Resources

According to the competitive exclusion principle, two sympatric rodent species competing for seeds of diameter dd cannot coexist stably if their niche overlap along the seed size axis exceeds a critical symmetry threshold of α12=0.800\alpha_{12} = 0.800. Species 1 consumes seeds with mean diameter μ1=3.50 mm\mu_1 = 3.50\text{ mm} and standard deviation σ=1.00 mm\sigma = 1.00\text{ mm}, while Species 2 consumes seeds with mean diameter μ2\mu_2 and the same variance σ=1.00 mm\sigma = 1.00\text{ mm}. Using the MacArthur-Levins symmetric Gaussian niche overlap model α12=exp⁡(−d1224σ2)\alpha_{12} = \exp\left(-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4\sigma^2}\right), where d12=∣μ1−μ2∣d_{12} = |\mu_1 - \mu_2|, calculate the minimum mean seed diameter separation threshold (d12,min⁡d_{12,\min}) required to prevent competitive exclusion.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Minimum niche separation distance d12,min⁡=2σ−ln⁡(α12)=2(1.00 mm)−ln⁡(0.800)=2(1.00)0.2231=0.945 mmd_{12,\min} = 2\sigma \sqrt{-\ln(\alpha_{12})} = 2(1.00\text{ mm})\sqrt{-\ln(0.800)} = 2(1.00)\sqrt{0.2231} = 0.945\text{ mm}.

Steps

01

Understand the Relationship Between Niche Overlap and Separation

The MacArthur-Levins model quantifies interspecific competition between two species utilizing a shared resource along a single continuous dimension (here, seed diameter dd). Assuming both species have Gaussian resource utilization curves with identical standard deviation σ\sigma, the niche overlap coefficient α12\alpha_{12} is defined as:

α12=exp⁡(−d1224σ2)\alpha_{12} = \exp\left(-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4\sigma^2}\right)

where:

  • d12=∣μ1−μ2∣d_{12} = |\mu_1 - \mu_2| represents the absolute difference (separation) between the mean seed sizes preferred by the two species.
  • σ\sigma is the niche width (standard deviation of resource use).
  • α12\alpha_{12} represents the competitive effect of Species 2 on Species 1.

To prevent competitive exclusion and allow stable coexistence, the competition coefficient must not exceed the critical threshold:

α12≤0.800\alpha_{12} \le 0.800

Because α12\alpha_{12} decreases as niche separation d12d_{12} increases, the minimum required separation d12,min⁡d_{12,\min} occurs at the maximum allowable overlap, α12=0.800\alpha_{12} = 0.800.


02

Solve for the Niche Separation Distance (d12d_{12})

Take the natural logarithm (ln⁡\ln) of both sides of the equation:

ln⁡(α12)=−d1224σ2\ln(\alpha_{12}) = -\frac{d_{12}^2}{4\sigma^2}

Multiply both sides by −4σ2-4\sigma^2:

d122=−4σ2ln⁡(α12)d_{12}^2 = -4\sigma^2 \ln(\alpha_{12})

Take the square root of both sides to isolate d12d_{12}:

d12=2σ−ln⁡(α12)d_{12} = 2\sigma \sqrt{-\ln(\alpha_{12})}


03

Substitute the Given Values

Given:

  • σ=1.00 mm\sigma = 1.00\text{ mm}
  • α12=0.800\alpha_{12} = 0.800

Compute the natural logarithm of the critical overlap threshold:

ln⁡(0.800)≈−0.22314  ⟹  −ln⁡(0.800)≈0.22314\ln(0.800) \approx -0.22314 \implies -\ln(0.800) \approx 0.22314

Now, evaluate the square root and multiply:

0.22314≈0.47238\sqrt{0.22314} \approx 0.47238

d12,min⁡=2⋅(1.00 mm)⋅0.47238≈0.945 mmd_{12,\min} = 2 \cdot (1.00\text{ mm}) \cdot 0.47238 \approx 0.945\text{ mm}

A separation of at least 0.945 mm0.945\text{ mm} between the mean preferred seed sizes is necessary to reduce the niche overlap to α12≤0.800\alpha_{12} \le 0.800, thereby permitting stable coexistence.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets the factor of 4 in the denominator of the Gaussian overlap exponent and uses 2σ² instead, yielding an underestimated separation distance.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    α12=exp⁡(−d1222σ2)=0.800\alpha_{12} = \exp\left(-\frac{d_{12}^2}{2\sigma^2}\right) = 0.800

    Correct

    α12=exp⁡(−d1224σ2)=0.800\alpha_{12} = \exp\left(-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4\sigma^2}\right) = 0.800

    You copied the formula with 2σ22\sigma^2 in the denominator instead of the given MacArthur-Levins formula denominator, 4σ24\sigma^2.

