Resources

A mainland-island model of gene flow involves a continental beetle population with a fixed dark-shell allele frequency pm=0.85p_m = 0.85. The island population initially has a lower frequency of this allele. Over a single generation, unidirectional migration occurs from mainland to island at a migration rate of m=0.08m = 0.08. After this migration event, the island population's allele frequency is measured to be pi′=0.380p_i' = 0.380. Assuming no selection, mutation, or drift operated during this single generation, reverse engineer and calculate the initial allele frequency on the island (pip_i) prior to gene flow.

Answer and steps

Final answer

pi≈0.339p_i \approx 0.339

Steps

01

Understand the Mainland-Island Model of Gene Flow

In population genetics, when unidirectional migration occurs from a large mainland population to an island population, the allele frequency on the island in the next generation (pi′p_i') is a weighted average of the alleles brought by immigrants and those from the original residents:

pi′=(1−m)pi+mpmp_i' = (1 - m)p_i + m p_m

Where:

  • pi′p_i' is the allele frequency on the island after migration (0.3800.380).
  • pip_i is the initial allele frequency on the island before migration.
  • pmp_m is the allele frequency in the mainland population (0.850.85).
  • mm is the migration rate, representing the fraction of the island population made up of new migrants (0.080.08).
  • 1−m1 - m is the proportion of the island population consisting of original residents (1−0.08=0.921 - 0.08 = 0.92).

02

Rearrange the Formula to Solve for pip_i

To determine the initial frequency (pip_i) prior to gene flow, isolate pip_i algebraically:

(1−m)pi=pi′−mpm(1 - m)p_i = p_i' - m p_m

pi=pi′−mpm1−mp_i = \frac{p_i' - m p_m}{1 - m}


03

Calculate the Numerical Value

Substitute the given values into the equation:

  1. Calculate the mainland contribution to the gene pool: m⋅pm=0.08⋅0.85=0.068m \cdot p_m = 0.08 \cdot 0.85 = 0.068
  2. Subtract this contribution from the post-migration frequency: pi′−mpm=0.380−0.068=0.312p_i' - m p_m = 0.380 - 0.068 = 0.312
  3. Divide by the proportion of original residents (1−m1 - m): pi=0.3120.92≈0.33913p_i = \frac{0.312}{0.92} \approx 0.33913

Rounding to three decimal places gives:

pi≈0.339p_i \approx 0.339


Pitfall to Avoid

  • Do not confuse the migration rate mm with the allele frequency of the migrants (pmp_m). The total influx of the allele into the island's gene pool is the product m⋅pmm \cdot p_m, not simply mm.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misremembers the migration formula by using m instead of (1 - m) for the resident island fraction, leading to an incorrect initial frequency of 3.89.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    pi′=m⋅pi+(1−m)⋅pmp_i' = m \cdot p_i + (1 - m) \cdot p_m

    Correct

    pi′=(1−m)pi+mpmp_i' = (1 - m)p_i + m p_m

    You reversed the weighting factors. The migration rate mm represents the proportion of new immigrants arriving from the mainland (with frequency pmp_m), while the remaining fraction (1−m)(1 - m) represents the resident islanders (with frequency pip_i).

  2. Step 2

    0.380=0.08⋅pi+0.92(0.85)  ⟹  0.380=0.08⋅pi+0.782  ⟹  0.08⋅pi=−0.4020.380 = 0.08 \cdot p_i + 0.92(0.85) \implies 0.380 = 0.08 \cdot p_i + 0.782 \implies 0.08 \cdot p_i = -0.402

    Correct

    0.380=(1−0.08)pi+0.08(0.85)  ⟹  0.380=0.92pi+0.068  ⟹  0.92pi=0.3120.380 = (1 - 0.08)p_i + 0.08(0.85) \implies 0.380 = 0.92p_i + 0.068 \implies 0.92p_i = 0.312

    You substituted the numbers and manipulated the linear equation accurately based on your initial formula, but the values were assigned to the swapped terms.

  3. Step 3

    pi=−0.402/0.08=−5.025p_i = -0.402 / 0.08 = -5.025

    Correct

    pi=0.3120.92≈0.339p_i = \frac{0.312}{0.92} \approx 0.339

    Because of the reversed formula in the first step, your calculation resulted in a negative value. Allele frequencies must always fall strictly within the range [0,1][0, 1].

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the relevant variables (pi′p_i', pmp_m, and mm) from the problem text.

You carried out the algebraic substitution and isolation steps accurately according to your written formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed model weights

You accidentally multiplied the resident frequency pip_i by mm and the migrant frequency pmp_m by (1−m)(1 - m) rather than pairing migrants with mm.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the immigrant fraction (mm) with the resident fraction (1−m1 - m) in the mainland-island weighted average equation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Pairing fractions with populations
  • pnew=(fraction resident)⋅president+(fraction immigrant)⋅pimmigrantp_{\text{new}} = (\text{fraction resident}) \cdot p_{\text{resident}} + (\text{fraction immigrant}) \cdot p_{\text{immigrant}}

  • Always verify that mm multiplies the mainland frequency pmp_m and (1−m)(1 - m) multiplies the initial island frequency pip_i.

