Resources

A cylindrical plant tissue sample is placed in an open beaker containing an aqueous sucrose solution at 20.0∘C20.0^\circ\text{C} (293.15K293.15\text{K}). The water potential equation is given by Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p, where the solute potential is Ψs=−iCRT\Psi_s = -iCRT. For sucrose, the ionization constant is i=1.0i = 1.0, and the gas constant is R=0.0831 L⋅bar/(mol⋅K)R = 0.0831\text{ L}\cdot\text{bar}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}). At equilibrium, the plant tissue neither gains nor loses net mass, and its internal turgor pressure is measured to be Ψp=+3.50 bar\Psi_p = +3.50\text{ bar}. If the total internal water potential of the tissue is Ψ=−4.80 bar\Psi = -4.80\text{ bar}, calculate the molar concentration (CC) of the surrounding external sucrose solution.

Answer and steps

Final answer

C=0.341 MC = 0.341\text{ M}

Steps

01

Calculate the internal solute potential (Ψs\Psi_s) of the plant tissue

The overall water potential of a plant cell is the sum of its solute potential and its pressure (turgor) potential:

Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p

We are given:

  • Total internal water potential: Ψ=−4.80 bar\Psi = -4.80\text{ bar}
  • Turgor pressure potential: Ψp=+3.50 bar\Psi_p = +3.50\text{ bar}

Rearranging the formula to solve for the internal solute potential Ψs\Psi_s:

Ψs=Ψ−Ψp\Psi_s = \Psi - \Psi_p

Substitute the given values:

Ψs=−4.80 bar−3.50 bar=−8.30 bar\Psi_s = -4.80\text{ bar} - 3.50\text{ bar} = -8.30\text{ bar}

Key Pitfall: Pay close attention to signs. Solute potential (Ψs\Psi_s) is always negative in a solution because dissolved solutes decrease the free energy of water. Subtracting a positive turgor pressure (Ψp\Psi_p) makes Ψs\Psi_s more negative than the total water potential.


02

Use the solute potential equation to find molar concentration (CC)

The relationship between solute potential, ionization, temperature, and molar concentration is given by the van 't Hoff equation:

Ψs=−iCRT\Psi_s = -iCRT

Rearranging to solve for the molar concentration CC:

C=−ΨsiRTC = \frac{-\Psi_s}{iRT}

Substitute the known parameters:

  • Ionization constant for sucrose: i=1.0i = 1.0 (sucrose is a non-electrolyte and does not dissociate in water)
  • Pressure constant: R=0.0831 L⋅bar/(mol⋅K)R = 0.0831\text{ L}\cdot\text{bar}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})
  • Absolute temperature: T=293.15 KT = 293.15\text{ K}
  • Solute potential: Ψs=−8.30 bar\Psi_s = -8.30\text{ bar}

C=−(−8.30 bar)(1.0)⋅(0.0831 L⋅bar/(mol⋅K))⋅(293.15 K)C = \frac{-(-8.30\text{ bar})}{(1.0) \cdot (0.0831\text{ L}\cdot\text{bar}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})) \cdot (293.15\text{ K})}


03

Compute the final value

First, calculate the denominator:

iRT=1.0⋅0.0831⋅293.15=24.360765 bar⋅L/moliRT = 1.0 \cdot 0.0831 \cdot 293.15 = 24.360765\text{ bar}\cdot\text{L}/\text{mol}

Now, divide the solute potential magnitude by this product:

C=8.3024.360765 mol/L≈0.3407 MC = \frac{8.30}{24.360765}\text{ mol/L} \approx 0.3407\text{ M}

Rounding to three significant figures gives:

C=0.341 MC = 0.341\text{ M}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student mistakenly uses the internal solute potential of the plant tissue instead of the external solution's solute potential to calculate concentration.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Ψ=Ψs+Ψp  ⟹  −4.80=Ψs+3.50  ⟹  Ψs=−8.30 bar\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p \implies -4.80 = \Psi_s + 3.50 \implies \Psi_s = -8.30\text{ bar}

  2. Step 2

    −8.30=−(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(293.15)-8.30 = -(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(293.15)

    Correct

    −4.80 bar=−(1.0)(C)(0.0831 L⋅bar/(mol⋅K))(293.15 K)-4.80\text{ bar} = -(1.0)(C)(0.0831\text{ L}\cdot\text{bar}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))(293.15\text{ K})

    At dynamic equilibrium, the total water potentials are equal: Ψexternal=Ψtissue=−4.80 bar\Psi_{\text{external}} = \Psi_{\text{tissue}} = -4.80\text{ bar}. Because the beaker is open to the atmosphere, the external pressure potential is Ψp=0 bar\Psi_p = 0\text{ bar}, which means the external solute potential is Ψs,external=Ψexternal=−4.80 bar\Psi_{s,\text{external}} = \Psi_{\text{external}} = -4.80\text{ bar}, not the tissue's internal solute potential of −8.30 bar-8.30\text{ bar}.

