Resources

A plant root hair cell uses an electrogenic proton-pumping ATPase (extH+ ext{H}^+-ATPase) to establish an electrochemical proton gradient across its plasma membrane into the soil solution. The soil water has a pH=6.00\text{pH} = 6.00 ([H+]out=1.00×10−6 M[\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}} = 1.00 \times 10^{-6}\text{ M}), and the root cytosol is regulated at pH=7.20\text{pH} = 7.20 ([H+]in=6.31×10−8 M[\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}} = 6.31 \times 10^{-8}\text{ M}). Under physiological conditions at T=298 KT = 298\text{ K} (R=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)R = 8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}), F=96485 C/molF = 96485\text{ C/mol}), cytosolic ATP\text{ATP} hydrolysis releases ΔGATP=−34.0 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = -34.0\text{ kJ/mol}, and the pump maintains a 1:11:1 stoichiometry (hydrolyzing 1 mol1\text{ mol} of ATP\text{ATP} per 1 mol1\text{ mol} of H+\text{H}^+ pumped outward). Determine the critical electrical threshold potential Vcrit=Vin−VoutV_{\text{crit}} = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}} (in millivolts) beyond which the membrane hyperpolarization is so negative that the pump stalls and can no longer extrude protons.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Vcrit=−281 mVV_{\text{crit}} = -281\text{ mV}

Steps

01

Thermodynamic Coupling of the HX+\ce{H+}-ATPase

To find the critical membrane potential (VcritV_{\text{crit}}) at which the proton pump stalls, we examine the thermodynamics of the coupled active transport process.

The proton pump couples the exergonic hydrolysis of ATP\ce{ATP} to the endergonic extrusion of protons (HX+\ce{H+}) from the cytosol into the extracellular space (soil solution):

ATP+HX2O+HXcytosol+⇌ADP+PXi+HXsoil+\ce{ATP + H2O + H+_{cytosol} <=> ADP + P_i + H+_{soil}}

For active transport to proceed in the outward direction, the overall change in Gibbs free energy (ΔGnet\Delta G_{\text{net}}) must be negative (ΔGnet<0\Delta G_{\text{net}} < 0). The pump reaches its thermodynamic stalling limit when the total free energy change equals zero:

ΔGnet=ΔGATP+ΔGtransport=0\Delta G_{\text{net}} = \Delta G_{\text{ATP}} + \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 0

02

Free Energy of Proton Transport (ΔGtransport\Delta G_{\text{transport}})

The free energy required to transport 1 mol1\text{ mol} of HX+\ce{H+} (z=+1z = +1) from the inside (cytosol) to the outside (soil) against both a concentration gradient and an electrical gradient is given by:

ΔGtransport=ΔGchem+ΔGelec\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = \Delta G_{\text{chem}} + \Delta G_{\text{elec}}

  • Chemical component (ΔGchem\Delta G_{\text{chem}}): ΔGchem=RTln⁡([HX+]out[HX+]in)=2.303 RT(pHin−pHout)\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[\ce{H+}]_{\text{out}}}{[\ce{H+}]_{\text{in}}}\right) = 2.303 \, RT (\text{pH}_{\text{in}} - \text{pH}_{\text{out}})

    Substituting the values: pHin−pHout=7.20−6.00=1.20\text{pH}_{\text{in}} - \text{pH}_{\text{out}} = 7.20 - 6.00 = 1.20 ΔGchem=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)⋅298 K⋅ln⁡(1.00×10−66.31×10−8)≈6847 J/mol=+6.85 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = 8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) \cdot 298\text{ K} \cdot \ln\left(\frac{1.00 \times 10^{-6}}{6.31 \times 10^{-8}}\right) \approx 6847\text{ J/mol} = +6.85\text{ kJ/mol}

  • Electrical component (ΔGelec\Delta G_{\text{elec}}): Moving a positive charge from a potential of VinV_{\text{in}} to VoutV_{\text{out}} requires: ΔGelec=zF(Vout−Vin)\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = z F (V_{\text{out}} - V_{\text{in}})

    Since the membrane potential is defined as Vm=Vin−VoutV_{\text{m}} = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}}, we have: ΔGelec=−zFVm=−FVm\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = -z F V_{\text{m}} = -F V_{\text{m}}

03

Solving for the Stalling Potential (VcritV_{\text{crit}})

Set the total free energy change to zero at the stall point:

ΔGATP+ΔGchem−FVcrit=0\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} + \Delta G_{\text{chem}} - F V_{\text{crit}} = 0

