Resources

In a study of bird mortality across four discrete forested woodlots of equal area (20 ha20\text{ ha} each), an ecologist records the initial nesting density (DD, in birds per hectare) and the resulting total deaths caused by nest predation (MpredM_{\text{pred}}) and a severe unseasonal hailstorm (MstormM_{\text{storm}}). For woodlots with densities D∈{5,10,20,40}D \in \{5, 10, 20, 40\}, the recorded predation mortalities are 88, 2424, 8080, and 256256 individuals, respectively, while hailstorm mortalities are 2020, 4040, 8080, and 160160 individuals. Rather than comparing raw counts, determine: (a) the per capita mortality rate function for predation, mpred(D)m_{\text{pred}}(D), expressed in terms of DD, and state whether it is positively density-dependent, inversely density-dependent, or density-independent; (b) the per capita mortality rate function for the hailstorm, mstorm(D)m_{\text{storm}}(D), and its density classification.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Total population in each woodlot is N=20DN = 20D. The per capita predation mortality is mpred(D)=Mpred20Dm_{\text{pred}}(D) = \frac{M_{\text{pred}}}{20D}: for D=5D = 5, m=8100=0.080m = \frac{8}{100} = 0.080 (8.0%8.0\%); for D=10D = 10, m=24200=0.120m = \frac{24}{200} = 0.120 (12.0%12.0\%); for D=20D = 20, m=80400=0.200m = \frac{80}{400} = 0.200 (20.0%20.0\%); for D=40D = 40, m=256800=0.320m = \frac{256}{800} = 0.320 (32.0%32.0\%). The function is mpred(D)=0.040+0.007Dm_{\text{pred}}(D) = 0.040 + 0.007D (or strictly monotonically increasing with DD); therefore, predation is positively density-dependent. (b) Hailstorm per capita mortality is mstorm(D)=Mstorm20D=20100=40200=80400=160800=0.200m_{\text{storm}}(D) = \frac{M_{\text{storm}}}{20D} = \frac{20}{100} = \frac{40}{200} = \frac{80}{400} = \frac{160}{800} = 0.200 (20.0%20.0\%); since mstorm(D)m_{\text{storm}}(D) is constant across all densities, the hailstorm is a density-independent factor.

Steps

01

Calculate the Total Population Size (NN) for Each Woodlot

The total population size NN in each woodlot depends on the area (A=20 haA = 20\text{ ha}) and the initial density (DD, in birds per hectare): N=A⋅D=20DN = A \cdot D = 20D

Evaluating NN for each woodlot:

  • For D=5 birds/haD = 5\text{ birds/ha}: N=20⋅5=100 birdsN = 20 \cdot 5 = 100\text{ birds}
  • For D=10 birds/haD = 10\text{ birds/ha}: N=20⋅10=200 birdsN = 20 \cdot 10 = 200\text{ birds}
  • For D=20 birds/haD = 20\text{ birds/ha}: N=20⋅20=400 birdsN = 20 \cdot 20 = 400\text{ birds}
  • For D=40 birds/haD = 40\text{ birds/ha}: N=20⋅40=800 birdsN = 20 \cdot 40 = 800\text{ birds}

02

Determine Per Capita Predation Mortality and Density Dependence

A common pitfall is to evaluate raw death counts instead of rates. Because population size increases with density, raw counts naturally increase even when the mortality rate is unchanged. To test for density dependence, calculate the per capita mortality rate, which is the proportion of the population dying: mpred(D)=MpredN=Mpred20Dm_{\text{pred}}(D) = \frac{M_{\text{pred}}}{N} = \frac{M_{\text{pred}}}{20D}

Evaluating for each woodlot:

  • At D=5D = 5: mpred(5)=8100=0.080(8.0%)m_{\text{pred}}(5) = \frac{8}{100} = 0.080\quad (8.0\%)
  • At D=10D = 10: mpred(10)=24200=0.120(12.0%)m_{\text{pred}}(10) = \frac{24}{200} = 0.120\quad (12.0\%)
  • At D=20D = 20: mpred(20)=80400=0.200(20.0%)m_{\text{pred}}(20) = \frac{80}{400} = 0.200\quad (20.0\%)
  • At D=40D = 40: mpred(40)=256800=0.320(32.0%)m_{\text{pred}}(40) = \frac{256}{800} = 0.320\quad (32.0\%)

