Resources

A plant physiology team evaluates water movement across an epidermal cell membrane. The internal solute potential of the plant cell is ψs=−0.75 MPa\psi_s = -0.75\text{ MPa} and its turgor (pressure) potential is ψp=+0.20 MPa\psi_p = +0.20\text{ MPa}. The cell is completely submerged in an open beaker containing an aqueous sucrose solution with a solute potential of ψs=−0.35 MPa\psi_s = -0.35\text{ MPa}. Remembering that an open container has a pressure potential of ψp=0 MPa\psi_p = 0\text{ MPa}, calculate the total water potential of the cell (ψcell\psi_{\text{cell}}), the total water potential of the solution (ψsol\psi_{\text{sol}}), and determine the direction of net water flux.

Answer and steps

Final answer

ψcell=−0.55 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.55\text{ MPa}; ψsol=−0.35 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa}; Net water flux moves into the cell (from solution to cell).

Steps

Step 1: Recall the Water Potential Equation

The total water potential (ψ\psi) of any biological system or solution is the sum of its solute (osmotic) potential (ψs\psi_s) and pressure (turgor) potential (ψp\psi_p):

ψ=ψs+ψp\psi = \psi_s + \psi_p


Step 2: Calculate the Water Potential of the Cell (ψcell\psi_{\text{cell}})

Substitute the given values for the cell into the water potential equation:

  • Solute potential: ψs=−0.75 MPa\psi_s = -0.75\text{ MPa}
  • Pressure potential: ψp=+0.20 MPa\psi_p = +0.20\text{ MPa}

ψcell=−0.75 MPa+0.20 MPa=−0.55 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.75\text{ MPa} + 0.20\text{ MPa} = -0.55\text{ MPa}


Step 3: Calculate the Water Potential of the External Solution (ψsol\psi_{\text{sol}})

For the aqueous sucrose solution in an open beaker:

  • Solute potential: ψs=−0.35 MPa\psi_s = -0.35\text{ MPa}
  • Pressure potential: ψp=0 MPa\psi_p = 0\text{ MPa} (open to atmospheric pressure)

ψsol=−0.35 MPa+0 MPa=−0.35 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa} + 0\text{ MPa} = -0.35\text{ MPa}


Step 4: Determine the Direction of Net Water Movement

Water moves spontaneously by osmosis from a region of higher (less negative) water potential to a region of lower (more negative) water potential:

  • Solution: ψsol=−0.35 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa}
  • Cell: ψcell=−0.55 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.55\text{ MPa}

Comparing the two values: −0.35 MPa>−0.55 MPa-0.35\text{ MPa} > -0.55\text{ MPa}

Because ψsol>ψcell\psi_{\text{sol}} > \psi_{\text{cell}}, the solution has the higher water potential. Therefore, the net water flux moves into the cell (from the external solution into the cell).

Common Pitfall: Solute potentials are negative numbers. A value closer to zero (like −0.35 MPa-0.35\text{ MPa}) represents a higher water potential than a value further from zero (like −0.55 MPa-0.55\text{ MPa}). Do not treat the larger absolute value as having higher potential.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets negative numbers by treating a more negative value as greater, mistakenly concluding that water moves out of the cell.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ψcell=ψs+ψp=−0.75+0.20=−0.55 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = \psi_s + \psi_p = -0.75 + 0.20 = -0.55\text{ MPa}

  2. Step 2

    ψsol=−0.35+0=−0.35 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35 + 0 = -0.35\text{ MPa}

  3. Step 3

    −0.55 MPa-0.55\text{ MPa} is larger than −0.35 MPa-0.35\text{ MPa}, so water moves from the cell into the solution.

    Correct

    −0.35 MPa>−0.55 MPa-0.35\text{ MPa} > -0.55\text{ MPa} (or ψsol>ψcell\psi_{\text{sol}} > \psi_{\text{cell}}), so water moves from the solution into the cell.

    On a number line, −0.35-0.35 lies to the right of −0.55-0.55, making −0.35 MPa-0.35\text{ MPa} greater than −0.55 MPa-0.55\text{ MPa}. Since water moves from higher (less negative) to lower (more negative) water potential, net flux is into the cell.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You stated and applied the formula ψ=ψs+ψp\psi = \psi_s + \psi_p accurately for both the cell and the solution.

You correctly substituted the values and carried out the arithmetic to find ψcell=−0.55 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.55\text{ MPa} and ψsol=−0.35 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Negative number magnitude comparison

You compared the absolute magnitudes (0.55>0.350.55 > 0.35) instead of signed values on the real number line.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating a negative number with a larger absolute value as greater than a negative number closer to zero leads to reversing the gradient of water potential.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Compare Negative Water Potentials
  • For two negative values, the one closer to zero is greater: −0.35>−0.55-0.35 > -0.55.

