Resources

A commercial greenhouse measures starch investment in two potato (Solanum tuberosum) cultivars. Cultivar X allocates starch to subterranean stem tubers (asexual perennating organs) at a concentration of 180 mg/g180\text{ mg/g} fresh weight, with each tuber averaging 120 g120\text{ g}. Cultivar Y reproduces sexually, allocating carbohydrate to true botanical seeds with an average mass of 1.5 mg1.5\text{ mg} per seed containing 450 μg450\,\mu\text{g} of endosperm starch. (a) Convert the starch content per asexual tuber to standard grams (g\text{g}). (b) Convert the starch content per sexual seed to milligrams (mg\text{mg}). (c) Calculate how many sexual seeds can be provisioned with the equivalent starch energy contained in a single tuber of Cultivar X.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Starch per tuber: 21.6 g21.6\text{ g}; (b) Starch per seed: 0.450 mg0.450\text{ mg}; (c) Number of seeds =21.6 g0.000450 g=48000 seeds= \frac{21.6\text{ g}}{0.000450\text{ g}} = 48000\text{ seeds}.

Steps

Part (a): Starch Content per Asexual Tuber

  1. Calculate total starch mass in milligrams (mg\text{mg}): The tuber has a total mass of 120 g120\text{ g} and contains 180 mg180\text{ mg} of starch per gram of fresh weight: Starch mass=120 g×180 mg/g=21600 mg\text{Starch mass} = 120\text{ g} \times 180\text{ mg/g} = 21600\text{ mg}
  2. Convert milligrams to grams (g\text{g}): Since 1 g=1000 mg1\text{ g} = 1000\text{ mg}: Starch mass in grams=21600 mg1000 mg/g=21.6 g\text{Starch mass in grams} = \frac{21600\text{ mg}}{1000\text{ mg/g}} = 21.6\text{ g}

Part (b): Starch Content per Botanical Seed

  1. Convert micrograms (μg\mu\text{g}) to milligrams (mg\text{mg}): Each seed contains 450 μg450\ \mu\text{g} of endosperm starch. Since 1 mg=1000 μg1\text{ mg} = 1000\ \mu\text{g}: Starch mass in milligrams=450 μg1000 μg/mg=0.450 mg\text{Starch mass in milligrams} = \frac{450\ \mu\text{g}}{1000\ \mu\text{g/mg}} = 0.450\text{ mg}

(Note: The total seed mass of 1.5 mg1.5\text{ mg} represents the entire seed structure; only the 450 μg450\ \mu\text{g} of starch is used for this comparison.)


Part (c): Equivalent Seed Provisioning Comparison

  1. Express both values in identical units:

    • Starch per tuber: 21.6 g=21600 mg21.6\text{ g} = 21600\text{ mg} (or 21.6 g21.6\text{ g})
    • Starch per seed: 0.450 mg=0.000450 g0.450\text{ mg} = 0.000450\text{ g}
  2. Determine the number of seeds provisioned: Divide the total starch in one tuber by the starch required per individual seed: Number of seeds=21.6 g0.000450 g=21600 mg0.450 mg=48000 seeds\text{Number of seeds} = \frac{21.6\text{ g}}{0.000450\text{ g}} = \frac{21600\text{ mg}}{0.450\text{ mg}} = 48000\text{ seeds}

Biological Takeaway: Asexual reproduction (vegetative propagation via stem tubers) represents a strategy of investing a large amount of energy into a few resilient propagules that can quickly establish shoots. In contrast, sexual reproduction (seeds) allocates minimal energy per unit to maximize the total number of offspring and facilitate wide dispersal and genetic diversity.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the metric prefix micro with milli and divides by 100 instead of 1000, resulting in 4.5 mg of starch per seed and 4800 seeds.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    120×180=21600 mg  ⟹  21600 mg/1000=21.6 g120 \times 180 = 21600\text{ mg} \implies 21600\text{ mg} / 1000 = 21.6\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    450 μg/100=4.5 mg450\ \mu\text{g} / 100 = 4.5\text{ mg}

    Correct

    450 μg1000 μg/mg=0.450 mg\frac{450\ \mu\text{g}}{1000\ \mu\text{g/mg}} = 0.450\text{ mg}

    You divided by 100100 instead of 10001000. Since the metric prefix micro- (μ\mu) denotes 10−610^{-6} and milli- (m\text{m}) denotes 10−310^{-3}, there are 1000 μg1000\ \mu\text{g} in 1 mg1\text{ mg}.

