Resources

A conservation biologist models the survival threshold of a clonal aquatic macrophyte invading a reservoir subjected to seasonal drying and pathogen outbreaks. Under purely asexual fragmentation, clone survival probability follows Psurv, asex=0.25P_{\text{surv, asex}} = 0.25 per individual fragment due to susceptibility to a specialized water mold. Under sexual reproduction, genetic outcrossing yields polymorphic offspring whose survival probability per seedling is Psurv, sex=0.60P_{\text{surv, sex}} = 0.60. If production of an asexual fragment requires an energetic cost of 1.5 units1.5\text{ units} while production of a sexually fertilized seed requires 4.0 units4.0\text{ units}, calculate the expected number of survivors per 1000 units1000\text{ units} of reproductive energy for each mode. Determine which mode crosses the higher reproductive efficiency threshold per unit energy.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Asexual: 166.7 survivors166.7\text{ survivors}; Sexual: 150.0 survivors150.0\text{ survivors}. The asexual mode yields the higher reproductive efficiency per unit energy (166.7>150.0166.7 > 150.0).

Steps

01

Asexual Reproduction Efficiency

To determine which reproductive strategy achieves higher efficiency per unit of parental investment, we calculate the number of surviving propagules produced per fixed allocation of energy (1000 units1000\text{ units}).

  • Number of fragments produced:
    Dividing the total energy budget by the energetic cost per fragment gives the number of offspring formed: Nasex=1000 units1.5 units/fragment=20003≈666.67 fragmentsN_{\text{asex}} = \frac{1000\text{ units}}{1.5\text{ units/fragment}} = \frac{2000}{3} \approx 666.67\text{ fragments}
  • Expected number of survivors:
    Multiplying the number of fragments by the survival probability under pathogen and drought conditions: Expected survivorsasex=Nasex⋅Psurv, asex=(20003)⋅0.25=5003≈166.7 survivors\text{Expected survivors}_{\text{asex}} = N_{\text{asex}} \cdot P_{\text{surv, asex}} = \left(\frac{2000}{3}\right) \cdot 0.25 = \frac{500}{3} \approx 166.7\text{ survivors}

02

Sexual Reproduction Efficiency

  • Number of seeds produced:
    Dividing the total energy budget by the energetic cost per sexually fertilized seed gives: Nsex=1000 units4.0 units/seed=250 seedsN_{\text{sex}} = \frac{1000\text{ units}}{4.0\text{ units/seed}} = 250\text{ seeds}
  • Expected number of survivors:
    Multiplying the number of seeds by the survival probability conferred by genetic diversity: Expected survivorssex=Nsex⋅Psurv, sex=250⋅0.60=150.0 survivors\text{Expected survivors}_{\text{sex}} = N_{\text{sex}} \cdot P_{\text{surv, sex}} = 250 \cdot 0.60 = 150.0\text{ survivors}

03

Comparison and Ecological Trade-off

  • Asexual mode: 166.7 survivors166.7\text{ survivors} per 1000 units1000\text{ units} of energy
  • Sexual mode: 150.0 survivors150.0\text{ survivors} per 1000 units1000\text{ units} of energy

Despite a substantially lower individual survival rate (0.250.25 vs. 0.600.60) due to pathogen susceptibility, the lower energetic cost of asexual vegetative fragmentation (1.51.5 vs. 4.0 units4.0\text{ units}) enables greater numerical output, resulting in a higher net reproductive yield.

Therefore, the asexual mode achieves the higher reproductive efficiency threshold per unit energy (166.7>150.0166.7 > 150.0).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student compares only the raw survival probabilities per propagule, ignoring differences in energetic cost per offspring.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Asexual fragments: 1000/1.5=666.67  ⟹  Asexual survivors=666.67×0.25=166.67\text{Asexual fragments: } 1000 / 1.5 = 666.67 \implies \text{Asexual survivors} = 666.67 \times 0.25 = 166.67

  2. Step 2

    Sexual seeds: 1000/4=250  ⟹  Sexual survivors=250×0.60=150\text{Sexual seeds: } 1000 / 4 = 250 \implies \text{Sexual survivors} = 250 \times 0.60 = 150

  3. Step 3

    Psurv, sex (0.60)>Psurv, asex (0.25)  ⟹  Sexual reproduction crosses the higher efficiency threshold.P_{\text{surv, sex}}\,(0.60) > P_{\text{surv, asex}}\,(0.25) \implies \text{Sexual reproduction crosses the higher efficiency threshold.}