Biological sanity check
  • Allele frequencies must strictly lie between 00 and 11 (0≤p≤10 \le p \le 1).

  • If your computed allele frequency is negative or greater than 11, immediately check your formula for sign or weight errors.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the mainland-island gene flow equation with correct population weights: pi′=(1−m)pi+mpmp_i' = (1 - m)p_i + m p_m.

  2. Substitute the given numerical values: 0.380=(1−0.08)pi+0.08(0.85)0.380 = (1 - 0.08)p_i + 0.08(0.85).

  3. Simplify the mainland contribution: 0.08×0.85=0.0680.08 \times 0.85 = 0.068, giving 0.380=0.92pi+0.0680.380 = 0.92 p_i + 0.068.

  4. Isolate the resident term: 0.92pi=0.380−0.068=0.3120.92 p_i = 0.380 - 0.068 = 0.312.

  5. Divide by the resident proportion: pi=0.3120.92≈0.33913p_i = \frac{0.312}{0.92} \approx 0.33913.

Final answer

pi≈0.339p_i \approx 0.339

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the gene pool weighting rule: the new island gene pool consists of (1−m)(1 - m) resident genes and mm mainland immigrant genes.

  • Practice doing a quick range check on any calculated allele frequency to ensure it satisfies 0≤p≤10 \le p \le 1.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the post-migration frequency with the initial frequency and calculates the forward change instead of reverse engineering p_i, arriving at 0.418.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    pi′=(1−m)⋅pi+m⋅pmp_i' = (1 - m) \cdot p_i + m \cdot p_m

  2. Step 2

    pi=(1−0.08)(0.380)+0.08(0.85)  ⟹  pi=0.92(0.380)+0.068  ⟹  pi=0.3496+0.068p_i = (1 - 0.08)(0.380) + 0.08(0.85) \implies p_i = 0.92(0.380) + 0.068 \implies p_i = 0.3496 + 0.068

    Correct

    0.380=(1−0.08)pi+0.08(0.85)  ⟹  0.380=0.92pi+0.0680.380 = (1 - 0.08)p_i + 0.08(0.85) \implies 0.380 = 0.92p_i + 0.068

    You plugged 0.3800.380 into the position of pip_i on the right side. Because 0.3800.380 is the post-migration frequency (pi′p_i'), it belongs on the left side of the equation.

  3. Step 3

    pi=0.4176≈0.418p_i = 0.4176 \approx 0.418

    Correct

    pi=0.380−0.0680.92=0.3120.92≈0.339p_i = \frac{0.380 - 0.068}{0.92} = \frac{0.312}{0.92} \approx 0.339

    Your final calculation is numerically consistent with the expression you set up, but the value is incorrect due to the swapped variable in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and wrote down the standard mainland-island gene flow equation.

You carried out the arithmetic operations and rounding accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Variable Role Confusion in Algebraic Inversion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the problem as a forward calculation of the next generation rather than identifying that the measured frequency was the post-migration value (pi′p_i') requiring algebraic inversion to find pip_i.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distinguish Prior vs. Posterior Variables
  • In population genetics time-step equations, primed variables (p′p') denote the population frequency after the evolutionary event, while unprimed variables (pp) denote the state before the event.

  • Label given values explicitly with their algebraic symbols before substituting: pi′=0.380p_i' = 0.380, pm=0.85p_m = 0.85, m=0.08m = 0.08, and mark pi=?p_i = ?

Sanity Check Direction of Frequency Shift
  • Gene flow pulls the recipient island frequency closer to the donor mainland frequency (pi<pi′<pmp_i < p_i' < p_m when mainland frequency is higher).

  • Since mainland frequency (0.850.85) is higher than the island's, migration must have increased the island's allele frequency. Therefore, the pre-migration frequency pip_i must be strictly less than 0.3800.380, which immediately rules out 0.4180.418.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the given values into their correct positions: 0.380=(1−0.08)pi+0.08(0.85)0.380 = (1 - 0.08)p_i + 0.08(0.85).

  2. Simplify the mainland contribution: 0.380=0.92pi+0.0680.380 = 0.92p_i + 0.068.

  3. Subtract 0.0680.068 from both sides: 0.92pi=0.3120.92p_i = 0.312.

  4. Divide by 0.920.92 to isolate pip_i: pi=0.3120.92≈0.33913p_i = \frac{0.312}{0.92} \approx 0.33913.

Final answer

pi≈0.339p_i \approx 0.339

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write down a variable key (pi′p_i', pip_i, pmp_m, mm) alongside the problem text before doing any calculations.

  • Perform a qualitative sanity check: if immigrants carry a higher frequency of an allele, the island frequency must have increased, meaning the initial frequency must be smaller than the final frequency.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student adds the mainland migrants to the whole population without weighting the resident island frequency by (1 - m), calculating p_i = 0.312.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    pi′=pi+m∗pm  ⟹  0.380=pi+0.08(0.85)p_i' = p_i + m * p_m \implies 0.380 = p_i + 0.08(0.85)

    Correct

    pi′=(1−m)pi+mpm  ⟹  0.380=(1−0.08)pi+0.08(0.85)p_i' = (1 - m)p_i + m p_m \implies 0.380 = (1 - 0.08)p_i + 0.08(0.85)

    In a mainland-island model, the new allele frequency on the island is a weighted average of original residents and incoming migrants: pi′=(1−m)pi+mpmp_i' = (1 - m)p_i + m p_m. You treated the resident contribution as an unweighted pip_i rather than scaling it by (1−m)=0.92(1 - m) = 0.92.

