Resources

Consider a mainland-island model of gene flow for a woodland snail where shell banding is determined by an autosomal locus with alleles AA (unbanded) and aa (banded). The island population initially has a banded allele frequency of q0=0.70q_0 = 0.70. Each generation, an influx of migrants from the mainland—where the banded allele frequency is fixed at qm=0.10q_m = 0.10—enters the island such that migrants constitute a constant fraction m=0.08m = 0.08 of the breeding pool. Simultaneously, directional selection favors unbanded snails on the island, imparting relative fitnesses wAA=1.0w_{AA} = 1.0, wAa=1.0w_{Aa} = 1.0, and waa=1.0−sw_{aa} = 1.0 - s. Determine: (a) the banded allele frequency on the island after exactly one generation of migration alone (q1migq_1^{\text{mig}}) prior to selection, and (b) the critical selection coefficient scrits_{\text{crit}} against banded homozygotes required to establish an equilibrium frequency of q^=0.30\hat{q} = 0.30 under the linear approximation Δq=−sq2(1−q)+m(qm−q)=0\Delta q = -s q^2(1-q) + m(q_m - q) = 0 (or exact one-generation gene balance where Δqsel+Δqmig=0\Delta q_{\text{sel}} + \Delta q_{\text{mig}} = 0).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) q1mig=0.652q_1^{\text{mig}} = 0.652; (b) scrit≈0.254s_{\text{crit}} \approx 0.254 (from s=m(q^−qm)q^2(1−q^)=0.08(0.20)(0.09)(0.70)=0.0160.063≈0.254s = \frac{m(\hat{q} - q_m)}{\hat{q}^2(1-\hat{q})} = \frac{0.08(0.20)}{(0.09)(0.70)} = \frac{0.016}{0.063} \approx 0.254).

Steps

Part (a): Allele Frequency After One Generation of Migration

In a mainland-island model, the new allele frequency on the island after migration, but before natural selection acts, is a weighted average of the resident island gene pool and the immigrant gene pool:

q1mig=(1−m)q0+mqmq_1^{\text{mig}} = (1 - m)q_0 + m q_m

where:

  • q0=0.70q_0 = 0.70 is the initial frequency of allele aa on the island,
  • qm=0.10q_m = 0.10 is the frequency of allele aa among mainland immigrants,
  • m=0.08m = 0.08 is the migration rate (fraction of the breeding population composed of immigrants).

Substitute the given values:

q1mig=(1−0.08)(0.70)+(0.08)(0.10)q_1^{\text{mig}} = (1 - 0.08)(0.70) + (0.08)(0.10) q1mig=(0.92)(0.70)+0.008=0.644+0.008=0.652q_1^{\text{mig}} = (0.92)(0.70) + 0.008 = 0.644 + 0.008 = 0.652


Part (b): Critical Selection Coefficient at Equilibrium

An evolutionary equilibrium q^\hat{q} is reached when the change in allele frequency due to directional selection balances the opposing change due to gene flow:

Δq=Δqsel+Δqmig=0\Delta q = \Delta q_{\text{sel}} + \Delta q_{\text{mig}} = 0

For directional selection against a completely recessive deleterious phenotype (aaaa) with relative fitnesses wAA=1.0w_{AA} = 1.0, wAa=1.0w_{Aa} = 1.0, and waa=1.0−sw_{aa} = 1.0 - s, the standard approximation for selection is:

Δqsel≈−sq2(1−q)\Delta q_{\text{sel}} \approx -s q^2(1 - q)

The shift due to gene flow is:

Δqmig=m(qm−q)\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = m(q_m - q)

Setting the magnitudes of these opposing evolutionary forces equal to establish the equilibrium frequency q^=0.30\hat{q} = 0.30:

sq^2(1−q^)=m(q^−qm)s \hat{q}^2(1 - \hat{q}) = m(\hat{q} - q_m)

Solving for the selection coefficient ss:

s=m(q^−qm)q^2(1−q^)s = \frac{m(\hat{q} - q_m)}{\hat{q}^2(1 - \hat{q})}

Substitute the target equilibrium frequency q^=0.30\hat{q} = 0.30, immigration allele frequency qm=0.10q_m = 0.10, and migration rate m=0.08m = 0.08:

