Resources

According to Charnov's Marginal Value Theorem, a foraging bee exploits nectar from flower patches where the cumulative energy extracted as a function of patch residence time tt (in minutes) follows the diminishing-returns function E(t)=120tt+2.00 JoulesE(t) = \frac{120t}{t + 2.00}\text{ Joules}. The transit travel time between consecutive patches is denoted by τ\tau (in minutes). Natural selection optimizes the long-term rate of energetic gain R(t)=E(t)τ+tR(t) = \frac{E(t)}{\tau + t}, which is maximized when the instantaneous rate of gain equals the overall average rate: dEdt∣t∗=E(t∗)τ+t∗\frac{dE}{dt}\Big|_{t^*} = \frac{E(t^*)}{\tau + t^*}. Evaluate the behavior of the optimal patch residence time t∗t^* under the extreme asymptotic limit where travel time between patches approaches infinity (lim⁡τ→∞t∗\lim_{\tau \to \infty} t^*), and determine the exact finite optimal residence time t∗t^* when travel time between patches is τ=6.00 minutes\tau = 6.00\text{ minutes}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

As transit travel time approaches infinity, the optimal residence time approaches infinity (limτ→∞t∗=∞\\lim_{\tau \to \infty} t^* = \infty); for travel time τ=6.00 minutes\tau = 6.00\text{ minutes}, the optimal patch residence time is t∗=3.46 minutest^* = 3.46\text{ minutes}.

Steps

01

The Marginal Value Theorem (MVT)

Charnov's Marginal Value Theorem predicts how an animal maximizes its average rate of energy intake, R(t)R(t), in a patchy environment where foraging in each patch experiences diminishing returns. The long-term rate of gain is:

R(t)=E(t)τ+tR(t) = \frac{E(t)}{\tau + t}

where:

  • tt is patch residence time,
  • τ\tau is travel time between patches,
  • E(t)E(t) is cumulative energy gained during time tt.

The rate R(t)R(t) is maximized at the optimal residence time t∗t^* where the instantaneous rate of gain equals the overall average rate:

dEdt∣t∗=E(t∗)τ+t∗\frac{dE}{dt}\Big|_{t^*} = \frac{E(t^*)}{\tau + t^*}


02

Differentiating the Energy Gain Function

The cumulative energy extracted is given by:

E(t)=120tt+2.00E(t) = \frac{120t}{t + 2.00}

Using the quotient rule to differentiate E(t)E(t) with respect to tt:

dEdt=120(t+2.00)−120t(1)(t+2.00)2=240(t+2.00)2\frac{dE}{dt} = \frac{120(t + 2.00) - 120t(1)}{(t + 2.00)^2} = \frac{240}{(t + 2.00)^2}


03

Setting Up the Optimality Equation

Substitute E(t∗)E(t^*) and dEdt∣t∗\frac{dE}{dt}\Big|_{t^*} into the MVT condition:

240(t∗+2.00)2=120t∗t∗+2.00τ+t∗\frac{240}{(t^* + 2.00)^2} = \frac{\frac{120t^*}{t^* + 2.00}}{\tau + t^*}

Rewriting the right-hand side gives:

240(t∗+2.00)2=120t∗(t∗+2.00)(τ+t∗)\frac{240}{(t^* + 2.00)^2} = \frac{120t^*}{(t^* + 2.00)(\tau + t^*)}

Since t∗>0t^* > 0, multiply both sides by (t∗+2.00)(t^* + 2.00) and divide by 120120:

2t∗+2.00=t∗τ+t∗\frac{2}{t^* + 2.00} = \frac{t^*}{\tau + t^*}

Cross-multiply to solve for t∗t^*:

2(τ+t∗)=t∗(t∗+2.00)2(\tau + t^*) = t^*(t^* + 2.00)

2τ+2t∗=(t∗)2+2t∗2\tau + 2t^* = (t^*)^2 + 2t^*

Subtracting 2t∗2t^* from both sides yields:

(t∗)2=2τ  ⟹  t∗=2τ(t^*)^2 = 2\tau \implies t^* = \sqrt{2\tau}


04

Evaluating the Asymptotic Limit (τ→∞\tau \to \infty)

As transit travel time approaches infinity:

lim⁡τ→∞t∗=lim⁡τ→∞2τ=∞\lim_{\tau \to \infty} t^* = \lim_{\tau \to \infty} \sqrt{2\tau} = \infty

Biological Interpretation: When the time cost to locate a new patch is infinitely large, traveling between patches becomes overwhelmingly disadvantageous compared to continuing to extract even tiny marginal amounts of nectar. Therefore, natural selection favors remaining in the patch indefinitely.


