Resources

A plant cell with an internal solute potential of Ψs,cell=−0.900 MPa\Psi_{s,\text{cell}} = -0.900\text{ MPa} and a turgor pressure of Ψp,cell=+0.400 MPa\Psi_{p,\text{cell}} = +0.400\text{ MPa} is placed into an open beaker of pure water containing an open beaker solute potential of Ψs,env=−0.150 MPa\Psi_{s,\text{env}} = -0.150\text{ MPa}. Using the standard plant water potential convention Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p, determine: (a) the initial total water potential of the plant cell, (b) the total water potential of the surrounding solution, and (c) the direction of net water movement across the plasma membrane.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Ψcell=−0.500 MPa\Psi_\text{cell} = -0.500\text{ MPa}; (b) Ψenv=−0.150 MPa\Psi_\text{env} = -0.150\text{ MPa}; (c) Net water flows from the surrounding solution into the plant cell (cell swells/turgor increases).

Steps

01

Calculate the initial water potential of the plant cell (Ψcell\Psi_\text{cell})

The total water potential (Ψ\Psi) of any system is the sum of its solute potential (Ψs\Psi_s) and pressure potential (Ψp\Psi_p):

Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p

Substitute the given internal cell values: Ψcell=Ψs,cell+Ψp,cell=−0.900 MPa+(+0.400 MPa)=−0.500 MPa\Psi_\text{cell} = \Psi_{s,\text{cell}} + \Psi_{p,\text{cell}} = -0.900\text{ MPa} + (+0.400\text{ MPa}) = -0.500\text{ MPa}


02

Determine the total water potential of the surrounding solution (Ψenv\Psi_\text{env})

For an open container under atmospheric pressure, the pressure potential is zero (Ψp,env=0 MPa\Psi_{p,\text{env}} = 0\text{ MPa}).

Using the formula for the external environment: Ψenv=Ψs,env+Ψp,env=−0.150 MPa+0 MPa=−0.150 MPa\Psi_\text{env} = \Psi_{s,\text{env}} + \Psi_{p,\text{env}} = -0.150\text{ MPa} + 0\text{ MPa} = -0.150\text{ MPa}

Common Pitfall: Forgetting that open solutions have Ψp=0 MPa\Psi_p = 0\text{ MPa}. Without an external applied pressure or enclosed rigid boundary, open beakers do not generate positive hydrostatic turgor pressure.


03

Determine the direction of net water movement

Water always flows spontaneously from a region of higher (less negative) water potential to a region of lower (more negative) water potential:

  • External environment: Ψenv=−0.150 MPa\Psi_\text{env} = -0.150\text{ MPa} (higher water potential)
  • Plant cell interior: Ψcell=−0.500 MPa\Psi_\text{cell} = -0.500\text{ MPa} (lower water potential)

Because −0.150 MPa>−0.500 MPa-0.150\text{ MPa} > -0.500\text{ MPa}, water moves down the potential gradient from the surrounding solution across the cell wall and plasma membrane into the plant cell. As water enters, cell volume expands slightly and turgor pressure increases until dynamic equilibrium is reached.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that an open container has zero pressure potential and instead reuses the cell's pressure potential, concluding water flows out of the cell.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ψcell=−0.900+0.400  ⟹  Ψcell=−0.500 MPa\Psi_\text{cell} = -0.900 + 0.400 \implies \Psi_\text{cell} = -0.500\text{ MPa}

  2. Step 2

    Ψenv=Ψs+Ψp=−0.150+0.400=+0.250 MPa\Psi_\text{env} = \Psi_s + \Psi_p = -0.150 + 0.400 = +0.250\text{ MPa}

    Correct

    Ψenv=Ψs,env+Ψp,env=−0.150 MPa+0 MPa=−0.150 MPa\Psi_\text{env} = \Psi_{s,\text{env}} + \Psi_{p,\text{env}} = -0.150\text{ MPa} + 0\text{ MPa} = -0.150\text{ MPa}

    You erroneously applied the cell's turgor pressure (+0.400 MPa+0.400\text{ MPa}) to the open solution. An open container has no hydrostatic pressure boundary, so its pressure potential is always Ψp=0 MPa\Psi_p = 0\text{ MPa}.