  3. Step 3

    C=8.3024.36=0.341 mol/LC = \frac{8.30}{24.36} = 0.341\text{ mol/L}

    Correct

    C=4.80 bar24.3608 bar⋅L/mol≈0.197 MC = \frac{4.80\text{ bar}}{24.3608\text{ bar}\cdot\text{L}/\text{mol}} \approx 0.197\text{ M}

    This numerical result is affected by substituting the internal solute potential rather than the external solution's solute potential.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the water potential component equation Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p to solve for internal solute potential.

You correctly identified and substituted the constants i=1.0i = 1.0, R=0.0831 L⋅bar/(mol⋅K)R = 0.0831\text{ L}\cdot\text{bar}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}), and T=293.15 KT = 293.15\text{ K} into the van 't Hoff equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Internal Solute Potential with External Solute Potential

You used the plant tissue's internal solute potential (−8.30 bar-8.30\text{ bar}) to find the beaker's concentration instead of finding the external solution's solute potential.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Equilibrium between a plant tissue and an external solution means total water potential is equal (Ψtissue=Ψsolution\Psi_{\text{tissue}} = \Psi_{\text{solution}}), not individual solute potentials (Ψs,tissue≠Ψs,solution\Psi_{s,\text{tissue}} \neq \Psi_{s,\text{solution}}). Because the beaker is open to atmospheric pressure, Ψp,solution=0 bar\Psi_{p,\text{solution}} = 0\text{ bar}, making Ψs,solution=Ψsolution=−4.80 bar\Psi_{s,\text{solution}} = \Psi_{\text{solution}} = -4.80\text{ bar}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Equilibrium Condition
  • At osmotic equilibrium, total water potential is equal on both sides: Ψin=Ψout\Psi_{\text{in}} = \Psi_{\text{out}}. Component potentials Ψs\Psi_s and Ψp\Psi_p do not have to be equal individually.

  • Always set Ψsolution=Ψtissue\Psi_{\text{solution}} = \Psi_{\text{tissue}} first before breaking down the solution's potential.

Open Container Rule
  • Any open beaker or unpressurized solution has a pressure potential of Ψp=0 bar\Psi_p = 0\text{ bar}.

  • Set Ψs,solution=Ψsolution−0=Ψsolution\Psi_{s,\text{solution}} = \Psi_{\text{solution}} - 0 = \Psi_{\text{solution}} when dealing with an open container.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the equilibrium condition: Ψsolution=Ψtissue=−4.80 bar\Psi_{\text{solution}} = \Psi_{\text{tissue}} = -4.80\text{ bar}.

  2. Account for the open beaker: Ψp,solution=0 bar\Psi_{p,\text{solution}} = 0\text{ bar}, so Ψs,solution=−4.80 bar\Psi_{s,\text{solution}} = -4.80\text{ bar}.

  3. Substitute Ψs,solution\Psi_{s,\text{solution}} into the van 't Hoff equation: −4.80=−(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(293.15)-4.80 = -(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(293.15).

  4. Solve for concentration: C=4.8024.3608≈0.197 MC = \frac{4.80}{24.3608} \approx 0.197\text{ M}.

Final answer

C=0.197 MC = 0.197\text{ M}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that turgor pressure (Ψp\Psi_p) allows a plant cell to balance a solution with a different solute potential (Ψs\Psi_s).

