Resources

An animal physiologist studies the homeostatic coordination between the nervous, muscular, and cardiovascular systems during cold stress. A mammal with a resting metabolic heat production of 80 W80\text{ W} must increase its total heat generation to maintain core body temperature in an ambient environment requiring 140 W140\text{ W} of heat loss. Shivering thermogenesis by the skeletal muscular system is engaged, where each gram of shivering muscle tissue generates an additional 0.25 W0.25\text{ W} of metabolic heat above rest. Calculate the minimum mass of skeletal muscle (in g\text{g}) that the somatic motor nervous system must synchronously recruit to eliminate the net heat deficit.

Answer and steps

Final answer

240 g240\text{ g}

Steps

01

Determine the net heat deficit

To maintain a stable core body temperature (thermal homeostasis), total metabolic heat production must equal the rate of heat loss to the cold environment:

Total Heat Production Required=140 W\text{Total Heat Production Required} = 140\text{ W}

The animal already produces heat at baseline through resting cellular metabolism:

Resting Heat Production=80 W\text{Resting Heat Production} = 80\text{ W}

The additional heat rate (ΔP\Delta P) that must be generated to offset the environmental heat loss is:

ΔP=140 W−80 W=60 W\Delta P = 140\text{ W} - 80\text{ W} = 60\text{ W}


02

Relate shivering thermogenesis to recruited muscle mass

When core temperature drops, the hypothalamus initiates coordinated autonomic and somatic responses. Somatic motor neurons stimulate rapid, involuntary contractions of skeletal muscle fibers—a process called shivering thermogenesis. The mechanical inefficiency of these non-locomotor contractions releases chemical energy predominantly as thermal energy.

Given that each gram of active shivering muscle contributes 0.25 W0.25\text{ W} above its resting metabolic output:

ΔP=m⋅(heat production per gram)\Delta P = m \cdot (\text{heat production per gram})

Where:

  • ΔP=60 W\Delta P = 60\text{ W}
  • Heat production per gram =0.25 W/g= 0.25\text{ W/g}
  • mm is the active muscle mass in grams.

03

Calculate the minimum required muscle mass

Rearranging the formula to solve for mass (mm):

m=60 W0.25 W/g=240 gm = \frac{60\text{ W}}{0.25\text{ W/g}} = 240\text{ g}

Common Pitfall: Do not divide the total heat requirement (140 W140\text{ W}) by the shivering rate. The 0.25 W/g0.25\text{ W/g} value represents heat produced above the resting state; resting metabolism already contributes the initial 80 W80\text{ W}.

Therefore, the somatic motor system must recruit at least 240 g240\text{ g} of skeletal muscle to maintain homeostatic body temperature.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the required muscle mass using total environmental heat loss instead of subtracting resting metabolic heat production, yielding an overestimated mass of 560 g.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Heat required=140 W\text{Heat required} = 140\text{ W}

    Correct

    ΔP=140 W−80 W=60 W\Delta P = 140\text{ W} - 80\text{ W} = 60\text{ W}

    You set the shivering demand equal to the entire environmental heat loss of 140 W140\text{ W}. Because the mammal already produces 80 W80\text{ W} through basal cellular metabolism, shivering muscle only needs to generate the difference, which is 60 W60\text{ W}.

  2. Step 2

    Muscle mass=140/0.25  ⟹  Muscle mass=560 g\text{Muscle mass} = 140 / 0.25 \implies \text{Muscle mass} = 560\text{ g}

    Correct

    m=60 W0.25 W/g=240 gm = \frac{60\text{ W}}{0.25\text{ W/g}} = 240\text{ g}

    You carried out the division calculation correctly for your value, but substituting the unadjusted 140 W140\text{ W} led to an overestimated muscle mass of 560 g560\text{ g} instead of 240 g240\text{ g}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the thermogenic rate of 0.25 W/g0.25\text{ W/g} as the conversion factor between heat rate and muscle mass.

You set up and performed the division calculation accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Baseline Metabolic Heat

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated total environmental heat loss as the entirely new metabolic load, overlooking that resting metabolism continues to run and supplies an initial baseline of thermal energy.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Account for Baseline Production
  • Net heat required from facultative thermogenesis equals total heat loss minus resting metabolic heat production: ΔP=Ploss−Pbasal\Delta P = P_{\text{loss}} - P_{\text{basal}}.