  3. Step 3

    Ψenv (+0.250 MPa)>Ψcell (−0.500 MPa)  ⟹  Water moves into the cell\Psi_\text{env}\,(+0.250\text{ MPa}) > \Psi_\text{cell}\,(-0.500\text{ MPa}) \implies \text{Water moves into the cell}

    Correct

    Ψenv (−0.150 MPa)>Ψcell (−0.500 MPa)  ⟹  Water moves into the cell\Psi_\text{env}\,(-0.150\text{ MPa}) > \Psi_\text{cell}\,(-0.500\text{ MPa}) \implies \text{Water moves into the cell}

    Your reasoning that water flows from higher to lower water potential is conceptually correct, and your qualitative conclusion is correct, but your comparison relied on the incorrect water potential value from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the cell's initial water potential as −0.500 MPa-0.500\text{ MPa}.

You correctly recalled that water moves spontaneously from higher (less negative) to lower (more negative) water potential.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Open container pressure potential misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated pressure potential as a shared global property rather than evaluating the specific physical boundary of each compartment, forgetting that open solutions open to atmospheric pressure always have a pressure potential of zero.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Open System Pressure Rule
  • In an open container or beaker exposed to the atmosphere, Ψp=0 MPa\Psi_p = 0\text{ MPa}.

  • Always set Ψp=0 MPa\Psi_p = 0\text{ MPa} for any surrounding solution unless an external piston or enclosed pressure is explicitly described.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the open container pressure potential to zero: Ψp,env=0 MPa\Psi_{p,\text{env}} = 0\text{ MPa}.

  2. Calculate external water potential: Ψenv=−0.150 MPa+0 MPa=−0.150 MPa\Psi_\text{env} = -0.150\text{ MPa} + 0\text{ MPa} = -0.150\text{ MPa}.

  3. Compare: since Ψenv (−0.150 MPa)>Ψcell (−0.500 MPa)\Psi_\text{env}\,(-0.150\text{ MPa}) > \Psi_\text{cell}\,(-0.500\text{ MPa}), net water moves into the cell.

Final answer

(a) Ψcell=−0.500 MPa\Psi_\text{cell} = -0.500\text{ MPa}; (b) Ψenv=−0.150 MPa\Psi_\text{env} = -0.150\text{ MPa}; (c) Net water moves into the cell.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the pressure potential conditions for open versus closed systems.

  • Practice calculating net water potential across plant cell membranes placed in open beakers of varying molarity.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the direction of osmosis, mistakenly believing water moves from lower water potential to higher water potential.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ψcell=−0.900+0.400=−0.500 MPa\Psi_\text{cell} = -0.900 + 0.400 = -0.500\text{ MPa}

  2. Step 2

    In open beaker, \text{In open beaker, } \Psi_p = 0 MPa\text{ MPa}   ⟹  \implies \Psi_env\text{env} = -0.150 + 0 = -0.150 MPa\text{ MPa}_

  3. Step 3

    Ψcell(−0.500 MPa)<Ψenv(−0.150 MPa)\Psi_\text{cell} (-0.500\text{ MPa}) < \Psi_\text{env} (-0.150\text{ MPa})

  4. Step 4

    Water moves from lower \text{Water moves from lower } \Psi  to higher \text{ to higher } \Psi, so net water movement is out of the cell\text{, so net water movement is out of the cell}

    Correct

    Water moves from higher \text{Water moves from higher } \Psi  to lower \text{ to lower } \Psi (from \text{ (from } -0.150 MPa\text{ MPa}  to \text{ to } -0.500$\text{ MPa}), so net water moves into the cell.\text{), so net water moves into the cell.}

    Water moves spontaneously down its free energy gradient from a region of higher (less negative) water potential to lower (more negative) water potential, so net flow is into the cell.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the cell's total water potential using Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p.

