Resources

Consider two species of monkeyflowers (Species 1Species\ 1 and Species 2Species\ 2) that exhibit both prezygotic and postzygotic isolation. The total reproductive isolation (RItotalRI_{\text{total}}) can be partitioned sequentially as RItotal=RIpre+(1−RIpre)×RIpostRI_{\text{total}} = RI_{\text{pre}} + (1 - RI_{\text{pre}}) \times RI_{\text{post}}, where values range from 00 (no isolation) to 11 (complete isolation). Field measurements reveal that ecological habitat divergence yields an isolation value of RIpre=0.70RI_{\text{pre}} = 0.70. Among the remaining 30%30\% of potential matings that occur, hybrid offspring suffer postzygotic hybrid breakdown, such that only 15%15\% of F2F_2 progeny successfully reach reproductive maturity (giving a postzygotic isolation coefficient of RIpost=1−0.15=0.85RI_{\text{post}} = 1 - 0.15 = 0.85). (a) Calculate the absolute contribution of the postzygotic barrier to total isolation, given by (1−RIpre)×RIpost(1 - RI_{\text{pre}}) \times RI_{\text{post}}. (b) Calculate the total reproductive isolation RItotalRI_{\text{total}}. (c) Distinguish conceptually between hybrid breakdown (F2F_2 generation failure) and hybrid inviability (F1F_1 generation failure).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) 0.2550.255 (or 25.5%25.5\%). (b) RItotal=0.955RI_{\text{total}} = 0.955 (or 95.5%95.5\%). (c) Hybrid inviability occurs when F1F_1 hybrid embryos fail to develop or die before reproductive maturity, whereas hybrid breakdown allows F1F_1 hybrids to be viable and fertile, but genetic incompatibilities manifest in the F2F_2 or backcross generations as inviability or sterility.

Steps

Part (a): Absolute Contribution of the Postzygotic Barrier

Reproductive barriers act sequentially in nature. When prezygotic isolation prevents a proportion of gene flow, postzygotic barriers can only act on the remaining gene flow that penetrates the initial prezygotic filter.

The absolute contribution of the postzygotic barrier represents the portion of total reproductive isolation accounted for by postzygotic isolation acting on that remainder:

Absolute Postzygotic Contribution=(1−RIpre)⋅RIpost\text{Absolute Postzygotic Contribution} = (1 - RI_{\text{pre}}) \cdot RI_{\text{post}}

Substitute the given values (RIpre=0.70RI_{\text{pre}} = 0.70 and RIpost=0.85RI_{\text{post}} = 0.85):

Absolute Postzygotic Contribution=(1−0.70)⋅0.85=0.30⋅0.85=0.255 (or 25.5%)\text{Absolute Postzygotic Contribution} = (1 - 0.70) \cdot 0.85 = 0.30 \cdot 0.85 = 0.255\text{ (or } 25.5\%)


Part (b): Total Reproductive Isolation (RItotalRI_{\text{total}})

Total reproductive isolation combines the initial prezygotic barrier with the realized postzygotic barrier:

RItotal=RIpre+(1−RIpre)⋅RIpostRI_{\text{total}} = RI_{\text{pre}} + (1 - RI_{\text{pre}}) \cdot RI_{\text{post}}

Substitute the prezygotic isolation and the calculated absolute postzygotic contribution:

RItotal=0.70+0.255=0.955 (or 95.5%)RI_{\text{total}} = 0.70 + 0.255 = 0.955\text{ (or } 95.5\%)

Common Pitfall: Do not simply add RIpre+RIpost=0.70+0.85=1.55RI_{\text{pre}} + RI_{\text{post}} = 0.70 + 0.85 = 1.55. Because isolation indices cannot exceed 1.01.0 (100%100\% isolation), postzygotic barriers must be weighted by the fraction of opportunities that evade prezygotic isolation: (1−RIpre)(1 - RI_{\text{pre}}).


Part (c): Conceptual Distinction Between Hybrid Inviability and Hybrid Breakdown

Both are postzygotic reproductive isolating mechanisms, but they fail at different generational stages:

  • Hybrid Inviability: The isolating mechanism acts directly on the first-generation (F1F_1) hybrids. Genetic incompatibilities or developmental disruptions prevent the F1F_1 zygote from developing normally, causing the embryo or juvenile to die before reaching reproductive maturity.
  • Hybrid Breakdown: The first-generation (F1F_1) hybrids develop normally and are viable and fertile. However, when these F1F_1 hybrids mate with each other (to form F2F_2 progeny) or backcross with either parental species, recombination disrupts co-adapted gene complexes, resulting in inviable, malformed, or sterile offspring in the F2F_2 or subsequent generations.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the postzygotic isolation coefficient RI_post with the proportion of surviving progeny (0.15) rather than the proportion that fails (0.85), calculating an incorrect absolute contribution.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    (1−RIpre)×RIpost=(1−0.70)×0.15  ⟹  0.30×0.15=0.045(1 - RI_{\text{pre}}) \times RI_{\text{post}} = (1 - 0.70) \times 0.15 \implies 0.30 \times 0.15 = 0.045