  • Practice distinguishing between total water potential Ψ\Psi and solute potential Ψs\Psi_s when setting up equilibrium equations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student omits the negative sign in the solute potential formula, treating Ψ_s as positive and arriving at a negative molar concentration.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    At equilibrium, Ψsolution=Ψtissue=−4.80 bar  ⟹  In an open beaker, Ψp=0, so Ψs=−4.80 bar\text{At equilibrium, } \Psi_{\text{solution}} = \Psi_{\text{tissue}} = -4.80\text{ bar} \implies \text{In an open beaker, } \Psi_p = 0\text{, so } \Psi_s = -4.80\text{ bar}

    Correct

    Ψs=Ψ−Ψp=−4.80 bar−3.50 bar=−8.30 bar\Psi_s = \Psi - \Psi_p = -4.80\text{ bar} - 3.50\text{ bar} = -8.30\text{ bar}

    You set Ψp=0\Psi_p = 0 and equated Ψs\Psi_s directly to the total water potential. However, the problem specifies that the tissue has an internal turgor pressure of Ψp=+3.50 bar\Psi_p = +3.50\text{ bar}. Rearranging Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p gives Ψs=Ψ−Ψp=−4.80 bar−3.50 bar=−8.30 bar\Psi_s = \Psi - \Psi_p = -4.80\text{ bar} - 3.50\text{ bar} = -8.30\text{ bar}.

  2. Step 2

    Ψs=iCRT  ⟹  −4.80=(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(293.15)\Psi_s = iCRT \implies -4.80 = (1.0)(C)(0.0831)(293.15)

    Correct

    Ψs=−iCRT  ⟹  −8.30=−(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(293.15)\Psi_s = -iCRT \implies -8.30 = -(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(293.15)

    You omitted the negative sign in the solute potential equation. The correct formula is Ψs=−iCRT\Psi_s = -iCRT because dissolved solutes always decrease the water potential relative to pure water.

  3. Step 3

    C=−4.8024.36=−0.197 mol/LC = \frac{-4.80}{24.36} = -0.197\text{ mol/L}

    Correct

    C=−ΨsiRT=−(−8.30 bar)(1.0)(0.0831)(293.15)≈0.341 MC = \frac{-\Psi_s}{iRT} = \frac{-(-8.30\text{ bar})}{(1.0)(0.0831)(293.15)} \approx 0.341\text{ M}

    Because of the missing negative sign and incorrect solute potential, your calculation produced a negative molarity. Molar concentration must be positive.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the system reaches equilibrium when water potentials are equal.

You correctly substituted the values for the ionization constant ii, the gas constant RR, and the absolute temperature TT.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Negative Sign in Solute Potential Formula

You dropped the negative sign in the formula Ψs=−iCRT\Psi_s = -iCRT, which led directly to a negative concentration value.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated solute potential as Ψs=iCRT\Psi_s = iCRT rather than Ψs=−iCRT\Psi_s = -iCRT, forgetting that solute potential is inherently negative or zero. Additionally, you set Ψp=0\Psi_p = 0 rather than subtracting the given positive turgor pressure (Ψp=+3.50 bar\Psi_p = +3.50\text{ bar}) from the total water potential.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Solute Potential Sign Convention
  • Solute potential is always calculated as Ψs=−iCRT\Psi_s = -iCRT. Dissolved solutes reduce free water energy, making Ψs≤0\Psi_s \le 0.

  • Always write the explicit negative sign in front of iCRTiCRT and verify that your calculated concentration CC is a positive quantity.

Separating Solute Potential and Turgor Pressure
  • Total water potential is the sum of solute potential and pressure potential: Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p.

  • Rearrange the equation to Ψs=Ψ−Ψp\Psi_s = \Psi - \Psi_p before solving for concentration whenever turgor pressure is non-zero.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the solute potential by subtracting the turgor pressure from total water potential: Ψs=Ψ−Ψp=−4.80 bar−3.50 bar=−8.30 bar\Psi_s = \Psi - \Psi_p = -4.80\text{ bar} - 3.50\text{ bar} = -8.30\text{ bar}.

  2. Set up the solute potential formula with the leading negative sign: Ψs=−iCRT\Psi_s = -iCRT.

  3. Rearrange to solve for molar concentration: C=−ΨsiRT=−(−8.30 bar)(1.0)(0.0831 L⋅bar/(mol⋅K))(293.15 K)C = \frac{-\Psi_s}{iRT} = \frac{-(-8.30\text{ bar})}{(1.0)(0.0831\text{ L}\cdot\text{bar}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))(293.15\text{ K})}.

  4. Compute the final value: C=8.3024.3608≈0.341 MC = \frac{8.30}{24.3608} \approx 0.341\text{ M}.

Final answer

C=0.341 MC = 0.341\text{ M}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the physical meaning of solute potential: adding solute lowers water potential, which is why Ψs\Psi_s must carry a negative sign.

