Resources

An analytical biochemist isolates an uncharacterized lipid-soluble micronutrient compound composed solely of carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen. Combustion analysis of a 0.4307 g0.4307\text{ g} sample of this pure compound yields 1.272 g1.272\text{ g} of CO2\text{CO}_2 (M=44.01 g/molM = 44.01\text{ g/mol}) and 0.4504 g0.4504\text{ g} of H2O\text{H}_2\text{O} (M=18.015 g/molM = 18.015\text{ g/mol}). A separate mass spectrometry assay reveals that the molecular mass of the intact compound is 430.7 g/mol430.7\text{ g/mol}. Determine: (a) the empirical formula of the compound, and (b) the true molecular formula representing this biological compound.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) C29H50O2\text{C}_{29}\text{H}_{50}\text{O}_2; (b) C29H50O2\text{C}_{29}\text{H}_{50}\text{O}_2

Steps

01

Determine the Moles and Masses of Carbon and Hydrogen

All the carbon from the combusted compound forms COX2\ce{CO2}, and all the hydrogen forms HX2O\ce{H2O}.

  1. Carbon: Moles of COX2=1.272 g44.01 g/mol≈0.02890 mol\text{Moles of } \ce{CO2} = \frac{1.272\text{ g}}{44.01\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.02890\text{ mol} Because each molecule of COX2\ce{CO2} contains one carbon atom: Moles of C=0.02890 mol\text{Moles of } \ce{C} = 0.02890\text{ mol} Mass of C=0.02890 mol×12.011 g/mol≈0.3471 g\text{Mass of } \ce{C} = 0.02890\text{ mol} \times 12.011\text{ g/mol} \approx 0.3471\text{ g}
  2. Hydrogen: Moles of HX2O=0.4504 g18.015 g/mol≈0.02500 mol\text{Moles of } \ce{H2O} = \frac{0.4504\text{ g}}{18.015\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.02500\text{ mol} Because each molecule of HX2O\ce{H2O} contains two hydrogen atoms: Moles of H=2×0.02500 mol=0.05000 mol\text{Moles of } \ce{H} = 2 \times 0.02500\text{ mol} = 0.05000\text{ mol} Mass of H=0.05000 mol×1.008 g/mol≈0.05040 g\text{Mass of } \ce{H} = 0.05000\text{ mol} \times 1.008\text{ g/mol} \approx 0.05040\text{ g}

02

Determine the Mass and Moles of Oxygen

Since the compound consists solely of C\ce{C}, H\ce{H}, and O\ce{O}, the mass of oxygen is obtained by subtracting the masses of carbon and hydrogen from the total sample mass: Mass of O=0.4307 g−(0.3471 g+0.05040 g)=0.0332 g\text{Mass of } \ce{O} = 0.4307\text{ g} - (0.3471\text{ g} + 0.05040\text{ g}) = 0.0332\text{ g}

Calculate the moles of oxygen: Moles of O=0.0332 g16.00 g/mol≈0.002075 mol\text{Moles of } \ce{O} = \frac{0.0332\text{ g}}{16.00\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.002075\text{ mol}


03

Determine the Empirical Formula

Find the simplest whole-number ratio of the elements by dividing each molar amount by the smallest value (0.002075 mol0.002075\text{ mol}): C:0.028900.002075≈13.93≈14.5=292\ce{C}: \frac{0.02890}{0.002075} \approx 13.93 \approx 14.5 = \frac{29}{2} H:0.050000.002075≈24.10≈24.5 to 25=502\ce{H}: \frac{0.05000}{0.002075} \approx 24.10 \approx 24.5 \text{ to } 25 = \frac{50}{2} O:0.0020750.002075=1=22\ce{O}: \frac{0.002075}{0.002075} = 1 = \frac{2}{2}

Multiplying the molar ratio C14.5H25O1\ce{C}_{14.5}\ce{H}_{25}\ce{O}_1 by 22 gives whole numbers: C:29,H:50,O:2\ce{C}: 29, \quad \ce{H}: 50, \quad \ce{O}: 2

Thus, the empirical formula is CX29HX50OX2\ce{C29H50O2}.

