Resources

A student hypothesizes that because dominant alleles mask recessive alleles in heterozygotes, natural selection should be substantially more effective at eliminating a rare deleterious allele from a population when the allele is recessive (aa) than when it is dominant (AA). To rigorously test this intuition, evaluate two large, randomly mating populations (N=100,000N = 100{,}000 each) undergoing selection with selection coefficient s=0.90s = 0.90: Population 1 possesses a rare deleterious recessive allele with frequency q=0.010q = 0.010 (wAA=1.0w_{AA} = 1.0, wAa=1.0w_{Aa} = 1.0, waa=0.10w_{aa} = 0.10). Population 2 possesses a rare deleterious dominant allele with frequency p=0.010p = 0.010 (waa=1.0w_{aa} = 1.0, wAa=0.10w_{Aa} = 0.10, wAA=0.10w_{AA} = 0.10). (a) Calculate the one-generation change in allele frequency Δq\Delta q for Population 1. (b) Calculate the one-generation change in allele frequency Δp\Delta p for Population 2. (c) Based on your calculations, explain why the student's intuition is fundamentally incorrect.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Δq≈−sq2(1−q)=−(0.90)(0.0001)(0.99)≈−8.91×10−5\Delta q \approx -s q^2(1 - q) = -(0.90)(0.0001)(0.99) \approx -8.91 \times 10^{-5}; (b) Δp≈−sp(1−p)=−(0.90)(0.010)(0.99)≈−8.91×10−3\Delta p \approx -s p(1 - p) = -(0.90)(0.010)(0.99) \approx -8.91 \times 10^{-3}; (c) The student's intuition is inverted: selection against a rare recessive allele is nearly ineffective (magnitude ∼q2\sim q^2) because over 99%99\% of copies are sequestered in phenotypically normal heterozygotes (AaAa), whereas a rare dominant allele is directly exposed to selection in every individual carrying it (magnitude ∼p\sim p), resulting in an elimination rate roughly 100100 times faster.

Steps

Part (a): Change in Allele Frequency for a Rare Deleterious Recessive Allele

Let pp be the frequency of the normal allele AA (p=0.990p = 0.990) and qq be the frequency of the deleterious recessive allele aa (q=0.010q = 0.010).

  1. Calculate the average fitness of Population 1 (wˉ\bar{w}): The relative fitness values are wAA=1.0w_{AA} = 1.0, wAa=1.0w_{Aa} = 1.0, and waa=1−s=0.10w_{aa} = 1 - s = 0.10, where s=0.90s = 0.90. wˉ=p2wAA+2pqwAa+q2waa=p2(1)+2pq(1)+q2(1−s)=1−sq2\bar{w} = p^2 w_{AA} + 2pq w_{Aa} + q^2 w_{aa} = p^2(1) + 2pq(1) + q^2(1 - s) = 1 - s q^2 Since q=0.010q = 0.010, q2=0.0001q^2 = 0.0001, so wˉ=1−0.90(0.0001)=0.99991≈1\bar{w} = 1 - 0.90(0.0001) = 0.99991 \approx 1.
  2. Calculate the new allele frequency q′q' and change Δq\Delta q: The frequency of allele aa in the next generation is: q′=pqwAa+q2waawˉ=pq(1)+q2(1−s)1−sq2=q(p+q−sq)1−sq2=q(1−sq)1−sq2q' = \frac{pq w_{Aa} + q^2 w_{aa}}{\bar{w}} = \frac{pq(1) + q^2(1 - s)}{1 - s q^2} = \frac{q(p + q - sq)}{1 - sq^2} = \frac{q(1 - sq)}{1 - sq^2} The change in frequency per generation is: Δq=q′−q=−sq2(1−q)1−sq2≈−sq2(1−q)\Delta q = q' - q = \frac{-s q^2(1 - q)}{1 - s q^2} \approx -s q^2(1 - q)
  3. Substitute the given values: Δq≈−(0.90)(0.010)2(1−0.010)=−(0.90)(0.0001)(0.99)≈−8.91×10−5\Delta q \approx -(0.90)(0.010)^2(1 - 0.010) = -(0.90)(0.0001)(0.99) \approx -8.91 \times 10^{-5}

Part (b): Change in Allele Frequency for a Rare Deleterious Dominant Allele

Let pp be the frequency of the deleterious dominant allele AA (p=0.010p = 0.010) and qq be the frequency of the normal recessive allele aa (q=0.990q = 0.990).