  • Whenever you finish calculating a physical quantity like mass, volume, or concentration, perform a quick sanity check to ensure the value is strictly positive.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses temperature in degrees Celsius instead of Kelvin in the solute potential formula.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    At equilibrium, \text{At equilibrium, } \Psi_{solution\text{solution}} = \Psi_{tissue\text{tissue}} = -4.80 bar\text{ bar}   ⟹  \implies \Psi_p = 0,  so \text{ so } \Psi_s = -4.80 bar\text{ bar}

    Correct

    \Psi_s = \Psi - \Psi_p = -4.80 bar\text{ bar} - 3.50 bar\text{ bar} = -8.30 bar\text{ bar}

    You assumed Ψp=0\Psi_p = 0, but the problem specifies that the tissue has an internal turgor pressure of Ψp=+3.50 bar\Psi_p = +3.50\text{ bar}. Rearranging Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p gives Ψs=−4.80−3.50=−8.30 bar\Psi_s = -4.80 - 3.50 = -8.30\text{ bar}.

  2. Step 2

    Ψs=−iCRT  ⟹  −4.80=−(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(20.0)\Psi_s = -iCRT \implies -4.80 = -(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(20.0)

    Correct

    Ψs=−iCRT  ⟹  −8.30=−(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(293.15)\Psi_s = -iCRT \implies -8.30 = -(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(293.15)

    You substituted temperature in degrees Celsius (20.020.0) rather than Kelvin (293.15 K293.15\text{ K}), and you carried forward the incorrect solute potential Ψs=−4.80 bar\Psi_s = -4.80\text{ bar}.

  3. Step 3

    C = 4.800.0831×20.0\frac{4.80}{0.0831 \times 20.0}   ⟹  \implies C = 4.801.662\frac{4.80}{1.662} = 2.89 mol/L\text{ mol/L}

    Correct

    C = 8.30(1.0)(0.0831)(293.15)\frac{8.30}{(1.0)(0.0831)(293.15)} ≈\approx 0.341 M\text{ M}

    Your algebraic manipulation and arithmetic were executed properly, but the final numerical value is affected by the incorrect solute potential and temperature from previous steps.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly stated that water potential is balanced at equilibrium.

You selected the correct formula for solute potential, Ψs=−iCRT\Psi_s = -iCRT.

You correctly identified the ionization constant i=1.0i = 1.0 and gas constant R=0.0831 L⋅bar/(mol⋅K)R = 0.0831\text{ L}\cdot\text{bar}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}).

You accurately rearranged the equation to solve for molar concentration CC.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Temperature Unit Error (Celsius vs. Kelvin) & Omitted Turgor Pressure

You entered temperature as 20.0∘C20.0^\circ\text{C} instead of 293.15 K293.15\text{ K}, and you set Ψp=0\Psi_p = 0 despite being given a positive turgor pressure of +3.50 bar+3.50\text{ bar}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

The gas constant RR includes units of K−1\text{K}^{-1}, requiring temperature to be in absolute units (Kelvin). Furthermore, plant cells contain cell walls that generate positive pressure potential (turgor pressure, Ψp\Psi_p), so solute potential must be determined via Ψs=Ψ−Ψp\Psi_s = \Psi - \Psi_p rather than assuming pressure is zero.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Temperature Must Be in Kelvin
  • In Ψs=−iCRT\Psi_s = -iCRT, temperature TT must always be expressed in Kelvin: T(K)=T(∘C)+273.15T(\text{K}) = T(^\circ\text{C}) + 273.15.

  • Always convert temperatures to Kelvin before multiplying by the gas constant RR.

Account for Plant Turgor Pressure
  • Plant cells maintain turgor pressure against their rigid cell walls, so Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p.

  • Subtract turgor pressure from total water potential to determine solute potential: Ψs=Ψ−Ψp\Psi_s = \Psi - \Psi_p.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate internal solute potential: Ψs=Ψ−Ψp=−4.80 bar−3.50 bar=−8.30 bar\Psi_s = \Psi - \Psi_p = -4.80\text{ bar} - 3.50\text{ bar} = -8.30\text{ bar}.

  2. Convert temperature to Kelvin: T=20.0+273.15=293.15 KT = 20.0 + 273.15 = 293.15\text{ K}.

  3. Substitute values into Ψs=−iCRT\Psi_s = -iCRT: −8.30=−(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(293.15)-8.30 = -(1.0)(C)(0.0831)(293.15).

