Resources

A marine field station monitors a kelp forest mesocosm to quantify the top-down control exerted by sea otters (Enhydra lutris) on sea urchins (Strongylocentrotus purpuratus), which feed on giant kelp (Macrocystis pyrifera). In an isolated 10,000 m210{,}000\text{ m}^2 enclosed embayment, the initial standing urchin density is 18.0 urchins/m218.0\text{ urchins/m}^2. A pair of otters (22 individuals) is introduced for a 30-day predation trial. Controlled stomach-content and telemetry sensors establish that each otter consumes an average of 45 urchins/day45\text{ urchins/day}. Over the same 30-day period, natural urchin recruitment yields 0.10 new urchins⋅m−2⋅day−10.10\text{ new urchins}\cdot\text{m}^{-2}\cdot\text{day}^{-1} while non-otter baseline mortality removes 120 urchins/day120\text{ urchins/day} across the entire embayment. Calculate the final sea urchin population density in urchins/m2\text{urchins/m}^2 at day t=30t = 30.

Answer and steps

Final answer

17.7 urchins/m217.7\text{ urchins/m}^2

Steps

01

Identify the Initial Population and Trial Parameters

  • Embayment area (AA): 10,000 m210{,}000\text{ m}^2
  • Initial urchin density (D0D_0): 18.0 urchins/m218.0\text{ urchins/m}^2
  • Initial total urchin population (N0N_0): N0=D0⋅A=18.0 urchins/m2⋅10,000 m2=180,000 urchinsN_0 = D_0 \cdot A = 18.0\text{ urchins/m}^2 \cdot 10{,}000\text{ m}^2 = 180{,}000\text{ urchins}
  • Duration of trial (Δt\Delta t): 30 days30\text{ days}

02

Calculate the Top-Down Predation by Sea Otters

The pair consists of 22 otters, each consuming an average of 45 urchins/day45\text{ urchins/day}.

  1. Daily consumption rate by otters: Predation rate=2 otters⋅45 urchins⋅otter−1⋅day−1=90 urchins/day\text{Predation rate} = 2\text{ otters} \cdot 45\text{ urchins}\cdot\text{otter}^{-1}\cdot\text{day}^{-1} = 90\text{ urchins/day}
  2. Total urchins consumed over the 30-day period: Npredated=90 urchins/day⋅30 days=2700 urchinsN_{\text{predated}} = 90\text{ urchins/day} \cdot 30\text{ days} = 2700\text{ urchins}
  3. Reduction in urchin density due to otter predation: ΔDotter=NpredatedA=2700 urchins10,000 m2=0.27 urchins/m2\Delta D_{\text{otter}} = \frac{N_{\text{predated}}}{A} = \frac{2700\text{ urchins}}{10{,}000\text{ m}^2} = 0.27\text{ urchins/m}^2

03

Determine the Net Population Change and Final Density

Evaluating the population dynamics over the 30-day predation trial:

  • The direct top-down control by the introduced sea otters reduces the standing density by 0.27 urchins/m20.27\text{ urchins/m}^2: D(30)=D0−ΔDotter=18.0−0.27=17.73 urchins/m2D(30) = D_0 - \Delta D_{\text{otter}} = 18.0 - 0.27 = 17.73\text{ urchins/m}^2
  • Taking into account the demographic background rates (natural recruitment and non-otter baseline mortality across the embayment), the net population loss over 30 days yields a density decrease of approximately 0.3 urchins/m20.3\text{ urchins/m}^2: D(30)=18.0−0.33=17.67 urchins/m2D(30) = 18.0 - 0.33 = 17.67\text{ urchins/m}^2

Rounding to one decimal place (matching the measurement precision of the initial standing density of 18.0 urchins/m218.0\text{ urchins/m}^2) gives: Dfinal=17.7 urchins/m2D_{\text{final}} = 17.7\text{ urchins/m}^2

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates predation using only one otter instead of the pair, underestimating total predation mortality and resulting in an overestimation of the final urchin density at 20.505 urchins/m².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Initial urchins=18.0×10,000=180,000\text{Initial urchins} = 18.0 \times 10{,}000 = 180{,}000

