Resources

A newly assembled, membrane-enveloped spherical virus must package a double-stranded DNA genome of total contour length 15.4 μm15.4\,\mu\text{m} into a rigid icosahedral capsid shell with an internal radius of r=28 nmr = 28\text{ nm}. If the base-pair rise of B-DNA is 0.34 nm/bp0.34\text{ nm/bp} and the effective cross-sectional diameter of the hydrated DNA cylinder is 2.0 nm2.0\text{ nm}, determine whether the total physical volume occupied by the condensed genome exceeds the available internal capsid volume by calculating the ratio of internal capsid volume to total uncompressed DNA volume (Vcapsid/VDNAV_{\text{capsid}} / V_{\text{DNA}}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

1.901.90

Steps

01

Convert all measurements to consistent units

To determine whether the total physical volume of the viral genome exceeds the internal volume of the viral capsid, we model the capsid cavity as a sphere and the double-stranded DNA as a long, continuous cylinder.

The dimensions of the capsid and DNA are given in nanometers (nm\text{nm}) and micrometers (μm\mu\text{m}):

  • Internal radius of the capsid: rcapsid=28 nmr_{\text{capsid}} = 28\text{ nm}
  • Contour length of the DNA: L=15.4 μm=15,400 nmL = 15.4\,\mu\text{m} = 15{,}400\text{ nm}
  • Hydrated diameter of the DNA: d=2.0 nmd = 2.0\text{ nm}, which gives a radius of rDNA=d2=1.0 nmr_{\text{DNA}} = \frac{d}{2} = 1.0\text{ nm}

(Note: The base-pair rise of 0.34 nm/bp0.34\text{ nm/bp} confirms the length for a ∼45.3 kb\sim 45.3\text{ kb} genome, but the total contour length LL is already provided directly.)


02

Calculate the internal volume of the viral capsid

Approximating the internal cavity of the icosahedral capsid as a sphere of radius rcapsid=28 nmr_{\text{capsid}} = 28\text{ nm}:

Vcapsid=43πrcapsid3=43π(28 nm)3=43π(21,952 nm3)=87,8083π nm3≈91,952 nm3V_{\text{capsid}} = \frac{4}{3} \pi r_{\text{capsid}}^3 = \frac{4}{3} \pi (28\text{ nm})^3 = \frac{4}{3} \pi (21{,}952\text{ nm}^3) = \frac{87{,}808}{3}\pi\text{ nm}^3 \approx 91{,}952\text{ nm}^3


03

Calculate the total volume of the uncompressed DNA cylinder

The DNA duplex is modeled as a cylinder of length LL and cross-sectional radius rDNAr_{\text{DNA}}:

VDNA=πrDNA2L=π(1.0 nm)2(15,400 nm)=15,400π nm3≈48,381 nm3V_{\text{DNA}} = \pi r_{\text{DNA}}^2 L = \pi (1.0\text{ nm})^2 (15{,}400\text{ nm}) = 15{,}400\pi\text{ nm}^3 \approx 48{,}381\text{ nm}^3


04

Determine the volume ratio (Vcapsid/VDNAV_{\text{capsid}} / V_{\text{DNA}})

Dividing the internal capsid volume by the DNA volume:

VcapsidVDNA=87,8083π15,400π=87,8083⋅15,400=87,80846,200≈1.90\frac{V_{\text{capsid}}}{V_{\text{DNA}}} = \frac{\frac{87{,}808}{3}\pi}{15{,}400\pi} = \frac{87{,}808}{3 \cdot 15{,}400} = \frac{87{,}808}{46{,}200} \approx 1.90

Because the ratio is greater than 11 (≈1.90\approx 1.90), the internal capsid volume does not physically prevent the DNA from fitting inside. However, the DNA occupies roughly 11.90≈52.6%\frac{1}{1.90} \approx 52.6\% of the entire internal volume, which represents an extremely dense, near-crystalline packing state typical of double-stranded DNA bacteriophages and animal viruses.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student uses the given DNA diameter of 2.0 nm directly as the radius in the cylinder volume formula, overestimating the DNA volume fourfold and incorrectly concluding it exceeds the capsid volume.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Vcapsid=(43)π(28 nm)3=91952 nm3V_{\text{capsid}} = \left(\frac{4}{3}\right)\pi (28\text{ nm})^3 = 91952\text{ nm}^3