    Correct

    (1−RIpre)×RIpost=(1−0.70)×0.85=0.30×0.85=0.255(1 - RI_{\text{pre}}) \times RI_{\text{post}} = (1 - 0.70) \times 0.85 = 0.30 \times 0.85 = 0.255

    You correctly set up the formula for absolute contribution, but you substituted 0.150.15 (the proportion of surviving hybrids) instead of RIpost=1−0.15=0.85RI_{\text{post}} = 1 - 0.15 = 0.85 (the isolation coefficient reflecting hybrid failure).

  2. Step 2

    RItotal=0.70+0.045=0.745RI_{\text{total}} = 0.70 + 0.045 = 0.745

    Correct

    RItotal=0.70+0.255=0.955RI_{\text{total}} = 0.70 + 0.255 = 0.955

    Your addition method followed the sequential isolation formula correctly, but your result was affected by the value carried forward from part (a).

  3. Step 3

    Hybrid inviability is the death or failure of F1 hybrid zygotes during development, whereas hybrid breakdown occurs when fertile F1 hybrids produce inviable or sterile F2 offspring.\text{Hybrid inviability is the death or failure of } F_1 \text{ hybrid zygotes during development, whereas hybrid breakdown occurs when fertile } F_1 \text{ hybrids produce inviable or sterile } F_2 \text{ offspring.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and applied the sequential isolation equations for parts (a) and (b).

You provided an accurate, precise biological distinction between hybrid inviability and hybrid breakdown.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating survival rate with isolation coefficient

You used the survival rate 0.150.15 instead of the reproductive isolation coefficient 0.850.85.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Reproductive isolation (RIRI) measures the proportion of gene flow that is blocked or the proportion of offspring that fail, not the proportion that survives. When survival is 15%15\%, reproductive isolation is 1−0.15=0.851 - 0.15 = 0.85.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolation vs. Viability
  • Reproductive isolation indices range from 00 (complete gene flow / 100%100\% survival) to 11 (complete reproductive barrier / 0%0\% survival). An isolation coefficient is defined as RI=1−(hybrid fitness or survival)RI = 1 - (\text{hybrid fitness or survival}).

  • Before substituting into RIRI equations, check whether the given percentage represents successful gene flow/survival or barrier strength/failure.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the correct postzygotic isolation coefficient: RIpost=1−0.15=0.85RI_{\text{post}} = 1 - 0.15 = 0.85.

  2. Evaluate the absolute contribution of the postzygotic barrier: (1−RIpre)×RIpost=(1−0.70)×0.85=0.30×0.85=0.255(1 - RI_{\text{pre}}) \times RI_{\text{post}} = (1 - 0.70) \times 0.85 = 0.30 \times 0.85 = 0.255.

  3. Compute total reproductive isolation: RItotal=RIpre+Absolute Contribution=0.70+0.255=0.955RI_{\text{total}} = RI_{\text{pre}} + \text{Absolute Contribution} = 0.70 + 0.255 = 0.955.

Final answer

(a) 0.2550.255 (or 25.5%25.5\%). (b) RItotal=0.955RI_{\text{total}} = 0.955 (or 95.5%95.5\%). (c) Hybrid inviability causes death or developmental failure in F1F_1 hybrids, whereas hybrid breakdown manifests as inviability or sterility in F2F_2 (or backcross) generations after fertile F1F_1 hybrids reproduce.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the definition RI=1−fitnessRI = 1 - \text{fitness} to avoid directly plugging in the survival fraction.

  • Review the sequential nature of reproductive barriers to see why postzygotic isolation only operates on the fraction (1−RIpre)(1 - RI_{\text{pre}}).