  1. Calculate the average fitness of Population 2 (wˉ\bar{w}): The fitness values are wAA=1−s=0.10w_{AA} = 1 - s = 0.10, wAa=1−s=0.10w_{Aa} = 1 - s = 0.10, and waa=1.0w_{aa} = 1.0. wˉ=p2(1−s)+2pq(1−s)+q2(1)=(p2+2pq)(1−s)+q2=1−s(1−q2)≈1\bar{w} = p^2(1 - s) + 2pq(1 - s) + q^2(1) = (p^2 + 2pq)(1 - s) + q^2 = 1 - s(1 - q^2) \approx 1
  2. Calculate the new allele frequency p′p' and change Δp\Delta p: Because heterozygous and homozygous dominant individuals both suffer selection, allele AA is exposed in both: p′=p2(1−s)+pq(1−s)wˉ=p(p+q)(1−s)wˉ=p(1−s)wˉp' = \frac{p^2(1 - s) + pq(1 - s)}{\bar{w}} = \frac{p(p + q)(1 - s)}{\bar{w}} = \frac{p(1 - s)}{\bar{w}} To first-order approximation for a rare dominant allele (p≪1p \ll 1, wˉ≈1\bar{w} \approx 1): Δp≈−sp(1−p)\Delta p \approx -s p(1 - p)
  3. Substitute the given values: Δp≈−(0.90)(0.010)(1−0.010)=−(0.90)(0.010)(0.99)≈−8.91×10−3\Delta p \approx -(0.90)(0.010)(1 - 0.010) = -(0.90)(0.010)(0.99) \approx -8.91 \times 10^{-3}

Part (c): Evaluating the Student's Intuition

The student's intuition is fundamentally incorrect:

  1. Proportional exposure to selection:

    • For a rare recessive allele (q=0.010q = 0.010), the vast majority of copies reside in heterozygotes (2pq≈0.01982pq \approx 0.0198), while only a tiny fraction are homozygous (q2=0.0001q^2 = 0.0001). Over 99%99\% of the deleterious recessive alleles are "hidden" inside phenotypically wild-type heterozygotes and are completely shielded from natural selection. As a result, the response to selection is proportional to q2q^2, making Δq\Delta q extremely small (≈−8.91×10−5\approx -8.91 \times 10^{-5}).
    • For a rare dominant allele (p=0.010p = 0.010), every single individual carrying the allele (predominantly heterozygotes AaAa) expresses the deleterious phenotype and experiences negative selection. The rate of reduction is proportional to pp, giving Δp≈−8.91×10−3\Delta p \approx -8.91 \times 10^{-3}.
  2. Comparison: Selection removes the rare dominant allele roughly ΔpΔq≈pq2=0.0100.0001=100\frac{\Delta p}{\Delta q} \approx \frac{p}{q^2} = \frac{0.010}{0.0001} = 100 times faster per generation than the recessive allele.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misapplies the standard recessive selection formula to Population 2 by squaring the dominant allele frequency instead of using the linear frequency term exposed in heterozygotes.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    wˉ=0.9902+2(0.990)(0.010)+0.10(0.010)2=0.99991  ⟹  Δq=−s⋅p⋅q2wˉ=−0.90(0.990)(0.010)20.99991=−0.000089\bar{w} = 0.990^2 + 2(0.990)(0.010) + 0.10(0.010)^2 = 0.99991 \implies \Delta q = -\frac{s \cdot p \cdot q^2}{\bar{w}} = -\frac{0.90(0.990)(0.010)^2}{0.99991} = -0.000089

  2. Step 2

    Δp=−s⋅q⋅p2wˉ=−0.90(0.990)(0.010)20.99991=−0.000089\Delta p = -\frac{s \cdot q \cdot p^2}{\bar{w}} = -\frac{0.90(0.990)(0.010)^2}{0.99991} = -0.000089