  1. Calculate the numerator: m(q^−qm)=0.08(0.30−0.10)=0.08(0.20)=0.016m(\hat{q} - q_m) = 0.08(0.30 - 0.10) = 0.08(0.20) = 0.016
  2. Calculate the denominator: q^2(1−q^)=(0.30)2(1−0.30)=(0.09)(0.70)=0.063\hat{q}^2(1 - \hat{q}) = (0.30)^2(1 - 0.30) = (0.09)(0.70) = 0.063
  3. Compute scrits_{\text{crit}}: scrit=0.0160.063=1663≈0.254s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{0.016}{0.063} = \frac{16}{63} \approx 0.254

Pitfall to avoid: When applying the selection term for a recessive allele, ensure the frequency of the recessive homozygote is squared (q^2\hat{q}^2), rather than using the linear frequency q^\hat{q}, because selection acts directly on the aaaa diploid genotype.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the mainland migrant proportion m with the resident proportion, weighting the mainland allele frequency by 1 - m instead of m.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    q1mig=m(q0)+(1−m)qm  ⟹  q1mig=(0.08)(0.70)+(0.92)(0.10)  ⟹  q1mig=0.056+0.092=0.148q_1^{\text{mig}} = m(q_0) + (1-m)q_m \implies q_1^{\text{mig}} = (0.08)(0.70) + (0.92)(0.10) \implies q_1^{\text{mig}} = 0.056 + 0.092 = 0.148

    Correct

    q1mig=(1−m)q0+mqm=(1−0.08)(0.70)+(0.08)(0.10)=0.644+0.008=0.652q_1^{\text{mig}} = (1 - m)q_0 + m q_m = (1 - 0.08)(0.70) + (0.08)(0.10) = 0.644 + 0.008 = 0.652

    You inverted the mixing proportions. Immigrants make up a fraction mm of the island pool and carry allele frequency qmq_m, while the original resident population constitutes the remaining fraction 1−m1-m and carries allele frequency q0q_0.

  2. Step 2

    −sq^2(1−q^)+m(qm−q^)=0  ⟹  scrit=m(q^−qm)q^2(1−q^)=0.08(0.30−0.10)(0.30)2(1−0.30)=0.0160.063≈0.254-s \hat{q}^2(1 - \hat{q}) + m(q_m - \hat{q}) = 0 \implies s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{m(\hat{q} - q_m)}{\hat{q}^2(1 - \hat{q})} = \frac{0.08(0.30 - 0.10)}{(0.30)^2(1 - 0.30)} = \frac{0.016}{0.063} \approx 0.254

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly balanced the selection pressure against recessive homozygotes with gene flow at equilibrium in Part (b).

You accurately evaluated the algebraic expressions and arithmetic to find scrit≈0.254s_{\text{crit}} \approx 0.254.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Weight inversion in weighted average

You assigned the immigrant fraction mm to the resident frequency q0q_0 and the resident fraction 1−m1-m to the immigrant frequency qmq_m.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the immigrant proportion with the resident proportion when writing out the weighted average for allele frequency after migration.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the Identity of the Migrant Proportion
  • In gene flow models, mm represents the fraction of incoming migrants, while 1−m1 - m represents the surviving resident pool.

  • Always pair mm with the migrant allele frequency qmq_m, and pair (1−m)(1 - m) with the resident allele frequency q0q_0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the island gene pool as (1−m)(1 - m) residents and mm immigrants: q1mig=(1−m)q0+mqmq_1^{\text{mig}} = (1 - m)q_0 + m q_m.

  2. Substitute the given island parameters: q1mig=(1−0.08)(0.70)+(0.08)(0.10)=0.92(0.70)+0.008q_1^{\text{mig}} = (1 - 0.08)(0.70) + (0.08)(0.10) = 0.92(0.70) + 0.008.

  3. Multiply and add: q1mig=0.644+0.008=0.652q_1^{\text{mig}} = 0.644 + 0.008 = 0.652.

Final answer

(a) q1mig=0.652q_1^{\text{mig}} = 0.652; (b) scrit≈0.254s_{\text{crit}} \approx 0.254

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before substituting numbers, explicitly label which term belongs to residents ((1−m)q0(1-m)q_0) and which belongs to immigrants (mqmm q_m).