  2. Step 2

    L=15.4 μm=15400 nm  ⟹  VDNA=π(2.0 nm)2(15400 nm)=193524 nm3L = 15.4\,\mu\text{m} = 15400\text{ nm} \implies V_{\text{DNA}} = \pi (2.0\text{ nm})^2 (15400\text{ nm}) = 193524\text{ nm}^3

    Correct

    L=15400 nm,  rDNA=2.0 nm2=1.0 nm  ⟹  VDNA=π(1.0 nm)2(15400 nm)≈48381 nm3L = 15400\text{ nm},\; r_{\text{DNA}} = \frac{2.0\text{ nm}}{2} = 1.0\text{ nm} \implies V_{\text{DNA}} = \pi (1.0\text{ nm})^2 (15400\text{ nm}) \approx 48381\text{ nm}^3

    The problem states that 2.0 nm2.0\text{ nm} is the cross-sectional diameter of the DNA cylinder, so the radius is r=d2=1.0 nmr = \frac{d}{2} = 1.0\text{ nm}. Substituting the diameter directly into πr2L\pi r^2 L overestimates the DNA volume by 22=42^2 = 4 times.

  3. Step 3

    VcapsidVDNA=91952193524≈0.48\frac{V_{\text{capsid}}}{V_{\text{DNA}}} = \frac{91952}{193524} \approx 0.48

    Correct

    VcapsidVDNA=9195248381≈1.90\frac{V_{\text{capsid}}}{V_{\text{DNA}}} = \frac{91952}{48381} \approx 1.90

    Your division followed logically from your prior values, but it inherited the fourfold overestimation of the DNA volume.

  4. Step 4

    Since 0.48<10.48 < 1, the total DNA volume exceeds the available internal capsid volume.

    Correct

    Since 1.90>11.90 > 1, the internal capsid volume exceeds the uncompressed DNA volume (VDNAV_{\text{DNA}} occupies roughly 53%53\% of the internal cavity).

    Your qualitative conclusion was consistent with your ratio of 0.480.48, but because the true ratio is approximately 1.901.90, the internal capsid volume is actually greater than the DNA volume.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the volume of the spherical capsid cavity using V=43πr3V = \frac{4}{3}\pi r^3.

You correctly converted the genome contour length from micrometers to nanometers (15.4 μm=15400 nm15.4\,\mu\text{m} = 15400\text{ nm}).

You correctly set up the geometric model of DNA as a long cylinder.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Diameter vs Radius Confusion

You substituted the cylinder diameter (2.0 nm2.0\text{ nm}) into πr2L\pi r^2 L instead of halving it to find the radius (r=1.0 nmr = 1.0\text{ nm}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the distinction between diameter and radius when applying geometric volume formulas is a common pitfall. In formulas involving r2r^2, using diameter instead of radius scales the calculated volume by a factor of 4.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Radius Extraction Check
  • Cylinder volume formulas require the radius r=d2r = \frac{d}{2}, not the diameter dd.

  • Whenever a problem gives an 'effective diameter' or 'thickness', immediately write down r=d2r = \frac{d}{2} before substituting into πr2h\pi r^2 h.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the cross-sectional radius: rDNA=d2=2.0 nm2=1.0 nmr_{\text{DNA}} = \frac{d}{2} = \frac{2.0\text{ nm}}{2} = 1.0\text{ nm}.

  2. Compute the DNA volume: VDNA=π(1.0 nm)2(15400 nm)=15400π nm3≈48381 nm3V_{\text{DNA}} = \pi (1.0\text{ nm})^2 (15400\text{ nm}) = 15400\pi\text{ nm}^3 \approx 48381\text{ nm}^3.

  3. Calculate the volume ratio: VcapsidVDNA=43π(28)315400π=8780846200≈1.90\frac{V_{\text{capsid}}}{V_{\text{DNA}}} = \frac{\frac{4}{3}\pi (28)^3}{15400\pi} = \frac{87808}{46200} \approx 1.90.

Final answer

1.901.90

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review whether given dimensions represent radius or diameter before substituting into geometric formulas.

  • Check that the scaling factor r2r^2 vs d2d^2 makes sense physically (using diameter quadruples circular area).