Substitute the known parameters: −34000 J/mol+6847 J/mol−(96485 C/mol)⋅Vcrit=0-34000\text{ J/mol} + 6847\text{ J/mol} - (96485\text{ C/mol}) \cdot V_{\text{crit}} = 0

−27153 J/mol=96485 C/mol⋅Vcrit-27153\text{ J/mol} = 96485\text{ C/mol} \cdot V_{\text{crit}}

Vcrit=−2715396485 V≈−0.2814 V=−281 mVV_{\text{crit}} = \frac{-27153}{96485}\text{ V} \approx -0.2814\text{ V} = -281\text{ mV}

When the cytosol hyperpolarizes to −281 mV-281\text{ mV} relative to the soil solution, the electrical resistance pulling HX+\ce{H+} back inside equals the driving energy from ATP\ce{ATP} hydrolysis, causing the pump to stall.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the direction of the pH gradient across the membrane, taking pH_out - pH_in instead of pH_in - pH_out for outward proton extrusion.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔGtransport=−ΔGATP=34.0 kJ/mol=34000 J/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = -\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = 34.0\text{ kJ/mol} = 34000\text{ J/mol}

  2. Step 2

    ΔGconc=2.303⋅R⋅T⋅(pHout−pHin)=2.303⋅8.314⋅298⋅(6.00−7.20)=−6846 J/mol\Delta G_{\text{conc}} = 2.303 \cdot R \cdot T \cdot (\text{pH}_{\text{out}} - \text{pH}_{\text{in}}) = 2.303 \cdot 8.314 \cdot 298 \cdot (6.00 - 7.20) = -6846\text{ J/mol}

    Correct

    ΔGchem=2.303⋅R⋅T⋅(pHin−pHout)=2.303⋅8.314⋅298⋅(7.20−6.00)≈+6847 J/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = 2.303 \cdot R \cdot T \cdot (\text{pH}_{\text{in}} - \text{pH}_{\text{out}}) = 2.303 \cdot 8.314 \cdot 298 \cdot (7.20 - 6.00) \approx +6847\text{ J/mol}

    Because pH=−log⁡10[H+]\text{pH} = -\log_{10}[\text{H}^+], the ratio ln⁡([H+]out/[H+]in)\ln([\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}} / [\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}}) equals 2.303(pHin−pHout)2.303(\text{pH}_{\text{in}} - \text{pH}_{\text{out}}). Since protons are pumped from a lower concentration in the cytosol (10−7.20 M10^{-7.20}\text{ M}) into a higher concentration outside (10−6.00 M10^{-6.00}\text{ M}), moving against the concentration gradient requires positive free energy (+6847 J/mol+6847\text{ J/mol}).

  3. Step 3

    ΔGelec=34000−(−6846)=40846 J/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = 34000 - (-6846) = 40846\text{ J/mol}

    Correct

    ΔGelec=34000−6847=27153 J/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = 34000 - 6847 = 27153\text{ J/mol}

    You used the correct relationship ΔGelec=ΔGtransport−ΔGchem\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = \Delta G_{\text{transport}} - \Delta G_{\text{chem}}, but the value was affected by your negative ΔGconc\Delta G_{\text{conc}} from Step 2.

  4. Step 4

    F⋅(−Vcrit)=40846 J/mol  ⟹  Vcrit=−4084696485=−0.423 V=−423 mVF \cdot (-V_{\text{crit}}) = 40846\text{ J/mol} \implies V_{\text{crit}} = -\frac{40846}{96485} = -0.423\text{ V} = -423\text{ mV}

    Correct

    F⋅(−Vcrit)=27153 J/mol  ⟹  Vcrit=−2715396485≈−0.281 V=−281 mVF \cdot (-V_{\text{crit}}) = 27153\text{ J/mol} \implies V_{\text{crit}} = -\frac{27153}{96485} \approx -0.281\text{ V} = -281\text{ mV}

    Your algebraic rearrangement for VcritV_{\text{crit}} is mathematically sound, but carrying forward 40846 J/mol40846\text{ J/mol} gave −423 mV-423\text{ mV} instead of −281 mV-281\text{ mV}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly established the overall thermodynamic stall condition ΔGnet=0\Delta G_{\text{net}} = 0.