  • Perform a quick sanity check: since migrants have a lower frequency (0.100.10) and make up only 8%8\% of the island, the new frequency should drop only slightly from 0.700.70, not plunge down to 0.1480.148.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misremembers the selection delta for a recessive disadvantage as depending linearly on q rather than on q², using s q(1 - q) in the denominator.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    q1mig=(1−m)q0+m(qm)  ⟹  q1mig=(0.92)(0.70)+(0.08)(0.10)  ⟹  q1mig=0.644+0.008=0.652q_1^{\text{mig}} = (1 - m)q_0 + m(q_m) \implies q_1^{\text{mig}} = (0.92)(0.70) + (0.08)(0.10) \implies q_1^{\text{mig}} = 0.644 + 0.008 = 0.652

  2. Step 2

    −sq^(1−q^)+m(qm−q^)=0  ⟹  scrit=m(q^−qm)q^(1−q^)-s\hat{q}(1 - \hat{q}) + m(q_m - \hat{q}) = 0 \implies s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{m(\hat{q} - q_m)}{\hat{q}(1 - \hat{q})}

    Correct

    −sq^2(1−q^)+m(qm−q^)=0  ⟹  scrit=m(q^−qm)q^2(1−q^)-s\hat{q}^2(1 - \hat{q}) + m(q_m - \hat{q}) = 0 \implies s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{m(\hat{q} - q_m)}{\hat{q}^2(1 - \hat{q})}

    Because selection acts only on the recessive homozygote aaaa with relative fitness 1−s1 - s (while AaAa has fitness 1.01.0), the change due to selection is proportional to the genotype frequency of homozygotes, giving Δqsel≈−sq2(1−q)\Delta q_{\text{sel}} \approx -s q^2(1 - q) rather than −sq(1−q)-s q(1 - q).

  3. Step 3

    scrit=0.08(0.30−0.10)0.30(0.70)=0.0160.21≈0.076s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{0.08(0.30 - 0.10)}{0.30(0.70)} = \frac{0.016}{0.21} \approx 0.076

    Correct

    scrit=0.08(0.30−0.10)(0.30)2(0.70)=0.0160.063≈0.254s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{0.08(0.30 - 0.10)}{(0.30)^2(0.70)} = \frac{0.016}{0.063} \approx 0.254

    Carrying the missing square into your calculation produced a denominator of 0.210.21 instead of 0.0630.063.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the one-generation post-migration frequency using the island-mainland gene flow formula.

You recognized that equilibrium occurs when the rate of change from selection balances gene flow (Δqsel+Δqmig=0\Delta q_{\text{sel}} + \Delta q_{\text{mig}} = 0).

You accurately calculated the migration delta numerator m(q^−qm)=0.016m(\hat{q} - q_m) = 0.016.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Recessive selection formula error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You used the general or additive selection formula Δq≈−sq(1−q)\Delta q \approx -s q(1 - q) rather than the selection formula for a fully recessive deleterious allele Δq≈−sq2(1−q)\Delta q \approx -s q^2(1 - q). Because heterozygotes are completely phenotypically unbanded and unselected (wAa=1.0w_{Aa} = 1.0), selection only eliminates copies of allele aa that occur in homozygous aaaa individuals (frequency q2q^2).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Dominance and Target Genotype
  • When a deleterious allele is completely recessive, selection acts exclusively on homozygous recessives, so Δqsel≈−sq2(1−q)\Delta q_{\text{sel}} \approx -s q^2(1 - q).

  • Always verify whether fitness differences affect heterozygotes (AaAa) or only homozygotes (aaaa) before choosing between qq and q2q^2.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the equilibrium condition with the recessive selection term: −sq^2(1−q^)+m(qm−q^)=0-s\hat{q}^2(1 - \hat{q}) + m(q_m - \hat{q}) = 0

  2. Solve for scrits_{\text{crit}}: scrit=m(q^−qm)q^2(1−q^)s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{m(\hat{q} - q_m)}{\hat{q}^2(1 - \hat{q})}

  3. Substitute q^=0.30\hat{q} = 0.30, qm=0.10q_m = 0.10, and m=0.08m = 0.08: scrit=0.08(0.30−0.10)(0.30)2(1−0.30)=0.016(0.09)(0.70)=0.0160.063≈0.254s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{0.08(0.30 - 0.10)}{(0.30)^2(1 - 0.30)} = \frac{0.016}{(0.09)(0.70)} = \frac{0.016}{0.063} \approx 0.254

Final answer

(a) q1mig=0.652q_1^{\text{mig}} = 0.652; (b) scrit≈0.254s_{\text{crit}} \approx 0.254

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the derivation of Δq\Delta q for dominant, codominant, and recessive alleles to see why recessive alleles depend on q2q^2.