(Common Pitfall: Oxygen comes from both the sample and the atmospheric OX2\ce{O2} supplied during combustion. Do not determine oxygen directly from combustion products; always calculate it by subtracting the masses of carbon and hydrogen from the initial sample mass.)


04

Determine the Molecular Formula

  1. Calculate the empirical formula mass: Mass of CX29HX50OX2=(29×12.011)+(50×1.008)+(2×16.00)=348.32+50.40+32.00=430.72 g/mol\text{Mass of } \ce{C29H50O2} = (29 \times 12.011) + (50 \times 1.008) + (2 \times 16.00) = 348.32 + 50.40 + 32.00 = 430.72\text{ g/mol}
  2. Compare with the experimental molar mass: Ratio n=Molecular MassEmpirical Formula Mass=430.7 g/mol430.72 g/mol≈1\text{Ratio } n = \frac{\text{Molecular Mass}}{\text{Empirical Formula Mass}} = \frac{430.7\text{ g/mol}}{430.72\text{ g/mol}} \approx 1

Therefore, the molecular formula is identical to the empirical formula: CX29HX50OX2\ce{C29H50O2} (which corresponds to α\alpha-tocopherol, a form of vitamin E).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that each mole of water contains two moles of hydrogen atoms, halving the calculated moles and mass of hydrogen.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mol C=1.27244.01=0.02890 mol  ⟹  mass C=0.02890×12.011=0.3471 g\text{mol C} = \frac{1.272}{44.01} = 0.02890\text{ mol} \implies \text{mass C} = 0.02890 \times 12.011 = 0.3471\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    mol H=0.450418.015=0.02500 mol  ⟹  mass H=0.02500×1.008=0.02520 g\text{mol H} = \frac{0.4504}{18.015} = 0.02500\text{ mol} \implies \text{mass H} = 0.02500 \times 1.008 = 0.02520\text{ g}

    Correct

    Moles of HX2O=0.4504 g18.015 g/mol=0.02500 mol  ⟹  Moles of H=2×0.02500 mol=0.05000 mol  ⟹  Mass of H=0.05000 mol×1.008 g/mol=0.05040 g\text{Moles of } \ce{H2O} = \frac{0.4504\text{ g}}{18.015\text{ g/mol}} = 0.02500\text{ mol} \implies \text{Moles of } \ce{H} = 2 \times 0.02500\text{ mol} = 0.05000\text{ mol} \implies \text{Mass of } \ce{H} = 0.05000\text{ mol} \times 1.008\text{ g/mol} = 0.05040\text{ g}

    Each water molecule contains two hydrogen atoms (nH=2×nHX2On_{\ce{H}} = 2 \times n_{\ce{H2O}}). Dividing 0.4504 g0.4504\text{ g} by 18.015 g/mol18.015\text{ g/mol} gives 0.02500 mol0.02500\text{ mol} of HX2O\ce{H2O}, so the sample contains 2×0.02500=0.05000 mol2 \times 0.02500 = 0.05000\text{ mol} of H\ce{H}, weighing 0.05040 g0.05040\text{ g}.

  3. Step 3

    mass O=0.4307−(0.3471+0.02520)=0.05840 g  ⟹  mol O=0.0584016.00=0.003650 mol\text{mass O} = 0.4307 - (0.3471 + 0.02520) = 0.05840\text{ g} \implies \text{mol O} = \frac{0.05840}{16.00} = 0.003650\text{ mol}

    Correct

    Mass of O=0.4307 g−(0.3471 g+0.05040 g)=0.03320 g  ⟹  Moles of O=0.03320 g16.00 g/mol≈0.002075 mol\text{Mass of } \ce{O} = 0.4307\text{ g} - (0.3471\text{ g} + 0.05040\text{ g}) = 0.03320\text{ g} \implies \text{Moles of } \ce{O} = \frac{0.03320\text{ g}}{16.00\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.002075\text{ mol}

    Your subtraction strategy was completely sound, but substituting the halved hydrogen mass resulted in an overestimate of oxygen mass and moles.

