Resources

A student hypothesizes: 'Adding water to an enclosed, non-distensible plant cell will continuously dilute internal solutes, causing its solute potential Ψs\Psi_s to increase toward zero and thus lower its turgor pressure Ψp\Psi_p.' Evaluate this statement quantitatively: A rigid plant cell with an initial volume V0=100 pLV_0 = 100\text{ pL} has Ψs=−1.20 MPa\Psi_s = -1.20\text{ MPa} and Ψp=+0.40 MPa\Psi_p = +0.40\text{ MPa} (so Ψcell=−0.80 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.80\text{ MPa}). It is transferred into pure water (Ψ=0 MPa\Psi = 0\text{ MPa}). Due to its rigid cellulose wall, it reaches complete dynamic equilibrium with only a 1.0%1.0\% increase in cell volume (Veq=1.01V0V_{\text{eq}} = 1.01 V_0). Calculate the new Ψs\Psi_s, the equilibrium total Ψ\Psi, and the new turgor pressure Ψp\Psi_p. Explain whether the student's hypothesis about turgor pressure decreasing is confirmed or refuted.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Ψs,eq=−1.19 MPa\Psi_{s,\text{eq}} = -1.19\text{ MPa}; Ψcell,eq=0.00 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell,eq}} = 0.00\text{ MPa}; Ψp,eq=+1.19 MPa\Psi_{p,\text{eq}} = +1.19\text{ MPa}; The hypothesis is refuted: endosmosis into a rigid cell causes a dramatic surge in turgor pressure (from +0.40 MPa+0.40\text{ MPa} to +1.19 MPa+1.19\text{ MPa}) despite the minor dilution of Ψs\Psi_s.

Steps

Step 1: Understand the Components of Water Potential

The total water potential of a plant cell (Ψcell\Psi_{\text{cell}}) is the sum of its solute (osmotic) potential (Ψs\Psi_s) and its pressure potential (turgor pressure, Ψp\Psi_p):

Ψcell=Ψs+Ψp\Psi_{\text{cell}} = \Psi_s + \Psi_p

  • Solute potential (Ψs\Psi_s): Measures the effect of dissolved solutes. Since pure water is defined as Ψs=0 MPa\Psi_s = 0\text{ MPa}, adding solutes always lowers this value (making it negative). Because Ψs\Psi_s is proportional to solute concentration (C=nVC = \frac{n}{V}), it is inversely related to cell volume when the amount of solute (nn) is constant: Ψs,1⋅V1=Ψs,2⋅V2\Psi_{s,1} \cdot V_1 = \Psi_{s,2} \cdot V_2
  • Pressure potential (Ψp\Psi_p): Measures the physical hydrostatic pressure exerted by the protoplast against the rigid cell wall. In a turgid plant cell, Ψp>0\Psi_p > 0.

Step 2: Calculate the New Solute Potential (Ψs,eq\Psi_{s,\text{eq}})

The total amount of solute in the cell does not change as water enters, but the cell volume increases by 1.0%1.0\% (Veq=1.01V0V_{\text{eq}} = 1.01 V_0):

Ψs,eq=Ψs,0⋅V0Veq\Psi_{s,\text{eq}} = \Psi_{s,0} \cdot \frac{V_0}{V_{\text{eq}}}

Substitute the given values:

Ψs,eq=−1.20 MPa⋅V01.01V0=−1.20 MPa1.01≈−1.188 MPa≈−1.19 MPa\Psi_{s,\text{eq}} = -1.20\text{ MPa} \cdot \frac{V_0}{1.01 V_0} = \frac{-1.20\text{ MPa}}{1.01} \approx -1.188\text{ MPa} \approx -1.19\text{ MPa}

The slight dilution of solutes makes Ψs\Psi_s only slightly less negative (from −1.20 MPa-1.20\text{ MPa} to −1.19 MPa-1.19\text{ MPa}).


Step 3: Determine the Equilibrium Water Potential (Ψcell,eq\Psi_{\text{cell,eq}})

Water moves down its potential gradient from an area of higher water potential to an area of lower water potential until dynamic equilibrium is reached.