The mortality rate increases as population density increases (0.080→0.120→0.200→0.3200.080 \to 0.120 \to 0.200 \to 0.320), best approximated linearly by mpred(D)=0.040+0.007Dm_{\text{pred}}(D) = 0.040 + 0.007D. Because the per capita mortality rate is strictly monotonically increasing with density, nest predation is positively density-dependent.


03

Determine Per Capita Hailstorm Mortality and Density Classification

Apply the same per capita mortality formula to the storm mortality: mstorm(D)=MstormN=Mstorm20Dm_{\text{storm}}(D) = \frac{M_{\text{storm}}}{N} = \frac{M_{\text{storm}}}{20D}

Evaluating for each woodlot:

  • At D=5D = 5: mstorm(5)=20100=0.200(20.0%)m_{\text{storm}}(5) = \frac{20}{100} = 0.200\quad (20.0\%)
  • At D=10D = 10: mstorm(10)=40200=0.200(20.0%)m_{\text{storm}}(10) = \frac{40}{200} = 0.200\quad (20.0\%)
  • At D=20D = 20: mstorm(20)=80400=0.200(20.0%)m_{\text{storm}}(20) = \frac{80}{400} = 0.200\quad (20.0\%)
  • At D=40D = 40: mstorm(40)=160800=0.200(20.0%)m_{\text{storm}}(40) = \frac{160}{800} = 0.200\quad (20.0\%)

The per capita mortality rate is constant at mstorm(D)=0.200m_{\text{storm}}(D) = 0.200 across all densities. Because the probability of an individual dying from the abiotic disturbance is completely unaffected by population density, the hailstorm is a density-independent factor.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student divides total mortality by density D instead of the total population N = 20D, neglecting woodlot area when finding per capita rates.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mpred(D)=MpredDm_{\text{pred}}(D) = \frac{M_{\text{pred}}}{D}

    Correct

    mpred(D)=MpredN=Mpred20Dm_{\text{pred}}(D) = \frac{M_{\text{pred}}}{N} = \frac{M_{\text{pred}}}{20D}

    Per capita mortality is the fraction of total living individuals that die, MN\frac{M}{N}. Because DD is the density in birds per hectare and each woodlot covers 20 ha20\text{ ha}, the total population size is N=20DN = 20D birds, not DD.

  2. Step 2

    For D=5:85=1.6  ⟹  For D=10:2410=2.4  ⟹  For D=20:8020=4.0  ⟹  For D=40:25640=6.4  ⟹  mpred(D)=0.8+0.14D\text{For } D = 5: \frac{8}{5} = 1.6 \implies \text{For } D = 10: \frac{24}{10} = 2.4 \implies \text{For } D = 20: \frac{80}{20} = 4.0 \implies \text{For } D = 40: \frac{256}{40} = 6.4 \implies m_{\text{pred}}(D) = 0.8 + 0.14D

    Correct

    For D=5:8100=0.080  ⟹  For D=10:24200=0.120  ⟹  For D=20:80400=0.200  ⟹  For D=40:256800=0.320  ⟹  mpred(D)=0.040+0.007D\text{For } D = 5: \frac{8}{100} = 0.080 \implies \text{For } D = 10: \frac{24}{200} = 0.120 \implies \text{For } D = 20: \frac{80}{400} = 0.200 \implies \text{For } D = 40: \frac{256}{800} = 0.320 \implies m_{\text{pred}}(D) = 0.040 + 0.007D

    Because the denominator omitted the woodlot area factor of 2020, each computed value and the resulting linear coefficients were exactly 2020 times too large.