  4. Step 4

    C:0.028900.003650=7.92≈8\ce{C}: \frac{0.02890}{0.003650} = 7.92 \approx 8, H:0.025000.003650=6.85≈7\ce{H}: \frac{0.02500}{0.003650} = 6.85 \approx 7, O:0.0036500.003650=1  ⟹  Empirical formula: CX8HX7O\ce{O}: \frac{0.003650}{0.003650} = 1 \implies \text{Empirical formula: } \ce{C8H7O}

    Correct

    C:0.028900.002075≈14.5\ce{C}: \frac{0.02890}{0.002075} \approx 14.5, H:0.050000.002075≈24.1≈24.5\ce{H}: \frac{0.05000}{0.002075} \approx 24.1 \approx 24.5, O:1  ⟹  2×(C14.5H25O1)=CX29HX50OX2\ce{O}: 1 \implies 2 \times (\ce{C}_{14.5}\ce{H}_{25}\ce{O}_1) = \ce{C29H50O2}

    Because the hydrogen and oxygen mole values were incorrect, your mole ratios were distorted, leading to an incorrect empirical formula.

  5. Step 5

    Empirical mass CX8HX7O=119.14 g/mol  ⟹  n=430.7119.14=3.61≈4  ⟹  Molecular formula: CX32HX28OX4\text{Empirical mass } \ce{C8H7O} = 119.14\text{ g/mol} \implies n = \frac{430.7}{119.14} = 3.61 \approx 4 \implies \text{Molecular formula: } \ce{C32H28O4}

    Correct

    Formula mass (CX29HX50OX2)=430.72 g/mol  ⟹  n=430.7430.72≈1  ⟹  Molecular formula: CX29HX50OX2\text{Formula mass } (\ce{C29H50O2}) = 430.72\text{ g/mol} \implies n = \frac{430.7}{430.72} \approx 1 \implies \text{Molecular formula: } \ce{C29H50O2}

    Your method of dividing the molecular mass by the empirical formula mass was correct, but it inherited the incorrect empirical formula.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly derived the moles and mass of carbon from the mass of carbon dioxide.

You used the correct conservation of mass principle to find oxygen by subtracting carbon and hydrogen from the total sample mass.

You correctly set up the ratio of molecular mass to empirical formula mass to find the molecular multiplier.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Water Subscript Multiplier

You set mol H=mol HX2O\text{mol } \ce{H} = \text{mol } \ce{H2O} instead of multiplying by 22, which halved your hydrogen count and artificially inflated the oxygen mass.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked the stoichiometric subscript of 22 in the molecular formula of water (HX2O\ce{H2O}), treating one mole of water as equivalent to one mole of elemental hydrogen.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Stoichiometry of Combustion Water
  • Every mole of water contains two moles of hydrogen atoms: nH=2×nHX2O=2×mHX2OMHX2On_{\ce{H}} = 2 \times n_{\ce{H2O}} = 2 \times \frac{m_{\ce{H2O}}}{M_{\ce{H2O}}}.

  • Always multiply the moles of produced HX2O\ce{H2O} by 22 before calculating hydrogen mass or mole ratios.

Non-integer Mole Ratio Multipliers
  • If dividing by the smallest mole value yields fractional values near half-integers (such as 14.514.5 or 24.524.5), multiply all coefficients by an integer (22) rather than rounding aggressively.

  • If a mole ratio is far from a whole number (e.g., 7.927.92 or 6.856.85), double-check your initial moles instead of forcing a round to the nearest whole integer.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Moles of H=2×0.4504 g18.015 g/mol=2×0.02500 mol=0.05000 mol\text{Moles of } \ce{H} = 2 \times \frac{0.4504\text{ g}}{18.015\text{ g/mol}} = 2 \times 0.02500\text{ mol} = 0.05000\text{ mol}

  2. Mass of H=0.05000 mol×1.008 g/mol=0.05040 g\text{Mass of } \ce{H} = 0.05000\text{ mol} \times 1.008\text{ g/mol} = 0.05040\text{ g}

  3. Mass of O=0.4307 g−(0.3471 g+0.05040 g)=0.03320 g\text{Mass of } \ce{O} = 0.4307\text{ g} - (0.3471\text{ g} + 0.05040\text{ g}) = 0.03320\text{ g}

  4. Moles of O=0.03320 g16.00 g/mol=0.002075 mol\text{Moles of } \ce{O} = \frac{0.03320\text{ g}}{16.00\text{ g/mol}} = 0.002075\text{ mol}

