Resources
A herd of 800 woodland caribou occupies a taiga range where lichens provide a fixed carrying capacity of individuals, with intrinsic rate . Wildlife managers consider culling the population down to individuals to 'prevent competitive starvation,' arguing that fewer individuals must produce fewer new calves per year. Using the logistic differential equation , calculate the instantaneous population productivity at versus , and identify which population density maximizes net population recruitment.
Answer and steps
Final answer
At , ; at , ; recruitment is maximized at
Steps
The Logistic Growth Model
The rate of population growth (productivity or net recruitment) is given by the logistic growth equation:
where:
- is the intrinsic per capita growth rate.
- is the population size (herd density).
- is the carrying capacity of the environment.
- represents the density-dependent environmental resistance factor (the unutilized fraction of the carrying capacity).
Calculate Productivity at
Substitute into the logistic equation:
At , strong intraspecific competition for lichen resources reduces the growth rate despite the large number of potential breeding adults.
Calculate Productivity at
Substitute into the logistic equation:
Determine the Population Density That Maximizes Recruitment
Expanding the growth equation yields a quadratic function with respect to :
This represents a downward-opening parabola with roots at and . The vertex (maximum point) occurs halfway between the two roots:
Thus, net population recruitment is maximized at individuals (which produces , compared to only at ).
Common Pitfall: Intuition often suggests that having more individuals () automatically produces more offspring per year than having fewer individuals (). However, as a population approaches carrying capacity , resource depletion causes per capita reproduction to decline steeply. Total recruitment peaks at intermediate density (), known ecologically as the point of Maximum Sustainable Yield (MSY).
Typical errors
01 A student confuses instantaneous per capita growth rate with total population growth rate, calculating r(1 - N/K) instead of rN(1 - N/K) and concluding that smaller population sizes always have higher recruitment.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You wrote the equation for the per capita growth rate instead of total population productivity , omitting the population size .
- Step 2Correct
Your arithmetic was accurate for the expression you evaluated, but omitting yielded instead of .
- Step 3Correct
Your calculation followed directly from your first formula, but omitting yielded instead of .
- Step 4Correct
Net recruitment is maximized at .
While does produce higher recruitment than , recruitment does not increase toward . As , total recruitment approaches because there are virtually no breeding individuals present.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly substituted the parameter values and into the density-dependent factor .
You accurately computed the environmental resistance values for both herd sizes.
You recognized that intraspecific competition is lower at than at .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the per capita growth rate (individual reproductive success, which decreases monotonically as increases) with the total population productivity (the product of per capita rate and the number of individuals , forming a downward-opening parabola with a maximum at ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish Total vs. Per Capita Growth Rate
Total population recruitment is (units: individuals/year). Per capita growth rate is (units: or individuals per individual per year).
Always multiply the intrinsic rate and environmental resistance factor by when asked for total herd productivity or net recruitment.
- Identify Peak Logistic Recruitment
The function is a downward parabola with roots at and , reaching its vertex at .
Find the maximum recruitment density at half of carrying capacity (), not at boundary densities near or .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the complete logistic rate equation: .
Calculate productivity at : .
Calculate productivity at : .
Find the density that maximizes : Since is quadratic in , the peak occurs at .
At , ; at , ; recruitment is maximized at individuals.
02 A student mistakenly assumes that net recruitment is maximized when population size is closest to carrying capacity K, identifying N = 800 or N = 1000 rather than N = K/2.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
N = 800:; = 0.20(800) = 32
- Step 2
N = 500:; = 0.20(500) = 100(0.5) = 50
- Step 3
K = 1000
CorrectN = = 500
Carrying capacity represents the maximum population size the environment can support, where net recruitment actually drops to zero (). Net population recruitment is represented by the growth rate , which reaches its maximum at individuals.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly evaluated the logistic growth equation at to obtain .
You correctly evaluated the logistic growth equation at to obtain .
You included the correct biological units on both growth rates.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou equated maximum population size () with maximum recruitment rate (). In logistic growth, as , intraspecific competition pushes per capita growth to zero, causing overall recruitment to drop to zero rather than reach a maximum.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish Population Size from Population Growth Rate
Carrying capacity is the saturation limit where growth stops (), whereas recruitment is the rate of adding new individuals.
Check your own calculated values: notice that at () is higher than at (), showing that growth declines as nears .
- Vertex of the Logistic Parabola
The equation is an inverted parabola with roots at and . Its peak occurs at the midpoint .
Set the derivative of with respect to to zero, or find the vertex of the quadratic: .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationExpress net recruitment as a quadratic function of population size: .
Find the population density that maximizes this quadratic: the vertex of a downward-opening parabola with roots at and lies at .
Substitute : .
Confirm with the calculations from earlier steps: at , which is strictly greater than at and at .
At , ; at , ; recruitment is maximized at
03 A student omits the density-dependent feedback term (1 - N/K) and applies exponential growth rN, finding recruitment scales linearly with population size.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You selected the exponential growth formula instead of the logistic differential equation specified in the prompt. In a resource-limited environment with carrying capacity , you must include the density-dependent factor to account for intraspecific competition.
- Step 2
N = 800: = 0.20(800) = 160 N = 500: = 0.20(500) = 100
CorrectN = 800: = 0.20(800) = 32 N = 500: = 0.20(500) = 50
Your arithmetic on these lines followed your exponential model correctly, but the values are incorrect because the calculations omitted the environmental resistance term .
- Step 3
N = 800
CorrectN = = 500 50 32 N = 800
Because you evaluated an exponential model, you concluded that recruitment scales monotonically with herd size. Under logistic growth, population recruitment forms a downward-opening parabola with respect to and peaks at intermediate density .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the numerical values for the intrinsic rate and the two herd sizes and .
You evaluated your chosen model equations with accurate arithmetic.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeWHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated population growth as unlimited (density-independent exponential growth) rather than resource-limited (density-dependent logistic growth). When carrying capacity is given, per capita reproduction declines as approaches due to competition for resources. As a result, total recruitment peaks at intermediate density () rather than at the highest density.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Model Selection Check
If a carrying capacity is provided, the population is resource-limited and governed by the logistic term .
Always verify whether growth is density-independent (exponential: ) or density-dependent (logistic: ) before substituting values.
- Maximum Recruitment Rule
In a standard logistic model, maximum net recruitment (maximum sustainable yield) occurs at , where .
Check whether intermediate density yields a higher net rate than densities near by testing the vertex of the quadratic growth function.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the full logistic equation: .
Evaluate at : .
Evaluate at : .
Find the maximum of the parabola : the vertex occurs at .
At , ; at , ; recruitment is maximized at individuals.
Lock it in
What is the difference between total population growth rate and per capita growth rate in the logistic model?
Total rate is (individuals/time). Per capita rate is (rate per individual).
Similar question
A population of alpine ibex has an intrinsic growth rate and carrying capacity . Calculate the total recruitment rate when , and compare it to the per capita rate at the same density.
Answer
. The per capita rate is .
A fishery biologist models cod stocks with and . Compare the total annual biomass recruitment at versus . Which density provides the Maximum Sustainable Yield (MSY)?
Answer
At : . At : . MSY occurs at .
A protected reserve contains bison with and . Managers consider two actions: leaving the herd at or harvesting it down to . Show whether recruitment rate changes between these two population sizes, and explain the ecological reason.
Answer
At : . At : . The recruitment is identical () because the parabola is symmetric around : at , high per capita reproduction compensates for fewer breeders, while at , many breeders compensate for low per capita reproduction.