You correctly related the electrical free energy component to Faraday's constant and the membrane potential.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign inversion in pH gradient chemical potential

Writing pHout−pHin\text{pH}_{\text{out}} - \text{pH}_{\text{in}} instead of pHin−pHout\text{pH}_{\text{in}} - \text{pH}_{\text{out}} when converting ln⁡([H+]final/[H+]initial)\ln([\text{H}^+]_{\text{final}} / [\text{H}^+]_{\text{initial}}) using negative logarithms.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the concentration ratio [X]destination[X]source\frac{[\text{X}]_{\text{destination}}}{[\text{X}]_{\text{source}}} with a simple subtraction of pH values without accounting for the negative sign inherent in pH=−log⁡10[H+]\text{pH} = -\log_{10}[\text{H}^+].

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
pH-to-Free Energy Sign Rule
  • ln⁡([H+]out[H+]in)=−2.303(pHout−pHin)=+2.303(pHin−pHout)\ln\left(\frac{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}}}{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}}}\right) = -2.303(\text{pH}_{\text{out}} - \text{pH}_{\text{in}}) = +2.303(\text{pH}_{\text{in}} - \text{pH}_{\text{out}})

  • Always verify physically: if [extH+][ ext{H}^+] is higher at the destination (lower pH), pumping into it is endergonic, so ΔGchem\Delta G_{\text{chem}} must be positive.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recalculate ΔGchem=2.303⋅8.314⋅298⋅(7.20−6.00)=+6847 J/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = 2.303 \cdot 8.314 \cdot 298 \cdot (7.20 - 6.00) = +6847\text{ J/mol}.

  2. Subtract ΔGchem\Delta G_{\text{chem}} from the total ATP driving energy: ΔGelec=34000−6847=27153 J/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = 34000 - 6847 = 27153\text{ J/mol}.

  3. Solve for VcritV_{\text{crit}} using ΔGelec=−F⋅Vcrit\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = -F \cdot V_{\text{crit}}: Vcrit=−27153 J/mol96485 C/mol≈−0.2814 VV_{\text{crit}} = -\frac{27153\text{ J/mol}}{96485\text{ C/mol}} \approx -0.2814\text{ V}.

Final answer

Vcrit=−281 mVV_{\text{crit}} = -281\text{ mV}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before calculating, perform a physical sanity check on ΔGchem\Delta G_{\text{chem}}: pumping toward higher concentration must always require positive free energy.

  • Remember that lower pH means higher proton concentration, which reverses the usual order of terms in subtraction formulas.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student ignores the chemical concentration gradient and equates the entire free energy of ATP hydrolysis solely to the electrical potential difference.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    At the stall potential, electrical work balances ATP hydrolysis directly: ΔGATP+z⋅F⋅(−Vcrit)=0\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} + z \cdot F \cdot (-V_{\text{crit}}) = 0

    Correct

    ΔGnet=ΔGATP+ΔGchem+ΔGelec=0  ⟹  ΔGATP+RTln⁡([H+]out[H+]in)−zFVcrit=0\Delta G_{\text{net}} = \Delta G_{\text{ATP}} + \Delta G_{\text{chem}} + \Delta G_{\text{elec}} = 0 \implies \Delta G_{\text{ATP}} + RT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}}}{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}}}\right) - zFV_{\text{crit}} = 0

    You omitted the chemical free-energy contribution ΔGchem=RTln⁡([H+]out/[H+]in)\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = RT \ln([\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}} / [\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}}). Because the soil is more acidic (pH=6.00\text{pH} = 6.00) than the cytosol (pH=7.20\text{pH} = 7.20), pumping protons outward requires work against both an electrical potential difference and a chemical concentration gradient.

  2. Step 2

    −34000 J/mol+1⋅96485 C/mol⋅(−Vcrit)=0  ⟹  −Vcrit=3400096485=0.3524 V-34000\text{ J/mol} + 1 \cdot 96485\text{ C/mol} \cdot (-V_{\text{crit}}) = 0 \implies -V_{\text{crit}} = \frac{34000}{96485} = 0.3524\text{ V}

    Correct

    −34000 J/mol+6847 J/mol−(96485 C/mol)⋅Vcrit=0  ⟹  Vcrit=−27153 J/mol96485 C/mol≈−0.2814 V-34000\text{ J/mol} + 6847\text{ J/mol} - (96485\text{ C/mol}) \cdot V_{\text{crit}} = 0 \implies V_{\text{crit}} = \frac{-27153\text{ J/mol}}{96485\text{ C/mol}} \approx -0.2814\text{ V}

    Your arithmetic and unit handling are correct, but this step carries forward the missing chemical work term.