  • Double-check given problem prompts for provided approximation formulas before writing them from memory.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student subtracts qm from q in the migration displacement term Δq_mig, reversing the direction of gene flow and yielding a negative selection coefficient.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    q1mig=(1−m)q0+m(qm)  ⟹  q1mig=(0.92)(0.70)+(0.08)(0.10)  ⟹  q1mig=0.644+0.008=0.652q_1^{\text{mig}} = (1-m)q_0 + m(q_m) \implies q_1^{\text{mig}} = (0.92)(0.70) + (0.08)(0.10) \implies q_1^{\text{mig}} = 0.644 + 0.008 = 0.652

  2. Step 2

    −sq^2(1−q^)+m(q^−qm)=0  ⟹  scrit=m(qm−q^)q^2(1−q^)-s\hat{q}^2(1-\hat{q}) + m(\hat{q}-q_m) = 0 \implies s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{m(q_m - \hat{q})}{\hat{q}^2(1-\hat{q})}

    Correct

    sq^2(1−q^)=m(q^−qm)  ⟹  scrit=m(q^−qm)q^2(1−q^)s\hat{q}^2(1-\hat{q}) = m(\hat{q} - q_m) \implies s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{m(\hat{q} - q_m)}{\hat{q}^2(1-\hat{q})}

    You set up the equilibrium equation with (qm−q^)(q_m - \hat{q}) in the numerator of your rearranged expression for scrits_{\text{crit}}. Because selection acts against the banded phenotype (waa=1−sw_{aa} = 1 - s), the selection coefficient ss must be positive (0<s≤10 < s \le 1). Equating the magnitude of selection loss to migration displacement requires s=m(q^−qm)q^2(1−q^)s = \frac{m(\hat{q} - q_m)}{\hat{q}^2(1-\hat{q})}.

  3. Step 3

    scrit=0.08(0.10−0.30)[(0.30)2(0.70)]  ⟹  scrit≈−0.254s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{0.08(0.10 - 0.30)}{[(0.30)^2(0.70)]} \implies s_{\text{crit}} \approx -0.254

    Correct

    scrit=0.08(0.30−0.10)(0.30)2(0.70)=0.0160.063≈0.254s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{0.08(0.30 - 0.10)}{(0.30)^2(0.70)} = \frac{0.016}{0.063} \approx 0.254

    Because of the reversed subtraction in your formula, your numerator evaluated to −0.016-0.016, yielding a negative selection coefficient.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the mainland-island gene flow equation to compute q1mig=0.652q_1^{\text{mig}} = 0.652 in part (a).

You correctly identified the quadratic selection term q^2(1−q^)\hat{q}^2(1-\hat{q}) for selection against a recessive homozygote.

You correctly evaluated the numerical magnitude 0.0160.063≈0.254\frac{0.016}{0.063} \approx 0.254.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed sign in migration-selection balance

You evaluated qm−q^=0.10−0.30=−0.20q_m - \hat{q} = 0.10 - 0.30 = -0.20 rather than balancing the opposing forces with positive magnitudes, giving s=−0.254s = -0.254.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

A selection coefficient ss defined by relative fitness waa=1−sw_{aa} = 1 - s must be positive (0<s≤10 < s \le 1) when selection acts against the banded genotype. When balancing opposing evolutionary forces at equilibrium, equate the magnitude of allele reduction caused by selection to the opposing displacement caused by gene flow: ∣Δqsel∣=∣Δqmig∣  ⟹  sq^2(1−q^)=m(q^−qm)|\Delta q_{\text{sel}}| = |\Delta q_{\text{mig}}| \implies s\hat{q}^2(1-\hat{q}) = m(\hat{q} - q_m).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Biological reality check on selection coefficients
  • If relative fitness is parameterized as w=1−sw = 1 - s for a disfavored genotype, ss must be positive (0<s≤10 < s \le 1).

  • Always check the sign of ss; a negative value would mean the genotype has higher fitness (w>1w > 1), contradicting the problem statement.