  • Always plot or visualize the potentials on a horizontal number line to confirm which is further right.

Rule of Osmosis
  • Water always moves down its potential gradient: from higher ψ\psi to lower ψ\psi.

  • Draw an arrow starting at the higher (less negative) value pointing toward the lower (more negative) value.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the calculated potentials: ψsol=−0.35 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa} and ψcell=−0.55 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.55\text{ MPa}.

  2. Since −0.35>−0.55-0.35 > -0.55, the surrounding solution has the higher water potential ( ψsol>ψcell\,\psi_{\text{sol}} > \psi_{\text{cell}}).

  3. Water moves spontaneously from higher ψ\psi to lower ψ\psi, so net water movement is from the solution into the cell.

Final answer

ψcell=−0.55 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.55\text{ MPa}; ψsol=−0.35 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa}; net water flux is into the cell (from solution to cell).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice ordering negative decimals on a number line before assigning direction to osmotic flux.

  • Remember the memory hook: 'less negative = higher potential'.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the direction of osmosis by believing water flows from lower water potential to higher water potential.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ψcell=−0.75 MPa+0.20 MPa=−0.55 MPa\Psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.75\text{ MPa} + 0.20\text{ MPa} = -0.55\text{ MPa}

  2. Step 2

    Ψsol=−0.35 MPa+0 MPa=−0.35 MPa\Psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa} + 0\text{ MPa} = -0.35\text{ MPa}

  3. Step 3

    Water moves from low water potential to high water potential (−0.55 MPa-0.55\text{ MPa} to −0.35 MPa-0.35\text{ MPa}), so water moves out of the cell into the solution.

    Correct

    Because ψsol(−0.35 MPa)>ψcell(−0.55 MPa)\psi_{\text{sol}} (-0.35\text{ MPa}) > \psi_{\text{cell}} (-0.55\text{ MPa}), water moves down its gradient from higher water potential to lower water potential, resulting in net flux into the cell.

    Water flows spontaneously down its free energy gradient from higher (less negative) water potential to lower (more negative) water potential. Since −0.35 MPa>−0.55 MPa-0.35\text{ MPa} > -0.55\text{ MPa}, water enters the cell.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the plant cell's total water potential as −0.55 MPa-0.55\text{ MPa}.

You correctly calculated the external solution's total water potential as −0.35 MPa-0.35\text{ MPa}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed osmosis gradient rule

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You reversed the direction of osmosis relative to water potential. Water moves from high water potential (less negative, higher free energy of water) to low water potential (more negative, lower free energy of water), rather than from low to high.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direction of Water Flux
  • Net water movement always occurs spontaneously from a region of higher (less negative) ψ\psi to a region of lower (more negative) ψ\psi.

  • Identify which value is greater algebraically: −0.35 MPa>−0.55 MPa-0.35\text{ MPa} > -0.55\text{ MPa}. Direct the arrow of net flow from the higher value to the lower value.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the two values algebraically: ψsol=−0.35 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa} and ψcell=−0.55 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.55\text{ MPa}, so ψsol>ψcell\psi_{\text{sol}} > \psi_{\text{cell}}.

  2. Apply the rule of osmosis: water moves down its potential gradient from higher ψ\psi to lower ψ\psi (from −0.35 MPa-0.35\text{ MPa} to −0.55 MPa-0.55\text{ MPa}).

  3. Conclude that net water flux moves from the solution into the cell.

Final answer

ψcell=−0.55 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.55\text{ MPa}; ψsol=−0.35 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa}; Net water flux moves into the cell (from solution to cell).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the thermodynamic principle of water potential: pure water has the highest potential (0 MPa), and water always diffuses toward more negative values.

  • Practice distinguishing between solute concentration (water flows from low solute to high solute) and water potential (water flows from high potential to low potential).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student subtracts pressure potential instead of adding it when calculating cell water potential, leading to an incorrect total water potential.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ψcell=ψs−ψp=−0.75−0.20=−0.95 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = \psi_s - \psi_p = -0.75 - 0.20 = -0.95\text{ MPa}

    Correct

    ψcell=ψs+ψp=−0.75 MPa+0.20 MPa=−0.55 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = \psi_s + \psi_p = -0.75\text{ MPa} + 0.20\text{ MPa} = -0.55\text{ MPa}

    You subtracted the pressure potential ψp\psi_p from the solute potential ψs\psi_s. Total water potential is the sum of solute potential and pressure potential: ψ=ψs+ψp\psi = \psi_s + \psi_p.