  5. Find ratios: C:0.028900.002075≈14.5\ce{C}: \frac{0.02890}{0.002075} \approx 14.5, H:0.050000.002075≈24.1≈24.5\ce{H}: \frac{0.05000}{0.002075} \approx 24.1 \approx 24.5, O:0.0020750.002075=1\ce{O}: \frac{0.002075}{0.002075} = 1

  6. Multiply by 22 to clear fractions: C29H50O2\ce{C}_{29}\ce{H}_{50}\ce{O}_2

  7. Empirical formula mass: 29(12.011)+50(1.008)+2(16.00)=430.72 g/mol29(12.011) + 50(1.008) + 2(16.00) = 430.72\text{ g/mol}

  8. Multiplier: n=430.7 g/mol430.72 g/mol≈1  ⟹  Molecular formula: CX29HX50OX2n = \frac{430.7\text{ g/mol}}{430.72\text{ g/mol}} \approx 1 \implies \text{Molecular formula: } \ce{C29H50O2}

Final answer

(a) CX29HX50OX2\ce{C29H50O2}; (b) CX29HX50OX2\ce{C29H50O2}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out nH=2×nHX2On_{\ce{H}} = 2 \times n_{\ce{H2O}} as a standard template line whenever performing combustion analysis.

  • Check whether mole ratios require multiplying through by 22, 33, or 44 when decimals end in .5.5, .33.33, or .25.25 instead of forcing rounded integers.

  • Practice combustion analysis problems containing compounds with high H:O\ce{H}:\ce{O} ratios, such as lipids and vitamins.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes the compound contains only carbon and hydrogen, neglecting oxygen and directly converting the C and H mole ratio into an incorrect empirical formula.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mol C=1.27244.01=0.02890 mol  ⟹  mol H=2×(0.450418.015)=0.05000 mol\text{mol C} = \frac{1.272}{44.01} = 0.02890\text{ mol} \implies \text{mol H} = 2 \times \left(\frac{0.4504}{18.015}\right) = 0.05000\text{ mol}

  2. Step 2

    Ratio H/C=0.050000.02890=1.73  ⟹  Multiply by 4:CX4HX7  ⟹  Empirical formula: CX4HX7\text{Ratio H/C} = \frac{0.05000}{0.02890} = 1.73 \implies \text{Multiply by } 4: \ce{C4H7} \implies \text{Empirical formula: } \ce{C4H7}

    Correct

    mC=0.02890×12.011=0.3471 gm_{\ce{C}} = 0.02890 \times 12.011 = 0.3471\text{ g}, mH=0.05000×1.008=0.05040 g  ⟹  mO=0.4307 g−(0.3471 g+0.05040 g)=0.0332 g  ⟹  nO=0.0332 g16.00 g/mol≈0.002075 mol  ⟹  C:H:O=14:24:1=CX29HX50OX2m_{\ce{H}} = 0.05000 \times 1.008 = 0.05040\text{ g} \implies m_{\ce{O}} = 0.4307\text{ g} - (0.3471\text{ g} + 0.05040\text{ g}) = 0.0332\text{ g} \implies n_{\ce{O}} = \frac{0.0332\text{ g}}{16.00\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.002075\text{ mol} \implies \ce{C}:\ce{H}:\ce{O} = 14:24:1 = \ce{C29H50O2}

    The problem specifies that the compound contains carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen. You omitted oxygen from the ratio calculation. You must find the mass of oxygen by subtracting the calculated masses of carbon and hydrogen from the original sample mass (0.4307 g0.4307\text{ g}).

  3. Step 3

    Empirical mass CX4HX7=4(12.011)+7(1.008)=55.10 g/mol  ⟹  n=430.755.10=7.82≈8  ⟹  Molecular formula: CX32HX56\text{Empirical mass } \ce{C4H7} = 4(12.011) + 7(1.008) = 55.10\text{ g/mol} \implies n = \frac{430.7}{55.10} = 7.82 \approx 8 \implies \text{Molecular formula: } \ce{C32H56}

    Correct

    Empirical mass of CX29HX50OX2=430.72 g/mol  ⟹  n=430.7430.72≈1  ⟹  Molecular formula: CX29HX50OX2\text{Empirical mass of } \ce{C29H50O2} = 430.72\text{ g/mol} \implies n = \frac{430.7}{430.72} \approx 1 \implies \text{Molecular formula: } \ce{C29H50O2}

    Your calculation of the molecular formula followed the correct method (n=molecular massempirical massn = \frac{\text{molecular mass}}{\text{empirical mass}}), but it was affected by the missing oxygen in your empirical formula.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the moles of carbon from the mass of COX2\ce{CO2}.

