Resources

In a social carnivore pack, a full sibling (r=0.50r = 0.50) engages in sentinel behavior that warns the group of approaching predators. Field observations establish that this cooperative warning behavior is evolutionarily stable and strictly favored by kin selection, generating a net inclusive fitness gain of ΔWinclusive=0.46\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = 0.46 units, where ΔWinclusive=rb−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = r b - c. Post-fledging survival monitoring indicates that the recipient sibling receives a direct fitness benefit of b=1.40b = 1.40 units of reproductive output. Work backward to determine the exact personal reproductive cost cc incurred by the sentinel individual.

Answer and steps

Final answer

The personal reproductive cost incurred by the sentinel is c=0.240 units of reproductive successc = 0.240\text{ units of reproductive success}.

Steps

Understanding Inclusive Fitness and Hamilton's Rule

According to kin selection theory and Hamilton's framework, an altruistic or cooperative behavior is favored by natural selection when it increases the actor's inclusive fitness.

The net inclusive fitness gain (ΔWinclusive\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}}) resulting from such an interaction is defined as: ΔWinclusive=rb−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = r b - c

Where:

  • rr is the coefficient of relatedness between the actor (the sentinel) and the recipient.
  • bb is the direct fitness benefit gained by the recipient.
  • rbr b represents the indirect fitness benefit gained by the actor through the recipient's increased reproductive success.
  • cc is the direct fitness cost (personal reproductive cost) incurred by the actor.

Step-by-Step Calculation

  1. Identify the given parameters:

    • Relatedness between full siblings: r=0.50r = 0.50
    • Benefit to the recipient sibling: b=1.40 unitsb = 1.40\text{ units}
    • Net inclusive fitness gain: ΔWinclusive=0.46 units\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = 0.46\text{ units}
  2. Rearrange the inclusive fitness equation to isolate the cost (cc): ΔWinclusive=rb−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = r b - c c=rb−ΔWinclusivec = r b - \Delta W_{\text{inclusive}}
  3. Calculate the indirect fitness benefit (rbr b): rb=0.50⋅1.40=0.70 unitsr b = 0.50 \cdot 1.40 = 0.70\text{ units}
  4. Solve for the personal reproductive cost (cc): c=0.70−0.46=0.240 unitsc = 0.70 - 0.46 = 0.240\text{ units}

Key Takeaway and Pitfall to Avoid

  • Common Pitfall: A frequent error is directly subtracting the net fitness gain from the total recipient benefit (1.40−0.461.40 - 0.46), forgetting that the recipient's reproductive benefit must first be devalued by the coefficient of relatedness (rr). The actor only shares half of their genes with a full sibling (r=0.50r = 0.50), meaning that 1.401.40 units of benefit to the sibling translates to an indirect benefit of only 0.700.70 units to the sentinel.
  • Because the indirect benefit (0.700.70) exceeds the personal cost (0.2400.240), the sentinel behavior yields a positive net inclusive fitness change (ΔWinclusive=+0.46\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = +0.46), satisfying Hamilton's rule (rb>cr b > c) and driving the evolutionary persistence of sentinel behavior.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student adds the net inclusive fitness gain to the indirect benefit instead of subtracting it when rearranging for c, obtaining c = 1.16.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔWinclusive=rb−c  ⟹  0.46=0.50×1.40−c  ⟹  0.46=0.70−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = rb - c \implies 0.46 = 0.50 \times 1.40 - c \implies 0.46 = 0.70 - c

  2. Step 2

    c=0.70+0.46c = 0.70 + 0.46

    Correct

    c=0.70−0.46c = 0.70 - 0.46

    When rearranging 0.46=0.70−c0.46 = 0.70 - c to solve for cc, you added 0.460.46 to 0.700.70 instead of subtracting it.

  3. Step 3

    c=1.16 unitsc = 1.16\text{ units}

    Correct

    c=0.24 unitsc = 0.24\text{ units}

    This final numerical value is incorrect as a direct consequence of the sign error in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and wrote down Hamilton's inclusive fitness formula ΔWinclusive=rb−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = rb - c.

You properly substituted the given values and calculated the indirect fitness benefit as rb=0.50×1.40=0.70rb = 0.50 \times 1.40 = 0.70 units.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error when isolating a subtracted variable

You added 0.460.46 to 0.700.70 instead of subtracting 0.460.46 from 0.700.70 when solving for cc.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When rearranging an equation of the form A=B−cA = B - c, isolating cc requires subtracting AA from BB (c=B−Ac = B - A). Misinterpreting the negative sign on cc led to adding the terms, producing a cost that exceeds the indirect benefit—which contradicts the premise that the behavior is favored by kin selection.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolating a subtracted term
  • For A=B−cA = B - c, add cc to both sides first (A+c=BA + c = B) and then subtract AA to obtain c=B−Ac = B - A.

