Resources
A newly discovered flowering plant taxon (Tragopogon novus) is determined to be an allotetraploid () formed via sympatric speciation between two diploid progenitor species: species X () and species Y (). In an experimental hybridization trial without meiotic duplication, the sterile hybrid exhibits complete failure of bivalent pairing during prophase I, forming univalents. Calculate backwards the number of somatic chromosomes () present in the sterile triploid backcross offspring produced if an unreduced diploid gamete () from species X accidentally fertilizes a normal haploid gamete () from species Y. State whether this backcross hybrid is functionally fertile or sterile, providing the mechanical chromosomal reason.
Answer and steps
Final answer
chromosomes; Functionally sterile, because the odd number of homoeologous chromosome sets prevents uniform homologous synapsis and bivalent disjunction during Meiosis I, leading to aneuploid gametes.
Steps
Determine the chromosome contribution of each gamete
- Unreduced gamete from Species X:
A normal diploid plant of Species X has a somatic chromosome number of . During meiotic non-reduction, the chromosome number is not halved. Therefore, the unreduced gamete carries the full somatic complement: - Normal haploid gamete from Species Y:
Species Y is also diploid with . A normal meiotic division yields a haploid gamete with half the somatic number:
Calculate the somatic chromosome number of the backcross hybrid
Fertilization combines the chromosomes of both gametes into the zygote:
Because the offspring inherits two sets of chromosomes from Species X and one set from Species Y (), it has three chromosome sets in total (), making it a triploid hybrid.
Determine functional fertility and the chromosomal mechanism
- Fertility status: The backcross hybrid is functionally sterile.
- Chromosomal mechanism:
- Sexual fertility requires regular homologous chromosome pairing (synapsis) into bivalents during prophase I, followed by equal segregation (disjunction) at anaphase I.
- In this triploid () hybrid, the odd number of homoeologous chromosome sets disrupts uniform pairing. The chromosomes either attempt to form unstable trivalents or form bivalents alongside lagging univalents.
- This uneven pairing leads to random, unequal segregation during meiosis I, resulting in aneuploid gametes with unbalanced genetic material that are inviable or produce non-viable offspring.
Common Pitfall
Do not confuse an allotetraploid with an unreduced hybrid backcross. In an allotetraploid (, constitution ), every chromosome has an identical homologue to pair with ( bivalents), conferring fertility. In contrast, this triploid backcross () contains an odd number of genome sets, guaranteeing meiotic imbalance and sterility.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the unreduced gamete from a diploid parent with the chromosome count of the allotetraploid, incorrectly adding 24 and 6 to get 30.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You used (the allotetraploid chromosome count) instead of the somatic count of diploid species X (). An unreduced gamete produced by species X retains its diploid complement of chromosomes.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
Your addition followed correctly from your first step, but because the unreduced gamete contributes chromosomes rather than , the zygote contains chromosomes.
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly halved the somatic number of diploid species Y to find the normal haploid gamete count of .
You correctly identified that the hybrid is sterile due to meiotic pairing failure caused by an uneven number of chromosome sets.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou initially wrote for the unreduced gamete, which was correct, but then crossed it out and replaced it with .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the somatic chromosome count of the allotetraploid derivative () with that of the diploid progenitor species X (). An unreduced gamete carries the unhalved chromosome count of its immediate parent species, which is diploid ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify the source parent
An unreduced gamete carries the full somatic complement () of the specific parent producing it.
Check whether the unreduced gamete originates from the diploid progenitor () or from the tetraploid taxon ().
- Sum gametic contributions
Somatic number of offspring () = chromosomes from gamete 1 + chromosomes from gamete 2.
Add (unreduced from X) and (haploid from Y) to obtain chromosomes ( triploid).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the chromosome count of species X: .
An unreduced gamete from species X fails to undergo reduction division, so it contributes chromosomes.
Combine with the normal gamete from species Y: chromosomes.
Because the offspring contains three chromosome sets (, ), homologous chromosomes cannot pair evenly into bivalents during prophase I, causing sterility.
chromosomes; functionally sterile due to failure of regular homologous pairing and segregation of odd chromosome sets during meiosis I.
02 The student mistakenly assumes an unreduced gamete has undergone meiosis normally, using n = 6 instead of 2n = 12 and arriving at 12 somatic chromosomes.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Gamete from species X = Gamete from species Y = Somatic chromosome number =
CorrectUnreduced gamete from species X = Normal haploid gamete from species Y = Somatic chromosome number =
The problem states that species X produced an unreduced diploid gamete (). You halved species X's chromosome number to , resulting in a calculated total of chromosomes instead of .
- Step 2
The hybrid is sterile.
- Step 3
Chromosomes from species X and Y cannot form bivalents because they lack homologs.
CorrectThe odd number of chromosome sets (, constitution ) prevents uniform homologous pairing and equal disjunction during Meiosis I, producing inviable aneuploid gametes.
Because of your earlier calculation that the hybrid has chromosomes (), you explained the sterility as a complete lack of homologs. In the actual triploid offspring (), two sets come from species X and one from species Y, so the sterility is driven by the irregular pairing and unequal segregation of three chromosome sets.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the interspecific hybrid offspring is sterile.
You correctly calculated that a normal haploid gamete from species Y contains chromosomes.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou divided the chromosome number of species X by two, overlooking that an unreduced gamete retains its full somatic complement ().