    Correct

    Survivorsasex (166.7)>Survivorssex (150.0)  ⟹  Asexual mode achieves higher reproductive efficiency per unit energy.\text{Survivors}_{\text{asex}}\,(166.7) > \text{Survivors}_{\text{sex}}\,(150.0) \implies \text{Asexual mode achieves higher reproductive efficiency per unit energy.}

    You compared the per-propagule survival probabilities (0.600.60 vs. 0.250.25) instead of comparing your calculated survivors per unit energy (166.7166.7 vs. 150.0150.0). Efficiency per unit energy depends on both the offspring production cost and individual survival probability.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the quantity of propagules produced by dividing the total energy budget by the energetic cost per propagule for both modes.

You correctly calculated the expected number of survivors per 1000 units1000\text{ units} of energy for both asexual fragmentation (166.67166.67) and sexual seeding (150150).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Metric confusion between individual survival probability and net energetic efficiency

You correctly computed the net surviving yield per energy allocation, but then based your final qualitative choice solely on individual seedling survival probability.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated individual propagule fitness (PsurvP_{\text{surv}}) with reproductive efficiency per unit parental investment (survivors per unit energy). A lower per-offspring survival rate can be overcome if low production costs allow an organism to produce far more total offspring.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the Target Metric
  • Reproductive efficiency per unit energy is defined as Total Surviving OffspringTotal Energy Invested\frac{\text{Total Surviving Offspring}}{\text{Total Energy Invested}}, not the per-propagule survival rate PsurvP_{\text{surv}}.

  • Always compare the final quotient (survivors/energy)(\text{survivors}/\text{energy}) when asked for energetic efficiency.

Evaluate Quantity vs. Quality Trade-offs
  • Efficiency=PsurvCost per offspring\text{Efficiency} = \frac{P_{\text{surv}}}{\text{Cost per offspring}}.

  • Notice that 0.251.5≈0.1667\frac{0.25}{1.5} \approx 0.1667 is greater than 0.604.0=0.150\frac{0.60}{4.0} = 0.150, showing asexual reproduction yields more survivors per single unit of energy.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the expected survivors per 1000 units1000\text{ units} of parental energy: Asexual=166.7 survivors\text{Asexual} = 166.7\text{ survivors}, while Sexual=150.0 survivors\text{Sexual} = 150.0\text{ survivors}.

  2. Identify that 166.7>150.0166.7 > 150.0, meaning asexual fragmentation yields more surviving individuals per unit of energy despite lower individual survival probability.

Final answer

Asexual: 166.7 survivors166.7\text{ survivors}; Sexual: 150.0 survivors150.0\text{ survivors}. The asexual mode yields the higher reproductive efficiency per unit energy (166.7>150.0166.7 > 150.0).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the trade-off between offspring quantity (low cost per propagule) and offspring quality (high survival probability).

  • Before writing your concluding sentence, re-read the prompt to ensure your comparison matches the requested metric (efficiency per unit energy vs. per-capita survival probability).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the calculation by multiplying energy by cost per propagule instead of dividing available energy by cost.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Asexual survivors\text{Asexual survivors} = 1000 ×\times 1.5 ×\times 0.25 = 375

    Correct

    Asexual survivors=10001.5×0.25≈166.7\text{Asexual survivors} = \frac{1000}{1.5} \times 0.25 \approx 166.7

    To find the number of asexual fragments produced from a fixed energy pool, you need to divide the total energy by the energetic cost per fragment, giving 10001.5≈666.67 fragments\frac{1000}{1.5} \approx 666.67\text{ fragments}, then multiply by the survival rate 0.250.25.

  2. Step 2

    Sexual survivors\text{Sexual survivors} = 1000 ×\times 4.0 ×\times 0.60 = 2400

    Correct

    Sexual survivors\text{Sexual survivors} = 10004.0\frac{1000}{4.0} ×\times 0.60 = 150.0

    Similarly, you must divide the available energy by the cost per seed to find the number of seeds produced: 10004.0=250 seeds\frac{1000}{4.0} = 250\text{ seeds}. Multiplying by the survival rate of 0.600.60 gives 150.0 survivors150.0\text{ survivors}.