05

Calculating Optimal Residence Time for τ=6.00 minutes\tau = 6.00\text{ minutes}

Substitute τ=6.00 minutes\tau = 6.00\text{ minutes} into the derived formula:

t∗=2⋅6.00=12.00≈3.4641 minutest^* = \sqrt{2 \cdot 6.00} = \sqrt{12.00} \approx 3.4641\text{ minutes}

Rounded to two decimal places, the optimal patch residence time is:

t∗=3.46 minutest^* = 3.46\text{ minutes}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misdifferentiates the quotient E(t) by differentiating the numerator and denominator independently, arriving at an incorrect derivative and an erroneous limit of 0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    dEdt=1201=120\frac{dE}{dt} = \frac{120}{1} = 120

    Correct

    dEdt=120(t+2.00)−120t(1)(t+2.00)2=240(t+2.00)2\frac{dE}{dt} = \frac{120(t + 2.00) - 120t(1)}{(t + 2.00)^2} = \frac{240}{(t + 2.00)^2}

    You differentiated the numerator and denominator independently rather than using the quotient rule ddt(uv)=u′v−uv′v2\frac{d}{dt}\left(\frac{u}{v}\right) = \frac{u'v - uv'}{v^2}. Because energy gain experiences diminishing returns, the marginal gain rate must depend on residence time tt rather than being a constant.

  2. Step 2

    120=120t∗t∗+2τ+t∗  ⟹  τ+t∗=t∗t∗+2120 = \frac{\frac{120t^*}{t^* + 2}}{\tau + t^*} \implies \tau + t^* = \frac{t^*}{t^* + 2}

    Correct

    240(t∗+2.00)2=120t∗(t∗+2.00)(τ+t∗)  ⟹  (t∗)2=2τ\frac{240}{(t^* + 2.00)^2} = \frac{120t^*}{(t^* + 2.00)(\tau + t^*)} \implies (t^*)^2 = 2\tau

    You correctly substituted your calculated derivative into Charnov's optimality equation, but the resulting algebraic relation was distorted by the incorrect derivative from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    As τ→∞,  t∗=0\text{As } \tau \to \infty,\; t^* = 0

    Correct

    lim⁡τ→∞t∗=lim⁡τ→∞2τ=∞\lim_{\tau \to \infty} t^* = \lim_{\tau \to \infty} \sqrt{2\tau} = \infty

    Your conclusion was affected by the flawed equation. Biologically and mathematically, as travel time between patches approaches infinity, locating another patch becomes infinitely costly, so natural selection favors remaining in the patch indefinitely (t∗→∞t^* \to \infty).

  4. Step 4

    6.00+t∗=t∗t∗+2  ⟹  (t∗+6)(t∗+2)=t∗  ⟹  (t∗)2+7t∗+12=0  ⟹  No positive real solution for t∗6.00 + t^* = \frac{t^*}{t^* + 2} \implies (t^* + 6)(t^* + 2) = t^* \implies (t^*)^2 + 7t^* + 12 = 0 \implies \text{No positive real solution for } t^*

    Correct

    t∗=2(6.00)=12.00≈3.46 minutest^* = \sqrt{2(6.00)} = \sqrt{12.00} \approx 3.46\text{ minutes}

    Your algebraic expansion and deduction that (t∗)2+7t∗+12=0(t^*)^2 + 7t^* + 12 = 0 has no positive real roots were logically consistent with your earlier equation, but the equation itself originated from the differentiation error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly stated and set up Charnov's Marginal Value Theorem optimality condition equating marginal gain rate to average gain rate.

You correctly cleared fractions and rearranged your algebraic equation into standard polynomial form.

You recognized that patch residence time t∗t^* must be a positive real quantity.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Quotient Rule Differentiation Error
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the derivative of a rational function as the quotient of the derivatives of the numerator and denominator, neglecting the quotient rule. In foraging ecology models, this removes the diminishing-returns curvature dEdt\frac{dE}{dt}, preventing you from finding the optimal balance between transit cost and patch exploitation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Quotient Rule for Differentiating Fractions
  • For differentiable functions u(t)u(t) and v(t)v(t), ddt(uv)=u′v−uv′v2\frac{d}{dt}\left(\frac{u}{v}\right) = \frac{u'v - uv'}{v^2}, not u′v′\frac{u'}{v'}.