  3. Step 3

    Vcrit=−352 mVV_{\text{crit}} = -352\text{ mV}

    Correct

    Vcrit=−281 mVV_{\text{crit}} = -281\text{ mV}

    Your final calculated value is −352 mV-352\text{ mV} instead of −281 mV-281\text{ mV} because the chemical gradient consumes part of the energy from ATP\text{ATP} hydrolysis.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that active transport stalls when the total free energy change ΔGnet=0\Delta G_{\text{net}} = 0.

You used the correct relationship between electrical work, valence (z=+1z = +1), and Faraday's constant (F=96485 C/molF = 96485\text{ C/mol}).

You converted units consistently between kJ/mol\text{kJ/mol}, J/mol\text{J/mol}, V\text{V}, and mV\text{mV}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of chemical concentration gradient

You equated the entire driving energy of ATP\text{ATP} hydrolysis exclusively to electrical potential without adding the free energy required to move protons against the concentration gradient.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing purely electrical stalling with electrochemical equilibrium. The driving force for any ion across a membrane is governed by the electrochemical potential difference (Δμ=ΔGchem+ΔGelec\Delta \mu = \Delta G_{\text{chem}} + \Delta G_{\text{elec}}), which always has both a chemical term (RTln⁡([ion]to/[ion]from)RT \ln([\text{ion}]_{\text{to}} / [\text{ion}]_{\text{from}})) and an electrical term (zFΔVzF\Delta V).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Electrochemical Potential Rule
  • For any ion transport process, ΔGtransport=RTln⁡([ion]dest[ion]source)+zF(Vdest−Vsource)\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{ion}]_{\text{dest}}}{[\text{ion}]_{\text{source}}}\right) + z F (V_{\text{dest}} - V_{\text{source}}).

  • Always write out both the chemical term and the electrical term before substituting zero for either.

Energy Budget Check
  • Energy released by ATP\text{ATP} hydrolysis (ΔGATP<0\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} < 0) must pay for all uphill transport work: ∣ΔGATP∣=ΔGchem+ΔGelec|\Delta G_{\text{ATP}}| = \Delta G_{\text{chem}} + \Delta G_{\text{elec}}.

  • Check whether a concentration difference exists across the membrane; if [ion]out≠[ion]in[\text{ion}]_{\text{out}} \neq [\text{ion}]_{\text{in}}, chemical work is non-zero.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the chemical free-energy change: ΔGchem=RTln⁡([H+]out[H+]in)=(8.314)(298)ln⁡(1.00×10−66.31×10−8)≈+6847 J/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}}}{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}}}\right) = (8.314)(298) \ln\left(\frac{1.00 \times 10^{-6}}{6.31 \times 10^{-8}}\right) \approx +6847\text{ J/mol}.

  2. Set up the complete thermodynamic balance at stall: ΔGATP+ΔGchem−FVcrit=0\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} + \Delta G_{\text{chem}} - F V_{\text{crit}} = 0.

  3. Substitute the values: −34000 J/mol+6847 J/mol−(96485 C/mol)⋅Vcrit=0  ⟹  −27153=96485⋅Vcrit-34000\text{ J/mol} + 6847\text{ J/mol} - (96485\text{ C/mol}) \cdot V_{\text{crit}} = 0 \implies -27153 = 96485 \cdot V_{\text{crit}}.

  4. Solve for the membrane potential: Vcrit=−2715396485 V≈−0.2814 V=−281 mVV_{\text{crit}} = \frac{-27153}{96485}\text{ V} \approx -0.2814\text{ V} = -281\text{ mV}.

Final answer

Vcrit=−281 mVV_{\text{crit}} = -281\text{ mV}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of the proton motive force (pmfpmf) and electrochemical potential (Δμ~H+\Delta \tilde{\mu}_{\text{H}^+}).

  • Practice setting up free-energy balances that explicitly partition ΔGtransport\Delta G_{\text{transport}} into chemical and electrical components.