  2. Step 2

    −d1222(1.00)2=ln⁡(0.800)  ⟹  −d1222=−0.2231  ⟹  d122=0.4462-\frac{d_{12}^2}{2(1.00)^2} = \ln(0.800) \implies -\frac{d_{12}^2}{2} = -0.2231 \implies d_{12}^2 = 0.4462

    Correct

    −d1224(1.00)2=ln⁡(0.800)  ⟹  −d1224≈−0.22314  ⟹  d122≈0.8926-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4(1.00)^2} = \ln(0.800) \implies -\frac{d_{12}^2}{4} \approx -0.22314 \implies d_{12}^2 \approx 0.8926

    Your algebraic solving and logarithm calculation were accurate, but the value of d122d_{12}^2 carried over the missing factor of 22 from the incorrect formula.

  3. Step 3

    d12,min⁡=0.4462≈0.668 mmd_{12,\min} = \sqrt{0.4462} \approx 0.668\text{ mm}

    Correct

    d12,min⁡=0.8926≈0.945 mmd_{12,\min} = \sqrt{0.8926} \approx 0.945\text{ mm}

    Your square root operation was calculated correctly from your prior value, but the final numerical answer is incorrect due to the initial denominator error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the threshold boundary occurs at α12=0.800\alpha_{12} = 0.800.

You correctly applied the natural logarithm to invert the exponential function.

You performed accurate arithmetic when evaluating ln⁡(0.800)≈−0.2231\ln(0.800) \approx -0.2231 and taking the final square root.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula transcription error

You wrote 2σ22\sigma^2 instead of 4σ24\sigma^2 in the exponent's denominator, confusing the single-distribution Gaussian exponent with the MacArthur-Levins overlap exponent.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

A standard normal distribution curve has the form exp⁡(−(x−μ)22σ2)\exp\left(-\frac{(x-\mu)^2}{2\sigma^2}\right), which makes 2σ22\sigma^2 an easy default to write by habit. However, the overlap integral of two symmetrical Gaussians with variance σ2\sigma^2 has an effective variance of 2σ22\sigma^2 in the difference distribution, resulting in 2(2σ2)=4σ22(2\sigma^2) = 4\sigma^2 in the exponent denominator.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Verify Model Formula
  • For symmetric Gaussian resource utilization curves with identical width σ\sigma, the overlap coefficient is α12=exp⁡(−d1224σ2)\alpha_{12} = \exp\left(-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4\sigma^2}\right).

  • Always compare the denominator of an overlap formula against the problem prompt before substituting values to ensure the factor of 4 is retained.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the given formula: α12=exp⁡(−d1224σ2)=0.800\alpha_{12} = \exp\left(-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4\sigma^2}\right) = 0.800.

  2. Take the natural logarithm of both sides: −d1224(1.00)2=ln⁡(0.800)≈−0.22314-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4(1.00)^2} = \ln(0.800) \approx -0.22314.

  3. Multiply both sides by −4-4: d122=−4(−0.22314)≈0.89257d_{12}^2 = -4(-0.22314) \approx 0.89257.

  4. Take the square root: d12,min⁡=0.89257≈0.945 mmd_{12,\min} = \sqrt{0.89257} \approx 0.945\text{ mm}.

Final answer

d12,min⁡≈0.945 mmd_{12,\min} \approx 0.945\text{ mm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check formulas from the prompt before beginning algebra, paying special attention to coefficients like the 44 in 4σ24\sigma^2.