  2. Step 2

    ψsol=−0.35 MPa+0 MPa=−0.35 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa} + 0\text{ MPa} = -0.35\text{ MPa}

  3. Step 3

    Since −0.35 MPa>−0.95 MPa, net water flux is into the cell.\text{Since } -0.35\text{ MPa} > -0.95\text{ MPa}\text{, net water flux is into the cell.}

    Correct

    Since ψsol=−0.35 MPa>ψcell=−0.55 MPa, net water flux is into the cell.\text{Since } \psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa} > \psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.55\text{ MPa}\text{, net water flux is into the cell.}

    You applied the correct biological rule that water moves toward the lower (more negative) water potential, which led to the correct direction of net flux despite carrying forward the incorrect numerical value of ψcell\psi_{\text{cell}}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled that an open container has a pressure potential of 0 MPa0\text{ MPa}.

You correctly identified that water moves from higher (less negative) water potential to lower (more negative) water potential.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula sign error

You wrote a minus sign between ψs\psi_s and ψp\psi_p instead of a plus sign.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated physical turgor pressure as a quantity that lowers water potential like solute concentration does, rather than recognizing that positive pressure pushes water out and therefore increases the overall water potential.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Water Potential Equation
  • Total water potential is always an additive sum: ψ=ψs+ψp\psi = \psi_s + \psi_p.

  • Always write the standard sum formula before substituting numerical values.

Sign of Turgor Pressure
  • Physical pressure pushes water outward, making ψp\psi_p positive in turgid plant cells and raising ψ\psi toward zero.

  • Add positive pressure potential directly to negative solute potential to yield a less negative total potential.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. ψcell=ψs+ψp=−0.75 MPa+(+0.20 MPa)=−0.55 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = \psi_s + \psi_p = -0.75\text{ MPa} + (+0.20\text{ MPa}) = -0.55\text{ MPa}

  2. ψsol=−0.35 MPa+0 MPa=−0.35 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa} + 0\text{ MPa} = -0.35\text{ MPa}

  3. Compare potentials: −0.35 MPa>−0.55 MPa  ⟹  ψsol>ψcell\text{Compare potentials: } -0.35\text{ MPa} > -0.55\text{ MPa} \implies \psi_{\text{sol}} > \psi_{\text{cell}}

Final answer

ψcell=−0.55 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.55\text{ MPa}; ψsol=−0.35 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.35\text{ MPa}; Net water flux is into the cell.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the fundamental equation as an additive relationship: ψ=ψs+ψp\psi = \psi_s + \psi_p.

  • Check whether positive turgor pressure makes the cell's total water potential less negative than its solute potential alone.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A plant cell with ψs=−0.90 MPa\psi_s = -0.90\text{ MPa} and ψp=+0.40 MPa\psi_p = +0.40\text{ MPa} is placed in an open beaker of pure water (ψs=0 MPa\psi_s = 0\text{ MPa}). Find ψcell\psi_{\text{cell}}, ψsol\psi_{\text{sol}}, and the direction of net water movement.

Answer

ψcell=−0.50 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = -0.50\text{ MPa}; ψsol=0 MPa\psi_{\text{sol}} = 0\text{ MPa}. Since 0>−0.500 > -0.50, water moves into the cell.

02

Cell A has ψs=−0.60 MPa\psi_s = -0.60\text{ MPa} and ψp=+0.10 MPa\psi_p = +0.10\text{ MPa}. Cell B has ψs=−0.80 MPa\psi_s = -0.80\text{ MPa} and ψp=+0.50 MPa\psi_p = +0.50\text{ MPa}. When placed in direct contact, which way will water move between Cell A and Cell B?

Answer

ψA=−0.60+0.10=−0.50 MPa\psi_A = -0.60 + 0.10 = -0.50\text{ MPa}; ψB=−0.80+0.50=−0.30 MPa\psi_B = -0.80 + 0.50 = -0.30\text{ MPa}. Since −0.30>−0.50-0.30 > -0.50 (ψB>ψA\psi_B > \psi_A), water moves from Cell B into Cell A.

03

A flaccid cell (ψp=0 MPa\psi_p = 0\text{ MPa}) with ψs=−0.85 MPa\psi_s = -0.85\text{ MPa} is placed in an open solution of ψs=−0.45 MPa\psi_s = -0.45\text{ MPa}. At equilibrium, what will be the cell's final turgor pressure ψp\psi_p, assuming negligible cell volume change?

Answer

At equilibrium, ψcell=ψsol=−0.45 MPa\psi_{\text{cell}} = \psi_{\text{sol}} = -0.45\text{ MPa}. Using ψ=ψs+ψp  ⟹  −0.45=−0.85+ψp\psi = \psi_s + \psi_p \implies -0.45 = -0.85 + \psi_p, we get ψp=+0.40 MPa\psi_p = +0.40\text{ MPa}.

Loading workspace…