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated a standard haploid gamete produced by normal meiosis () with an unreduced meiotic gamete (), causing you to treat the cross as a standard diploid hybrid rather than a triploid backcross.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Defining an Unreduced Gamete
An unreduced gamete forms when meiotic reduction fails, meaning it carries the somatic chromosome number (), not the haploid number ().
Always check whether a gamete is designated as 'normal/reduced' or 'unreduced' before adding chromosome contributions.
- Explaining Triploid Sterility
In an odd-ploidy organism like a triploid (), sterility is caused by the inability of three sets of chromosomes to segregate evenly into balanced pairs during Meiosis I.
Attribute sterility in hybrids to unbalanced trivalent/univalent pairing and subsequent aneuploidy, rather than a total absence of homologs.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the chromosome contribution of the unreduced gamete from species X: .
Identify the chromosome contribution of the normal haploid gamete from species Y: .
Add the two gametic contributions together to find the somatic count: .
Confirm functional fertility: The offspring has genome constitution (), making it a triploid and functionally sterile.
State the meiotic cause: During Prophase I and Anaphase I, the three chromosome sets cannot achieve uniform bivalent synapsis and equal disjunction, leading to genetically unbalanced (aneuploid) gametes.
chromosomes; functionally sterile due to unequal segregation of the three chromosome sets during Meiosis I resulting in aneuploid gametes.
03 The student concludes the hybrid is fertile because the total somatic number of chromosomes is even (18), overlooking that triploidy causes univalent/trivalent segregation defects.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Unreduced gamete = 12 ⟹ Haploid gamete = 6 ⟹ Somatic chromosome number = 12 + 6 = 18
- Step 2
The hybrid is fertile. Since 18 is an even number, all chromosomes can pair into 9 bivalents during meiosis.
CorrectFunctionally sterile: the hybrid is triploid (, genome constitution ). The odd number of genome sets prevents uniform homologous synapsis and regular disjunction during Meiosis I, leading to univalents/trivalents and aneuploid gametes.
An even total number of chromosomes does not guarantee homologous pairing. Chromosomes must pair with their specific homologues; here, two sets come from species X and one set comes from species Y (). The odd ploidy level () causes trivalent formation and univalents, leading to unequal segregation and complete functional sterility.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the unreduced gamete contributes chromosomes and the haploid gamete contributes chromosomes.
You accurately summed the gametic chromosomes to arrive at a somatic count of .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that any even somatic chromosome number () allows chromosomes to pair pairwise into regular bivalents, overlooking that synapsis requires specific homology between full genome sets (, or ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Ploidy vs. Total Count
Fertility depends on balanced homologous sets (even ploidy level ), not simply whether the total chromosome count is an even number.
Always determine the genomic formula (such as ) to verify whether each chromosome has an equal, matching homologous partner.
- Meiotic Segregation in Triploids
In an odd-ploid hybrid (), homoeologous chromosomes form multivalent associations (trivalents) or univalents, causing random non-disjunction at anaphase I and inviable aneuploid gametes.
Classify triploid hybrids as functionally sterile unless an unreduced gamete event or whole-genome duplication restores amphidiploid balance.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite out the genomic composition: Species X contributes () and Species Y contributes (), giving an constitution ().
Analyze pairing at prophase I: each homologous group consists of three chromosomes, resulting in either a trivalent or a bivalent plus an unpaired univalent.
Conclude the phenotypic fertility: unequal distribution of chromosomes during anaphase I generates unbalanced (aneuploid) gametes, rendering the backcross hybrid functionally sterile.
chromosomes; functionally sterile due to meiotic failure and aneuploidy resulting from an unbalanced triploid genome ().
Lock it in
What does an 'unreduced gamete' mean for a diploid organism with ?
The gamete has chromosomes (). Non-reduction during meiosis preserves the full somatic chromosome number rather than halving it.
Similar question
A diploid grass species A () and diploid grass species B () produce an allotetraploid species C (). An unreduced gamete from species B accidentally fertilizes a normal haploid gamete from species A. What is the chromosome count () of this backcross hybrid, and is it expected to be fertile or sterile?
Answer
chromosomes; functionally sterile. Key steps: Unreduced gamete from species B carries chromosomes; normal haploid gamete from species A carries chromosomes. Summing them yields chromosomes (triploid, ). Triploids have an odd number of genome sets, which disrupts meiotic bivalent pairing and yields aneuploid, inviable gametes.
Two diploid plant species, P () and Q (), can hybridize. If an unreduced gamete from an autotetraploid form of species P () fertilizes a normal haploid gamete from diploid species Q (), calculate the total chromosome count of the resulting progeny and determine its ploidy level.
Answer
chromosomes; pentaploid (). Key steps: An unreduced gamete from the tetraploid parent retains all somatic chromosomes (). The normal haploid gamete from species Q contributes chromosomes (). Fertilization yields chromosomes, containing sets of chromosomes ().
In a speciation experiment, diploid species M () and diploid species N () form an allotetraploid (). During a reciprocal cross, an unreduced gamete from species M fuses with an unreduced gamete from species N. Determine the chromosome number, ploidy level, and functional fertility of the resulting plant.
Answer
chromosomes; allotetraploid (); functionally fertile. Key steps: Both gametes are unreduced, each contributing chromosomes (). Because each chromosome from species M and species N has an identical homologous partner from the same parent, each chromosome can form a stable bivalent during prophase I, restoring regular disjunction and sexual fertility.