  • The surrounding pure water has Ψext=0.00 MPa\Psi_{\text{ext}} = 0.00\text{ MPa}.
  • At dynamic equilibrium: Ψcell,eq=Ψext=0.00 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell,eq}} = \Psi_{\text{ext}} = 0.00\text{ MPa}

Step 4: Calculate the Equilibrium Turgor Pressure (Ψp,eq\Psi_{p,\text{eq}})

Rearrange the total water potential equation to solve for Ψp,eq\Psi_{p,\text{eq}}:

Ψcell,eq=Ψs,eq+Ψp,eq\Psi_{\text{cell,eq}} = \Psi_{s,\text{eq}} + \Psi_{p,\text{eq}}

Ψp,eq=Ψcell,eq−Ψs,eq\Psi_{p,\text{eq}} = \Psi_{\text{cell,eq}} - \Psi_{s,\text{eq}}

Ψp,eq=0.00 MPa−(−1.19 MPa)=+1.19 MPa\Psi_{p,\text{eq}} = 0.00\text{ MPa} - (-1.19\text{ MPa}) = +1.19\text{ MPa}


Step 5: Evaluate the Student's Hypothesis

  • Common Pitfall to Avoid: It is easy to think of a plant cell like a loose, expandable balloon, where dilution solely dictates the outcome. In plant cells, however, the rigid cell wall has very low elasticity (high volumetric elastic modulus).
  • A tiny influx of water (only a 1.0%1.0\% volume increase) results in minimal dilution of solutes (shifting Ψs\Psi_s by only +0.01 MPa+0.01\text{ MPa}), but it generates a massive increase in physical wall resistance.
  • As a result, turgor pressure Ψp\Psi_p surges from +0.40 MPa+0.40\text{ MPa} to +1.19 MPa+1.19\text{ MPa} rather than decreasing.

Therefore, the student's hypothesis is refuted.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student mistakenly assumes that solute potential and turgor pressure are directly proportional rather than governed by the water potential equilibrium with the external solution.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Ψs=−1.201.01⟹Ψs=−1.19 MPa\Psi_s = \frac{-1.20}{1.01} \Longrightarrow \Psi_s = -1.19\text{ MPa}

  2. Step 2

    Ψp drops proportionally with solute potential: 0.401.01=+0.396 MPa⟹Ψ=−1.19+0.39=−0.80 MPa\Psi_p \text{ drops proportionally with solute potential: } \frac{0.40}{1.01} = +0.396\text{ MPa} \Longrightarrow \Psi = -1.19 + 0.39 = -0.80\text{ MPa}

    Correct

    Ψcell,eq=Ψext=0.00 MPa⟹Ψp,eq=Ψcell,eq−Ψs,eq=0.00−(−1.19 MPa)=+1.19 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell,eq}} = \Psi_{\text{ext}} = 0.00\text{ MPa} \Longrightarrow \Psi_{p,\text{eq}} = \Psi_{\text{cell,eq}} - \Psi_{s,\text{eq}} = 0.00 - (-1.19\text{ MPa}) = +1.19\text{ MPa}

    At dynamic equilibrium in pure water, total water potential must equal the surrounding pure water (Ψ=0 MPa\Psi = 0\text{ MPa}). Because the cell wall is rigid and resists expansion, water influx drives turgor pressure up to +1.19 MPa+1.19\text{ MPa} rather than diluting it down.

  3. Step 3

    The hypothesis is confirmed because Ψp decreases from +0.40 MPa to +0.40 MPa.\text{The hypothesis is confirmed because } \Psi_p \text{ decreases from } +0.40\text{ MPa} \text{ to } +0.40\text{ MPa.}

    Correct

    The hypothesis is refuted: Ψp surges from +0.40 MPa to +1.19 MPa.\text{The hypothesis is refuted: } \Psi_p \text{ surges from } +0.40\text{ MPa} \text{ to } +1.19\text{ MPa}.

    Because your calculated turgor pressure was incorrect, your conclusion that the hypothesis was confirmed is also incorrect. Turgor pressure actually increases significantly.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the inverse relationship between volume and solute concentration to calculate the diluted solute potential.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equilibrium Water Potential Misconception

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated hydrostatic turgor pressure as if it were a solute that dilutes with volume (C1V1=C2V2C_1 V_1 = C_2 V_2), overlooking the boundary condition that a cell in pure water reaches equilibrium when its total water potential equals the external water potential (Ψcell=Ψext=0 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell}} = \Psi_{\text{ext}} = 0\text{ MPa}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Equilibrium Criterion
  • Net water movement ceases when internal total water potential equals external total water potential: Ψcell,eq=Ψext\Psi_{\text{cell,eq}} = \Psi_{\text{ext}}.

  • Always find total equilibrium Ψ\Psi from the external solution first, before calculating internal pressure potential.

Turgor Pressure in Rigid Walls
  • Turgor pressure is a mechanical reaction force governed by Ψp=Ψcell−Ψs\Psi_p = \Psi_{\text{cell}} - \Psi_s, not a diluted chemical concentration.

  • Solve for Ψp\Psi_p by subtracting the diluted Ψs\Psi_s from the external equilibrium Ψ\Psi.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that in pure water, dynamic equilibrium requires Ψcell,eq=Ψext=0.00 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell,eq}} = \Psi_{\text{ext}} = 0.00\text{ MPa}.