  • Always identify the numerator u(t)=120tu(t) = 120t and denominator v(t)=t+2v(t) = t + 2, compute u′=120u' = 120 and v′=1v' = 1, and write out 120(t+2)−120t(t+2)2\frac{120(t + 2) - 120t}{(t + 2)^2} before simplifying.

Biological Sanity Check for Diminishing Returns
  • A diminishing-returns patch gain function must yield a decreasing marginal rate of gain (dEdt>0\frac{dE}{dt} > 0 and d2Edt2<0\frac{d^2E}{dt^2} < 0).

  • Check whether your calculated dEdt\frac{dE}{dt} decreases with time tt. If dEdt\frac{dE}{dt} is constant, the curve is linear and an optimal finite departure time cannot exist.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the quotient rule to E(t)=120tt+2.00E(t) = \frac{120t}{t + 2.00}: dEdt=120(t+2.00)−120t(1)(t+2.00)2=240(t+2.00)2\frac{dE}{dt} = \frac{120(t + 2.00) - 120t(1)}{(t + 2.00)^2} = \frac{240}{(t + 2.00)^2}.

  2. Substitute dEdt∣t∗\frac{dE}{dt}\Big|_{t^*} and E(t∗)E(t^*) into the MVT condition: 240(t∗+2.00)2=120t∗t∗+2.00τ+t∗\frac{240}{(t^* + 2.00)^2} = \frac{\frac{120t^*}{t^* + 2.00}}{\tau + t^*}.

  3. Divide both sides by 120120 and multiply both sides by (t∗+2.00)(t^* + 2.00): 2t∗+2.00=t∗τ+t∗\frac{2}{t^* + 2.00} = \frac{t^*}{\tau + t^*}.

  4. Cross-multiply and simplify: 2(τ+t∗)=t∗(t∗+2.00)  ⟹  2τ+2t∗=(t∗)2+2t∗  ⟹  (t∗)2=2τ2(\tau + t^*) = t^*(t^* + 2.00) \implies 2\tau + 2t^* = (t^*)^2 + 2t^* \implies (t^*)^2 = 2\tau, so t∗=2τt^* = \sqrt{2\tau}.

  5. Evaluate the asymptotic limit: lim⁡τ→∞t∗=lim⁡τ→∞2τ=∞\lim_{\tau \to \infty} t^* = \lim_{\tau \to \infty} \sqrt{2\tau} = \infty.

  6. Substitute τ=6.00 minutes\tau = 6.00\text{ minutes}: t∗=2(6.00)=12.00≈3.46 minutest^* = \sqrt{2(6.00)} = \sqrt{12.00} \approx 3.46\text{ minutes}.

Final answer

lim⁡τ→∞t∗=∞\lim_{\tau \to \infty} t^* = \infty, and for τ=6.00 minutes\tau = 6.00\text{ minutes}, t∗=3.46 minutest^* = 3.46\text{ minutes}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the quotient rule and practice differentiating rational expressions where both numerator and denominator contain the variable.

  • Work through graphical tangents of Charnov's Marginal Value Theorem to visualize how shifting the travel time τ\tau along the negative horizontal axis changes the optimal tangent point on the gain curve.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student maximizes cumulative energy E(t) directly instead of the rate of gain R(t), wrongly assuming the optimal residence time occurs where dE/dt = 0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Set dEdt=0\frac{dE}{dt} = 0 to maximize gain in the patch   ⟹  240(t∗+2)2=0\implies \frac{240}{(t^* + 2)^2} = 0

    Correct

    dEdt∣t∗=E(t∗)τ+t∗  ⟹  240(t∗+2.00)2=120t∗(t∗+2.00)(τ+t∗)\frac{dE}{dt}\Big|_{t^*} = \frac{E(t^*)}{\tau + t^*} \implies \frac{240}{(t^* + 2.00)^2} = \frac{120t^*}{(t^* + 2.00)(\tau + t^*)}

    Natural selection optimizes the overall long-term rate of energy intake R(t)=E(t)τ+tR(t) = \frac{E(t)}{\tau + t}, not the cumulative patch energy E(t)E(t) in isolation. Maximizing R(t)R(t) requires equating the marginal rate of gain to the overall rate, dEdt∣t∗=E(t∗)τ+t∗\frac{dE}{dt}\Big|_{t^*} = \frac{E(t^*)}{\tau + t^*}, rather than setting the marginal gain to zero.