  • Practice deriving or recalling why Gaussian overlap models feature 4σ24\sigma^2 rather than 2σ22\sigma^2.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to take the square root of d₁₂² after solving for the exponent, reporting d₁₂² as the final separation distance.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    exp⁡(−d122/(4(1.00)2))=0.800  ⟹  −d122/4=ln⁡(0.800)  ⟹  −d122/4=−0.2231\exp(-d_{12}^2 / (4(1.00)^2)) = 0.800 \implies -d_{12}^2 / 4 = \ln(0.800) \implies -d_{12}^2 / 4 = -0.2231

  2. Step 2

    d12,min⁡=4×0.2231=0.892 mmd_{12,\min} = 4 \times 0.2231 = 0.892\text{ mm}

    Correct

    d12,min⁡2=4×0.22314=0.8926  ⟹  d12,min⁡=0.8926≈0.945 mmd_{12,\min}^2 = 4 \times 0.22314 = 0.8926 \implies d_{12,\min} = \sqrt{0.8926} \approx 0.945\text{ mm}

    Multiplying both sides of −d1224=−0.2231-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4} = -0.2231 by −4-4 isolates d122d_{12}^2, not d12d_{12}. You needed to take the square root of 0.89240.8924 to obtain the actual linear separation distance.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the MacArthur-Levins symmetric niche overlap formula.

You took the natural logarithm of both sides accurately to eliminate the exponential function.

You evaluated ln⁡(0.800)≈−0.2231\ln(0.800) \approx -0.2231 correctly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted square root when solving for squared variable

You isolated d122d_{12}^2 as 4×0.2231=0.8924 \times 0.2231 = 0.892 but labeled it directly as d12,min⁡d_{12,\min} without taking the square root.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating a squared algebraic variable (d122d_{12}^2) with the linear quantity (d12d_{12}) during the final simplification step, often because the variable began inside an exponential exponent −d1224σ2-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4\sigma^2}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Track Variable Powers Explicitly
  • When an unknown appears as x2x^2, clearing coefficients leaves x2=Cx^2 = C, requiring x=Cx = \sqrt{C}.

  • Always write out d122=…d_{12}^2 = \dots explicitly on its own line before taking the square root to find d12d_{12}.

Perform a Dimensional / Unit Sanity Check
  • If σ\sigma is in millimeters, −d1224σ2-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4\sigma^2} is dimensionless, so d122d_{12}^2 carries units of mm2\text{mm}^2, while the required distance d12d_{12} must be in mm\text{mm}.

  • Check that each algebraic transition maintains dimensional consistency so you catch unextracted roots.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply both sides by −4-4 to isolate d122d_{12}^2: d122=(−4)×(−0.22314)=0.89256 mm2d_{12}^2 = (-4) \times (-0.22314) = 0.89256\text{ mm}^2.

  2. Take the principal square root of both sides: d12,min⁡=0.89256 mm2≈0.945 mmd_{12,\min} = \sqrt{0.89256\text{ mm}^2} \approx 0.945\text{ mm}.

Final answer

d12,min⁡≈0.945 mmd_{12,\min} \approx 0.945\text{ mm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write down d122d_{12}^2 on its own line whenever solving quadratic or Gaussian exponents before concluding with d12d_{12}.

  • Complete the three targeted flashcards on isolating squared variables in Gaussian niche models.

  • Solve the follow-up practice exercises to reinforce applying the square root step.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses common log (log₁₀) instead of the natural log (ln) when inverting the exponential function.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    exp⁡(−d1224σ2)=0.800\exp\left(-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4\sigma^2}\right) = 0.800

  2. Step 2

    −d1224(1.00)2=log⁡10(0.800)  ⟹  −d1224=−0.0969\frac{-d_{12}^2}{4(1.00)^2} = \log_{10}(0.800) \implies \frac{-d_{12}^2}{4} = -0.0969

    Correct

    −d1224(1.00)2=ln⁡(0.800)  ⟹  −d1224≈−0.2231\frac{-d_{12}^2}{4(1.00)^2} = \ln(0.800) \implies \frac{-d_{12}^2}{4} \approx -0.2231

    The exponential function exp⁡(u)=eu\exp(u) = e^u has base ee, so its inverse is the natural logarithm ln⁡\ln, not log⁡10\log_{10}. Evaluating ln⁡(0.800)\ln(0.800) gives ≈−0.2231\approx -0.2231 instead of −0.0969-0.0969.

  3. Step 3

    d122=0.3876d_{12}^2 = 0.3876

    Correct

    d122=−4(−0.2231)≈0.8926d_{12}^2 = -4(-0.2231) \approx 0.8926

    Your algebra to isolate d122d_{12}^2 was mechanically correct, but the value is affected by using log⁡10\log_{10} in the previous step.

  4. Step 4

    d12,min⁡=0.3876≈0.623 mmd_{12,\min} = \sqrt{0.3876} \approx 0.623\text{ mm}

    Correct

    d12,min⁡=0.8926≈0.945 mmd_{12,\min} = \sqrt{0.8926} \approx 0.945\text{ mm}

    Your square root calculation followed your intermediate result, but the final numerical value is lower than required due to the logarithm base error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the MacArthur-Levins Gaussian niche overlap equation.