  2. Apply the water potential equation: Ψcell,eq=Ψs,eq+Ψp,eq\Psi_{\text{cell,eq}} = \Psi_{s,\text{eq}} + \Psi_{p,\text{eq}}.

  3. Substitute the known values: 0.00 MPa=−1.19 MPa+Ψp,eq0.00\text{ MPa} = -1.19\text{ MPa} + \Psi_{p,\text{eq}}, giving Ψp,eq=+1.19 MPa\Psi_{p,\text{eq}} = +1.19\text{ MPa}.

  4. Compare the initial and final turgor pressures: Ψp\Psi_p rose from +0.40 MPa+0.40\text{ MPa} to +1.19 MPa+1.19\text{ MPa}, directly refuting the hypothesis.

Final answer

Ψs,eq=−1.19 MPa\Psi_{s,\text{eq}} = -1.19\text{ MPa}; Ψcell,eq=0.00 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell,eq}} = 0.00\text{ MPa}; Ψp,eq=+1.19 MPa\Psi_{p,\text{eq}} = +1.19\text{ MPa}; The hypothesis is refuted.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the fundamental equilibrium condition Ψcell=Ψext\Psi_{\text{cell}} = \Psi_{\text{ext}} for cells in open solutions.

  • Practice solving for turgor pressure as a dependent mechanical variable using Ψp=Ψ−Ψs\Psi_p = \Psi - \Psi_s.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misapplies the water potential formula as Ψ = Ψs - Ψp, resulting in an erroneous sign for turgor pressure calculation at equilibrium.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Veq=1.01⋅100=101 pL  ⟹  Ψs=−1.20⋅(100101)=−1.19 MPaV_{\text{eq}} = 1.01 \cdot 100 = 101\text{ pL} \implies \Psi_s = -1.20 \cdot \left(\frac{100}{101}\right) = -1.19\text{ MPa}

  2. Step 2

    Ψ=0 MPa\Psi = 0\text{ MPa}

  3. Step 3

    Ψ=Ψs−Ψp  ⟹  0=−1.19−Ψp  ⟹  Ψp=−1.19 MPa\Psi = \Psi_s - \Psi_p \implies 0 = -1.19 - \Psi_p \implies \Psi_p = -1.19\text{ MPa}

    Correct

    Ψ=Ψs+Ψp  ⟹  0=−1.19 MPa+Ψp  ⟹  Ψp=+1.19 MPa\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p \implies 0 = -1.19\text{ MPa} + \Psi_p \implies \Psi_p = +1.19\text{ MPa}

    The total water potential of a plant cell is the sum of solute potential and pressure potential, Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p, not the difference.

  4. Step 4

    The hypothesis is confirmed because Ψp\Psi_p decreases from +0.40 MPa+0.40\text{ MPa} to −1.19 MPa-1.19\text{ MPa}.

    Correct

    The hypothesis is refuted: endosmosis into a rigid cell causes turgor pressure to surge from +0.40 MPa+0.40\text{ MPa} to +1.19 MPa+1.19\text{ MPa}.

    Because of the sign error in Step 3, you concluded that turgor pressure decreased, whereas it actually increased substantially.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the volume dilution relation to find the new solute potential.

You correctly identified that the equilibrium cell water potential matches the surrounding pure water potential at 0 MPa0\text{ MPa}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign Error in Water Potential Formula

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You subtracted turgor pressure from solute potential (writing Ψ=Ψs−Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s - \Psi_p) rather than adding them (Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p), overlooking that positive hydrostatic pressure elevates water potential.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Water Potential Equation
  • Total water potential is the algebraic sum of its components: Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p.

  • Always write Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p and solve for Ψp=Ψ−Ψs\Psi_p = \Psi - \Psi_s.

Sign Sense Check for Turgor Pressure
  • Living, turgid plant cells have a positive hydrostatic wall pressure (Ψp>0\Psi_p > 0).

  • When a plant cell absorbs water, check that turgor pressure becomes more positive, never negative.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall the fundamental relationship Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p.

  2. Substitute the known equilibrium values: 0 MPa=−1.19 MPa+Ψp0\text{ MPa} = -1.19\text{ MPa} + \Psi_p.

  3. Solve for turgor pressure: Ψp=0 MPa−(−1.19 MPa)=+1.19 MPa\Psi_p = 0\text{ MPa} - (-1.19\text{ MPa}) = +1.19\text{ MPa}.

  4. Compare the new turgor pressure (+1.19 MPa+1.19\text{ MPa}) with the initial turgor pressure (+0.40 MPa+0.40\text{ MPa}). Because Ψp\Psi_p increased significantly, the hypothesis is refuted.