  • Always subtract baseline heat production from total environmental demand before dividing by the specific shivering rate.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the net thermal deficit: ΔP=140 W−80 W=60 W\Delta P = 140\text{ W} - 80\text{ W} = 60\text{ W}.

  2. Divide this deficit by the heat production rate per gram of shivering muscle: m=60 W0.25 W/gm = \frac{60\text{ W}}{0.25\text{ W/g}}.

  3. Evaluate the quotient: m=240 gm = 240\text{ g}.

Final answer

240 g240\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying baseline physiological contributions versus facultative (regulatory) responses in homeostasis problems.

  • Draw a simple energy balance equation (Pin=PlossP_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{loss}}, where Pin=Pbasal+PregulatoryP_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{basal}} + P_{\text{regulatory}}) before calculating physical quantities.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student multiplies the net heat deficit by the specific shivering rate instead of dividing by it, obtaining 15 g of muscle.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Net heat deficit=140 W−80 W=60 W\text{Net heat deficit} = 140\text{ W} - 80\text{ W} = 60\text{ W}

  2. Step 2

    Muscle mass=60×0.25\text{Muscle mass} = 60 \times 0.25

    Correct

    Muscle mass=60 W0.25 W/g\text{Muscle mass} = \frac{60\text{ W}}{0.25\text{ W/g}}

    Because each gram of muscle produces 0.25 W0.25\text{ W}, total muscle mass is obtained by dividing the total extra power needed by the power produced per gram (m=ΔPrm = \frac{\Delta P}{r}), not by multiplying.

  3. Step 3

    Muscle mass=15 g\text{Muscle mass} = 15\text{ g}

    Correct

    Muscle mass=240 g\text{Muscle mass} = 240\text{ g}

    This result follows directly from the inverted operation in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the net heat deficit needed to offset environmental heat loss.

You identified the relevant quantitative values given in the problem.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted rate operation

You set up a multiplication between power and power per unit mass instead of dividing to isolate grams.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing rate multiplication with division when solving for the denominator unit; tracking units ([W]/[W/g]=g[\text{W}] / [\text{W/g}] = \text{g}) prevents multiplying [W]×[W/g]=[W2/g][\text{W}] \times [\text{W/g}] = [\text{W}^2/\text{g}].

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensional Analysis
  • Dividing total power (W)(\text{W}) by specific power (W/g)(\text{W/g}) yields mass (g)(\text{g}).

  • Always carry units through your calculation to verify that your answer ends with the desired unit.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the relationship: ΔP=m×r\Delta P = m \times r, where r=0.25 W/gr = 0.25\text{ W/g}.

  2. Solve for muscle mass: m=ΔPr=60 W0.25 W/gm = \frac{\Delta P}{r} = \frac{60\text{ W}}{0.25\text{ W/g}}.

  3. Evaluate the quotient: m=60×4=240 gm = 60 \times 4 = 240\text{ g}.

Final answer

240 g240\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out unit fractions explicitly when converting rates to quantities.

  • Perform a sanity check: if each gram produces only a fraction of a watt, you will need more grams of muscle than the number of watts required.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student adds the resting metabolic rate to the environmental heat loss instead of subtracting it, resulting in a calculated muscle mass of 880 g.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Total heat needed=140 W+80 W=220 W\text{Total heat needed} = 140\text{ W} + 80\text{ W} = 220\text{ W}

    Correct

    ΔP=140 W−80 W=60 W\Delta P = 140\text{ W} - 80\text{ W} = 60\text{ W}

    To maintain a steady core temperature, total heat production must equal heat loss (140 W140\text{ W}). Because the resting body already produces 80 W80\text{ W}, shivering thermogenesis only needs to cover the remaining deficit: 140 W−80 W=60 W140\text{ W} - 80\text{ W} = 60\text{ W}, not the sum.

  2. Step 2

    Muscle mass=2200.25  ⟹  Muscle mass=880 g\text{Muscle mass} = \frac{220}{0.25} \implies \text{Muscle mass} = 880\text{ g}

    Correct

    m=60 W0.25 W/g=240 gm = \frac{60\text{ W}}{0.25\text{ W/g}} = 240\text{ g}

    Your division step correctly applied the formula m=ΔP0.25 W/gm = \frac{\Delta P}{0.25\text{ W/g}}, but your result inherited the incorrect heat deficit from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that shivering muscle mass is found by dividing the additional heat required by the specific thermogenic power output of 0.25 W/g0.25\text{ W/g}.