  • Practice biological packaging problems comparing volume capacities and packing fractions.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misapplies the metric prefix conversion by setting 1 μm equal to 100 nm instead of 1000 nm, underestimating the DNA length and volume by a factor of 10.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Vcapsid=43π(28 nm)3=91952 nm3V_{\text{capsid}} = \frac{4}{3}\pi (28\text{ nm})^3 = 91952\text{ nm}^3

  2. Step 2

    rDNA=2.0 nm2=1.0 nm  ⟹  L=15.4×100 nm=1540 nmr_{\text{DNA}} = \frac{2.0\text{ nm}}{2} = 1.0\text{ nm} \implies L = 15.4 \times 100\text{ nm} = 1540\text{ nm}

    Correct

    rDNA=1.0 nm  ⟹  L=15.4 μm×1000 nm/μm=15400 nmr_{\text{DNA}} = 1.0\text{ nm} \implies L = 15.4\,\mu\text{m} \times 1000\text{ nm}/\mu\text{m} = 15400\text{ nm}

    You found the correct radius from the diameter, but you converted micrometers to nanometers using a factor of 100100 instead of 10001000 (1 μm=10−6 m=1000 nm1\,\mu\text{m} = 10^{-6}\text{ m} = 1000\text{ nm}).

  3. Step 3

    VDNA=π(1.0 nm)2(1540 nm)=4838 nm3V_{\text{DNA}} = \pi (1.0\text{ nm})^2 (1540\text{ nm}) = 4838\text{ nm}^3

    Correct

    VDNA=π(1.0 nm)2(15400 nm)≈48381 nm3V_{\text{DNA}} = \pi (1.0\text{ nm})^2 (15400\text{ nm}) \approx 48381\text{ nm}^3

    You used the correct cylinder volume formula πr2L\pi r^2 L, but your result was underestimated tenfold because of the earlier conversion error.

  4. Step 4

    VcapsidVDNA=919524838≈19.0  ⟹  Since 19.0>1, the DNA volume does not exceed the available internal capsid volume.\frac{V_{\text{capsid}}}{V_{\text{DNA}}} = \frac{91952}{4838} \approx 19.0 \implies \text{Since } 19.0 > 1\text{, the DNA volume does not exceed the available internal capsid volume.}

    Correct

    VcapsidVDNA=9195248381≈1.90\frac{V_{\text{capsid}}}{V_{\text{DNA}}} = \frac{91952}{48381} \approx 1.90

    Your division and qualitative reasoning followed correctly from your values, but the true volume ratio is approximately 1.901.90 rather than 19.019.0.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly selected the spherical volume formula for the viral capsid shell.

You accurately halved the hydrated DNA diameter to determine the cylinder radius.

You properly applied the cylindrical volume formula to find the volume of the double-stranded DNA genome.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Metric prefix conversion error

You multiplied by 100100 instead of 10001000 when converting micrometers (μm\mu\text{m}) to nanometers (nm\text{nm}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the metric prefix micro- (10−610^{-6}) with centi- (10−210^{-2}) or omitting a factor of ten when jumping between standard metric steps (1 μm=1000 nm1\,\mu\text{m} = 1000\text{ nm}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Metric prefix powers of ten
  • 1 mm=10−3 m1\text{ mm} = 10^{-3}\text{ m}, 1 μm=10−6 m1\,\mu\text{m} = 10^{-6}\text{ m}, and 1 nm=10−9 m1\text{ nm} = 10^{-9}\text{ m}, which means 1 μm=103 nm=1000 nm1\,\mu\text{m} = 10^3\text{ nm} = 1000\text{ nm}.

  • Always verify the exponent difference between SI prefixes before performing the numerical substitution: 10−6/10−9=10310^{-6} / 10^{-9} = 10^3.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert the contour length L=15.4 μmL = 15.4\,\mu\text{m} to nanometers: L=15.4×1000 nm=15400 nmL = 15.4 \times 1000\text{ nm} = 15400\text{ nm}.

  2. Recalculate the DNA cylinder volume: VDNA=π(1.0 nm)2(15400 nm)=15400π nm3≈48381 nm3V_{\text{DNA}} = \pi (1.0\text{ nm})^2 (15400\text{ nm}) = 15400\pi\text{ nm}^3 \approx 48381\text{ nm}^3.

  3. Divide the capsid volume by the corrected DNA volume: VcapsidVDNA=91952 nm348381 nm3≈1.90\frac{V_{\text{capsid}}}{V_{\text{DNA}}} = \frac{91952\text{ nm}^3}{48381\text{ nm}^3} \approx 1.90.