  • Whenever solving for a variable with a negative coefficient, explicitly move it to the other side first before isolating it.

Biological sanity check with Hamilton's rule
  • If a behavior produces a positive net inclusive fitness gain (ΔWinclusive>0\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} > 0), the personal reproductive cost cc must be strictly less than the indirect benefit rbrb.

  • Compare your solved cost cc to rb=0.70rb = 0.70; finding c=1.16>0.70c = 1.16 > 0.70 immediately reveals that the net change would be negative, signaling an algebraic mistake.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Add cc to both sides of the equation: 0.46+c=0.700.46 + c = 0.70.

  2. Subtract 0.460.46 from both sides to isolate cc: c=0.70−0.46c = 0.70 - 0.46.

  3. Evaluate the difference: c=0.24 unitsc = 0.24\text{ units}.

Final answer

c=0.24 units of reproductive successc = 0.24\text{ units of reproductive success}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review linear equation rearrangements involving subtracted terms by writing out intermediate steps like A+c=BA + c = B.

  • Perform a quick qualitative check using Hamilton's rule: verify that c<rbc < rb whenever ΔWinclusive>0\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} > 0.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student ignores the coefficient of relatedness r and calculates cost directly as benefit minus net gain, yielding c = 0.94.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔWinclusive=b−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = b - c

    Correct

    ΔWinclusive=rb−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = r b - c

    You wrote the inclusive fitness formula without the coefficient of relatedness rr. Natural selection evaluates indirect fitness gains through shared genes, so the recipient's reproductive benefit bb must be multiplied by rr.

  2. Step 2

    0.46=1.40−c  ⟹  c=1.40−0.460.46 = 1.40 - c \implies c = 1.40 - 0.46

    Correct

    0.46=0.50×1.40−c  ⟹  c=0.70−0.460.46 = 0.50 \times 1.40 - c \implies c = 0.70 - 0.46

    Your algebraic rearrangement was clean, but substituting into the incomplete formula carried over the missing relatedness factor.

  3. Step 3

    c=0.94 unitsc = 0.94\text{ units}

    Correct

    c=0.240 unitsc = 0.240\text{ units}

    Because r=0.50r = 0.50 was omitted earlier, your final cost is overstated.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the cost cc subtracts from the overall fitness gain.

You carried out the algebraic rearrangement and subtraction accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted coefficient of relatedness

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the recipient's direct reproductive benefit as equivalent to the actor's indirect genetic gain, neglecting that benefits to relatives must be scaled by the coefficient of relatedness (rr) in Hamilton's inclusive fitness framework.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Weighting Benefits by Relatedness
  • Inclusive fitness change is ΔWinclusive=rb−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = r b - c, where indirect benefit is rbr b, not simply bb.

  • Always verify whether the benefit bb occurs in another individual; if so, scale it by rr before subtracting personal cost cc.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the full inclusive fitness expression: ΔWinclusive=rb−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = r b - c.

  2. Substitute the known values: 0.46=(0.50)(1.40)−c0.46 = (0.50)(1.40) - c.

  3. Calculate the actor's indirect benefit: rb=0.70r b = 0.70.

  4. Solve for the personal reproductive cost: c=0.70−0.46c = 0.70 - 0.46.

Final answer

c=0.240 unitsc = 0.240\text{ units}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Hamilton's rule and practice calculating indirect fitness as r×br \times b across different genealogical relationships.

  • Solve reverse kin-selection problems where you must isolate either rr, bb, or cc from net inclusive fitness.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student assumes Hamilton's rule threshold at neutrality where rb - c = 0, calculating cost as c = rb = 0.70 and ignoring the positive net gain.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    rb−c=0  ⟹  c=rbr b - c = 0 \implies c = r b

    Correct

    ΔWinclusive=rb−c=0.46  ⟹  c=rb−0.46\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = r b - c = 0.46 \implies c = r b - 0.46

    You set the net change in inclusive fitness to 00, which represents the neutral threshold for Hamilton's rule (rb=cr b = c). The problem states that the behavior provides a net gain of ΔWinclusive=0.46\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = 0.46, so you must set rb−c=0.46r b - c = 0.46.