  • Practice partitioning reproductive isolation with multiple barriers (e.g., pollinator isolation, pollen-pistil incompatibility, and hybrid sterility).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates total isolation by simply summing the individual isolation coefficients without weighting postzygotic isolation by the remaining mating opportunities.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    (1−0.70)×0.85=0.30×0.85=0.255(1 - 0.70) \times 0.85 = 0.30 \times 0.85 = 0.255

  2. Step 2

    RItotal=RIpre+RIpost=0.70+0.85=1.55RI_{\text{total}} = RI_{\text{pre}} + RI_{\text{post}} = 0.70 + 0.85 = 1.55

    Correct

    RItotal=RIpre+(1−RIpre)×RIpost=0.70+0.255=0.955RI_{\text{total}} = RI_{\text{pre}} + (1 - RI_{\text{pre}}) \times RI_{\text{post}} = 0.70 + 0.255 = 0.955

    You simply added the two isolation coefficients rather than adding the absolute postzygotic contribution from part (a) to the prezygotic isolation. Total reproductive isolation cannot exceed 1.01.0 (100%100\%).

  3. Step 3

    Hybrid inviability involves inviable F1 hybrids failing to reach adulthood, while hybrid breakdown involves viable F1 hybrids whose F2 progeny are weak or inviable.\text{Hybrid inviability involves inviable } F_1 \text{ hybrids failing to reach adulthood, while hybrid breakdown involves viable } F_1 \text{ hybrids whose } F_2 \text{ progeny are weak or inviable.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the absolute postzygotic barrier contribution in part (a).

You provided an accurate biological distinction between F1F_1 inviability and F2F_2 hybrid breakdown in part (c).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unweighted Summation of Sequential Barriers

You computed the weighted postzygotic term in part (a), but forgot to plug that result into the formula for total isolation in part (b).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating independent additive probabilities with sequential biological filters. Reproductive barriers act in chronological order, so downstream (postzygotic) barriers only act upon the gene flow that circumvents upstream (prezygotic) barriers. Consequently, total reproductive isolation cannot exceed 1.01.0.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Bounded Isolation Check
  • RItotal≤1.0RI_{\text{total}} \le 1.0 by definition. Any calculated value >1.0> 1.0 indicates that sequential weighting was omitted.

  • Check your final numerical value whenever calculating isolation indices; if it exceeds 1.01.0, make sure postzygotic isolation is weighted by (1−RIpre)(1 - RI_{\text{pre}}).

Sequential Chain Rule
  • RItotal=RIpre+Absolute RIpostRI_{\text{total}} = RI_{\text{pre}} + \text{Absolute } RI_{\text{post}}, where Absolute RIpost=(1−RIpre)×RIpost\text{Absolute } RI_{\text{post}} = (1 - RI_{\text{pre}}) \times RI_{\text{post}}.

  • Directly carry over your weighted result from part (a) into part (b) rather than re-introducing unweighted RIpostRI_{\text{post}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Combine the prezygotic barrier and the realized postzygotic contribution: RItotal=RIpre+(1−RIpre)×RIpostRI_{\text{total}} = RI_{\text{pre}} + (1 - RI_{\text{pre}}) \times RI_{\text{post}}

  2. Substitute the known values: RItotal=0.70+0.255=0.955RI_{\text{total}} = 0.70 + 0.255 = 0.955

Final answer

RItotal=0.955RI_{\text{total}} = 0.955 (or 95.5%95.5\%)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always double-check that your total reproductive isolation index lies strictly between 00 and 11.

  • Practice sequential barrier partitioning problems where multiple prezygotic or postzygotic components act in a chain.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student reverses the definitions of hybrid breakdown and hybrid inviability across the F1 and F2 generations.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    (1−0.70)×0.85=0.30×0.85=0.255(1 - 0.70) \times 0.85 = 0.30 \times 0.85 = 0.255

  2. Step 2

    RItotal=0.70+0.255=0.955RI_{\text{total}} = 0.70 + 0.255 = 0.955

  3. Step 3

    Hybrid breakdown is when F1F_1 hybrids are inviable and fail to develop, whereas hybrid inviability is when fertile F1F_1 hybrids produce inviable F2F_2 offspring.

    Correct

    Hybrid inviability occurs when F1F_1 hybrids fail to develop normally or die before maturity, whereas hybrid breakdown occurs when viable, fertile F1F_1 hybrids produce inviable or sterile F2F_2 (or backcross) offspring.

    You reversed the two terms across the F1F_1 and F2F_2 generations. Hybrid inviability strikes directly in the F1F_1 generation, while hybrid breakdown allows F1F_1 hybrids to survive and reproduce before genetic incompatibilities appear in the F2F_2 generation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the absolute postzygotic isolation contribution using (1−RIpre)×RIpost(1 - RI_{\text{pre}}) \times RI_{\text{post}}.