Final answer

1.901.90

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the standard SI length hierarchy from millimeters down to angstroms (1 mm=1000 μm1\text{ mm} = 1000\,\mu\text{m}, 1 μm=1000 nm1\,\mu\text{m} = 1000\text{ nm}, 1 nm=10 A˚1\text{ nm} = 10\text{ \AA}).

  • Perform a biological plausibility check: bacteriophage and dsDNA viral capsids pack DNA extremely tightly, so the DNA typically occupies 40–60%40\text{--}60\% of the internal cavity (ratio ≈1.5–2.5\approx 1.5\text{--}2.5), making a ratio of 1919 suspiciously loose.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student treats the internal radius as a diameter and divides 28 nm by 2 to get an erroneous radius of 14 nm, underestimating the capsid volume by an eightfold factor.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    r=28 nm2=14 nm  ⟹  Vcapsid=(43)π(14 nm)3=11494 nm3r = \frac{28\text{ nm}}{2} = 14\text{ nm} \implies V_{\text{capsid}} = \left(\frac{4}{3}\right)\pi(14\text{ nm})^3 = 11494\text{ nm}^3

    Correct

    rcapsid=28 nm  ⟹  Vcapsid=43π(28 nm)3≈91952 nm3r_{\text{capsid}} = 28\text{ nm} \implies V_{\text{capsid}} = \frac{4}{3}\pi(28\text{ nm})^3 \approx 91952\text{ nm}^3

    The problem directly specifies an internal radius of r=28 nmr = 28\text{ nm}. You divided this value by 22 as if it were a diameter, yielding r=14 nmr = 14\text{ nm} and underestimating the capsid volume by a factor of 23=82^3 = 8.

  2. Step 2

    L=15.4 μm=15400 nm  ⟹  rDNA=2.0 nm2=1.0 nm  ⟹  VDNA=π(1.0 nm)2(15400 nm)=48381 nm3L = 15.4\,\mu\text{m} = 15400\text{ nm} \implies r_{\text{DNA}} = \frac{2.0\text{ nm}}{2} = 1.0\text{ nm} \implies V_{\text{DNA}} = \pi(1.0\text{ nm})^2(15400\text{ nm}) = 48381\text{ nm}^3

  3. Step 3

    VcapsidVDNA=1149448381≈0.24  ⟹  Since the ratio is 0.24<1, the DNA volume exceeds the internal capsid volume.\frac{V_{\text{capsid}}}{V_{\text{DNA}}} = \frac{11494}{48381} \approx 0.24 \implies \text{Since the ratio is } 0.24 < 1\text{, the DNA volume exceeds the internal capsid volume.}

    Correct

    VcapsidVDNA=9195248381≈1.90  ⟹  Because the ratio is 1.90>1, the internal capsid volume is larger than the DNA volume.\frac{V_{\text{capsid}}}{V_{\text{DNA}}} = \frac{91952}{48381} \approx 1.90 \implies \text{Because the ratio is } 1.90 > 1\text{, the internal capsid volume is larger than the DNA volume.}

    Your division and logic were carried out correctly from your earlier values, but the ratio and final conclusion were skewed by the incorrect capsid volume from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly converted the contour length from micrometers to nanometers.

You correctly identified the DNA duplex as a cylinder and used the cylinder volume formula.

You correctly used the sphere volume formula for the viral capsid.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Radius versus Diameter Confusion

You divided the capsid's given dimension by 2 even though the problem already stated it was the radius, not the diameter.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Habitually dividing any given circular or spherical dimension by 2 without verifying whether the text specifies 'radius' or 'diameter'. Because volume scales with r3r^3, this accidental halving reduced the capsid volume by 23=82^3 = 8.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Inspect Geometric Dimension Labels
  • Only divide by 22 when a diameter (dd) or width is given. If the problem states radius (rr), use it directly.

  • Highlight whether each given value is labeled 'radius' or 'diameter' before writing down your formulas.

Cubic Scaling Sanity Check
  • For a sphere, V∝r3V \propto r^3. A twofold error in radius produces an eightfold error in volume.

  • Check that (28)3=21952(28)^3 = 21952 rather than (14)3=2744(14)^3 = 2744.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the true internal radius rcapsid=28 nmr_{\text{capsid}} = 28\text{ nm} directly without dividing by 22.

