Resources

Consider the mathematical limit of evolutionary change in a population as census size approaches an asymptotic boundary. In a massive open marine population of copepods with N→∞N \to \infty, genetic drift approaches zero (variance in allele frequency per generation σΔp2=p(1−p)2N→0\sigma_{\Delta p}^2 = \frac{p(1-p)}{2N} \to 0). Now consider the opposite extreme: a single gravid female colonizes an isolated tidal pool (N=1N = 1 diploid individual, representing 2N=22N = 2 gene copies). (a) For an initial heterozygote female (A1A2A_1A_2 with p=0.500p = 0.500), calculate the exact probabilities of instantaneous fixation of allele A1A_1 (p=1.000p = 1.000), fixation of A2A_2 (p=0.000p = 0.000), or retention of polymorphism (p=0.500p = 0.500) among her immediate diploid zygotes if she self-fertilizes. (b) Contrast this single-individual founder bottleneck with the conceptual definition of population evolution.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Under Mendelian segregation of self-fertilization, gamete pairing probabilities are P(A1A1)=0.250P(A_1A_1) = 0.250, P(A1A2)=0.500P(A_1A_2) = 0.500, and P(A2A2)=0.250P(A_2A_2) = 0.250. For any single offspring zygote, the probability of allele A1A_1 fixing is 0.2500.250, allele A2A_2 fixing is 0.2500.250, and polymorphism being retained is 0.5000.500; (b) The single founder female does not evolve during her dispersal; rather, sampling error drastically reconfigures the allele frequencies of the nascent daughter population, demonstrating that evolution is a generational population-level sampling phenomenon.

Steps

Part (a): Calculating Probabilities of Allele Fixation and Polymorphism

  1. Model the Segregation of Gametes: An individual with genotype A1A2A_1A_2 produces gametes via Mendelian segregation. Assuming unbiased meiosis, the probabilities of producing alleles A1A_1 and A2A_2 in both sets of gametes (maternal and paternal) are: P(A1)=0.500,P(A2)=0.500P(A_1) = 0.500, \quad P(A_2) = 0.500
  2. Determine Zygotic Probabilities via Self-Fertilization: Combining independent gametes gives the standard monohybrid cross probabilities for an individual offspring zygote:

    • Homozygous A1A1A_1A_1: P(A1A1)=P(A1)⋅P(A1)=0.500⋅0.500=0.250P(A_1A_1) = P(A_1) \cdot P(A_1) = 0.500 \cdot 0.500 = 0.250 In an A1A1A_1A_1 zygote, the frequency of allele A1A_1 is p=1.000p = 1.000, representing instantaneous fixation of A1A_1.
    • Homozygous A2A2A_2A_2: P(A2A2)=P(A2)⋅P(A2)=0.500⋅0.500=0.250P(A_2A_2) = P(A_2) \cdot P(A_2) = 0.500 \cdot 0.500 = 0.250 In an A2A2A_2A_2 zygote, the frequency of allele A1A_1 is p=0.000p = 0.000 (allele A2A_2 is fixed at frequency 1.0001.000).
    • Heterozygous A1A2A_1A_2: P(A1A2)=2⋅[P(A1)⋅P(A2)]=2⋅(0.500⋅0.500)=0.500P(A_1A_2) = 2 \cdot [P(A_1) \cdot P(A_2)] = 2 \cdot (0.500 \cdot 0.500) = 0.500 In an A1A2A_1A_2 zygote, the allele frequency remains p=0.500p = 0.500, preserving the initial polymorphism.

Part (b): Contrasting the Bottleneck with Population Evolution

  1. Evolution Occurs Across Generations in Populations: Biological evolution is defined as a change in allele frequencies over time within a gene pool across generations. An individual organism retains its inherited genetic makeup (A1A2A_1A_2) throughout its lifetime; it develops, reproduces, and dies, but it does not evolve.
  2. The Nature of Extreme Founder Effects: When a single gravid female establishes a new colony, the colonization event itself is a dispersal event, not evolution. Evolution occurs when her offspring are generated: the extreme sampling error of drawing two gametes from her restricted pool (N=1N = 1 diploid parent, 2N=22N = 2 gene copies) drastically shifts the allele frequencies from the parent generation (p=0.500p = 0.500) to the next generation (p=1.000p = 1.000, 0.5000.500, or 0.0000.000). This demonstrates that evolutionary mechanisms such as genetic drift are strictly population-level, generational phenomena.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the probability of allele fixation with the initial allele frequency of the founding gene copies, assuming equal one-third chances for the three possible outcomes.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Possible zygote outcomes: fixation of A1A_1, fixation of A2A_2, or polymorphism ⟹ Number of possible outcomes = 3 ⟹ P(fixation of A1)=1/3,P(fixation of A2)=1/3,P(retention of polymorphism)=1/3P(\text{fixation of } A_1) = 1/3, P(\text{fixation of } A_2) = 1/3, P(\text{retention of polymorphism}) = 1/3