  • Solve problems where pH differences and membrane voltages oppose or reinforce active transport.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the sign of the electrical potential difference across the membrane, concluding that V_crit is positive instead of negative.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔGtransport=R⋅T⋅ln⁡([H+]out[H+]in)+z⋅F⋅Vcrit=−ΔGATP\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = R \cdot T \cdot \ln\left(\frac{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}}}{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}}}\right) + z \cdot F \cdot V_{\text{crit}} = -\Delta G_{\text{ATP}}

    Correct

    ΔGtransport=R⋅T⋅ln⁡([H+]out[H+]in)+z⋅F⋅(Vout−Vin)=R⋅T⋅ln⁡([H+]out[H+]in)−z⋅F⋅Vcrit=−ΔGATP\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = R \cdot T \cdot \ln\left(\frac{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}}}{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}}}\right) + z \cdot F \cdot (V_{\text{out}} - V_{\text{in}}) = R \cdot T \cdot \ln\left(\frac{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}}}{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}}}\right) - z \cdot F \cdot V_{\text{crit}} = -\Delta G_{\text{ATP}}

    Moving a positive charge from inside to outside moves it across a potential difference of ΔV=Vfinal−Vinitial=Vout−Vin\Delta V = V_{\text{final}} - V_{\text{initial}} = V_{\text{out}} - V_{\text{in}}. Since the membrane potential is defined as Vm=Vin−VoutV_{\text{m}} = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}}, the electrical work term is +zF(Vout−Vin)=−zFVm+z F (V_{\text{out}} - V_{\text{in}}) = -z F V_{\text{m}}. Writing +zFVcrit+z F V_{\text{crit}} inverts the sign of the electrical potential.

  2. Step 2

    6846 J/mol+1⋅96485 C/mol⋅Vcrit=34000 J/mol  ⟹  96485⋅Vcrit=34000−6846=27154 J/mol6846\text{ J/mol} + 1 \cdot 96485\text{ C/mol} \cdot V_{\text{crit}} = 34000\text{ J/mol} \implies 96485 \cdot V_{\text{crit}} = 34000 - 6846 = 27154\text{ J/mol}

    Correct

    6846 J/mol−1⋅96485 C/mol⋅Vcrit=34000 J/mol  ⟹  −96485⋅Vcrit=27154 J/mol6846\text{ J/mol} - 1 \cdot 96485\text{ C/mol} \cdot V_{\text{crit}} = 34000\text{ J/mol} \implies -96485 \cdot V_{\text{crit}} = 27154\text{ J/mol}

    Your arithmetic and evaluation of the chemical term were executed accurately, but the calculation propagated the sign error from the previous step.

  3. Step 3

    Vcrit=2715496485=+281 mVV_{\text{crit}} = \frac{27154}{96485} = +281\text{ mV}

    Correct

    Vcrit=−2715496485 V≈−281 mVV_{\text{crit}} = -\frac{27154}{96485}\text{ V} \approx -281\text{ mV}

    Because of the inverted sign in the electrical work term, your final answer is +281 mV+281\text{ mV} rather than −281 mV-281\text{ mV}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the pump reaches its thermodynamic stalling limit when the free energy of transport equals the free energy released by ATP hydrolysis.

You accurately evaluated the chemical concentration gradient component ΔGchem=RTln⁡([H+]out[H+]in)≈+6846 J/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}}}{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}}}\right) \approx +6846\text{ J/mol}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in electrical potential difference

You substituted the membrane potential Vm=Vin−VoutV_{\text{m}} = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}} directly with a positive sign instead of accounting for the direction of outward movement, which requires Vout−Vin=−VmV_{\text{out}} - V_{\text{in}} = -V_{\text{m}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the direction of ion movement when setting up electrochemical free energy. Moving an ion from inside to outside means the electrical work is zF(Vdestination−Vorigin)=zF(Vout−Vin)zF(V_{\text{destination}} - V_{\text{origin}}) = zF(V_{\text{out}} - V_{\text{in}}). Because membrane potential is defined as Vm=Vin−VoutV_{\text{m}} = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}}, the electrical term for outward transport must be −zFVm-zFV_{\text{m}}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direction of Electrochemical Work
  • For any transport from compartment A to compartment B, ΔGelec=zF(VB−VA)\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = z F (V_{\text{B}} - V_{\text{A}}).

  • Always identify the origin and destination compartments first, write (Vdestination−Vorigin)(V_{\text{destination}} - V_{\text{origin}}), and then express it in terms of Vm=Vin−VoutV_{\text{m}} = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}}.

Physiological Reality Check
  • Pumping positive charges (H+\text{H}^+) out of an already negative cell requires work against an inward electrical pull.

  • Check that extreme negative (hyperpolarized) potentials make outward proton extrusion harder, not easier, which means stalling must occur at a large negative VmV_{\text{m}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the thermodynamic stalling condition: ΔGnet=ΔGATP+ΔGtransport=0\Delta G_{\text{net}} = \Delta G_{\text{ATP}} + \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 0, meaning ΔGtransport=−ΔGATP=+34000 J/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = -\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = +34000\text{ J/mol}.

