Resources

Two populations of sea urchins, StrongylocentrotusStrongylocentrotus purpuratuspurpuratus and StrongylocentrotusStrongylocentrotus franciscanusfranciscanus, release gametes synchronously into open seawater. Gametic isolation depends on the binding affinity of the sperm surface protein bindin to the egg surface receptor EBR1EBR1. Let the fertilization efficiency EfE_f as a function of bindin sequence divergence dd (expressed as percentage amino acid difference) be modeled by the threshold relationship Ef(d)=100−12.5dE_f(d) = 100 - 12.5 d for d≤8%d \le 8\%, and Ef(d)=0%E_f(d) = 0\% for d>8%d > 8\%. (a) Determine the minimum sequence divergence threshold dcritd_{\text{crit}} at which complete prezygotic gametic isolation (Ef=0%E_f = 0\%) is established. (b) If two morphologically indistinguishable populations exhibit a bindin divergence of d=6.4%d = 6.4\%, calculate the expected fertilization efficiency EfE_f between heterospecific gametes. (c) Classify this reproductive barrier as prezygotic or postzygotic, and explain its biochemical mechanism.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) dcrit=8.0%d_{\text{crit}} = 8.0\%. (b) Ef=20.0%E_f = 20.0\%. (c) Prezygotic gametic isolation; it prevents interspecific zygote formation via biochemical incompatibility between the sperm bindin protein and the egg vitelline envelope receptor EBR1EBR1.

Steps

(a) Minimum Sequence Divergence for Complete Isolation

Complete gametic isolation occurs when the fertilization efficiency drops to zero (Ef=0%E_f = 0\%).

Setting the model equation Ef(d)=100−12.5dE_f(d) = 100 - 12.5d equal to 00:

100−12.5d=0100 - 12.5d = 0

12.5d=10012.5d = 100

d=10012.5=8.0%d = \frac{100}{12.5} = 8.0\%

According to the piecewise model, Ef(d)=0%E_f(d) = 0\% for all d≥8%d \ge 8\%. Therefore, the minimum sequence divergence threshold required for complete gametic isolation is:

dcrit=8.0%d_{\text{crit}} = 8.0\%


(b) Fertilization Efficiency at d=6.4%d = 6.4\%

Because d=6.4%d = 6.4\% is less than the critical threshold of 8%8\%, we substitute d=6.4d = 6.4 into the linear relationship:

Ef(6.4)=100−12.5⋅6.4E_f(6.4) = 100 - 12.5 \cdot 6.4

Ef(6.4)=100−80.0=20.0%E_f(6.4) = 100 - 80.0 = 20.0\%

Thus, heterospecific gametes retain an expected cross-fertilization rate of 20.0%20.0\%, indicating an incomplete reproductive barrier between these populations.


(c) Classification and Biochemical Mechanism

  • Classification: Prezygotic barrier (specifically, gametic isolation).
  • Biochemical Mechanism: Broadcast-spawning marine organisms release sperm and eggs directly into seawater, where geographic and behavioral barriers cannot prevent interspecific contact. Instead, reproductive specificity relies on molecular recognition at the egg envelope. The sea urchin sperm head displays the species-specific adhesion protein bindin, which must bind with high affinity to the extracellular egg receptor EBR1EBR1 on the vitelline envelope.

    Amino acid sequence divergence in bindin alters its tertiary structure, reducing complementary non-covalent interactions (such as hydrophobic and electrostatic contacts) with EBR1EBR1. When divergence reaches or exceeds 8%8\%, the binding affinity becomes insufficient to trigger membrane fusion and egg activation, preventing zygote formation entirely.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the percentage value with its decimal fraction and substitutes 0.064 instead of 6.4 into the percentage-based formula.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    100−12.5d=0  ⟹  12.5d=100  ⟹  dcrit=8%100 - 12.5d = 0 \implies 12.5d = 100 \implies d_{\text{crit}} = 8\%

  2. Step 2

    d=0.064  ⟹  Ef=100−12.5(0.064)  ⟹  Ef=100−0.8=99.2%d = 0.064 \implies E_f = 100 - 12.5(0.064) \implies E_f = 100 - 0.8 = 99.2\%

    Correct

    Ef=100−12.5(6.4)=100−80.0=20.0%E_f = 100 - 12.5(6.4) = 100 - 80.0 = 20.0\%

    You converted d=6.4%d = 6.4\% into the decimal fraction 0.0640.064. However, the model definition specifies that dd is input directly as the percentage value (d=6.4d = 6.4), consistent with your calculation in part (a) where d=8d = 8 corresponds to 8%8\%.

  3. Step 3

    Prezygotic barrier. Bindin protein cannot bind to the EBR1 receptor, preventing fertilization.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set the efficiency equation to zero and solved for the threshold in part (a).

You correctly classified the reproductive barrier as prezygotic in part (c).

You accurately described the biochemical interaction between sperm bindin and egg EBR1EBR1 receptors.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit Conversion Error in Formula Input

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You converted a percentage value into its decimal form (0.0640.064) before plugging it into an empirical equation that already assumes input values in percentage form (d=6.4d = 6.4).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Verify Variable Units in Empirical Models
  • Check whether a formula expects percentage inputs as whole numbers (d=6.4d = 6.4) or decimal proportions (d=0.064d = 0.064). Look at other terms or constants in the formula to see the scale.

  • Notice that 100−12.5(8)=0100 - 12.5(8) = 0, which confirms that an 8%8\% divergence enters the formula as 88, not 0.080.08.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the unit convention of dd in Ef(d)=100−12.5dE_f(d) = 100 - 12.5d: since dcrit=8%d_{\text{crit}} = 8\%, we substitute d=6.4d = 6.4 directly without dividing by 100100.