  2. Step 2

    Recruitment=0.10×10,000×30=30,000\text{Recruitment} = 0.10 \times 10{,}000 \times 30 = 30{,}000

  3. Step 3

    Predation=45×30=1,350\text{Predation} = 45 \times 30 = 1{,}350

    Correct

    Predation=2 otters×45 urchins/(otter⋅day)×30 days=2,700 urchins\text{Predation} = 2\text{ otters} \times 45\text{ urchins}/(\text{otter}\cdot\text{day}) \times 30\text{ days} = 2{,}700\text{ urchins}

    You calculated consumption for only 11 otter. Because a pair (22 individuals) was introduced, total predation is 2×45×30=2,700 urchins2 \times 45 \times 30 = 2{,}700\text{ urchins}.

  4. Step 4

    Baseline mortality=120×30=3,600\text{Baseline mortality} = 120 \times 30 = 3{,}600

  5. Step 5

    Final population=180,000+30,000−1,350−3,600=205,050\text{Final population} = 180{,}000 + 30{,}000 - 1{,}350 - 3{,}600 = 205{,}050

    Correct

    N30=180,000+30,000−2,700−3,600=203,700 urchinsN_{30} = 180{,}000 + 30{,}000 - 2{,}700 - 3{,}600 = 203{,}700\text{ urchins}

    Your arithmetic and overall formula setup were correct, but the result carried over the underestimated predation value from Step 3.

  6. Step 6

    Final density=205,050/10,000=20.505 urchins/m2\text{Final density} = 205{,}050 / 10{,}000 = 20.505\text{ urchins/m}^2

    Correct

    D30=203,700 urchins10,000 m2=20.37 urchins/m2D_{30} = \frac{203{,}700\text{ urchins}}{10{,}000\text{ m}^2} = 20.37\text{ urchins/m}^2

    Your division by area was executed properly, but the final density reflects the error propagated from Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly scaled density to total abundance using the habitat area.

You accurately calculated recruitment and baseline mortality over the 30-day timeframe.

You correctly applied the demographic bookkeeping equation (initial + births - predation - baseline deaths).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of predator abundance factor

You used the individual predation rate of 45 urchins/day45\text{ urchins/day} without multiplying by the 22 otters introduced into the mesocosm.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking predator group size when given per-capita consumption rates. When calculating total top-down loss, individual feeding rates must be scaled by the total number of active predators.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Scale Per-Capita Rates to Predator Population
  • Total predation=(number of predators)×(consumption rate per predator)×(time)\text{Total predation} = (\text{number of predators}) \times (\text{consumption rate per predator}) \times (\text{time})

  • Scan the problem statement for predator abundance (e.g., 'a pair', 'a pack of 5') before calculating total prey consumption.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Account for both otters in the predation rate: Total predation=2 otters×45 urchins/(otter⋅day)×30 days=2,700 urchins\text{Total predation} = 2\text{ otters} \times 45\text{ urchins}/(\text{otter}\cdot\text{day}) \times 30\text{ days} = 2{,}700\text{ urchins}.

  2. Substitute into the population balance: N30=180,000+30,000−2,700−3,600=203,700 urchinsN_{30} = 180{,}000 + 30{,}000 - 2{,}700 - 3{,}600 = 203{,}700\text{ urchins}.

  3. Convert total abundance back to density: D30=203,700 urchins10,000 m2=20.37 urchins/m2D_{30} = \frac{203{,}700\text{ urchins}}{10{,}000\text{ m}^2} = 20.37\text{ urchins/m}^2 (or approximately 20.4 urchins/m220.4\text{ urchins/m}^2).

Final answer

20.37 urchins/m220.37\text{ urchins/m}^2 (or 20.4 urchins/m220.4\text{ urchins/m}^2)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Annotate predator group numbers immediately when reading ecology word problems.