You performed the arithmetic division 2200.25=880\frac{220}{0.25} = 880 accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Additive Instead of Subtractive Heat Balance

No, this is a conceptual misunderstanding of homeostatic thermal energy balance.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the resting metabolic rate as an extra requirement on top of environmental heat loss rather than as an existing heat source. In thermal homeostasis, Total Heat Produced=Resting Metabolism+Shivering Heat=Heat Loss\text{Total Heat Produced} = \text{Resting Metabolism} + \text{Shivering Heat} = \text{Heat Loss}. Therefore, shivering heat must equal Heat Loss−Resting Metabolism\text{Heat Loss} - \text{Resting Metabolism}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Establish Homeostatic Balance
  • Heat Loss Rate=Basal Production+Active Thermogenesis\text{Heat Loss Rate} = \text{Basal Production} + \text{Active Thermogenesis}

  • Set the required total heat equal to environmental heat loss, then subtract baseline heat to find the net deficit.

Compute Recruited Tissue Mass
  • m=ΔPdeficitspecific metabolic powerm = \frac{\Delta P_{\text{deficit}}}{\text{specific metabolic power}}

  • Divide only the net additional thermal demand by the per-gram rate of active shivering tissue.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the net heat deficit needed to match heat loss: ΔP=140 W−80 W=60 W\Delta P = 140\text{ W} - 80\text{ W} = 60\text{ W}.

  2. Divide the net deficit by the thermogenic power of shivering muscle: m=60 W0.25 W/g=240 gm = \frac{60\text{ W}}{0.25\text{ W/g}} = 240\text{ g}.

Final answer

240 g240\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice writing the full steady-state balance equation (Ploss=Pbasal+PshiveringP_{\text{loss}} = P_{\text{basal}} + P_{\text{shivering}}) before plugging in numbers.

  • Check whether your computed metabolic rate is greater than the total environmental heat loss; active heat generation should never exceed what is lost unless body temperature is actively rising.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A small mammal has a resting metabolic heat rate of 12 W12\text{ W}. During a sudden temperature drop, heat loss to the environment increases to 21 W21\text{ W}. If shivering muscle fibers produce 0.15 W/g0.15\text{ W/g} above basal levels, what mass of skeletal muscle must contract to maintain body temperature?

Answer

60 g60\text{ g}. First find the net heat deficit: ΔP=21 W−12 W=9 W\Delta P = 21\text{ W} - 12\text{ W} = 9\text{ W}. Then divide by the shivering rate: m=9 W0.15 W/g=60 gm = \frac{9\text{ W}}{0.15\text{ W/g}} = 60\text{ g}.

02

An arctic researcher measures a canine with a basal metabolic rate of 95 W95\text{ W}. In sub-zero winds, heat loss reaches 170 W170\text{ W}. Peripheral vasoconstriction reduces heat loss by 15 W15\text{ W}, while the remaining deficit is met by shivering thermogenesis producing 0.30 W/g0.30\text{ W/g}. Calculate the required shivering muscle mass.

Answer

200 g200\text{ g}. The adjusted heat loss after vasoconstriction is 170 W−15 W=155 W170\text{ W} - 15\text{ W} = 155\text{ W}. The net metabolic deficit to be bridged by shivering is 155 W−95 W=60 W155\text{ W} - 95\text{ W} = 60\text{ W}. Muscle mass recruited is m=60 W0.30 W/g=200 gm = \frac{60\text{ W}}{0.30\text{ W/g}} = 200\text{ g}.

03

A rodent exposed to acute cold requires 4.8 W4.8\text{ W} of total heat production to maintain thermal balance. Its resting metabolic rate is 2.0 W2.0\text{ W}. Brown adipose tissue (BAT) non-shivering thermogenesis provides 60%60\% of the necessary additional heat, while skeletal muscle shivering provides the remaining 40%40\% at a rate of 0.08 W/g0.08\text{ W/g}. Find the required mass of shivering muscle.

Answer

14 g14\text{ g}. Total deficit is ΔP=4.8 W−2.0 W=2.8 W\Delta P = 4.8\text{ W} - 2.0\text{ W} = 2.8\text{ W}. The shivering muscle contribution is 40%40\% of 2.8 W2.8\text{ W}, which equals 1.12 W1.12\text{ W}. The active muscle mass is m=1.12 W0.08 W/g=14 gm = \frac{1.12\text{ W}}{0.08\text{ W/g}} = 14\text{ g}.

Loading workspace…