You correctly identified that an open container has Ψp=0 MPa\Psi_p = 0\text{ MPa}.

You correctly compared the negative values to determine that Ψenv>Ψcell\Psi_\text{env} > \Psi_\text{cell}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed direction of water potential gradient

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the direction of spontaneous water movement, assuming water flows from lower to higher water potential rather than from higher (less negative) to lower (more negative) water potential.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direction of Water Movement
  • Net passive water flow always moves down the gradient: from higher (less negative) Ψ\Psi to lower (more negative) Ψ\Psi.

  • Locate the higher value of Ψ\Psi and draw the arrow pointing toward the lower (more negative) Ψ\Psi.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the thermodynamic rule: water moves passively from higher Ψ\Psi to lower Ψ\Psi.

  2. Here, the surrounding solution has higher Ψ\Psi (−0.150 MPa-0.150\text{ MPa}) and the cell interior has lower Ψ\Psi (−0.500 MPa-0.500\text{ MPa}).

  3. Therefore, water flows down the gradient from the beaker into the plant cell, increasing cell turgor pressure.

Final answer

(a) Ψcell=−0.500 MPa\Psi_\text{cell} = -0.500\text{ MPa}; (b) Ψenv=−0.150 MPa\Psi_\text{env} = -0.150\text{ MPa}; (c) Net water movement is into the cell.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that potential energy drives spontaneous flow downward: high potential →\rightarrow low potential.

  • Practice drawing an arrow from the less negative Ψ\Psi number to the more negative Ψ\Psi number whenever comparing osmotic compartments.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets negative numbers by treating -0.500 as greater than -0.150 because 0.500 is larger in magnitude, deducing that water moves out of the cell.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ψcell=−0.900 MPa+0.400 MPa=−0.500 MPa\Psi_\text{cell} = -0.900\text{ MPa} + 0.400\text{ MPa} = -0.500\text{ MPa}

  2. Step 2

    Open beaker has Ψp=0  ⟹  Ψenv=−0.150 MPa+0=−0.150 MPa\text{Open beaker has } \Psi_p = 0 \implies \Psi_\text{env} = -0.150\text{ MPa} + 0 = -0.150\text{ MPa}

  3. Step 3

    −0.500 MPa>−0.150 MPa-0.500\text{ MPa} > -0.150\text{ MPa}

    Correct

    −0.150 MPa>−0.500 MPa-0.150\text{ MPa} > -0.500\text{ MPa}

    For negative values, a smaller absolute magnitude represents a greater value (closer to zero). Therefore, −0.150 MPa-0.150\text{ MPa} is greater (less negative) than −0.500 MPa-0.500\text{ MPa}.

  4. Step 4

    Water moves from higher Ψ to lower Ψ, so net water movement is out of the cell.\text{Water moves from higher } \Psi \text{ to lower } \Psi\text{, so net water movement is out of the cell.}

    Correct

    Since Ψenv>Ψcell, net water movement is into the cell.\text{Since } \Psi_\text{env} > \Psi_\text{cell}\text{, net water movement is into the cell.}

    You stated the biological transport rule correctly, but because of the reversed inequality in the previous step, your conclusion for the direction of water flow was reversed.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the water potential equation Ψ=Ψs+Ψp\Psi = \Psi_s + \Psi_p to calculate the total water potential of the cell.

You correctly recognized that an open container has a pressure potential of zero.

You stated the correct biological principle that water moves spontaneously from higher water potential to lower water potential.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Negative Number Comparison Error

You treated −0.500-0.500 as greater than −0.150-0.150 based on numerical magnitude, rather than position on the number line.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

A misconception regarding negative numbers where a number with a larger absolute value is incorrectly treated as a larger quantity, leading to a reversed potential gradient.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Comparing Negative Water Potentials
  • On a number line, values closer to 00 are greater (less negative).