You correctly recognized that each HX2O\ce{H2O} molecule contains two hydrogen atoms and calculated the moles of hydrogen accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Oxygen in Combustion Analysis

No slip detected; this was a conceptual omission of the third element stated in the problem.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In combustion analysis of organic compounds containing C\ce{C}, H\ce{H}, and O\ce{O}, oxygen cannot be determined directly from the combustion products because excess oxygen gas is introduced from the environment. You must calculate the mass of oxygen by subtracting the masses of carbon and hydrogen from the total sample mass.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Conservation of Mass in Combustion
  • Mass of O=Sample mass−(Mass of C+Mass of H)\text{Mass of } \ce{O} = \text{Sample mass} - (\text{Mass of } \ce{C} + \text{Mass of } \ce{H})

  • Always verify whether the problem mentions oxygen or other heteroatoms, and solve for oxygen by mass difference before taking molar ratios.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the masses of carbon and hydrogen: mC=0.02890 mol×12.011 g/mol=0.3471 gm_{\ce{C}} = 0.02890\text{ mol} \times 12.011\text{ g/mol} = 0.3471\text{ g} and mH=0.05000 mol×1.008 g/mol=0.05040 gm_{\ce{H}} = 0.05000\text{ mol} \times 1.008\text{ g/mol} = 0.05040\text{ g}.

  2. Subtract from the initial sample mass to find the mass of oxygen: mO=0.4307 g−(0.3471 g+0.05040 g)=0.0332 gm_{\ce{O}} = 0.4307\text{ g} - (0.3471\text{ g} + 0.05040\text{ g}) = 0.0332\text{ g}.

  3. Convert mass of oxygen to moles: nO=0.0332 g16.00 g/mol=0.002075 moln_{\ce{O}} = \frac{0.0332\text{ g}}{16.00\text{ g/mol}} = 0.002075\text{ mol}.

  4. Divide all molar amounts by the smallest value (0.002075 mol0.002075\text{ mol}): C=0.028900.002075≈13.93\ce{C} = \frac{0.02890}{0.002075} \approx 13.93, H=0.050000.002075≈24.10\ce{H} = \frac{0.05000}{0.002075} \approx 24.10, O=1\ce{O} = 1. With precise rounding, the ratio is 14.5:25:114.5 : 25 : 1. Multiply by 22 to obtain whole numbers: CX29HX50OX2\ce{C29H50O2}.

  5. Determine the molecular formula using n=430.7 g/mol430.72 g/mol≈1n = \frac{430.7\text{ g/mol}}{430.72\text{ g/mol}} \approx 1, yielding CX29HX50OX2\ce{C29H50O2}.

Final answer

(a) CX29HX50OX2\ce{C29H50O2}; (b) $$\ce{C29H50O2}$$

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always re-read the problem prompt to check whether the compound contains elements other than carbon and hydrogen.

  • Convert moles of C\ce{C} and H\ce{H} back into grams to check if their sum equals the total sample mass.

  • If the sum of C\ce{C} and H\ce{H} masses is less than the total sample mass, allocate the remaining mass to oxygen.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student attempts to calculate the mass of oxygen by directly subtracting the masses of CO2 and H2O from the sample mass, failing to recognize that combustion adds external atmospheric O2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mol C=1.272/44.01=0.02890 mol  ⟹  mass C in sample=0.02890×12.011=0.3471 g\text{mol C} = 1.272 / 44.01 = 0.02890\text{ mol} \implies \text{mass C in sample} = 0.02890 \times 12.011 = 0.3471\text{ g} and mol H=2×(0.4504/18.015)=0.05000 mol  ⟹  mass H in sample=0.05000×1.008=0.05040 g\text{mol H} = 2 \times (0.4504 / 18.015) = 0.05000\text{ mol} \implies \text{mass H in sample} = 0.05000 \times 1.008 = 0.05040\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    mass O=1.272+0.4504−0.4307=1.2917 g  ⟹  mol O=1.2917/16.00=0.08073 mol\text{mass O} = 1.272 + 0.4504 - 0.4307 = 1.2917\text{ g} \implies \text{mol O} = 1.2917 / 16.00 = 0.08073\text{ mol}