  2. Express transport free energy for outward extrusion: ΔGtransport=RTln⁡([H+]out[H+]in)+zF(Vout−Vin)=ΔGchem−zFVcrit\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}}}{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}}}\right) + z F (V_{\text{out}} - V_{\text{in}}) = \Delta G_{\text{chem}} - z F V_{\text{crit}}.

  3. Substitute the numerical values: 6847 J/mol−(96485 C/mol)⋅Vcrit=34000 J/mol6847\text{ J/mol} - (96485\text{ C/mol}) \cdot V_{\text{crit}} = 34000\text{ J/mol}.

  4. Solve for VcritV_{\text{crit}}: −(96485 C/mol)⋅Vcrit=27153 J/mol  ⟹  Vcrit=−0.2814 V≈−281 mV-(96485\text{ C/mol}) \cdot V_{\text{crit}} = 27153\text{ J/mol} \implies V_{\text{crit}} = -0.2814\text{ V} \approx -281\text{ mV}.

Final answer

Vcrit=−281 mVV_{\text{crit}} = -281\text{ mV}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of membrane potential (Vm=Vin−VoutV_{\text{m}} = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}}) and practice writing ΔGelec\Delta G_{\text{elec}} for both inward and outward ion flux.

  • Perform a physical sanity check on electrical gradients: ask whether the sign of VmV_{\text{m}} opposes or favors the direction of ion movement.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A lysosomal V-type H+-ATPase\text{V-type}\text{ H}^+\text{-ATPase} pumps protons from the cytosol (pH=7.40\text{pH} = 7.40) into the lysosome lumen (pH=4.80\text{pH} = 4.80) at 298 K298\text{ K}. Calculate the chemical component of the free energy change, ΔGchem\Delta G_{\text{chem}}, per mole of protons pumped outward into the lumen (R=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)R = 8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})).

Answer

ΔGchem=2.303×8.314×298×(7.40−4.80)=+14.8 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = 2.303 \times 8.314 \times 298 \times (7.40 - 4.80) = +14.8\text{ kJ/mol}.

02

A bacterial cell maintains an internal pH=7.60\text{pH} = 7.60 in an environment with pH=6.60\text{pH} = 6.60. If its membrane potential is Vm=Vin−Vout=−120 mVV_{\text{m}} = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}} = -120\text{ mV}, calculate the total electrochemical free energy change ΔμH+\Delta \mu_{\text{H}^+} (in kJ/mol\text{kJ/mol}) required to extrude 1 mol1\text{ mol} of protons at 298 K298\text{ K} (F=96485 C/molF = 96485\text{ C/mol}).

Answer

ΔGchem=2.303×8.314×298×(7.60−6.60)≈+5.71 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = 2.303 \times 8.314 \times 298 \times (7.60 - 6.60) \approx +5.71\text{ kJ/mol}. ΔGelec=−FVm=−(96485)(−0.120 V)=+11.58 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = -F V_{\text{m}} = -(96485)(-0.120\text{ V}) = +11.58\text{ kJ/mol}. Total ΔμH+=5.71+11.58=+17.29 kJ/mol\Delta \mu_{\text{H}^+} = 5.71 + 11.58 = +17.29\text{ kJ/mol}.

03

An archaeal primary proton pump hydrolyzes 1 mol1\text{ mol} of ATP (ΔGATP=−31.0 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = -31.0\text{ kJ/mol}) to pump 2 mol2\text{ mol} of protons out of the cell. The internal pH is 7.007.00 and external pH is 5.005.00 at 298 K298\text{ K}. Find the critical membrane potential Vcrit=Vin−VoutV_{\text{crit}} = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}} (in mV\text{mV}) at which the pump stalls.

Answer

For 2 mol2\text{ mol} H+\text{H}^+: ΔGchem=2×[2.303×8.314×298×(7.00−5.00)]=+22.82 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = 2 \times [2.303 \times 8.314 \times 298 \times (7.00 - 5.00)] = +22.82\text{ kJ/mol}. At stall: ΔGATP+ΔGtransport=0  ⟹  −31.0+22.82−2FVcrit=0  ⟹  −8.18 kJ/mol=2(96485)Vcrit  ⟹  Vcrit=−42.4 mV\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} + \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 0 \implies -31.0 + 22.82 - 2FV_{\text{crit}} = 0 \implies -8.18\text{ kJ/mol} = 2(96485)V_{\text{crit}} \implies V_{\text{crit}} = -42.4\text{ mV}.

Loading workspace…