  4. Solve for concentration: C=8.30(1.0)(0.0831)(293.15)=8.3024.3608≈0.341 MC = \frac{8.30}{(1.0)(0.0831)(293.15)} = \frac{8.30}{24.3608} \approx 0.341\text{ M}.

Final answer

C=0.341 MC = 0.341\text{ M}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice converting temperatures to Kelvin automatically whenever an equation involves the gas constant RR.

  • Review the difference between open-container solutions (where Ψp=0\Psi_p = 0) and living plant cells with turgor pressure (where Ψp>0\Psi_p > 0).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A zucchini tissue sample at equilibrium in an open beaker of sucrose solution has a measured total water potential of Ψ=−3.20 bar\Psi = -3.20\text{ bar}. The temperature is 22.0∘C22.0^\circ\text{C} (295.15 K295.15\text{ K}), i=1.0i = 1.0, and R=0.0831 L⋅bar/(mol⋅K)R = 0.0831\text{ L}\cdot\text{bar}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}). Calculate the molar concentration (CC) of the surrounding sucrose solution.

Answer

C≈0.130 MC \approx 0.130\text{ M}. Key steps: In an open container, Ψp=0\Psi_p = 0, so Ψs,solution=Ψsolution=Ψtissue=−3.20 bar\Psi_{s,\text{solution}} = \Psi_{\text{solution}} = \Psi_{\text{tissue}} = -3.20\text{ bar}. Then C=−ΨsiRT=3.20(1.0)(0.0831)(295.15)≈0.130 MC = \frac{-\Psi_s}{iRT} = \frac{3.20}{(1.0)(0.0831)(295.15)} \approx 0.130\text{ M}.

02

A plant tissue core has an internal solute potential of Ψs=−7.50 bar\Psi_s = -7.50\text{ bar} and an internal turgor pressure of Ψp=+4.00 bar\Psi_p = +4.00\text{ bar}. It is placed in an open beaker containing an aqueous NaCl\text{NaCl} solution (i=2.0i = 2.0) at 20.0∘C20.0^\circ\text{C} (293.15 K293.15\text{ K}). At equilibrium, no net mass change occurs. Calculate the molar concentration (CC) of the NaCl\text{NaCl} solution.

Answer

C≈0.0718 MC \approx 0.0718\text{ M}. Key steps: Calculate total tissue water potential Ψ=Ψs+Ψp=−7.50+4.00=−3.50 bar\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p = -7.50 + 4.00 = -3.50\text{ bar}. At equilibrium in an open beaker, Ψs,solution=Ψtissue=−3.50 bar\Psi_{s,\text{solution}} = \Psi_{\text{tissue}} = -3.50\text{ bar}. Then C=−ΨsiRT=3.50(2.0)(0.0831)(293.15)=3.5048.72≈0.0718 MC = \frac{-\Psi_s}{iRT} = \frac{3.50}{(2.0)(0.0831)(293.15)} = \frac{3.50}{48.72} \approx 0.0718\text{ M}.

03

A potato core is placed in an open 0.250 M0.250\text{ M} glucose solution (i=1.0i = 1.0) at 25.0∘C25.0^\circ\text{C} (298.15 K298.15\text{ K}). At equilibrium, the potato cells maintain an internal solute potential of Ψs=−9.20 bar\Psi_s = -9.20\text{ bar}. Determine the turgor pressure (Ψp\Psi_p) within the potato cells at equilibrium.

Answer

Ψp=+3.01 bar\Psi_p = +3.01\text{ bar}. Key steps: In the open beaker, Ψp=0\Psi_p = 0, so Ψsolution=Ψs=−(1.0)(0.250)(0.0831)(298.15)≈−6.19 bar\Psi_{\text{solution}} = \Psi_s = -(1.0)(0.250)(0.0831)(298.15) \approx -6.19\text{ bar}. At equilibrium, Ψtissue=Ψsolution=−6.19 bar\Psi_{\text{tissue}} = \Psi_{\text{solution}} = -6.19\text{ bar}. Using Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p, solve for turgor pressure: Ψp=Ψ−Ψs=−6.19−(−9.20)=+3.01 bar\Psi_p = \Psi - \Psi_s = -6.19 - (-9.20) = +3.01\text{ bar}.

Loading workspace…