  2. Calculate 12.5⋅6.4=80.012.5 \cdot 6.4 = 80.0.

  3. Subtract from 100100: Ef=100−80.0=20.0%E_f = 100 - 80.0 = 20.0\%.

Final answer

(a) dcrit=8.0%d_{\text{crit}} = 8.0\%. (b) Ef=20.0%E_f = 20.0\%. (c) Prezygotic barrier (gametic isolation); sequence divergence prevents sperm bindin from binding the egg vitelline receptor EBR1EBR1, blocking fertilization.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always cross-check your input scale in part (b) against your solution in part (a). Since 12.5×8=10012.5 \times 8 = 100, the formula requires dd as a percentage (6.46.4), not as a decimal (0.0640.064).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misclassifies gametic isolation as a postzygotic barrier because gametes have already been released into the environment.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    100−12.5d=0  ⟹  dcrit=8%100 - 12.5 d = 0 \implies d_{\text{crit}} = 8\%

  2. Step 2

    Ef=100−12.5(6.4)  ⟹  Ef=100−80=20%E_f = 100 - 12.5 (6.4) \implies E_f = 100 - 80 = 20\%

  3. Step 3

    Postzygotic barrier.\text{Postzygotic barrier.}

    Correct

    Prezygotic barrier (gametic isolation).\text{Prezygotic barrier (gametic isolation).}

    You classified this barrier as postzygotic, but because the barrier prevents fertilization from occurring, no zygote ever forms, making it prezygotic.

  4. Step 4

    Bindin fails to bind to the egg receptor EBR1, so fertilization cannot occur.\text{Bindin fails to bind to the egg receptor EBR1, so fertilization cannot occur.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the critical threshold dcrit=8%d_{\text{crit}} = 8\%.

You evaluated the piecewise model accurately at d=6.4%d = 6.4\%.

You explained the biochemical mechanism of bindin-EBR1 binding failure clearly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conceptual confusion between prezygotic and postzygotic barriers

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the barrier with an event occurring after gamete release rather than after zygote formation. In evolutionary biology, the dividing line between prezygotic and postzygotic barriers is the fusion of sperm and egg to form a single-celled diploid zygote, not the behavioral or physiological release of gametes.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Locating the Zygote Boundary
  • A barrier is prezygotic if it acts before or at the moment of fertilization (preventing zygote formation); it is postzygotic only if a hybrid zygote is actually formed.

  • Check whether a zygote forms: because gametic incompatibility blocks fertilization entirely, classify gametic isolation as prezygotic.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall the biological definition of a zygote: the single diploid cell resulting from the fusion of male and female pronuclei.

  2. Determine whether fertilization takes place: bindin and EBR1EBR1 fail to bind, so sperm and egg membranes never fuse and fertilization is blocked.

  3. Conclude that because no zygote is formed, the barrier is prezygotic gametic isolation.

Final answer

(a) dcrit=8.0%d_{\text{crit}} = 8.0\%. (b) Ef=20.0%E_f = 20.0\%. (c) Prezygotic gametic isolation; sequence divergence prevents bindin from binding egg receptor EBR1EBR1, blocking fertilization before a zygote can form.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the five major types of prezygotic barriers (habitat, temporal, behavioral, mechanical, and gametic) and notice that all five prevent the creation of a zygote.

  • Whenever classifying reproductive isolation, explicitly ask: 'Did sperm and egg fuse to create a zygote?'

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a species pair of abalone, cross-fertilization efficiency is modeled as F(s)=100−15sF(s) = 100 - 15s for s≤6.67%s \le 6.67\%, where ss is the percent sequence divergence of the sperm lysin protein. Calculate the expected cross-fertilization efficiency when s=4.0%s = 4.0\%.

Answer

Substitute s=4.0s = 4.0 directly into the percentage-scaled formula: F(4.0)=100−15(4.0)=100−60=40.0%F(4.0) = 100 - 15(4.0) = 100 - 60 = 40.0\%.

02

Two sympatric frog species release gametes in the same pond. Sperm chemotactic attraction efficiency to egg jelly coat peptides is given by A(d)=100−8.0dA(d) = 100 - 8.0d (in percent), where dd is the percent amino acid divergence of the receptor peptide. Determine: (a) the minimum divergence dcritd_{\text{crit}} for 0%0\% attraction, and (b) whether a population with d=10.5%d = 10.5\% exhibits prezygotic or postzygotic isolation.

Answer

(a) Set 100−8.0d=0  ⟹  dcrit=12.5%100 - 8.0d = 0 \implies d_{\text{crit}} = 12.5\%. (b) Prezygotic isolation (specifically gametic or behavioral/chemical prevention of fertilization), because divergence prevents gamete meeting and fertilization prior to zygote formation.

03

In a hybrid zone between two broadcast-spawning coral species, prezygotic gametic compatibility is modeled by C(d)=100−25dC(d) = 100 - 25d, where dd is sequence divergence in percent. If heterospecific crosses produce viable, fertile F1F_1 colonies with an overall hybrid fitness of 90%90\% compared to parentals, what is the total reproductive isolation RI=1−(C/100×Whybrid)RI = 1 - (C/100 \times W_{\text{hybrid}}) when d=2.4%d = 2.4\%?

Answer

First calculate gametic compatibility: C(2.4)=100−25(2.4)=100−60=40%C(2.4) = 100 - 25(2.4) = 100 - 60 = 40\%. Then compute relative gene flow through both barriers: 40%×90%=0.40×0.90=0.3640\% \times 90\% = 0.40 \times 0.90 = 0.36. Total reproductive isolation is RI=1−0.36=0.64RI = 1 - 0.36 = 0.64 (or 64%64\%).

Loading workspace…