  2. Step 2

    As τ→∞\tau \to \infty, t∗→∞t^* \to \infty

    Correct

    lim⁡τ→∞t∗=lim⁡τ→∞2τ=∞\lim_{\tau \to \infty} t^* = \lim_{\tau \to \infty} \sqrt{2\tau} = \infty

    Your asymptotic conclusion is numerically correct, but your underlying reasoning was based on dEdt=0\frac{dE}{dt}=0 having no finite solution rather than solving (t∗)2=2τ(t^*)^2 = 2\tau and taking the limit as τ→∞\tau \to \infty.

  3. Step 3

    dEdt=0\frac{dE}{dt} = 0 regardless of travel time   ⟹  t∗\implies t^* has no finite solution (or t∗→∞t^* \to \infty)

    Correct

    t∗=2τ=2(6.00)=12.00≈3.46 minutest^* = \sqrt{2\tau} = \sqrt{2(6.00)} = \sqrt{12.00} \approx 3.46\text{ minutes}

    Because the optimality condition depends directly on transit travel time τ\tau, a finite travel time of τ=6.00 minutes\tau = 6.00\text{ minutes} yields a well-defined finite optimal residence time of t∗≈3.46 minutest^* \approx 3.46\text{ minutes}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the derivative of the cumulative energy function using the quotient rule to obtain dEdt=240(t+2)2\frac{dE}{dt} = \frac{240}{(t+2)^2}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Wrong Optimization Objective in Foraging Model

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated patch exploitation as unconstrained single-variable maximization of cumulative energy E(t)E(t), overlooking that foraging time has an opportunity cost determined by transit travel time τ\tau. In Charnov's Marginal Value Theorem, fitness is maximized when the instantaneous rate of gain equals the average intake rate over the entire cycle (travel time plus residence time).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Marginal Value Theorem Criterion
  • An optimal forager leaves a patch when the instantaneous rate of gain drops to the average rate across the entire habitat: dEdt∣t∗=E(t∗)τ+t∗\frac{dE}{dt}\Big|_{t^*} = \frac{E(t^*)}{\tau + t^*}.

  • Never set dEdt=0\frac{dE}{dt} = 0 in an MVT problem; always set dEdt\frac{dE}{dt} equal to the average rate E(t)τ+t\frac{E(t)}{\tau + t}.

Role of Travel Time ($\tau$)
  • Longer travel times lower the average intake rate, favoring longer patch residence times (t∗t^*), while shorter travel times favor leaving sooner.

  • Check that your optimal residence time expression t∗t^* explicitly depends on travel time τ\tau before taking limits or substituting values.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. 240(t∗+2.00)2=120t∗t∗+2.00τ+t∗\frac{240}{(t^* + 2.00)^2} = \frac{\frac{120t^*}{t^* + 2.00}}{\tau + t^*}

  2. Simplify by multiplying both sides by (t∗+2.00)(t^* + 2.00) and dividing by 120120: 2t∗+2.00=t∗τ+t∗\frac{2}{t^* + 2.00} = \frac{t^*}{\tau + t^*}

  3. Cross-multiply: 2(τ+t∗)=t∗(t∗+2.00)  ⟹  2τ+2t∗=(t∗)2+2t∗  ⟹  (t∗)2=2τ2(\tau + t^*) = t^*(t^* + 2.00) \implies 2\tau + 2t^* = (t^*)^2 + 2t^* \implies (t^*)^2 = 2\tau

  4. Take the positive root: t∗=2τt^* = \sqrt{2\tau}

  5. As τ→∞\tau \to \infty, lim⁡τ→∞2τ=∞\lim_{\tau \to \infty} \sqrt{2\tau} = \infty

  6. Substitute τ=6.00 minutes\tau = 6.00\text{ minutes}: t∗=2(6.00)=12.00≈3.46 minutest^* = \sqrt{2(6.00)} = \sqrt{12.00} \approx 3.46\text{ minutes}

Final answer

lim⁡τ→∞t∗=∞\lim_{\tau \to \infty} t^* = \infty, and for τ=6.00 minutes\tau = 6.00\text{ minutes}, t∗=3.46 minutest^* = 3.46\text{ minutes}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the graphical tangent construction of the Marginal Value Theorem to visualize why optimal departure occurs before total energy is exhausted.