    Correct

    Δp=−spq(p+q)wˉ≈−sp(1−p)=−(0.90)(0.010)(0.99)≈−8.91×10−3\Delta p = -\frac{s p q(p + q)}{\bar{w}} \approx -s p(1 - p) = -(0.90)(0.010)(0.99) \approx -8.91 \times 10^{-3}

    You squared the dominant allele frequency pp as if it were only selected against in homozygotes (AAAA). Because allele AA is dominant, heterozygotes (AaAa) also suffer reduced fitness, so selection acts on the linear term p(1−p)p(1 - p) rather than p2(1−p)p^2(1 - p).

  3. Step 3

    "The student is incorrect because both alleles decrease by the same magnitude (-0.000089), showing selection acts with equal effectiveness on rare dominant and recessive alleles."

    Correct

    Selection is roughly 100 times more effective at removing the rare dominant allele (Δp≈−8.91×10−3\Delta p \approx -8.91 \times 10^{-3}) than the rare recessive allele (Δq≈−8.91×10−5\Delta q \approx -8.91 \times 10^{-5}) because over 99%99\% of copies of a rare recessive allele are hidden in unaffected heterozygotes, whereas every copy of a dominant allele is phenotypically exposed to selection.

    Your conceptual conclusion was misled by your calculation in part (b). In reality, natural selection purges rare dominant alleles much faster than rare recessive alleles.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the average fitness wˉ=0.99991\bar{w} = 0.99991 for Population 1.

You accurately evaluated Δq≈−8.91×10−5\Delta q \approx -8.91 \times 10^{-5} for selection against a rare recessive allele.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misapplying Recessive Selection Formula to a Dominant Allele

You treated selection against a rare dominant allele as mathematically symmetric to selection against a rare recessive allele.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked how dominance determines phenotypic exposure: rare recessive alleles are mostly sheltered in heterozygotes (frequency proportional to q2q^2), whereas rare dominant alleles are fully expressed in heterozygotes (frequency proportional to pp).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify which genotypes express the deleterious phenotype
  • For a recessive trait, only homozygotes (aaaa) are selected against; for a dominant trait, both heterozygotes (AaAa) and homozygotes (AAAA) are selected against.

  • Always write out the genotypes experiencing selection before writing the numerator of Δp\Delta p or Δq\Delta q.

Check the power of the rare allele frequency in $\Delta$
  • When an allele is rare, Δq∝q2\Delta q \propto q^2 for recessive selection, but Δp∝p\Delta p \propto p for dominant selection.

  • Ensure the numerator for dominant selection contains the linear term spqs p q, not sp2qs p^2 q.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. For Population 2, the deleterious dominant allele AA is expressed in both AAAA and AaAa, which both have fitness 1−s=0.101 - s = 0.10.

  2. The mean fitness is wˉ=(p2+2pq)(1−s)+q2=1−s(1−q2)=1−0.90(1−0.992)≈0.982\bar{w} = (p^2 + 2pq)(1 - s) + q^2 = 1 - s(1 - q^2) = 1 - 0.90(1 - 0.99^2) \approx 0.982.

  3. The frequency change is Δp=−sp(1−p)2wˉ≈−sp(1−p)=−(0.90)(0.010)(0.99)≈−8.91×10−3\Delta p = -\frac{s p(1 - p)^2}{\bar{w}} \approx -s p(1 - p) = -(0.90)(0.010)(0.99) \approx -8.91 \times 10^{-3}.

  4. Comparing magnitudes: ∣Δp∣∣Δq∣≈8.91×10−38.91×10−5=100\frac{|\Delta p|}{|\Delta q|} \approx \frac{8.91 \times 10^{-3}}{8.91 \times 10^{-5}} = 100.

Final answer

(a) Δq≈−8.91×10−5\Delta q \approx -8.91 \times 10^{-5}; (b) Δp≈−8.91×10−3\Delta p \approx -8.91 \times 10^{-3}; (c) The student's intuition is inverted: selection removes a rare dominant allele ≈100\approx 100 times faster because rare recessive alleles are sequestered in phenotypically normal heterozygotes, while rare dominant alleles are directly exposed in heterozygotes.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice deriving Δp\Delta p from first principles using a genotype fitness table rather than relying on memorized formulas.