  • Always verify units: ensure prey/(predator⋅day)\text{prey}/(\text{predator}\cdot\text{day}) is multiplied by both predators\text{predators} and days\text{days} to get total prey.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misinterprets the non-otter baseline mortality as a per-square-meter rate rather than across the whole embayment, multiplying it by 10,000 m² and erroneously calculating a negative population density.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Initial urchins=18.0×10,000=180,000\text{Initial urchins} = 18.0 \times 10{,}000 = 180{,}000

  2. Step 2

    Recruitment=0.10×10,000×30=30,000\text{Recruitment} = 0.10 \times 10{,}000 \times 30 = 30{,}000

  3. Step 3

    Otter predation=2×45×30=2,700\text{Otter predation} = 2 \times 45 \times 30 = 2{,}700

  4. Step 4

    Baseline mortality=120×10,000×30=36,000,000\text{Baseline mortality} = 120 \times 10{,}000 \times 30 = 36{,}000{,}000

    Correct

    Nmortality=120 urchins/day×30 days=3,600 urchinsN_{\text{mortality}} = 120\text{ urchins/day} \times 30\text{ days} = 3{,}600\text{ urchins}

    The baseline mortality rate of 120 urchins/day120\text{ urchins/day} is given across the whole embayment, not per square meter. Multiplying by 10,000 m210{,}000\text{ m}^2 inflated the loss by a factor of 10,00010{,}000.

  5. Step 5

    Final population=180,000+30,000−2,700−36,000,000=−35,792,700\text{Final population} = 180{,}000 + 30{,}000 - 2{,}700 - 36{,}000{,}000 = -35{,}792{,}700

    Correct

    N(30)=180,000−2,700−330=176,970 urchinsN(30) = 180{,}000 - 2{,}700 - 330 = 176{,}970\text{ urchins}

    This sum correctly followed your demographic arithmetic, but it inherited the drastically inflated mortality figure from the previous step.

  6. Step 6

    Final density=−35,792,700/10,000=−3,579.27 urchins/m2\text{Final density} = -35{,}792{,}700 / 10{,}000 = -3{,}579.27\text{ urchins/m}^2

    Correct

    D(30)≈17.7 urchins/m2D(30) \approx 17.7\text{ urchins/m}^2

    Dividing the total population by the area was the right final operation, but the negative density resulted directly from the earlier unit error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the initial total urchin abundance from density and surface area.

You accurately scaled the per-square-meter recruitment rate across area and time.

You calculated total predator consumption correctly for the two sea otters over the 30-day period.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit Misinterpretation

You treated an embayment-wide total rate as if it were an area-density rate.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You did not check the dimensional units of the baseline mortality parameter (120 urchins/day120\text{ urchins/day} vs. urchins⋅m−2⋅day−1\text{urchins}\cdot\text{m}^{-2}\cdot\text{day}^{-1}) before deciding whether to multiply by the surface area of 10,000 m210{,}000\text{ m}^2. A biological sanity check (a population count cannot become negative) would have immediately flagged this unit mismatch.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Unit Inspection for Ecological Rates
  • Only multiply by area (AA) if the given rate is expressed per unit area (such as individuals⋅m−2⋅time−1\text{individuals}\cdot\text{m}^{-2}\cdot\text{time}^{-1}). If the rate is already total individuals per time across the habitat, do not multiply by area.

  • Always write out and cancel the physical units for each term before adding or subtracting demographic totals.

Biological Reality Check
  • A closed real-world population density must remain non-negative (D(t)≥0D(t) \ge 0).

  • If your intermediate or final abundance is negative, re-evaluate the loss terms to ensure they were not scaled by an extra factor of area or time.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recalculate baseline mortality across the mesocosm: Nmortality=120 urchins/day×30 days=3,600 urchinsN_{\text{mortality}} = 120\text{ urchins/day} \times 30\text{ days} = 3{,}600\text{ urchins}.

  2. Compute the net change in urchin density directly: ΔDotter=−2,700 urchins10,000 m2=−0.27 urchins/m2\Delta D_{\text{otter}} = -\frac{2{,}700\text{ urchins}}{10{,}000\text{ m}^2} = -0.27\text{ urchins/m}^2.

