Resources
In a laboratory experiment investigating postzygotic barriers in two fruit fly species ( and ), female hybrids are viable and fertile, whereas of male hybrids are completely sterile due to abnormal spermatogenesis. A geneticist samples a cohort of offspring and observes an overall fertility rate of exactly across all surviving individuals (assuming an equal sex ratio of males to females, males and females). (a) Identify the specific postzygotic isolating mechanism operating in this cross. (b) Name the classic biological rule or genetic principle that accounts for the sterility being restricted to the heterogametic () male sex. (c) If a reciprocal cross produces inviable male embryos before hatching, state which postzygotic barrier has replaced hybrid sterility for the heterogametic sex.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Hybrid sterility (or hybrid infertility). (b) Haldane's Rule. (c) Hybrid inviability (or hybrid lethality).
Steps
Identifying the Postzygotic Isolating Mechanism
Step-by-Step Explanation
Reproductive isolating mechanisms prevent interbreeding between distinct biological species and are divided into prezygotic (before fertilization) and postzygotic (after fertilization) barriers.
Postzygotic barriers include:
- Hybrid inviability (hybrid lethality): The hybrid embryo or offspring fails to develop properly or dies prematurely.
- Hybrid sterility (reduced hybrid fertility): The hybrid offspring reaches maturity but cannot produce functional gametes (e.g., due to defective meiosis, abnormal gametogenesis, or chromosomal incompatibility).
- Hybrid breakdown: First-generation () hybrids are viable and fertile, but subsequent generations ( or backcrosses) are weak or sterile.
In this experiment, the males survive to adulthood but are unable to produce functional sperm due to abnormal spermatogenesis. Because these offspring are fully viable yet reproductively non-functional, the operating mechanism is hybrid sterility (or hybrid infertility).
Determining the Genetic Principle for Heterogametic Infertility
In interspecific crosses, when only one sex among the hybrid progeny is inviable or sterile, it is almost universally the heterogametic sex—the sex with two different sex chromosomes (such as males in fruit flies and mammals, or females in birds and butterflies).
This empirical evolutionary observation is known as Haldane's Rule (formulated by J.B.S. Haldane in 1922):
"When in the offspring of two different animal races one sex is absent, rare, or sterile, that sex is the heterozygous [heterogametic] sex."
In fruit flies (), males are heterogametic () and females are homogametic (). Recessive incompatibility alleles on the chromosome from one species interact poorly with autosomal or cytoplasmic factors from the other species; in males, these hemizygous -linked incompatibilities are fully expressed because there is no homologous counterpart to mask them. Thus, sterility is restricted to males via Haldane's Rule.
Identifying the Barrier in the Reciprocal Cross
When male embryos in the reciprocal cross fail to hatch and die during early development, the postzygotic barrier is no longer related to adult gamete production. Because development is arrested before adulthood, the mechanism is hybrid inviability (or hybrid lethality). Under Haldane's rule, the expression of incompatibilities can manifest either as inviability or sterility, depending on the specific epistatic genetic interactions involved in the cross.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Conflating hybrid inviability and hybrid sterility: Inviability pertains to survival/developmental failure, while sterility pertains to gamete production failure in surviving adults.
- Misidentifying the heterogametic sex across systems: In mammals and Drosophila, males are heterogametic (). In birds, reptiles, and lepidopterans (butterflies and moths), females are the heterogametic sex () and would be the sex affected under Haldane's Rule.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses hybrid breakdown with hybrid sterility, mistakenly believing that failure in only one sex or postzygotic failure in F1 represents hybrid breakdown.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
a) Hybrid breakdown
Correct(a) Hybrid sterility (or hybrid infertility)
The barrier affects the generation directly, where surviving adult males fail to produce functional sperm. Because the adult hybrid survives but cannot reproduce, this is hybrid sterility. Hybrid breakdown only applies when the generation is fully viable and fertile, but defects emerge in the or backcross generations.
- Step 2
b) Haldane's rule
- Step 3
c) Hybrid inviability
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized Haldane's rule as governing the heterogametic sex bias in hybrid sterility and inviability.
You accurately identified hybrid inviability when developmental arrest occurs prior to hatching.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo; this reflects a conceptual misunderstanding of the generation in which hybrid breakdown manifests.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused hybrid breakdown with hybrid sterility, likely interpreting the partial cohort fertility () or sex-specific failure in the generation as a 'breakdown' rather than recognizing that hybrid breakdown strictly requires fertile parents producing defective or backcross offspring.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Generational Timing of Postzygotic Barriers
If reproductive or developmental failure happens directly in the first generation (), it is either hybrid inviability (fails to reach maturity) or hybrid sterility (matures but cannot form viable gametes). Hybrid breakdown only occurs in or backcross generations after fertile hybrids mate.
Check which generation exhibits the defect: an infertile adult individual is an example of hybrid sterility, not hybrid breakdown.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the generation in which the reproductive barrier appears: here, it occurs directly in the male offspring.
Evaluate the survival and reproductive status of these individuals: they survive to adulthood, but their spermatogenesis is defective, rendering them unable to produce fertile gametes.
Classify the mechanism based on adult gametic failure in : adult viability combined with gametic infertility defines hybrid sterility.
(a) Hybrid sterility (or hybrid infertility)
02 The student confuses Haldane's rule with the Dobzhansky-Muller incompatibility model, naming the molecular mechanism of negative epistatic interactions rather than the rule describing the heterogametic sex pattern.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Hybrid sterility
- Step 2
Dobzhansky-Muller model
CorrectHaldane's Rule
You provided the Dobzhansky–Muller incompatibility model, which describes the general epistatic mechanism of postzygotic isolation. However, the specific biological rule stating that hybrid sterility or inviability preferentially strikes the heterogametic ( or ) sex is Haldane's rule.