  3. Step 3

    Rate increases with D, so it is positively density-dependent.\text{Rate increases with } D\text{, so it is positively density-dependent.}

  4. Step 4

    mstorm(D)=MstormD  ⟹  evaluations equal 4.0  ⟹  mstorm(D)=4.0m_{\text{storm}}(D) = \frac{M_{\text{storm}}}{D} \implies \text{evaluations equal } 4.0 \implies m_{\text{storm}}(D) = 4.0

    Correct

    mstorm(D)=Mstorm20D=20100=40200=80400=160800=0.200m_{\text{storm}}(D) = \frac{M_{\text{storm}}}{20D} = \frac{20}{100} = \frac{40}{200} = \frac{80}{400} = \frac{160}{800} = 0.200

    Dividing by DD instead of N=20DN = 20D produced a per capita rate of 4.04.0 (400%400\% mortality) instead of the true constant proportion of 0.2000.200 (20%20\% mortality).

  5. Step 5

    Rate is constant, so it is density-independent.\text{Rate is constant, so it is density-independent.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the functional trend required for both density-dependent and density-independent classifications.

You recognized that evaluating per capita rates rather than raw mortality counts is required to assess density dependence.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of woodlot area in per capita denominator

You divided total counts by density DD instead of total population N=Area⋅DN = \text{Area} \cdot D.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated population density (DD, in birds per hectare) with total population size (NN, in birds). A per capita rate represents the probability of an individual dying and must be scaled by total individuals N=A⋅DN = A \cdot D, ensuring rates remain bounded between 00 and 11.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimension and Range Check
  • A per capita mortality rate is dimensionless ([deaths]/[individuals][\text{deaths}]/[\text{individuals}]) and must satisfy 0≤m(D)≤10 \le m(D) \le 1 for a single mortality source.

  • Always check whether your per capita rate exceeds 1.01.0. If it does, check whether you divided by density rather than total abundance N=A⋅DN = A \cdot D.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate total population NN for each woodlot: N=A⋅D=20DN = A \cdot D = 20D.

  2. Compute per capita predation mortality: mpred(D)=Mpred20Dm_{\text{pred}}(D) = \frac{M_{\text{pred}}}{20D}, giving 0.080,0.120,0.200,0.3200.080, 0.120, 0.200, 0.320, which forms mpred(D)=0.040+0.007Dm_{\text{pred}}(D) = 0.040 + 0.007D.

  3. Compute per capita storm mortality: mstorm(D)=Mstorm20D=20100=0.200m_{\text{storm}}(D) = \frac{M_{\text{storm}}}{20D} = \frac{20}{100} = 0.200 across all woodlots.

Final answer

(a) mpred(D)=0.040+0.007Dm_{\text{pred}}(D) = 0.040 + 0.007D, positively density-dependent; (b) mstorm(D)=0.200m_{\text{storm}}(D) = 0.200, density-independent.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before dividing counts, explicitly write down the formula converting density to total population size: N=Area×DN = \text{Area} \times D.

  • Verify that any proportion or per capita mortality probability falls in the interval [0,1][0, 1].

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses absolute mortality counts with per capita mortality rates and concludes that the hailstorm is positively density-dependent because raw deaths increase with density.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    N=20D  ⟹  mpred(5)=0.08,mpred(10)=0.12,mpred(20)=0.20,mpred(40)=0.32  ⟹  mpred(D)=0.04+0.007D  ⟹  Positively density-dependent.N = 20D \implies m_{\text{pred}}(5) = 0.08, m_{\text{pred}}(10) = 0.12, m_{\text{pred}}(20) = 0.20, m_{\text{pred}}(40) = 0.32 \implies m_{\text{pred}}(D) = 0.04 + 0.007D \implies \text{Positively density-dependent.}

  2. Step 2

    N=20D  ⟹  mstorm(D)=20100=0.20N = 20D \implies m_{\text{storm}}(D) = \frac{20}{100} = 0.20

  3. Step 3

    Hailstorm deaths increase from 20 to 160 as density increases. Because total deaths increase with density, it is positively density-dependent.

    Correct

    Because the per capita mortality rate mstorm(D)=0.200m_{\text{storm}}(D) = 0.200 is constant regardless of density, the hailstorm is density-independent.