Final answer

Ψs,eq=−1.19 MPa\Psi_{s,\text{eq}} = -1.19\text{ MPa}; Ψcell,eq=0.00 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell,eq}} = 0.00\text{ MPa}; Ψp,eq=+1.19 MPa\Psi_{p,\text{eq}} = +1.19\text{ MPa}; The hypothesis is refuted because turgor pressure increases from +0.40 MPa+0.40\text{ MPa} to +1.19 MPa+1.19\text{ MPa}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice stating the water potential equation Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p from memory before isolating any variable.

  • Perform a physical sign check: turgor pressure inside a turgid cell must be positive.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A rigid plant cell has an initial solute potential Ψs=−0.90 MPa\Psi_s = -0.90\text{ MPa} and turgor pressure Ψp=+0.30 MPa\Psi_p = +0.30\text{ MPa}. It is placed in pure water (Ψ=0 MPa\Psi = 0\text{ MPa}). Assuming negligible volume change at equilibrium, find its equilibrium total water potential Ψcell\Psi_{\text{cell}} and its equilibrium turgor pressure Ψp\Psi_p.

Answer

Ψcell=0.00 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell}} = 0.00\text{ MPa} and Ψp=+0.90 MPa\Psi_p = +0.90\text{ MPa}. Dynamic equilibrium requires Ψcell=Ψext=0.00 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell}} = \Psi_{\text{ext}} = 0.00\text{ MPa}. With negligible volume change, Ψs≈−0.90 MPa\Psi_s \approx -0.90\text{ MPa}, so Ψp=0.00−(−0.90 MPa)=+0.90 MPa\Psi_p = 0.00 - (-0.90\text{ MPa}) = +0.90\text{ MPa}.

02

A flaccid plant cell with volume V0=50 pLV_0 = 50\text{ pL}, Ψs=−1.50 MPa\Psi_s = -1.50\text{ MPa}, and Ψp=0.00 MPa\Psi_p = 0.00\text{ MPa} is placed in a sucrose solution with Ψ=−0.50 MPa\Psi = -0.50\text{ MPa}. At equilibrium, the cell volume expands by 2.0%2.0\% (V=1.02V0V = 1.02 V_0). Calculate the equilibrium solute potential Ψs,eq\Psi_{s,\text{eq}} and the equilibrium turgor pressure Ψp,eq\Psi_{p,\text{eq}}.

Answer

Ψs,eq=−1.47 MPa\Psi_{s,\text{eq}} = -1.47\text{ MPa} and Ψp,eq=+0.97 MPa\Psi_{p,\text{eq}} = +0.97\text{ MPa}. Step 1: Dilution gives Ψs,eq=−1.501.02≈−1.47 MPa\Psi_{s,\text{eq}} = \frac{-1.50}{1.02} \approx -1.47\text{ MPa}. Step 2: At equilibrium, Ψcell=Ψext=−0.50 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell}} = \Psi_{\text{ext}} = -0.50\text{ MPa}. Step 3: Ψp=Ψ−Ψs=−0.50−(−1.47)=+0.97 MPa\Psi_p = \Psi - \Psi_s = -0.50 - (-1.47) = +0.97\text{ MPa}.

03

A plant cell with Ψs=−1.00 MPa\Psi_s = -1.00\text{ MPa} and Ψp=+0.60 MPa\Psi_p = +0.60\text{ MPa} is immersed in an open salt solution with solute potential Ψs=−0.80 MPa\Psi_s = -0.80\text{ MPa}. (a) State the initial direction of net water flow. (b) If the cell wall contracts by 1.0%1.0\% to reach dynamic equilibrium, calculate the final turgor pressure Ψp\Psi_p.

Answer

(a) Water enters the cell because Ψcell=−1.00+0.60=−0.40 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell}} = -1.00 + 0.60 = -0.40\text{ MPa} is higher than Ψsol=−0.80 MPa\Psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.80\text{ MPa}? No, wait: Ψcell=−0.40 MPa>Ψext=−0.80 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.40\text{ MPa} > \Psi_{\text{ext}} = -0.80\text{ MPa}, so net water moves OUT of the cell down the potential gradient. (b) Ψp=+0.21 MPa\Psi_p = +0.21\text{ MPa}. Upon losing water, Veq=0.99V0V_{\text{eq}} = 0.99 V_0, so Ψs,eq=−1.000.99≈−1.01 MPa\Psi_{s,\text{eq}} = \frac{-1.00}{0.99} \approx -1.01\text{ MPa}. At equilibrium, Ψcell=−0.80 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.80\text{ MPa}, so Ψp=−0.80−(−1.01)=+0.21 MPa\Psi_p = -0.80 - (-1.01) = +0.21\text{ MPa}.

Loading workspace…