- Step 3
Hybrid inviability
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou accurately identified hybrid sterility when surviving adult hybrids fail gametogenesis.
You correctly identified hybrid inviability when developmental arrest occurs during the embryonic stage.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou recalled the molecular mechanism explaining how hybrid incompatibilities evolve, but applied it where the prompt asked for the sex-specific empirical rule.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating the genetic basis of incompatibility with the pattern of sex-biased hybrid breakdown. The Dobzhansky–Muller incompatibility (DMI) model explains how neutral or adaptive lineage-specific mutations interact negatively upon hybridization without intermediate fitness valleys. Haldane's rule specifically describes the observation that whenever one sex in an hybrid cross is sterile or inviable, it is predominantly the heterogametic sex ( males or females), primarily driven by the dominance theory of hemizygous - or -linked incompatibilities.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Rule vs. Model Distinction
Haldane's rule names the empirical pattern of heterogametic vulnerability ( males or females suffer sterility or inviability first).
Check whether the question focuses on the sex bias ( vs. ) or on general two-locus epistatic incompatibilities across populations.
- Hemizygosity and Dominance
In heterogametic hybrids (), recessive deleterious -linked alleles from one species are exposed hemizygously because there is no homologous counterpart to mask them.
Associate heterogametic hybrid breakdown directly with J.B.S. Haldane's classic 1922 formulation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationObserve that the prompt specifically highlights sterility restricted to the heterogametic () male sex while homogametic () females remain fertile.
Recall that J.B.S. Haldane formulated the rule: 'When in the offspring of two different animal races one sex is absent, rare, or sterile, that sex is the heterogametic sex.'
Name Haldane's Rule as the classic biological principle accounting for this pattern.
(a) Hybrid sterility. (b) Haldane's Rule. (c) Hybrid inviability.
03 The student confuses hybrid inviability with gametic isolation, inappropriately applying a prezygotic barrier concept to post-fertilization embryonic death.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
a) Hybrid sterility
- Step 2
b) Haldane's rule
- Step 3
c) Gametic mortality
CorrectHybrid inviability (or hybrid lethality)
Gametic mortality is a prezygotic barrier where gametes fail to survive or fuse before fertilization. Because male embryos formed and subsequently died prior to hatching, fertilization had already occurred, making this postzygotic barrier hybrid inviability.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified the reproductive isolation in adult flies as hybrid sterility.
You correctly identified Haldane's rule as the genetic principle explaining heterogametic male sterility.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused prezygotic barriers affecting unfertilized gametes with postzygotic barriers affecting the survival of developing zygotes and embryos. Because the question specifies that embryos formed before dying, fertilization has already succeeded, meaning the barrier is hybrid inviability rather than gametic mortality.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish Prezygotic from Postzygotic Barriers
A barrier is prezygotic if it prevents mating or fertilization (such as gametic isolation/mortality), and postzygotic if it acts after fertilization has formed a zygote (such as hybrid inviability, hybrid sterility, or hybrid breakdown).
Check whether a zygote or embryo was formed. If an embryo exists and dies during development, classify the barrier as hybrid inviability.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the timing of reproductive failure: fertilization successfully produced embryos, which then died prior to hatching.
Classify by category: because fertilization occurred, the mechanism must be postzygotic.
Identify the specific postzygotic barrier: embryonic death during development corresponds to hybrid inviability (or hybrid lethality).
(a) Hybrid sterility. (b) Haldane's Rule. (c) Hybrid inviability (or hybrid lethality).
Lock it in
What distinguishes hybrid sterility from hybrid breakdown?
Hybrid sterility affects the generation directly (viable adults cannot reproduce), whereas hybrid breakdown occurs only in or backcross generations from fertile parents.
Similar question
Two species of cotton plants are crossed. The resulting hybrid plants are vigorous, healthy, and fully fertile. However, when these plants self-pollinate, the resulting seedlings are stunted and die before producing seeds. Identify the specific postzygotic isolating mechanism operating here.
Answer
Hybrid breakdown. Key steps: (1) Observe that the generation is fully viable and fertile; (2) Note that developmental failure and inviability first appear in the generation; (3) Failure in or backcross generations following a fertile is specifically defined as hybrid breakdown.
In a cross between two species of silkworm, all male moths () are viable and fertile, whereas all female moths () die during pupal metamorphosis before emerging as adults. (a) Name the postzygotic isolating barrier observed. (b) Explain how this outcome conforms to Haldane's rule.
Answer
(a) Hybrid inviability. (b) In silkworms, females are the heterogametic sex (). Haldane's rule dictates that when one sex of an interspecific cross is inviable or sterile, it is predominantly the heterogametic sex; here, only the heterogametic females fail to survive metamorphosis.
In a mammalian hybrid cross, females () are fertile, but males () produce motile sperm that carry severe chromosomal missegregations, resulting in viable zygotes when mated with parental females. Simultaneously, females backcrossed to parental males produce viable, fertile offspring. Classify the barrier affecting the males and contrast why this is not considered hybrid breakdown.
Answer
The barrier is hybrid sterility. Key steps: (1) The defect directly impairs the gametic transmission and reproductive success of the adult male, meeting the definition of hybrid sterility. (2) It is not hybrid breakdown because the breakdown definition requires successful reproduction by individuals leading to weak or sterile or backcross progeny; the sterile males cannot produce an generation at all.