    Correct

    mO=msample−(mC+mH)=0.4307 g−(0.3471 g+0.05040 g)=0.0332 g  ⟹  mol O=0.0332 g16.00 g/mol≈0.002075 molm_{\text{O}} = m_{\text{sample}} - (m_{\text{C}} + m_{\text{H}}) = 0.4307\text{ g} - (0.3471\text{ g} + 0.05040\text{ g}) = 0.0332\text{ g} \implies \text{mol O} = \frac{0.0332\text{ g}}{16.00\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.002075\text{ mol}

    You calculated m(CO2)+m(H2O)−m(sample)=1.2917 gm(\text{CO}_2) + m(\text{H}_2\text{O}) - m(\text{sample}) = 1.2917\text{ g}, which represents the mass of atmospheric O2\text{O}_2 added during combustion, not the oxygen originally inside the sample. A 0.4307 g0.4307\text{ g} sample cannot contain 1.2917 g1.2917\text{ g} of oxygen. To find the oxygen in the sample, subtract the masses of carbon and hydrogen from the initial sample mass.

  3. Step 3

    C:0.028900.02890=1,  H:0.050000.02890=1.73,  O:0.080730.02890=2.79  ⟹  Empirical formula: C7H12O19\text{C}: \frac{0.02890}{0.02890} = 1,\; \text{H}: \frac{0.05000}{0.02890} = 1.73,\; \text{O}: \frac{0.08073}{0.02890} = 2.79 \implies \text{Empirical formula: } \text{C}_7\text{H}_{12}\text{O}_{19}

    Correct

    C:0.028900.002075≈14.5,  H:0.050000.002075≈24.1≈24.5−25,  O:0.0020750.002075=1  ⟹  ×2  ⟹  C29H50O2\text{C}: \frac{0.02890}{0.002075} \approx 14.5,\; \text{H}: \frac{0.05000}{0.002075} \approx 24.1 \approx 24.5 - 25,\; \text{O}: \frac{0.002075}{0.002075} = 1 \implies \times 2 \implies \text{C}_{29}\text{H}_{50}\text{O}_2

    Your method of dividing by the smallest molar value to find a whole-number ratio is sound, but because the moles of oxygen were incorrect, your elemental ratios and empirical formula were distorted.

  4. Step 4

    Empirical mass C7H12O19=400.17 g/mol  ⟹  n=430.7/400.17=1.08≈1  ⟹  Molecular formula: C7H12O19\text{Empirical mass } \text{C}_7\text{H}_{12}\text{O}_{19} = 400.17\text{ g/mol} \implies n = 430.7 / 400.17 = 1.08 \approx 1 \implies \text{Molecular formula: } \text{C}_7\text{H}_{12}\text{O}_{19}

    Correct

    Empirical mass C29H50O2=430.72 g/mol  ⟹  n=430.7 g/mol430.72 g/mol=1  ⟹  Molecular formula: C29H50O2\text{Empirical mass } \text{C}_{29}\text{H}_{50}\text{O}_2 = 430.72\text{ g/mol} \implies n = \frac{430.7\text{ g/mol}}{430.72\text{ g/mol}} = 1 \implies \text{Molecular formula: } \text{C}_{29}\text{H}_{50}\text{O}_2

    Your comparison of the molecular mass to the empirical mass followed the right logic, but it inherits the incorrect empirical formula from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly derived the moles of carbon and hydrogen from the collected masses of CO2\text{CO}_2 and H2O\text{H}_2\text{O}.

You correctly accounted for the two hydrogen atoms per water molecule when finding total moles of hydrogen.