  3. Step 3

    21600 mg/4.5 mg=4800 seeds21600\text{ mg} / 4.5\text{ mg} = 4800\text{ seeds}

    Correct

    21600 mg0.450 mg=48000 seeds\frac{21600\text{ mg}}{0.450\text{ mg}} = 48000\text{ seeds}

    You correctly set up the ratio of total tuber starch to seed starch, but your result was off by a factor of 10 because of the previous unit conversion error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total starch content in milligrams for the potato tuber.

You accurately converted milligrams to grams using the factor 1 g=1000 mg1\text{ g} = 1000\text{ mg}.

You used the correct logical strategy of dividing total resource allocation by individual offspring investment.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Metric prefix conversion factor error

You divided by 100 rather than 1000 when converting micrograms to milligrams.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing metric step sizes (treating micro- to milli- as a factor of 10210^2 rather than 10310^3). Standard SI prefixes (milli-, micro-, nano-) change by orders of 10310^3, not 10210^2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
SI Prefix Step Sizes
  • 1 g=103 mg=106 μg1\text{ g} = 10^3\text{ mg} = 10^6\ \mu\text{g}; therefore, 1 mg=1000 μg1\text{ mg} = 1000\ \mu\text{g}.

  • Whenever converting between consecutive standard prefixes (milli, micro, nano), always use a factor of 1000, reserving 100 for centi-.

Biological Magnitude Check
  • True botanical seeds have a total mass of 1.5 mg1.5\text{ mg}.

  • Check that your calculated nutrient component (4.5 mg4.5\text{ mg}) does not exceed the total physical mass of the seed (1.5 mg1.5\text{ mg}).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the standard conversion 1 mg=1000 μg1\text{ mg} = 1000\ \mu\text{g}: 450 μg1000=0.450 mg\frac{450\ \mu\text{g}}{1000} = 0.450\text{ mg}.

  2. Compute the ratio using equivalent units: 21600 mg0.450 mg=48000 seeds\frac{21600\text{ mg}}{0.450\text{ mg}} = 48000\text{ seeds}.

Final answer

(a) 21.6 g21.6\text{ g}; (b) 0.450 mg0.450\text{ mg}; (c) 48000 seeds48000\text{ seeds}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the standard SI 3-decade prefix ladder: kilo-(103)\text{kilo-} (10^3), base (100)(10^0), milli-(10−3)\text{milli-} (10^{-3}), micro-(10−6)\text{micro-} (10^{-6}), and nano-(10−9)\text{nano-} (10^{-9}).

  • Perform a sanity check against total seed mass before proceeding to subsequent calculations.

  • Practice multi-tier unit conversions involving biological energy and nutrient allocations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses the total seed mass of 1.5 mg instead of the endosperm starch content of 450 μg to determine the number of provisioned seeds, obtaining 14400 seeds.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    120×180=21600 mg  ⟹  21600/1000=21.6 g120 \times 180 = 21600\text{ mg} \implies 21600 / 1000 = 21.6\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    450 μg/1000=0.45 mg450\,\mu\text{g} / 1000 = 0.45\text{ mg}

  3. Step 3

    21600 mg/1.5 mg=14400 seeds21600\text{ mg} / 1.5\text{ mg} = 14400\text{ seeds}

    Correct

    21600 mg0.450 mg/seed=48000 seeds\frac{21600\text{ mg}}{0.450\text{ mg/seed}} = 48000\text{ seeds}

    You divided the total tuber starch by the entire seed mass (1.5 mg1.5\text{ mg}) rather than the seed's starch content (0.45 mg0.45\text{ mg}). To find equivalent starch provisioning, you must compare starch to starch.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total starch mass in one tuber as 21.6 g21.6\text{ g}.

You successfully converted the seed starch content from 450 μg450\,\mu\text{g} to 0.45 mg0.45\text{ mg}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Variable confusion: total organ mass vs. reserve nutrient mass

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the total structural mass of the botanical seed (1.5 mg1.5\text{ mg}) with its stored energy reserve (0.45 mg0.45\text{ mg} of endosperm starch), resulting in an energy comparison between unequal biological variables.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match Energy Currency
  • When comparing resource provisioning between reproductive propagules, compare the specific stored nutrient quantity rather than total gross organ weight.

  • Check that the denominator represents the same component (endosperm starch) as the numerator (tuber starch).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the starch allocation per sexual seed: 0.450 mg0.450\text{ mg}.

  2. Divide the single tuber's starch reserve by the starch reserve per seed: 21600 mg0.450 mg/seed=48000 seeds\frac{21600\text{ mg}}{0.450\text{ mg/seed}} = 48000\text{ seeds}.

Final answer

48000 seeds48000\text{ seeds}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review resource allocation tradeoffs between vegetative propagules (large investment, few units) and sexual seeds (minimal investment, many units).