You correctly combined the sequential isolating components to find RItotalRI_{\text{total}}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed Generation-Specific Postzygotic Barriers

You swapped the terms 'hybrid inviability' and 'hybrid breakdown' across the F1F_1 and F2F_2 generations.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating immediate postzygotic lethality (F1F_1 hybrid inviability) with multi-generational recombinant failure (F2F_2 hybrid breakdown caused by disrupted co-adapted gene complexes).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Generational Timing of Postzygotic Barriers
  • Inviability or sterility occurring directly in the first cross (F1F_1) is hybrid inviability or hybrid sterility; failure delayed until the F2F_2 or backcross generation is hybrid breakdown.

  • Identify which specific generation suffers developmental failure or sterility before naming the barrier.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the generation in which developmental failure first occurs.

  2. Define hybrid inviability as the failure of F1F_1 hybrid embryos to develop or survive to maturity.

  3. Define hybrid breakdown as the pattern where F1F_1 hybrids are viable and fertile, but their F2F_2 or backcross progeny suffer inviability, malformation, or sterility.

Final answer

(a) 0.2550.255 (or 25.5%25.5\%). (b) RItotal=0.955RI_{\text{total}} = 0.955 (or 95.5%95.5\%). (c) Hybrid inviability occurs when F1F_1 hybrid embryos fail to develop or die before reproductive maturity, whereas hybrid breakdown allows F1F_1 hybrids to be viable and fertile, but genetic incompatibilities manifest in the F2F_2 or backcross generations as inviability or sterility.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the three classic postzygotic barriers: hybrid inviability (F1F_1 dies), hybrid sterility (F1F_1 sterile), and hybrid breakdown (F1F_1 fertile, F2F_2 fails).

  • Associate the word 'breakdown' with a delayed process where the hybrid lineage begins normally but 'breaks down' after genetic recombination in the second generation.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two frog species have a prezygotic temporal isolation of RIpre=0.60RI_{\text{pre}} = 0.60. In laboratory crosses, 10%10\% of F1F_1 hybrid tadpoles survive to metamorphosis. (a) Determine RIpostRI_{\text{post}}. (b) Calculate the absolute contribution of postzygotic isolation. (c) Calculate RItotalRI_{\text{total}}.

Answer

(a) RIpost=1−0.10=0.90RI_{\text{post}} = 1 - 0.10 = 0.90. (b) Absolute Contribution=(1−0.60)×0.90=0.40×0.90=0.36\text{Absolute Contribution} = (1 - 0.60) \times 0.90 = 0.40 \times 0.90 = 0.36. (c) RItotal=0.60+0.36=0.96RI_{\text{total}} = 0.60 + 0.36 = 0.96.

02

In a hybrid zone of two plant species, floral morphology causes prezygotic isolation of RIpre=0.80RI_{\text{pre}} = 0.80. Of the successful cross-pollinations, F1F_1 hybrids are healthy, but their pollen viability is reduced by 50%50\% (RIpost=0.50RI_{\text{post}} = 0.50). Does the prezygotic barrier or postzygotic barrier make a larger absolute contribution to total isolation? Show your calculations.

Answer

Prezygotic contribution =RIpre=0.80= RI_{\text{pre}} = 0.80. Absolute postzygotic contribution =(1−RIpre)×RIpost=(1−0.80)×0.50=0.20×0.50=0.10= (1 - RI_{\text{pre}}) \times RI_{\text{post}} = (1 - 0.80) \times 0.50 = 0.20 \times 0.50 = 0.10. The prezygotic barrier makes a much larger absolute contribution (0.800.80 vs. 0.100.10) because it acts first and filters out 80%80\% of potential gene flow.

03

Two fruit fly species display habitat isolation of RIhab=0.40RI_{\text{hab}} = 0.40 and behavioral mating isolation of RIbeh=0.50RI_{\text{beh}} = 0.50 among those that share habitats. For individuals that mate, F1F_1 hybrids fail to develop (RIpost=1.0RI_{\text{post}} = 1.0). Calculate the cumulative reproductive isolation across all three sequential barriers.

Answer

Total isolation can be calculated sequentially:

  1. Unisolated after habitat: 1−0.40=0.601 - 0.40 = 0.60.
  2. Absolute behavioral contribution: 0.60×0.50=0.300.60 \times 0.50 = 0.30.
  3. Cumulative prezygotic isolation: 0.40+0.30=0.700.40 + 0.30 = 0.70.
  4. Absolute postzygotic contribution: (1−0.70)×1.0=0.30×1.0=0.30(1 - 0.70) \times 1.0 = 0.30 \times 1.0 = 0.30.
  5. Total reproductive isolation: RItotal=0.70+0.30=1.00RI_{\text{total}} = 0.70 + 0.30 = 1.00 (complete isolation).
Loading workspace…