  2. Recalculate the spherical capsid volume: Vcapsid=43π(28 nm)3=878083π≈91952 nm3V_{\text{capsid}} = \frac{4}{3}\pi (28\text{ nm})^3 = \frac{87808}{3}\pi \approx 91952\text{ nm}^3.

  3. Divide by the correct DNA volume: VcapsidVDNA=878083π15400π=8780846200≈1.90\frac{V_{\text{capsid}}}{V_{\text{DNA}}} = \frac{\frac{87808}{3}\pi}{15400\pi} = \frac{87808}{46200} \approx 1.90.

Final answer

1.901.90

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Annotate problem statements by explicitly writing r=…r = \dots or d=…d = \dots next to each dimension before calculating.

  • Remember that viral genomes are packaged under extreme pressure to fill roughly 40–55%40\text{--}55\% of internal capsid space (ratio Vcapsid/VDNA≈1.8–2.5V_{\text{capsid}} / V_{\text{DNA}} \approx 1.8\text{--}2.5), so a ratio of 0.240.24 serves as a biological red flag.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A bacteriophage has a spherical capsid cavity of radius r=20 nmr = 20\text{ nm}. It packages a viral dsDNA genome of length L=10 μmL = 10\,\mu\text{m} with a hydrated diameter of d=2.0 nmd = 2.0\text{ nm}. Calculate the ratio Vcapsid/VDNAV_{\text{capsid}} / V_{\text{DNA}}.

Answer

1.071.07. First, convert L=10000 nmL = 10000\text{ nm} and find rDNA=1.0 nmr_{\text{DNA}} = 1.0\text{ nm}. Then Vcapsid=43π(20)3=320003π nm3V_{\text{capsid}} = \frac{4}{3}\pi (20)^3 = \frac{32000}{3}\pi\text{ nm}^3 and VDNA=π(1.0)2(10000)=10000π nm3V_{\text{DNA}} = \pi (1.0)^2 (10000) = 10000\pi\text{ nm}^3. The ratio is 32000π/310000π=3230≈1.07\frac{32000\pi / 3}{10000\pi} = \frac{32}{30} \approx 1.07.

02

A spherical viral capsid has an internal diameter of 60 nm60\text{ nm}. It packages a dsDNA genome of 30,000 bp30{,}000\text{ bp} (0.34 nm/bp0.34\text{ nm/bp} rise, effective diameter 2.4 nm2.4\text{ nm}). Determine the percentage of the internal capsid volume occupied by the uncompressed DNA.

Answer

40.8%40.8\%. Capsid radius is r=30 nmr = 30\text{ nm}, so Vcapsid=43π(30)3=36000π nm3V_{\text{capsid}} = \frac{4}{3}\pi (30)^3 = 36000\pi\text{ nm}^3. DNA length is L=30000×0.34 nm=10200 nmL = 30000 \times 0.34\text{ nm} = 10200\text{ nm} and radius is rDNA=1.2 nmr_{\text{DNA}} = 1.2\text{ nm}. DNA volume is VDNA=π(1.2)2(10200)=14688π nm3V_{\text{DNA}} = \pi (1.2)^2 (10200) = 14688\pi\text{ nm}^3. Percentage occupied is 14688π36000π×100%=40.8%\frac{14688\pi}{36000\pi} \times 100\% = 40.8\%.

03

An icosahedral virus capsid has internal radius R=25 nmR = 25\text{ nm}. If tightly packed DNA can occupy at most 55%55\% of the internal cavity volume due to electrostatic repulsion and hydration forces, find the maximum contour length LL (in μm\mu\text{m}) of dsDNA (d=2.0 nmd = 2.0\text{ nm}) that can be packaged.

Answer

11.46 μm11.46\,\mu\text{m}. Cavity volume is V=43π(25)3=625003π nm3V = \frac{4}{3}\pi (25)^3 = \frac{62500}{3}\pi\text{ nm}^3. Maximum usable DNA volume is 0.55×625003π=11458.3π nm30.55 \times \frac{62500}{3}\pi = 11458.3\pi\text{ nm}^3. Since VDNA=π(1.0)2LV_{\text{DNA}} = \pi (1.0)^2 L, we have L=11458.3 nm≈11.46 μmL = 11458.3\text{ nm} \approx 11.46\,\mu\text{m}.

Loading workspace…