours}, G2=(144800)×18.0=3.24 hoursG_2 = \left(\frac{144}{800}\right) \times 18.0 = 3.24\text{ hours}

  2. Step 2

    M cells=48+24+16+8=96  ⟹  M=(96800)×18.0=2.16 hoursM\text{ cells} = 48 + 24 + 16 + 8 = 96 \implies M = \left(\frac{96}{800}\right) \times 18.0 = 2.16\text{ hours}

  3. Step 3

    Anaphase duration=(16800)×18.0 hours=0.36 hours\text{Anaphase duration} = \left(\frac{16}{800}\right) \times 18.0\text{ hours} = 0.36\text{ hours}

  4. Step 4

    Anaphase=0.36 minutes\text{Anaphase} = 0.36\text{ minutes}

    Correct

    tAnaphase=0.36 hours×60 min/hour=21.6 minutest_{\text{Anaphase}} = 0.36\text{ hours} \times 60\text{ min/hour} = 21.6\text{ minutes}

    You replaced the unit 'hours' with 'minutes' without multiplying by the conversion factor 60 minutes/hour60\text{ minutes/hour}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the cell counts corresponding to G1G_1, S\text{S}, G2G_2, and M\text{M} phases.

You accurately set up the proportionality formula using Nphase/Ntotal×TN_{\text{phase}} / N_{\text{total}} \times T for all phases.

You correctly calculated the duration of anaphase in hours as 0.36 hours0.36\text{ hours}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit conversion omitted

You recognized that the question asked for minutes, but you carried over the numerical value 0.360.36 from hours directly to minutes.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated changing the unit symbol as sufficient without applying dimensional analysis (1 hour=60 minutes1\text{ hour} = 60\text{ minutes}) to convert the numerical value.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensional Analysis
  • t (minutes)=t (hours)×60minuteshourt\text{ (minutes)} = t\text{ (hours)} \times 60\frac{\text{minutes}}{\text{hour}}

  • Always multiply the value in hours by 6060 and write out the units canceling explicitly before stating a result in minutes.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the conversion to minutes: tAnaphase=0.36 hours×60minuteshourt_{\text{Anaphase}} = 0.36\text{ hours} \times 60\frac{\text{minutes}}{\text{hour}}.

  2. Multiply the numerical values: 0.36×60=21.60.36 \times 60 = 21.6.

Final answer

(a) tG1=6.12 hourst_{G_1} = 6.12\text{ hours}, tS=6.48 hourst_{\text{S}} = 6.48\text{ hours}, tG2=3.24 hourst_{G_2} = 3.24\text{ hours}, tM=2.16 hourst_{\text{M}} = 2.16\text{ hours}; (b) tAnaphase=21.6 minutest_{\text{Anaphase}} = 21.6\text{ minutes}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out dimensional conversion factors with explicit units (e.g., ×60 min1 h\times \frac{60\text{ min}}{1\text{ h}}) so units cancel visibly.

  • Perform a sanity check on unit magnitude: since a minute is a much smaller unit than an hour, the numerical value representing the same time interval must become larger, never remain identical.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misidentifies the sub-phases of interphase by confusing pre-replication as G2 and post-replication as G1, reversing the durations of G1 and G2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    G1 is post-replication=3.24 hours  ⟹  (144/800)×18.0=3.24 hoursG_1\text{ is post-replication} = 3.24\text{ hours} \implies (144 / 800) \times 18.0 = 3.24\text{ hours}

    Correct

    tG1=272800×18.0 h=6.12 hourst_{G_1} = \frac{272}{800} \times 18.0\text{ h} = 6.12\text{ hours}

    You designated G1G_1 as post-replication and used 144144 cells. In the cell cycle, G1G_1 (Gap 1) occurs before DNA replication (pre-replication), so it corresponds to the 272272 pre-replication cells.

  2. Step 2

    S is replicating=(288/800)×18.0=6.48 hours\text{S is replicating} = (288 / 800) \times 18.0 = 6.48\text{ hours}

  3. Step 3

    G2 is pre-replication=(272/800)×18.0=6.12 hoursG_2\text{ is pre-replication} = (272 / 800) \times 18.0 = 6.12\text{ hours}

    Correct

    tG2=144800×18.0 h=3.24 hourst_{G_2} = \frac{144}{800} \times 18.0\text{ h} = 3.24\text{ hours}

    You designated G2G_2 as pre-replication and used 272272 cells. G2G_2 (Gap 2) occurs after DNA synthesis is complete (post-replication) and before mitosis, so it corresponds to the 144144 post-replication cells.