    Correct

    P(A1A1)=0.500×0.500=0.250P(A_1A_1) = 0.500 \times 0.500 = 0.250, P(A2A2)=0.500×0.500=0.250P(A_2A_2) = 0.500 \times 0.500 = 0.250, P(A1A2)=2×(0.500×0.500)=0.500P(A_1A_2) = 2 \times (0.500 \times 0.500) = 0.500

    You listed the three possible qualitative outcomes and assigned them equal probabilities of 1/31/3. Because self-fertilization combines independent maternal and paternal gametes (0.5A1+0.5A2)20.5A_1 + 0.5A_2)^2, heterozygosity can arise in two distinct ways (A1A2A_1A_2 and A2A1A_2A_1), producing a 1:2:11:2:1 Mendelian ratio rather than equal thirds.

  2. Step 2

    Evolution requires changes in allele frequencies across a population over generations. ⟹ An individual cannot evolve because its genetic makeup is fixed at conception. ⟹ The single founder bottleneck represents extreme sampling variance where drift instantaneously alters frequencies in the next generation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly articulated that evolution requires changes in allele frequencies across a population over generations.

You accurately explained that an individual cannot evolve because its genetic makeup is fixed at conception.

You correctly recognized that a single founder bottleneck creates extreme sampling variance (genetic drift) in the subsequent generation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equiprobable outcome fallacy in Mendelian crosses

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the three distinct zygotic states as equally likely events rather than deriving their probabilities from independent gamete combinations via Mendelian segregation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Mendelian Gametic Union
  • For a self-fertilizing monohybrid (A1A2A_1A_2), zygotic probabilities follow the binomial expansion (pA1+qA2)2=p2A1A1+2pqA1A2+q2A2A2(pA_1 + qA_2)^2 = p^2 A_1A_1 + 2pq A_1A_2 + q^2 A_2A_2.

  • Always determine zygotic probabilities by multiplying gametic frequencies rather than dividing 11 by the number of possible outcomes.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify gamete probabilities produced by meiosis in an A1A2A_1A_2 parent: P(A1)=0.500P(A_1) = 0.500 and P(A2)=0.500P(A_2) = 0.500.

  2. Multiply independent gamete probabilities for self-fertilization: P(A1A1)=0.500×0.500=0.250P(A_1A_1) = 0.500 \times 0.500 = 0.250, P(A2A2)=0.500×0.500=0.250P(A_2A_2) = 0.500 \times 0.500 = 0.250, and P(A1A2)=2×(0.500×0.500)=0.500P(A_1A_2) = 2 \times (0.500 \times 0.500) = 0.500.

Final answer

(a) P(fixation of A1)=0.250P(\text{fixation of } A_1) = 0.250, P(fixation of A2)=0.250P(\text{fixation of } A_2) = 0.250, P(retention of polymorphism)=0.500P(\text{retention of polymorphism}) = 0.500; (b) The founding female's genome remains static, while sampling error in her offspring alters allele frequencies in the daughter population, showing that evolution is a generational population phenomenon.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how independent assortment during meiosis leads to a 1:2:11:2:1 genotypic ratio in single-locus selfing crosses.

  • Practice constructing Punnett squares or binomial expansions for founder bottleneck scenarios to verify probability weights before stating outcomes.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student believes that an individual organism itself undergoes evolutionary change during a severe environmental bottleneck rather than the population across generations.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Self-fertilization cross: A1A2×A1A2A_1A_2 \times A_1A_2 ⟹ Zygote ratios: 14A1A1\frac{1}{4} A_1A_1, 12A1A2\frac{1}{2} A_1A_2, 14A2A2\frac{1}{4} A_2A_2 ⟹ P(fixation of A1)=14=0.25P(\text{fixation of } A_1) = \frac{1}{4} = 0.25, P(fixation of A2)=14=0.25P(\text{fixation of } A_2) = \frac{1}{4} = 0.25, P(retention of polymorphism)=12=0.50P(\text{retention of polymorphism}) = \frac{1}{2} = 0.50

  2. Step 2

    In a bottleneck, the individual colonizer evolves by adapting its genotype to the new tidal pool. This differs from standard evolution only because one individual changes rather than many. Evolution occurs within the founder's lifetime through extreme genetic drift.