  • Always circle or list the specific target nutrient (starch) separately from overall organ fresh weight before calculating ratios.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student divides the tuber starch mass in grams directly by the seed starch mass in milligrams without unit conversion, underestimating the seed count by a factor of 1000 to get 48 seeds.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    120×180 mg=21600 mg  ⟹  21600 mg=21.6 g120 \times 180\text{ mg} = 21600\text{ mg} \implies 21600\text{ mg} = 21.6\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    450 μg=0.45 mg450\ \mu\text{g} = 0.45\text{ mg}

  3. Step 3

    21.60.45=48 seeds\frac{21.6}{0.45} = 48\text{ seeds}

    Correct

    21600 mg0.450 mg=48000 seeds\frac{21600\text{ mg}}{0.450\text{ mg}} = 48000\text{ seeds}

    You divided a quantity in grams (21.6 g21.6\text{ g}) by a quantity in milligrams (0.45 mg0.45\text{ mg}) without matching the units first, which underestimated the seed count by a factor of 10001000.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total starch mass of the potato tuber in grams.

You correctly converted the seed endosperm starch from micrograms to milligrams.

You recognized that the comparison requires dividing the tuber starch mass by the starch mass of an individual seed.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inconsistent unit quotient

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You divided quantities with different metric prefixes (grams over milligrams) without converting both to a common base unit first.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Unit Consistency Check
  • Before dividing two physical quantities to find a dimensionless ratio or count, both quantities must have the exact same unit.

  • Convert both numerator and denominator to the same unit (e.g., both to g\text{g} or both to mg\text{mg}) and cancel the units explicitly.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express both starch masses in the same unit: Tuber starch =21600 mg= 21600\text{ mg} (or 21.6 g21.6\text{ g}), Seed starch =0.450 mg= 0.450\text{ mg} (or 0.000450 g0.000450\text{ g}).

  2. Divide the identical units: Number of seeds=21600 mg0.450 mg=48000\text{Number of seeds} = \frac{21600\text{ mg}}{0.450\text{ mg}} = 48000.

Final answer

(a) 21.6 g21.6\text{ g}; (b) 0.450 mg0.450\text{ mg}; (c) 48000 seeds48000\text{ seeds}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write the units explicitly into division setups to verify that they cancel out completely.

  • Practice mental sanity checks: an energy-rich vegetative storage organ like a large potato tuber should provision tens of thousands of tiny botanical seeds, not just a few dozen.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sunflower seed contains 800 μg800\ \mu\text{g} of lipid reserves. Convert this lipid mass to milligrams (mg\text{mg}) and standard grams (g\text{g}).

Answer

0.8 mg0.8\text{ mg} and 0.0008 g0.0008\text{ g} (8×10−4 g8 \times 10^{-4}\text{ g}). Divide 800 μg800\ \mu\text{g} by 10001000 to get 0.8 mg0.8\text{ mg}, then divide by 10001000 again to get 0.0008 g0.0008\text{ g}.

02

A ginger rhizome (asexual organ) stores 15 g15\text{ g} of starch. A ginger flower produces true seeds that each contain 300 μg300\ \mu\text{g} of starch. Calculate how many true seeds contain the equivalent starch of one rhizome.

Answer

50000 seeds50000\text{ seeds}. Convert rhizome starch to micrograms: 15 g=15000000 μg15\text{ g} = 15000000\ \mu\text{g} (or seed starch to grams: 300 μg=0.0003 g300\ \mu\text{g} = 0.0003\text{ g}). Divide: 15 g0.0003 g=50000 seeds\frac{15\text{ g}}{0.0003\text{ g}} = 50000\text{ seeds}.

03

An onion bulb has a dry storage reserve of 18 g18\text{ g}. An individual onion seed has an embryo and endosperm storing 120 μg120\ \mu\text{g} of carbohydrates and 30 μg30\ \mu\text{g} of proteins. (a) Find the total nutrient reserve per seed in milligrams. (b) Determine how many seeds match the total dry storage of the bulb.

Answer

(a) 0.15 mg0.15\text{ mg}; (b) 120000 seeds120000\text{ seeds}. (a) Total reserve per seed =120 μg+30 μg=150 μg= 120\ \mu\text{g} + 30\ \mu\text{g} = 150\ \mu\text{g}. In milligrams: 1501000=0.15 mg\frac{150}{1000} = 0.15\text{ mg}. (b) Convert bulb mass to milligrams: 18 g=18000 mg18\text{ g} = 18000\text{ mg}. Number of seeds =18000 mg0.15 mg=120000 seeds= \frac{18000\text{ mg}}{0.15\text{ mg}} = 120000\text{ seeds}.

Loading workspace…