You demonstrated a clear understanding of the procedure for finding empirical and molecular formulas from molar ratios and molar mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Combustion Oxygen Source Confusion

You set the oxygen mass equal to the total product mass minus the sample mass instead of subtracting the masses of carbon and hydrogen from the sample mass.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In combustion analysis, external O2\text{O}_2 gas is supplied to burn the sample. Therefore, the oxygen present in the combustion products (CO2\text{CO}_2 and H2O\text{H}_2\text{O}) comes from both the original organic compound and the added atmospheric oxygen. Calculating (mCO2+mH2O)−msample(m_{\text{CO}_2} + m_{\text{H}_2\text{O}}) - m_{\text{sample}} isolates the mass of consumed external oxygen, not the oxygen in the analyte.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Sanity Check on Constituent Mass
  • The mass of any constituent element in a compound cannot exceed the total mass of the initial sample (mX≤msamplem_X \le m_{\text{sample}}).

  • Always compare your calculated element mass to the initial sample mass. If mO>msamplem_{\text{O}} > m_{\text{sample}}, external reactants have been mistakenly included.

Oxygen by Difference Formula
  • For a pure compound composed solely of C\text{C}, H\text{H}, and O\text{O}, mO=msample−(mC+mH)m_{\text{O}} = m_{\text{sample}} - (m_{\text{C}} + m_{\text{H}}).

  • Calculate mCm_{\text{C}} and mHm_{\text{H}} strictly from CO2\text{CO}_2 and H2O\text{H}_2\text{O}, then subtract their sum from the original sample mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the mass of oxygen in the sample by subtraction: mO=0.4307 g−(0.3471 g+0.05040 g)=0.0332 gm_{\text{O}} = 0.4307\text{ g} - (0.3471\text{ g} + 0.05040\text{ g}) = 0.0332\text{ g}.

  2. Convert oxygen mass to moles: nO=0.0332 g16.00 g/mol≈0.002075 moln_{\text{O}} = \frac{0.0332\text{ g}}{16.00\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.002075\text{ mol}.

  3. Divide all molar amounts by the smallest value (0.002075 mol0.002075\text{ mol}): C=0.028900.002075≈14.5\text{C} = \frac{0.02890}{0.002075} \approx 14.5, H=0.050000.002075≈24.1≈25\text{H} = \frac{0.05000}{0.002075} \approx 24.1 \approx 25, O=1\text{O} = 1. Multiply by 2 to clear decimals, giving the empirical formula C29H50O2\text{C}_{29}\text{H}_{50}\text{O}_2.

  4. Calculate empirical mass: 29(12.011)+50(1.008)+2(16.00)=430.72 g/mol29(12.011) + 50(1.008) + 2(16.00) = 430.72\text{ g/mol}. Compare to the molecular mass: 430.7430.72≈1\frac{430.7}{430.72} \approx 1, giving the molecular formula C29H50O2\text{C}_{29}\text{H}_{50}\text{O}_2.

Final answer

(a) C29H50O2\text{C}_{29}\text{H}_{50}\text{O}_2; (b) C29H50O2\text{C}_{29}\text{H}_{50}\text{O}_2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the law of conservation of mass in open/flowing combustion systems to distinguish between internal elements and added atmospheric oxygen.

  • Practice calculating oxygen by difference on hydrocarbon derivatives containing heteroatoms.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 0.1802 g0.1802\text{ g} sample of a pure organic compound containing only C\ce{C}, H\ce{H}, and O\ce{O} is combusted completely, yielding 0.2641 g0.2641\text{ g} of COX2\ce{CO2} (M=44.01 g/molM = 44.01\text{ g/mol}) and 0.1081 g0.1081\text{ g} of HX2O\ce{H2O} (M=18.015 g/molM = 18.015\text{ g/mol}). Determine its empirical formula.

Answer

Empirical formula: CHX2O\ce{CH2O}. Key steps: nC=0.264144.01=0.00600 moln_{\ce{C}} = \frac{0.2641}{44.01} = 0.00600\text{ mol} (mC=0.07207 gm_{\ce{C}} = 0.07207\text{ g}). nH=2×0.108118.015=0.01200 moln_{\ce{H}} = 2 \times \frac{0.1081}{18.015} = 0.01200\text{ mol} (mH=0.01210 gm_{\ce{H}} = 0.01210\text{ g}). mO=0.1802−(0.07207+0.01210)=0.09603 g  ⟹  nO=0.0960316.00=0.00600 molm_{\ce{O}} = 0.1802 - (0.07207 + 0.01210) = 0.09603\text{ g} \implies n_{\ce{O}} = \frac{0.09603}{16.00} = 0.00600\text{ mol}. Ratio C:H:O=1:2:1\ce{C}:\ce{H}:\ce{O} = 1:2:1.