  3. Step 3

    2400 > 375   ⟹  \implies Sexual reproduction crosses the higher efficiency threshold.\text{Sexual reproduction crosses the higher efficiency threshold.}

    Correct

    166.7 > 150.0   ⟹  \implies Asexual reproduction crosses the higher efficiency threshold.\text{Asexual reproduction crosses the higher efficiency threshold.}

    Your comparison followed logically from your calculated values, but because the survivor counts were incorrect, the final efficiency conclusion was reversed.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the individual survival probabilities for each reproductive strategy.

You compared your calculated values to draw a clear conclusion regarding reproductive efficiency.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Operation inversion (energy allocation)

You multiplied the energy budget by unit cost instead of dividing available energy by the cost per propagule.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating unit cost with rate of return: allocating a fixed energy budget EE across propagules each requiring cost cc yields N=EcN = \frac{E}{c} offspring, not E×cE \times c.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensional analysis of offspring output
  • Number of offspring=Total energy (units)Cost per offspring (units/offspring)\text{Number of offspring} = \frac{\text{Total energy (units)}}{\text{Cost per offspring (units/offspring)}}

  • Check that units cancel correctly: unitsunits/propagule=propagules\frac{\text{units}}{\text{units/propagule}} = \text{propagules}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the number of asexual fragments: Nasex=10001.5=20003≈666.67 fragmentsN_{\text{asex}} = \frac{1000}{1.5} = \frac{2000}{3} \approx 666.67\text{ fragments}.

  2. Calculate expected asexual survivors: 20003×0.25=5003≈166.7 survivors\frac{2000}{3} \times 0.25 = \frac{500}{3} \approx 166.7\text{ survivors}.

  3. Calculate the number of sexual seeds: Nsex=10004.0=250 seedsN_{\text{sex}} = \frac{1000}{4.0} = 250\text{ seeds}.

  4. Calculate expected sexual survivors: 250×0.60=150.0 survivors250 \times 0.60 = 150.0\text{ survivors}.

  5. Compare net survivor yields: 166.7>150.0166.7 > 150.0.

Final answer

Asexual mode: 166.7 survivors166.7\text{ survivors}; Sexual mode: 150.0 survivors150.0\text{ survivors}. The asexual mode yields the higher reproductive efficiency threshold per unit energy (166.7>150.0166.7 > 150.0).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always perform a quick units check: multiplying energy by energy per seed produces energy2\text{energy}^2, not a count of offspring.

  • Remember that lower energetic cost per propagule allows an organism to generate a vastly larger number of initial offspring, which can outweigh lower survival probabilities.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the number of propagules produced from the energy budget but omits multiplying by their survival probabilities.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Asexual survivors=1000/1.5=666.67\text{Asexual survivors} = 1000 / 1.5 = 666.67

    Correct

    Nasex=10001.5≈666.67  ⟹  Expected survivors=666.67×0.25≈166.7N_{\text{asex}} = \frac{1000}{1.5} \approx 666.67 \implies \text{Expected survivors} = 666.67 \times 0.25 \approx 166.7

    You calculated the total number of asexual fragments produced from the energy budget, but you forgot to multiply by the fragment survival probability (Psurv, asex=0.25P_{\text{surv, asex}} = 0.25) to find the expected survivors.

  2. Step 2

    Sexual survivors=1000/4.0=250\text{Sexual survivors} = 1000 / 4.0 = 250

    Correct

    Nsex=10004.0=250  ⟹  Expected survivors=250×0.60=150.0N_{\text{sex}} = \frac{1000}{4.0} = 250 \implies \text{Expected survivors} = 250 \times 0.60 = 150.0

    You found the correct number of fertilized seeds formed, but you did not factor in their survival probability (Psurv, sex=0.60P_{\text{surv, sex}} = 0.60) to obtain the true expected number of survivors.

  3. Step 3

    666.67>250  ⟹  Asexual reproduction crosses the higher efficiency threshold.666.67 > 250 \implies \text{Asexual reproduction crosses the higher efficiency threshold.}

    Correct

    166.7>150.0  ⟹  Asexual mode yields the higher reproductive efficiency threshold.166.7 > 150.0 \implies \text{Asexual mode yields the higher reproductive efficiency threshold.}

    Your final qualitative conclusion happens to match the true answer, but your comparison was based on raw propagule counts rather than the actual surviving offspring.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly divided the total energy pool by the unit energetic cost for both reproductive strategies to determine offspring output.