You substituted the niche width σ=1.00 mm\sigma = 1.00\text{ mm} into the denominator accurately.

You executed the downstream algebraic steps and square root isolation correctly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Wrong Logarithm Base

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You inverted the natural exponential function exp⁡(x)=ex\exp(x) = e^x using the common logarithm log⁡10\log_{10} rather than the natural logarithm ln⁡\ln.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Inverse of Exponential Functions
  • The inverse of exe^x (or exp⁡(x)\exp(x)) is always ln⁡(x)=log⁡e(x)\ln(x) = \log_e(x), whereas log⁡10(x)\log_{10}(x) only inverts 10x10^x.

  • Whenever an equation contains exp⁡(… )\exp(\dots), take the natural logarithm ln⁡\ln of both sides: ln⁡(exp⁡(u))=u\ln(\exp(u)) = u.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. ln⁡(exp⁡(−d1224(1.00)2))=ln⁡(0.800)\ln\left(\exp\left(-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4(1.00)^2}\right)\right) = \ln(0.800)

  2. −d1224=ln⁡(0.800)≈−0.22314-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4} = \ln(0.800) \approx -0.22314

  3. d122=−4(−0.22314)≈0.89257d_{12}^2 = -4(-0.22314) \approx 0.89257

  4. d12,min⁡=0.89257≈0.945 mmd_{12,\min} = \sqrt{0.89257} \approx 0.945\text{ mm}

Final answer

0.945 mm0.945\text{ mm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinct bases of ln⁡\ln (base ee) and log⁡\log (base 1010) on your scientific calculator.

  • Check the units and biological interpretation: lower separation than 0.945 mm0.945\text{ mm} results in overlap exceeding 0.8000.800, causing competitive exclusion.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two species of finches feed on seeds along a continuous size axis. Both have Gaussian utilization curves with σ=0.50 mm\sigma = 0.50\text{ mm}. If stable coexistence requires α12≤0.500\alpha_{12} \le 0.500, calculate the minimum difference in mean beak size d12,min⁡d_{12,\min}.

Answer

d12,min⁡=2σ−ln⁡(α12)=2(0.50)−ln⁡(0.500)=1.000.6931≈0.833 mmd_{12,\min} = 2\sigma\sqrt{-\ln(\alpha_{12})} = 2(0.50)\sqrt{-\ln(0.500)} = 1.00\sqrt{0.6931} \approx 0.833\text{ mm}.

02

Two competing rodent species have symmetric Gaussian resource curves with σ=1.20 mm\sigma = 1.20\text{ mm} and means μ1=4.00 mm\mu_1 = 4.00\text{ mm} and μ2=5.50 mm\mu_2 = 5.50\text{ mm}. Calculate their MacArthur-Levins niche overlap coefficient α12\alpha_{12}. Will they coexist if the competitive exclusion threshold is αcrit=0.700\alpha_{\text{crit}} = 0.700?

Answer

d12=∣5.50−4.00∣=1.50 mmd_{12} = |5.50 - 4.00| = 1.50\text{ mm}. Then α12=exp⁡(−1.5024(1.20)2)=exp⁡(−2.255.76)=exp⁡(−0.3906)≈0.677\alpha_{12} = \exp\left(-\frac{1.50^2}{4(1.20)^2}\right) = \exp\left(-\frac{2.25}{5.76}\right) = \exp(-0.3906) \approx 0.677. Because α12=0.677≤0.700\alpha_{12} = 0.677 \le 0.700, the species will stably coexist.

03

Suppose the critical threshold for coexistence between two insect species is αcrit=e−1≈0.368\alpha_{\text{crit}} = e^{-1} \approx 0.368. Express the minimum required niche separation d12,min⁡d_{12,\min} as an exact multiple of the niche standard deviation σ\sigma.

Answer

Using α12=exp⁡(−d1224σ2)=e−1\alpha_{12} = \exp\left(-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4\sigma^2}\right) = e^{-1}, equate the exponents: −d1224σ2=−1  ⟹  d122=4σ2  ⟹  d12,min⁡=2σ-\frac{d_{12}^2}{4\sigma^2} = -1 \implies d_{12}^2 = 4\sigma^2 \implies d_{12,\min} = 2\sigma.

Loading workspace…