  2. Step 2

    c=0.50×1.40  ⟹  c=0.70 unitsc = 0.50 \times 1.40 \implies c = 0.70\text{ units}

    Correct

    c=(0.50×1.40)−0.46=0.70−0.46=0.24 unitsc = (0.50 \times 1.40) - 0.46 = 0.70 - 0.46 = 0.24\text{ units}

    Your arithmetic evaluation 0.50×1.40=0.700.50 \times 1.40 = 0.70 was correct, but because the net gain was omitted from the formula, your final cost is overstated by 0.460.46.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the values for relatedness (r=0.50r = 0.50) and recipient benefit (b=1.40b = 1.40).

You accurately multiplied rr and bb to find the total indirect benefit of 0.700.70 units.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Neutrality threshold substituted for non-zero net fitness gain

You solved for the maximum threshold cost at which Hamilton's rule barely holds (rb−c=0r b - c = 0) rather than accounting for the non-zero net inclusive fitness gain.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the condition for evolutionary break-even (rb−c=0r b - c = 0) with scenarios where an empirical net inclusive fitness gain (ΔWinclusive>0\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} > 0) is measured and specified.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Inclusive Fitness Formula
  • Net inclusive fitness change is given by ΔWinclusive=rb−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = r b - c, which only equals 00 at exact evolutionary neutrality.

  • Always substitute the provided non-zero value for ΔWinclusive\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} before solving for the cost cc.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Start with the full inclusive fitness expression: ΔWinclusive=rb−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = r b - c.

  2. Rearrange to isolate the cost: c=rb−ΔWinclusivec = r b - \Delta W_{\text{inclusive}}.

  3. Substitute the given quantities: c=(0.50)(1.40)−0.46=0.70−0.46c = (0.50)(1.40) - 0.46 = 0.70 - 0.46.

Final answer

c=0.24 unitsc = 0.24\text{ units} (or 0.240 units0.240\text{ units})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Check whether an altruism problem gives a specific net fitness gain ΔW\Delta W or asks for a threshold maximum cost.

  • Practice isolating cc from ΔW=rb−c\Delta W = r b - c algebraically before plugging in numbers.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A prairie dog gives an alarm call to alert first cousins (r=0.125r = 0.125). The warning yields a cumulative direct benefit of b=3.20b = 3.20 reproductive units to the cousins and results in a net inclusive fitness gain of ΔWinclusive=0.15\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = 0.15 units for the caller. Calculate the personal reproductive cost cc incurred by the caller.

Answer

c=0.25 unitsc = 0.25\text{ units}. Key steps: Calculate indirect benefit rb=0.125×3.20=0.40rb = 0.125 \times 3.20 = 0.40. Rearrange ΔWinclusive=rb−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = rb - c to get c=rb−ΔWinclusive=0.40−0.15=0.25c = rb - \Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = 0.40 - 0.15 = 0.25.

02

In a cooperative bird species, a helper aids both parents in raising a brood of full siblings (r=0.50r = 0.50). Helping increases total sibling fledgling output by b=2.40b = 2.40 fledglings. The helper completely forfeits its own breeding attempt, incurring a direct personal cost of c=0.85c = 0.85 fledglings. Determine the net inclusive fitness change ΔWinclusive\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} and state whether helping behavior is favored by natural selection.

Answer

ΔWinclusive=+0.35 units\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = +0.35\text{ units}; helping is favored by natural selection. Key steps: Indirect benefit rb=0.50×2.40=1.20rb = 0.50 \times 2.40 = 1.20. Net inclusive fitness gain ΔWinclusive=rb−c=1.20−0.85=+0.35\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = rb - c = 1.20 - 0.85 = +0.35. Since ΔWinclusive>0\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} > 0 (or rb>crb > c), Hamilton's rule is satisfied.

03

An animal performs an altruistic act that aids two different relatives simultaneously: a full sibling (r1=0.50r_1 = 0.50) who receives benefit b1=1.20b_1 = 1.20, and a half-sibling (r2=0.25r_2 = 0.25) who receives benefit b2=1.60b_2 = 1.60. If the interaction yields a net inclusive fitness gain of ΔWinclusive=0.38\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = 0.38 units, determine the actor's personal reproductive cost cc.

Answer

c=0.62 unitsc = 0.62\text{ units}. Key steps: Generalized inclusive fitness is ΔWinclusive=∑(ribi)−c\Delta W_{\text{inclusive}} = \sum (r_i b_i) - c. Total indirect benefit is r1b1+r2b2=(0.50×1.20)+(0.25×1.60)=0.60+0.40=1.00r_1 b_1 + r_2 b_2 = (0.50 \times 1.20) + (0.25 \times 1.60) = 0.60 + 0.40 = 1.00. Rearrange for cost: c=1.00−0.38=0.62c = 1.00 - 0.38 = 0.62.

Loading workspace…