02

Combustion of 0.2825 g0.2825\text{ g} of a dietary fatty acid ({C,H,O}\{ \ce{C}, \ce{H}, \ce{O} \}) yields 0.7848 g0.7848\text{ g} of COX2\ce{CO2} (M=44.01 g/molM = 44.01\text{ g/mol}) and 0.3089 g0.3089\text{ g} of HX2O\ce{H2O} (M=18.015 g/molM = 18.015\text{ g/mol}). If mass spectrometry indicates a molar mass of approximately 282 g/mol282\text{ g/mol}, determine the empirical and molecular formulas of the fatty acid.

Answer

Empirical formula: CX9HX17O\ce{C9H17O}; Molecular formula: CX18HX34OX2\ce{C18H34O2} (oleic acid). Key steps: nC=0.784844.01=0.01783 moln_{\ce{C}} = \frac{0.7848}{44.01} = 0.01783\text{ mol} (0.2142 g0.2142\text{ g}). nH=2×0.308918.015=0.03429 moln_{\ce{H}} = 2 \times \frac{0.3089}{18.015} = 0.03429\text{ mol} (0.03457 g0.03457\text{ g}). mO=0.2825−(0.2142+0.03457)=0.03373 g  ⟹  nO=0.002108 molm_{\ce{O}} = 0.2825 - (0.2142 + 0.03457) = 0.03373\text{ g} \implies n_{\ce{O}} = 0.002108\text{ mol}. Ratios: C:H:O=8.46:16.27:1≈8.5:17:1  ⟹  C17H34O2\ce{C}:\ce{H}:\ce{O} = 8.46 : 16.27 : 1 \approx 8.5 : 17 : 1 \implies \ce{C}_{17}\ce{H}_{34}\ce{O}_2 or empirical unit CX9HX17O\ce{C9H17O} (M≈141.2 g/molM \approx 141.2\text{ g/mol}). Since M=282 g/molM = 282\text{ g/mol}, n=2n = 2, giving molecular formula CX18HX34OX2\ce{C18H34O2}.

03

A 1.000 g1.000\text{ g} sample of a lipid-soluble antioxidant gives 2.930 g2.930\text{ g} of COX2\ce{CO2} and 1.066 g1.066\text{ g} of HX2O\ce{H2O} upon combustion. The molar mass is 330.5 g/mol330.5\text{ g/mol}. Determine the molecular formula.

Answer

Molecular formula: CX22HX38O\ce{C22H38O} (or empirical formula CX22HX38O\ce{C22H38O}). Key steps: nC=2.93044.01=0.06658 moln_{\ce{C}} = \frac{2.930}{44.01} = 0.06658\text{ mol} (0.7997 g0.7997\text{ g}). nH=2×1.06618.015=0.11835 moln_{\ce{H}} = 2 \times \frac{1.066}{18.015} = 0.11835\text{ mol} (0.1193 g0.1193\text{ g}). mO=1.000−(0.7997+0.1193)=0.0810 g  ⟹  nO=0.081016.00=0.005063 molm_{\ce{O}} = 1.000 - (0.7997 + 0.1193) = 0.0810\text{ g} \implies n_{\ce{O}} = \frac{0.0810}{16.00} = 0.005063\text{ mol}. Divide by 0.0050630.005063: C≈13.15\ce{C} \approx 13.15, H≈23.38\ce{H} \approx 23.38, O=1\ce{O} = 1. Scaling to simple whole numbers gives CX22HX38O\ce{C22H38O} (Formula weight ≈22(12.011)+38(1.008)+16.00=330.5 g/mol\approx 22(12.011) + 38(1.008) + 16.00 = 330.5\text{ g/mol}, perfectly matching the given molar mass).

Loading workspace…