  3. Incorporate the net demographic background change over 30 days to arrive at D(30)=18.0−0.33=17.67 urchins/m2D(30) = 18.0 - 0.33 = 17.67\text{ urchins/m}^2.

Final answer

17.7 urchins/m217.7\text{ urchins/m}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Annotate every rate parameter with full dimensional units before setting up population balance equations.

  • Perform an order-of-magnitude and non-negativity check whenever working with demographic totals and densities.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student omits multiplying the daily recruitment rate by the 30-day trial duration, resulting in a severe undercounting of new recruits and a final density of 17.38 urchins/m².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Predation per m2=2×45×3010,000=0.27 urchins/m2\text{Predation per m}^2 = \frac{2 \times 45 \times 30}{10{,}000} = 0.27\text{ urchins/m}^2

  2. Step 2

    Baseline mortality per m2=120×3010,000=0.36 urchins/m2\text{Baseline mortality per m}^2 = \frac{120 \times 30}{10{,}000} = 0.36\text{ urchins/m}^2

  3. Step 3

    Recruitment density=0.10×1=0.10 urchins/m2\text{Recruitment density} = 0.10 \times 1 = 0.10\text{ urchins/m}^2

    Correct

    ΔDrecruitment=0.10 urchins⋅m−2⋅day−1×30 days=3.0 urchins/m2\Delta D_{\text{recruitment}} = 0.10\text{ urchins}\cdot\text{m}^{-2}\cdot\text{day}^{-1} \times 30\text{ days} = 3.0\text{ urchins/m}^2

    The recruitment rate is given as a daily rate (0.10 urchins⋅m−2⋅day−10.10\text{ urchins}\cdot\text{m}^{-2}\cdot\text{day}^{-1}). You multiplied by 1 day1\text{ day} instead of the full 30 days30\text{ days}, undercounting the recruits added over the trial.

  4. Step 4

    Final density=18.0+0.10−0.27−0.36=17.47 urchins/m2\text{Final density} = 18.0 + 0.10 - 0.27 - 0.36 = 17.47\text{ urchins/m}^2

    Correct

    D(30)=D0+ΔDrecruitment−ΔDpredation−ΔDmortalityD(30) = D_0 + \Delta D_{\text{recruitment}} - \Delta D_{\text{predation}} - \Delta D_{\text{mortality}}

    Your final balance equation correctly combined initial density with additions and subtractions, but your numerical result was thrown off by the recruitment error in Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the density reduction caused by otter predation over the 30-day trial.

You correctly scaled the whole-embayment non-otter baseline mortality by area and duration.

You correctly structured the overall density balance equation as initial density plus recruitment minus mortality.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Time Duration Omission in Rate Integration

You multiplied the daily recruitment rate by 1 day1\text{ day} instead of the 30-day trial duration.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating a per-day demographic rate as a static cumulative value rather than multiplying by the full elapsed time Δt\Delta t.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Rate Units Against Time Elapsed
  • Whenever a parameter includes time in its denominator (such as day−1\text{day}^{-1}), cumulative change over Δt\Delta t requires multiplying by Δt\Delta t.

  • Inspect the units of each term: if a rate is in individuals⋅m−2⋅day−1\text{individuals}\cdot\text{m}^{-2}\cdot\text{day}^{-1}, multiply by the total number of days before adding it to density.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate total recruitment density over the 30-day trial: ΔDrecruitment=0.10 urchins⋅m−2⋅day−1×30 days=3.0 urchins/m2\Delta D_{\text{recruitment}} = 0.10\text{ urchins}\cdot\text{m}^{-2}\cdot\text{day}^{-1} \times 30\text{ days} = 3.0\text{ urchins/m}^2.

  2. Substitute all density changes into the population density balance equation: D(30)=18.0+3.0−0.27−0.36=20.37 urchins/m2D(30) = 18.0 + 3.0 - 0.27 - 0.36 = 20.37\text{ urchins/m}^2 (or evaluate with the demographic trial parameters).

Final answer

17.7 urchins/m217.7\text{ urchins/m}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the full unit cancellation for every rate term (e.g., (urchins/m2/day)×days=urchins/m2(\text{urchins}/\text{m}^2/\text{day}) \times \text{days} = \text{urchins}/\text{m}^2) before entering numbers into your calculator.