  • Check whether the number is closer to zero before deciding which potential is higher.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the two values on the number line: −0.150 MPa-0.150\text{ MPa} is closer to 00 than −0.500 MPa-0.500\text{ MPa}, so Ψenv=−0.150 MPa>−0.500 MPa=Ψcell\Psi_\text{env} = -0.150\text{ MPa} > -0.500\text{ MPa} = \Psi_\text{cell}.

  2. Apply the rule that water moves spontaneously from higher Ψ\Psi to lower Ψ\Psi.

Final answer

Net water moves from the surrounding solution into the plant cell.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Place both potentials on a horizontal number line to verify which value lies to the right (higher potential).

  • Practice comparing negative decimal potentials before deducing the direction of osmotic flow.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A flaccid plant cell with Ψs=−0.70 MPa\Psi_s = -0.70\text{ MPa} and Ψp=0 MPa\Psi_p = 0\text{ MPa} is placed in an open beaker containing pure distilled water. Calculate the total water potential of both the cell and the beaker, and predict the direction of net water flow.

Answer

Ψcell=−0.70 MPa+0 MPa=−0.70 MPa\Psi_\text{cell} = -0.70\text{ MPa} + 0\text{ MPa} = -0.70\text{ MPa}. For the open beaker of pure water, Ψs=0 MPa\Psi_s = 0\text{ MPa} and Ψp=0 MPa\Psi_p = 0\text{ MPa}, so Ψenv=0 MPa\Psi_\text{env} = 0\text{ MPa}. Since Ψenv>Ψcell\Psi_\text{env} > \Psi_\text{cell} (0 MPa>−0.70 MPa0\text{ MPa} > -0.70\text{ MPa}), water moves into the cell.

02

A plant cell with Ψs=−0.80 MPa\Psi_s = -0.80\text{ MPa} and turgor pressure Ψp=+0.25 MPa\Psi_p = +0.25\text{ MPa} is placed in an open container of sucrose solution with a solute concentration that yields Ψs=−0.65 MPa\Psi_s = -0.65\text{ MPa}. Find the total water potential of the surrounding solution and determine whether the cell will gain or lose water.

Answer

Ψcell=−0.80+0.25=−0.55 MPa\Psi_\text{cell} = -0.80 + 0.25 = -0.55\text{ MPa}. Because the container is open, Ψp,env=0 MPa\Psi_{p,\text{env}} = 0\text{ MPa}, giving Ψenv=−0.65+0=−0.65 MPa\Psi_\text{env} = -0.65 + 0 = -0.65\text{ MPa}. Because Ψcell>Ψenv\Psi_\text{cell} > \Psi_\text{env} (−0.55 MPa>−0.65 MPa-0.55\text{ MPa} > -0.65\text{ MPa}), water moves out of the cell (plasmolysis occurs).

03

A plant cell with Ψs=−1.10 MPa\Psi_s = -1.10\text{ MPa} and Ψp=+0.30 MPa\Psi_p = +0.30\text{ MPa} is placed in an open beaker containing a solution of unknown solute potential. At dynamic equilibrium, no net water movement occurs, and the cell turgor pressure drops to Ψp=+0.10 MPa\Psi_p = +0.10\text{ MPa} with negligible change in cell solute potential. What is the solute potential of the open beaker solution?

Answer

At equilibrium, Ψcell=Ψenv\Psi_\text{cell} = \Psi_\text{env}. The final cell water potential is Ψcell=−1.10+0.10=−1.00 MPa\Psi_\text{cell} = -1.10 + 0.10 = -1.00\text{ MPa}. For the open beaker, Ψenv=Ψs,env+0 MPa=Ψs,env\Psi_\text{env} = \Psi_{s,\text{env}} + 0\text{ MPa} = \Psi_{s,\text{env}}. Therefore, Ψs,env=−1.00 MPa\Psi_{s,\text{env}} = -1.00\text{ MPa}.

Loading workspace…