You correctly compared the two calculated values to identify which strategy yielded the larger result.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Survival Probability in Reproductive Output

You stopped calculating after finding the number of produced fragments and seeds, labeling production output directly as survivors.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating raw propagule production (fecundity) with net reproductive success (realized fitness), forgetting that reproductive efficiency requires multiplying total offspring by their post-dispersal survival probability.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Production vs. Recruitment
  • Expected Survivors=Total Propagules Produced×Psurvival\text{Expected Survivors} = \text{Total Propagules Produced} \times P_{\text{survival}}

  • Always multiply the count of produced offspring by their environmental survival probability before evaluating fitness or reproductive efficiency.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate expected asexual survivors: Survivorsasex=(10001.5)×0.25=5003≈166.7\text{Survivors}_{\text{asex}} = \left(\frac{1000}{1.5}\right) \times 0.25 = \frac{500}{3} \approx 166.7

  2. Calculate expected sexual survivors: Survivorssex=(10004.0)×0.60=250×0.60=150.0\text{Survivors}_{\text{sex}} = \left(\frac{1000}{4.0}\right) \times 0.60 = 250 \times 0.60 = 150.0

  3. Compare surviving offspring per 1000 units1000\text{ units} of energy: 166.7>150.0166.7 > 150.0

Final answer

Asexual: 166.7 survivors166.7\text{ survivors}; Sexual: 150.0 survivors150.0\text{ survivors}. The asexual mode yields the higher reproductive efficiency per unit energy (166.7>150.0166.7 > 150.0).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • In ecological fitness problems, distinguish between 'offspring produced' and 'offspring that survive to establishment'.

  • Double-check that all given environmental probabilities (PsurvP_{\text{surv}}) are integrated into your expected value formulas.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A perennial grass allocates 600 kJ600\text{ kJ} to reproduction. A runner (asexual) costs 3 kJ3\text{ kJ} with a survival probability of 0.400.40. A seed (sexual) costs 8 kJ8\text{ kJ} with a survival probability of 0.900.90. Calculate the expected survivors for each mode and state which is more efficient per unit energy.

Answer

Asexual: 6003×0.40=200×0.40=80 survivors\frac{600}{3} \times 0.40 = 200 \times 0.40 = 80\text{ survivors}. Sexual: 6008×0.90=75×0.90=67.5 survivors\frac{600}{8} \times 0.90 = 75 \times 0.90 = 67.5\text{ survivors}. The asexual mode is more efficient (80>67.580 > 67.5).

02

A colonial cnidarian can reproduce by bud fragmentation (cost =5 units= 5\text{ units}, Psurv=0.20P_{\text{surv}} = 0.20) or planula larvae (cost =12 units= 12\text{ units}). What minimum survival probability Psurv, planulaP_{\text{surv, planula}} must sexual larvae achieve for sexual reproduction to be more energetically efficient than budding?

Answer

Psurv, planula>0.48P_{\text{surv, planula}} > 0.48. Budding efficiency is 0.205=0.04 survivors/unit\frac{0.20}{5} = 0.04\text{ survivors/unit}. For sexual reproduction to exceed this, P12>0.04  ⟹  P>0.04×12=0.48\frac{P}{12} > 0.04 \implies P > 0.04 \times 12 = 0.48.

03

In a fluctuating alpine habitat, an angiosperm allocates 1200 units1200\text{ units} of carbon. Vegetative bulbils cost 6 units6\text{ units} each with survival Pveg=0.50P_{\text{veg}} = 0.50. Outcrossed seeds cost 15 units15\text{ units} each. During an extreme frost year, seed survival is Pseed=0.75P_{\text{seed}} = 0.75, but during a mild year, seed survival is Pseed=0.90P_{\text{seed}} = 0.90. For each year type, determine which reproductive mode provides greater net survivor yield per energy budget.

Answer

Bulbils yield 12006×0.50=100 survivors\frac{1200}{6} \times 0.50 = 100\text{ survivors} in all years. Frost year seeds: 120015×0.75=80×0.75=60 survivors\frac{1200}{15} \times 0.75 = 80 \times 0.75 = 60\text{ survivors} (bulbils win: 100>60100 > 60). Mild year seeds: 80×0.90=72 survivors80 \times 0.90 = 72\text{ survivors} (bulbils still win: 100>72100 > 72). Bulbils provide greater yield in both years.

Loading workspace…