    Density dependence is defined by how the per capita mortality rate (proportion of individuals dying) changes with density, not by absolute death counts. Because mstorm(D)=0.20m_{\text{storm}}(D) = 0.20 is constant across all densities, the storm is density-independent.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly related woodlot area and density to find the total population size using N=20DN = 20D.

You calculated the per capita predation mortality rates across all woodlots accurately.

You correctly derived the linear rate function for predation and concluded it is positively density-dependent.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
confusing absolute counts with per capita rates

You noticed the raw number of hailstorm deaths increased from 2020 to 160160 and used that raw increase to classify density dependence instead of relying on the per capita rate you just computed.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing absolute mortality count with per capita mortality rate when defining density dependence. Because population size NN increases with density, raw counts of deaths often increase even when the mortality rate is completely constant.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Ecological Definition of Density Dependence
  • Density dependence requires that the per capita rate (proportion dying, MN\frac{M}{N}) changes with density DD, not the raw count (MM).

  • Always evaluate whether MN\frac{M}{N} increases, decreases, or remains constant across densities before stating a classification.

Abiotic vs. Biotic Typical Patterns
  • Severe abiotic weather disturbances (such as storms, freezes, and floods) usually kill an equal percentage of individuals regardless of density, making them density-independent.

  • Check whether the factor acts uniformly on individuals independent of crowding.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate per capita storm mortality across all densities: 20100=40200=80400=160800=0.200\frac{20}{100} = \frac{40}{200} = \frac{80}{400} = \frac{160}{800} = 0.200.

  2. Observe that mstorm(D)=0.200m_{\text{storm}}(D) = 0.200 is constant across all densities.

  3. Conclude that because the per capita mortality rate is invariant with respect to density, the hailstorm is a density-independent factor.

Final answer

(a) mpred(D)=0.040+0.007Dm_{\text{pred}}(D) = 0.040 + 0.007D, positively density-dependent; (b) mstorm(D)=0.200m_{\text{storm}}(D) = 0.200, density-independent.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between absolute numbers of deaths and proportional (per capita) mortality.

  • Practice classifying mortality tables by calculating MN\frac{M}{N} for every given density before drawing conclusions.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 50 ha50\text{ ha} nature reserve has an elk density of D=4 elk/haD = 4\text{ elk/ha}. During winter, 4040 elk die from severe cold. What is the total elk population NN and the per capita winter mortality rate mm?

Answer

N=50 ha×4 elk/ha=200 elkN = 50\text{ ha} \times 4\text{ elk/ha} = 200\text{ elk}. Per capita mortality m=40200=0.20m = \frac{40}{200} = 0.20 (20%20\%).

02

Two islands have areas of 10 ha10\text{ ha} and 40 ha40\text{ ha}, with rodent densities of 10 rodents/ha10\text{ rodents/ha} and 20 rodents/ha20\text{ rodents/ha}, respectively. An owl population kills 1515 rodents on Island 1 and 120120 rodents on Island 2. Determine the per capita predation rate on each island and state whether predation shows positive density dependence.

Answer

For Island 1: N1=10×10=100N_1 = 10 \times 10 = 100, m1=15100=0.15m_1 = \frac{15}{100} = 0.15 (15%15\%). For Island 2: N2=40×20=800N_2 = 40 \times 20 = 800, m2=120800=0.15m_2 = \frac{120}{800} = 0.15 (15%15\%). Because the per capita mortality rate is identical (0.150.15) despite density increasing from 1010 to 20 rodents/ha20\text{ rodents/ha}, predation is density-independent in this range.

03

In a 15 ha15\text{ ha} marsh, larval parasite deaths follow M(D)=0.3D2M(D) = 0.3 D^2, where DD is host density (hosts/ha). Find the functional form of the per capita mortality rate m(D)m(D) in terms of DD, and classify its density dependence.

Answer

Total host population is N=15DN = 15D. Per capita mortality is m(D)=M(D)N=0.3D215D=0.02Dm(D) = \frac{M(D)}{N} = \frac{0.3 D^2}{15 D} = 0.02 D. Because m(D)m(D) is a strictly increasing linear function of density DD, the parasite mortality is positively density-dependent.

Loading workspace…