  4. Step 4

    M=((48+24+16+8)/800)×18.0=2.16 hours\text{M} = ((48 + 24 + 16 + 8) / 800) \times 18.0 = 2.16\text{ hours}

  5. Step 5

    Anaphase=(16/800)×18.0 hours=0.36 hours  ⟹  0.36×60=21.6 minutes\text{Anaphase} = (16 / 800) \times 18.0\text{ hours} = 0.36\text{ hours} \implies 0.36 \times 60 = 21.6\text{ minutes}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the proportionality relation tphase=NphaseNtotal×Tt_{\text{phase}} = \frac{N_{\text{phase}}}{N_{\text{total}}} \times T across all sub-problems.

You accurately identified the S\text{S} phase as the DNA replication interval.

You summed all four mitotic sub-phases to determine the total duration of M\text{M} phase.

You successfully converted the anaphase duration from hours into minutes.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed G1 and G2 sub-phases

You swapped the order of G1G_1 and G2G_2 relative to DNA replication, labeling pre-replication as G2G_2 and post-replication as G1G_1.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the sequential order of interphase sub-phases (G1→S→G2G_1 \to \text{S} \to G_2). G1G_1 precedes the synthesis phase (pre-replication, 2C2C DNA content), whereas G2G_2 follows synthesis (post-replication, 4C4C DNA content).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Interphase Chronology
  • Interphase proceeds in the strict order G1→S→G2G_1 \to \text{S} \to G_2.

  • Associate 'G1G_1' with 'pre-replication/first gap before synthesis' and 'G2G_2' with 'post-replication/second gap after synthesis'.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify G1G_1 as the pre-replication pool: NG1=272 cellsN_{G_1} = 272\text{ cells}.

  2. Calculate tG1=272800×18.0 h=6.12 hourst_{G_1} = \frac{272}{800} \times 18.0\text{ h} = 6.12\text{ hours}.

  3. Identify G2G_2 as the post-replication pool: NG2=144 cellsN_{G_2} = 144\text{ cells}.

  4. Calculate tG2=144800×18.0 h=3.24 hourst_{G_2} = \frac{144}{800} \times 18.0\text{ h} = 3.24\text{ hours}.

Final answer

(a) tG1=6.12 hourst_{G_1} = 6.12\text{ hours}, tS=6.48 hourst_{\text{S}} = 6.48\text{ hours}, tG2=3.24 hourst_{G_2} = 3.24\text{ hours}, tM=2.16 hourst_{\text{M}} = 2.16\text{ hours}; (b) tAnaphase=21.6 minutest_{\text{Anaphase}} = 21.6\text{ minutes}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the cell cycle sequence as G1→S→G2→MG_1 \to \text{S} \to G_2 \to \text{M}.

  • Verify that DNA content is single (2C2C) in G1G_1 and duplicated (4C4C) in G2G_2.

  • Always double-check which gap phase comes before or after the labeled synthesis stage.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a root tip sample with a total cycle duration of T=20.0 hoursT = 20.0\text{ hours}, 1,0001{,}000 active cells were observed: 550550 in G1G_1, 250250 in S\text{S}, 100100 in G2G_2, and 100100 in mitosis. Calculate the duration (in hours) of the S\text{S} phase.

Answer

tS=5.0 hourst_{\text{S}} = 5.0\text{ hours}. Key step: tS=2501,000×20.0 h=0.25×20.0 h=5.0 hourst_{\text{S}} = \frac{250}{1{,}000} \times 20.0\text{ h} = 0.25 \times 20.0\text{ h} = 5.0\text{ hours}.

02

A cell culture has a generation time of 16.0 hours16.0\text{ hours}. Out of 500500 cells counted, 4040 are in metaphase and 1515 are in anaphase. How many minutes does a cell spend in anaphase?

Answer

tAnaphase=28.8 minutest_{\text{Anaphase}} = 28.8\text{ minutes}. Key steps: t=15500×16.0 h=0.03×16.0 h=0.48 hourst = \frac{15}{500} \times 16.0\text{ h} = 0.03 \times 16.0\text{ h} = 0.48\text{ hours}; then 0.48×60=28.8 minutes0.48 \times 60 = 28.8\text{ minutes}.

03

In a proliferating tissue with T=24.0 hoursT = 24.0\text{ hours}, 900900 total cells are counted. Interphase accounts for 810810 cells (G1=405G_1 = 405, S=270\text{S} = 270, G2=135G_2 = 135) and M\text{M} phase accounts for 9090 cells. A student mistakenly calculates tG1=405810×24.0 h=12.0 hourst_{G_1} = \frac{405}{810} \times 24.0\text{ h} = 12.0\text{ hours}. Identify the error and calculate the correct duration of G1G_1.

Answer

Correct duration: tG1=10.8 hourst_{G_1} = 10.8\text{ hours}. Key error: The student used the interphase count (810810) instead of total cells (900900). Correct step: tG1=405900×24.0 h=0.45×24.0 h=10.8 hourst_{G_1} = \frac{405}{900} \times 24.0\text{ h} = 0.45 \times 24.0\text{ h} = 10.8\text{ hours}.

Loading workspace…