Equilibrium of opposing forces
  • At equilibrium, opposing evolutionary forces must have equal magnitudes: ∣Δqforce 1∣=∣Δqforce 2∣|\Delta q_{\text{force 1}}| = |\Delta q_{\text{force 2}}|.

  • Set the magnitude of selection loss sq^2(1−q^)s\hat{q}^2(1-\hat{q}) equal to the net gene flow displacement m∣qm−q^∣m|q_m - \hat{q}|, ensuring all parameters remain positive.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Equate the rate of allele removal by directional selection to the net influx displacement: sq^2(1−q^)=m(q^−qm)s\hat{q}^2(1-\hat{q}) = m(\hat{q} - q_m).

  2. Solve for the positive selection coefficient: scrit=m(q^−qm)q^2(1−q^)s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{m(\hat{q} - q_m)}{\hat{q}^2(1-\hat{q})}.

  3. Substitute the parameters: scrit=0.08(0.30−0.10)(0.30)2(1−0.30)=0.016(0.09)(0.70)=0.0160.063≈0.254s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{0.08(0.30 - 0.10)}{(0.30)^2(1 - 0.30)} = \frac{0.016}{(0.09)(0.70)} = \frac{0.016}{0.063} \approx 0.254.

Final answer

scrit≈0.254s_{\text{crit}} \approx 0.254

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice isolating parameters from equilibrium equations by equating absolute force magnitudes.

  • Perform a sign sanity check on all evolutionary coefficients (ss, mm, hh, NeN_e) before finalizing your answer.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An island butterfly population has an initial wing-spot allele frequency of p0=0.60p_0 = 0.60. Immigrants arrive from the mainland with fixed frequency pm=0.20p_m = 0.20, making up m=0.05m = 0.05 of the island's breeding adults. Calculate the wing-spot allele frequency after one generation of migration alone.

Answer

p1=0.58p_1 = 0.58. Using p1=(1−m)p0+mpm=(0.95)(0.60)+(0.05)(0.20)=0.57+0.01=0.58p_1 = (1 - m)p_0 + m p_m = (0.95)(0.60) + (0.05)(0.20) = 0.57 + 0.01 = 0.58.

02

A lake population of fish has an allele frequency of q0=0.85q_0 = 0.85. Gene flow from a connecting river occurs at rate m=0.12m = 0.12 per generation, where the river allele frequency is qm=0.35q_m = 0.35. Directional selection acts against the homozygous recessive phenotype such that Δqsel=−sq2(1−q)\Delta q_{\text{sel}} = -s q^2(1 - q). If the population is held at equilibrium q^=0.50\hat{q} = 0.50, determine the selection coefficient ss.

Answer

s=0.144s = 0.144. At equilibrium, sq^2(1−q^)=m(q^−qm)s \hat{q}^2(1 - \hat{q}) = m(\hat{q} - q_m). Thus, s=0.12(0.50−0.35)(0.50)2(1−0.50)=0.12(0.15)0.25(0.50)=0.0180.125=0.144s = \frac{0.12(0.50 - 0.35)}{(0.50)^2(1 - 0.50)} = \frac{0.12(0.15)}{0.25(0.50)} = \frac{0.018}{0.125} = 0.144.

03

In a plant population on serpentine soil, allele AA confers heavy metal tolerance (p0=0.90p_0 = 0.90). Windborne pollen from non-tolerant pastures (pm=0.10p_m = 0.10) introduces alleles at rate m=0.15m = 0.15. In the absence of selection, write the general recurrence formula for ptp_t after tt generations, and calculate p2p_2 (the frequency after two consecutive generations of gene flow).

Answer

pt=pm+(p0−pm)(1−m)tp_t = p_m + (p_0 - p_m)(1 - m)^t; p2=0.678p_2 = 0.678. Key steps: After generation 1, p1=(0.85)(0.90)+(0.15)(0.10)=0.765+0.015=0.780p_1 = (0.85)(0.90) + (0.15)(0.10) = 0.765 + 0.015 = 0.780. After generation 2, p2=(0.85)(0.780)+(0.15)(0.10)=0.663+0.015=0.678p_2 = (0.85)(0.780) + (0.15)(0.10) = 0.663 + 0.015 = 0.678.

Loading workspace…