  • Practice solving MVT algebraic equations by setting dEdt=E(t)τ+t\frac{dE}{dt} = \frac{E(t)}{\tau + t} and solving for t∗t^* as a function of τ\tau.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student expands the algebraic equation incorrectly by omitting the linear cross term, obtaining (t*)² - 2t* - 12 = 0 instead of (t*)² - 12 = 0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    dEdt=240(t+2)2  ⟹  240(t∗+2)2=120t∗(t∗+2)(τ+t∗)\frac{dE}{dt} = \frac{240}{(t+2)^2} \implies \frac{240}{(t^*+2)^2} = \frac{120t^*}{(t^*+2)(\tau+t^*)}

  2. Step 2

    2(τ+t∗)=t∗(t∗+2)  ⟹  2τ+2t∗=(t∗)2+2t∗  ⟹  (t∗)2=2τ  ⟹  t∗=2τ  ⟹  As τ→∞, t∗→∞2(\tau+t^*) = t^*(t^*+2) \implies 2\tau + 2t^* = (t^*)^2 + 2t^* \implies (t^*)^2 = 2\tau \implies t^* = \sqrt{2\tau} \implies \text{As } \tau \to \infty,\ t^* \to \infty

  3. Step 3

    2(6.00+t∗)=t∗(t∗+2)  ⟹  12+2t∗=(t∗)2+4t∗  ⟹  (t∗)2+2t∗−12=02(6.00 + t^*) = t^*(t^*+2) \implies 12 + 2t^* = (t^*)^2 + 4t^* \implies (t^*)^2 + 2t^* - 12 = 0

    Correct

    t∗=2(6.00)=12.00t^* = \sqrt{2(6.00)} = \sqrt{12.00}

    When re-expanding t∗(t∗+2)t^*(t^* + 2), you distributed incorrectly to get (t∗)2+4t∗(t^*)^2 + 4t^* instead of (t∗)2+2t∗(t^*)^2 + 2t^*. More directly, you did not need to re-solve the equation from scratch because you had already proven that t∗=2τt^* = \sqrt{2\tau}.

  4. Step 4

    t∗=−2+4+482  ⟹  t∗=−1+13 minutest^* = \frac{-2 + \sqrt{4+48}}{2} \implies t^* = -1 + \sqrt{13}\text{ minutes}

    Correct

    t∗=12.00≈3.46 minutest^* = \sqrt{12.00} \approx 3.46\text{ minutes}

    Applying the quadratic formula to your incorrect quadratic equation yielded t∗=−1+13≈2.61 minutest^* = -1 + \sqrt{13} \approx 2.61\text{ minutes} instead of the correct value 12.00≈3.46 minutes\sqrt{12.00} \approx 3.46\text{ minutes}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You computed the first derivative dEdt=240(t+2)2\frac{dE}{dt} = \frac{240}{(t+2)^2} completely accurately.

You set up the Marginal Value Theorem optimality condition correctly.

You solved the general parametric relationship to find t∗=2τt^* = \sqrt{2\tau}.

You correctly concluded that the optimal residence time approaches infinity as travel time approaches infinity.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic expansion error / redundant re-derivation

You accidentally expanded t∗(t∗+2)t^*(t^* + 2) as (t∗)2+4t∗(t^*)^2 + 4t^* instead of (t∗)2+2t∗(t^*)^2 + 2t^*.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You restarted the algebraic solution from the beginning for the numerical part rather than substituting the given parameter directly into the general formula t∗=2τt^* = \sqrt{2\tau} that you had already established.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Reuse Derived Closed Forms
  • Once a general formula y=f(x)y = f(x) is derived symbolically, substitute numerical values directly into that result rather than repeating the derivation.

  • Plug τ=6.00\tau = 6.00 directly into your derived formula t∗=2τt^* = \sqrt{2\tau} to get t∗=2(6.00)=12.00≈3.46 minutest^* = \sqrt{2(6.00)} = \sqrt{12.00} \approx 3.46\text{ minutes}.