    Correct

    The individual founder does not evolve during colonization or throughout her lifetime; she retains her A1A2A_1A_2 genotype. Evolution occurs strictly across generations at the population level, where severe sampling error during gamete union alters allele frequencies in the daughter generation.

    Individual organisms do not change their inherited genotype or evolve during their lifetime. Genetic drift is a sampling phenomenon that changes allele frequencies between parent and offspring generations in a population.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly modeled the self-fertilization event as a monohybrid cross between heterozygous alleles.

You calculated the exact probabilities of homozygosity and heterozygosity in the resulting zygotes.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Individual vs Population Evolution Misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated individual physiological acclimation or phenotypic plasticity with biological evolution, attributing evolutionary changes in genotype to a single organism's lifespan rather than to generational allele frequency shifts across a population.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Fundamental Unit of Evolution
  • Evolution is strictly defined as a change in the genetic composition (allele frequencies) of a population over generations. Individuals do not evolve; they develop and reproduce.

  • Always evaluate whether the described change is occurring within an individual's lifetime (not evolution) or between generations in a gene pool (evolution).

Mechanism of Genetic Drift
  • Genetic drift arises from random sampling of gametes when producing offspring, altering allele proportions from parents to progeny.

  • Attribute drift to generational transmission error in small populations, never to somatic or genotypic transformation of an adult organism.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the fundamental definition of biological evolution: a change in allele frequencies within a gene pool across generations.

  2. Clarify the status of the founder individual: the female maintains her diploid genotype (A1A2A_1A_2, p=0.500p = 0.500) throughout her entire life.

  3. Explain the founder effect bottleneck: drawing two gametes to produce a daughter zygote represents extreme sampling error (N=1N = 1), producing shifts to p=1.000p = 1.000, p=0.500p = 0.500, or p=0.000p = 0.000 in the next generation.

Final answer

(a) P(fixation of A1)=0.250P(\text{fixation of } A_1) = 0.250, P(fixation of A2)=0.250P(\text{fixation of } A_2) = 0.250, P(retention of polymorphism)=0.500P(\text{retention of polymorphism}) = 0.500; (b) The founding female does not evolve during dispersal or throughout her life; evolution occurs at the population level across generations through random gametic sampling error.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between individual physiological adaptation/acclimation and population-level genetic evolution.

  • Practice identifying the generation where allele frequency shifts take place in founder event scenarios.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A self-fertilizing diploid annual plant with genotype BbBb colonizes a new patch. Calculate the probability that a single offspring zygote is homozygous (either BBBB or bbbb).

Answer

0.5000.500 (or 50%50\%). By Mendelian segregation, P(BB)=0.5×0.5=0.25P(BB) = 0.5 \times 0.5 = 0.25 and P(bb)=0.5×0.5=0.25P(bb) = 0.5 \times 0.5 = 0.25. Summing both mutually exclusive homozygous states gives P(homozygous)=0.25+0.25=0.50P(\text{homozygous}) = 0.25 + 0.25 = 0.50.

02

A single gravid female copepod heterozygous at a neutral locus (A1A2A_1A_2) founds a population in an isolated pool and self-fertilizes, producing two independent zygotes. What is the probability that allele A1A_1 is completely lost from this new population in the first generation?

Answer

0.06250.0625 (or 1/161/16). Allele A1A_1 is lost only if both independent offspring are homozygous A2A2A_2A_2. The probability for each zygote is P(A2A2)=0.250P(A_2A_2) = 0.250. For two independent zygotes, P(both A2A2)=0.250×0.250=0.0625P(\text{both } A_2A_2) = 0.250 \times 0.250 = 0.0625.

03

Suppose a founding hermaphroditic organism has an asymmetric gamete production such that pollen carries allele A1A_1 with probability 0.600.60 and A2A_2 with 0.400.40, while ovules produce each allele at 0.500.50. Calculate the probability of instantaneous fixation of allele A1A_1 in a single selfed offspring.

Answer

0.3000.300 (or 30%30\%). Instantaneous fixation of A1A_1 requires homozygous A1A1A_1A_1. P(A1A1)=P(A1 from pollen)×P(A1 from ovule)=0.60×0.50=0.300P(A_1A_1) = P(A_1\text{ from pollen}) \times P(A_1\text{ from ovule}) = 0.60 \times 0.50 = 0.300.

Loading workspace…