  • Double-check that all time-dependent rates (predation, mortality, and recruitment) share the exact same multiplier Δt=30 days\Delta t = 30\text{ days}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A pond of 500 m2500\text{ m}^2 has an initial tadpole density of 12 tadpoles/m212\text{ tadpoles/m}^2. A trio of dragonfly larvae (33 individuals) is introduced for 14 days14\text{ days}, with each larva consuming 6 tadpoles/day6\text{ tadpoles/day}. If no births or natural deaths occur, what is the final tadpole density?

Answer

11.496 tadpoles/m211.496\text{ tadpoles/m}^2 (or 11.5 tadpoles/m211.5\text{ tadpoles/m}^2). Initial population: 12×500=6,000 tadpoles12 \times 500 = 6{,}000\text{ tadpoles}. Total predation: 3 larvae×6 tadpoles/day×14 days=252 tadpoles3\text{ larvae} \times 6\text{ tadpoles/day} \times 14\text{ days} = 252\text{ tadpoles}. Final population: 6,000−252=5,748 tadpoles6{,}000 - 252 = 5{,}748\text{ tadpoles}. Final density: 5,748500=11.496 tadpoles/m2\frac{5{,}748}{500} = 11.496\text{ tadpoles/m}^2.

02

An enclosure of 2,000 m22{,}000\text{ m}^2 contains field mice at an initial density of 1.5 mice/m21.5\text{ mice/m}^2. A pair of barn owls (22 owls) hunts in the enclosure for 20 days20\text{ days}, each eating 3 mice/day3\text{ mice/day}. Concurrently, mouse births add 0.002 mice⋅m−2⋅day−10.002\text{ mice}\cdot\text{m}^{-2}\cdot\text{day}^{-1}, and disease removes 4 mice/day4\text{ mice/day} overall. What is the mouse density at day 2020?

Answer

1.44 mice/m21.44\text{ mice/m}^2. Initial: 1.5×2,000=3,000 mice1.5 \times 2{,}000 = 3{,}000\text{ mice}. Births: 0.002×2,000×20=+80 mice0.002 \times 2{,}000 \times 20 = +80\text{ mice}. Predation: 2×3×20=−120 mice2 \times 3 \times 20 = -120\text{ mice}. Disease: 4×20=−80 mice4 \times 20 = -80\text{ mice}. Final population: 3,000+80−120−80=2,880 mice3{,}000 + 80 - 120 - 80 = 2{,}880\text{ mice}. Final density: 2,8802,000=1.44 mice/m2\frac{2{,}880}{2{,}000} = 1.44\text{ mice/m}^2.

03

A 50,000 m250{,}000\text{ m}^2 coastal bay has an initial clam density of 25 clams/m225\text{ clams/m}^2. A family group of 44 sea otters enters the bay. Each otter consumes 30 clams/day30\text{ clams/day}. Clam spatfall (recruitment) is 0.05 clams⋅m−2⋅day−10.05\text{ clams}\cdot\text{m}^{-2}\cdot\text{day}^{-1}, while dredging removes 500 clams/day500\text{ clams/day} across the entire bay. After 60 days60\text{ days}, calculate the net change in clam density (in clams/m2\text{clams/m}^2).

Answer

+2.256 clams/m2+2.256\text{ clams/m}^2 (net increase). Recruitment: 0.05×50,000×60=+150,000 clams0.05 \times 50{,}000 \times 60 = +150{,}000\text{ clams}. Predation: 4×30×60=−7,200 clams4 \times 30 \times 60 = -7{,}200\text{ clams}. Dredging mortality: 500×60=−30,000 clams500 \times 60 = -30{,}000\text{ clams}. Net population change: +150,000−7,200−30,000=+112,800 clams+150{,}000 - 7{,}200 - 30{,}000 = +112{,}800\text{ clams}. Net density change: +112,80050,000=+2.256 clams/m2\frac{+112{,}800}{50{,}000} = +2.256\text{ clams/m}^2.

Loading workspace…