Monomial-Binomial Distribution
  • a(b+c)=ab+aca(b + c) = ab + ac

  • Ensure each term inside the parentheses is multiplied only by the factor outside: t∗(t∗+2)=(t∗)2+2t∗t^*(t^* + 2) = (t^*)^2 + 2t^*, not (t∗)2+4t∗(t^*)^2 + 4t^*.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute τ=6.00 minutes\tau = 6.00\text{ minutes} into the general expression t∗=2τt^* = \sqrt{2\tau} derived in Step 2.

  2. Evaluate t∗=2(6.00)=12.00t^* = \sqrt{2(6.00)} = \sqrt{12.00}.

  3. Compute the numerical square root: 12.00≈3.4641 minutes\sqrt{12.00} \approx 3.4641\text{ minutes}, which rounds to 3.46 minutes3.46\text{ minutes}.

Final answer

lim⁡τ→∞t∗=∞\lim_{\tau \to \infty} t^* = \infty, and for τ=6.00 minutes\tau = 6.00\text{ minutes}, t∗=3.46 minutest^* = 3.46\text{ minutes}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Take advantage of closed-form symbolic solutions you have already derived instead of re-solving equations with specific numbers.

  • When expanding products like x(x+c)x(x + c), double-check the coefficient of the linear term before combining it with other sides of an equation.

  • Practice using the graphical tangent method of Charnov's Marginal Value Theorem to cross-check that longer travel times always increase optimal patch residence time.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A foraging bird extracts seeds from a patch following the gain curve E(t)=80tt+1.00 JoulesE(t) = \frac{80t}{t + 1.00}\text{ Joules}. Using the quotient rule, find the instantaneous rate of gain dEdt\frac{dE}{dt} as an explicit function of tt.

Answer

dEdt=80(t+1.00)−80t(1)(t+1.00)2=80(t+1.00)2 Joules/minute\frac{dE}{dt} = \frac{80(t + 1.00) - 80t(1)}{(t + 1.00)^2} = \frac{80}{(t + 1.00)^2}\text{ Joules/minute}.

02

For the same bird with E(t)=80tt+1.00 JoulesE(t) = \frac{80t}{t + 1.00}\text{ Joules}, travel time between patches is τ=4.00 minutes\tau = 4.00\text{ minutes}. Using the MVT optimality condition dEdt∣t∗=E(t∗)τ+t∗\frac{dE}{dt}\Big|_{t^*} = \frac{E(t^*)}{\tau + t^*}, determine the optimal patch residence time t∗t^*.

Answer

t∗=2.00 minutest^* = 2.00\text{ minutes}. Setting 80(t∗+1)2=80t∗(t∗+1)(4+t∗)\frac{80}{(t^* + 1)^2} = \frac{80t^*}{(t^* + 1)(4 + t^*)} simplifies to 1t∗+1=t∗4+t∗\frac{1}{t^* + 1} = \frac{t^*}{4 + t^*}, giving 4+t∗=(t∗)2+t∗  ⟹  (t∗)2=4  ⟹  t∗=2.00 minutes4 + t^* = (t^*)^2 + t^* \implies (t^*)^2 = 4 \implies t^* = 2.00\text{ minutes}.

03

In a patchy desert habitat, a rodent experiences an energy gain function E(t)=Ktt+cE(t) = \frac{K t}{t + c} where K,c>0K, c > 0. Show that the optimal residence time satisfies t∗=cτt^* = \sqrt{c\tau}, and explain what happens to t∗t^* if travel time τ\tau decreases toward 00.

Answer

Equating Kc(t∗+c)2=Kt∗(t∗+c)(τ+t∗)\frac{Kc}{(t^* + c)^2} = \frac{Kt^*}{(t^* + c)(\tau + t^*)} yields ct∗+c=t∗τ+t∗\frac{c}{t^* + c} = \frac{t^*}{\tau + t^*}, so cτ+ct∗=(t∗)2+ct∗  ⟹  (t∗)2=cτ  ⟹  t∗=cτc\tau + ct^* = (t^*)^2 + ct^* \implies (t^*)^2 = c\tau \implies t^* = \sqrt{c\tau}. As τ→0\tau \to 0, t∗→0t^* \to 0, meaning that when patches are packed with zero transit cost, foragers abandon patches almost immediately to exploit only the highest initial intake rate.

Loading workspace…