  2. Step 2

    0.380=pi+0.068  ⟹  pi=0.380−0.068  ⟹  pi=0.3120.380 = p_i + 0.068 \implies p_i = 0.380 - 0.068 \implies p_i = 0.312

    Correct

    0.380=0.92pi+0.068  ⟹  0.92pi=0.312  ⟹  pi=0.3120.92≈0.3390.380 = 0.92p_i + 0.068 \implies 0.92p_i = 0.312 \implies p_i = \frac{0.312}{0.92} \approx 0.339

    Your algebraic rearrangement was executed consistently from your starting equation, but the final value was thrown off by the missing factor of 1−m=0.921 - m = 0.92.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the migrant influx of the allele is given by the product m⋅pmm \cdot p_m.

You carried out the subtraction 0.380−0.068=0.3120.380 - 0.068 = 0.312 accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Resident Weighting in Gene Flow

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating an absolute addition of immigrant alleles with population-level gene flow. In gene flow, the arrival of migrants dilutes the resident proportion to (1−m)(1 - m) so that total population proportions sum to 11.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Weighted Average Principle
  • In single-generation unidirectional gene flow, the island gene pool consists of two fractions: (1−m)(1 - m) from original residents and mm from migrants, giving pi′=(1−m)pi+mpmp_i' = (1 - m)p_i + m p_m.

  • Always verify that the weights assigned to the resident and migrant frequencies sum to 11, namely (1−m)+m=1(1 - m) + m = 1.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. 0.380=0.92pi+0.0680.380 = 0.92p_i + 0.068

  2. 0.92pi=0.380−0.068=0.3120.92p_i = 0.380 - 0.068 = 0.312

  3. pi=0.3120.92≈0.33913p_i = \frac{0.312}{0.92} \approx 0.33913

Final answer

pi≈0.339p_i \approx 0.339

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the general gene flow formula p′=(1−m)p0+mpmp' = (1 - m)p_0 + m p_m before substituting values.

  • Check that the initial island frequency pip_i lies on the opposite side of pi′p_i' relative to pmp_m (since pm=0.85>0.380p_m = 0.85 > 0.380, pip_i must be less than 0.3800.380).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An island butterfly population receives unidirectional gene flow from a large mainland population where a wing-pattern allele frequency is pm=0.70p_m = 0.70. The migration rate is m=0.15m = 0.15. If the initial island allele frequency before migration was pi=0.20p_i = 0.20, what is the new island allele frequency (pi′p_i') after one generation of migration?

Answer

pi′=0.275p_i' = 0.275. Key steps: Use pi′=(1−m)pi+mpm=(1−0.15)(0.20)+0.15(0.70)=0.85(0.20)+0.105=0.170+0.105=0.275p_i' = (1 - m)p_i + m p_m = (1 - 0.15)(0.20) + 0.15(0.70) = 0.85(0.20) + 0.105 = 0.170 + 0.105 = 0.275.

02

In a plant population on an isolated coastal sandbar, unidirectional pollen flow arrives from an inland forest population where allele frequency pm=0.60p_m = 0.60. Over one generation, pollen flow occurs at rate m=0.05m = 0.05. Post-flow testing reveals the sandbar allele frequency is pi′=0.410p_i' = 0.410. Calculate the pre-flow allele frequency on the sandbar (pip_i).

Answer

pi=0.400p_i = 0.400. Key steps: Set up pi′=(1−m)pi+mpm  ⟹  0.410=0.95pi+0.05(0.60)=0.95pi+0.030p_i' = (1 - m)p_i + m p_m \implies 0.410 = 0.95 p_i + 0.05(0.60) = 0.95 p_i + 0.030. Then 0.95pi=0.3800.95 p_i = 0.380, giving pi=0.3800.95=0.400p_i = \frac{0.380}{0.95} = 0.400.

03

A mainland population has an allele frequency pm=0.90p_m = 0.90, while an offshore island population has an initial frequency pi=0.30p_i = 0.30. After a single storm-driven migration event, the island allele frequency shifts to pi′=0.42p_i' = 0.42. Determine the migration rate mm, representing the fraction of the island population composed of new migrants.

Answer

m=0.20m = 0.20. Key steps: Use Δp=m(pm−pi)  ⟹  pi′−pi=m(pm−pi)\Delta p = m(p_m - p_i) \implies p_i' - p_i = m(p_m - p_i). Substitute values: 0.42−0.30=m(0.90−0.30)  ⟹  0.12=0.60m  ⟹  m=0.120.60=0.200.42 - 0.30 = m(0.90 - 0.30) \implies 0.12 = 0.60 m \implies m = \frac{0.12}{0.60} = 0.20.

Loading workspace…