  • Compare the ratio of heterozygotes to homozygotes (2pq/q2=2p/q2pq / q^2 = 2p/q) when an allele is rare to reinforce why recessive alleles remain shielded from selection.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student omits the mean fitness denominator w̄ and calculates allele frequency change assuming w̄ = 1, leading to slightly shifted frequency changes and an incomplete fitness normalization.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Correct
  1. Step 1

    p=0.990,q=0.010  ⟹  Δq=−s⋅p⋅q2=−0.90(0.990)(0.010)2=−0.0000891p = 0.990, \quad q = 0.010 \implies \Delta q = -s \cdot p \cdot q^2 = -0.90(0.990)(0.010)^2 = -0.0000891

  2. Step 2

    q=0.990,p=0.010  ⟹  Δp=−s⋅p⋅q=−0.90(0.010)(0.990)=−0.00891q = 0.990, \quad p = 0.010 \implies \Delta p = -s \cdot p \cdot q = -0.90(0.010)(0.990) = -0.00891

  3. Step 3

    The student's hypothesis is incorrect because ∣Δp∣=0.00891|\Delta p| = 0.00891 is about 100100 times larger than ∣Δq∣=0.0000891|\Delta q| = 0.0000891, showing that dominant deleterious alleles are eliminated much faster because they are exposed to selection in heterozygotes.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the selection response formulas for both rare recessive and rare dominant alleles.

You accurately carried out the numerical calculations to find Δq=−8.91×10−5\Delta q = -8.91 \times 10^{-5} and Δp=−8.91×10−3\Delta p = -8.91 \times 10^{-3}.

You articulated the key biological mechanism: deleterious recessive alleles are largely shielded in heterozygotes, while dominant alleles are directly exposed to selection.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
none
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Mean Fitness Normalization
  • The exact change in allele frequency is Δq=−sq2(1−q)wˉ\Delta q = \frac{-s q^2(1-q)}{\bar{w}} for a recessive allele and Δp=−sp(1−p)wˉ\Delta p = \frac{-s p(1-p)}{\bar{w}} for a dominant allele.

  • Always verify that wˉ≈1\bar{w} \approx 1 holds when using the simplified formulas −spq2-s p q^2 and −spq-s p q, as large allele frequencies or strong selection across the entire population can make wˉ\bar{w} noticeably less than 11.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Compare the exact formula Δp=−sp(1−p)wˉ\Delta p = \frac{-s p(1-p)}{\bar{w}} with your approximation to see how small the difference is when p=0.010p = 0.010.

  • Investigate how mutation-selection balance maintains rare deleterious recessives at much higher equilibrium frequencies (hatq=μ/s\\hat{q} = \sqrt{\mu / s}) than rare dominants (hatp=μ/s\\hat{p} = \mu / s).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A population has a deleterious allele at frequency 0.0200.020 with selection coefficient s=0.50s = 0.50. Assuming Hardy-Weinberg genotype proportions before selection, approximate the one-generation change in allele frequency if the allele is: (a) completely recessive, and (b) completely dominant.

Answer

(a) Δq≈−sq2(1−q)=−(0.50)(0.020)2(0.98)=−1.96×10−4\Delta q \approx -s q^2(1 - q) = -(0.50)(0.020)^2(0.98) = -1.96 \times 10^{-4}. (b) Δp≈−sp(1−p)=−(0.50)(0.020)(0.98)=−9.80×10−3\Delta p \approx -s p(1 - p) = -(0.50)(0.020)(0.98) = -9.80 \times 10^{-3}.

02

In a random-mating insect population, a lethal mutation (s=1.0s = 1.0) arises. In Case A, the lethal mutation is completely recessive (q=0.005q = 0.005). In Case B, the lethal mutation is completely dominant (p=0.005p = 0.005). Calculate the percentage of mutant allele copies eliminated by selection in the first generation for each case.

Answer

Case A (recessive): Only homozygotes die. Proportion of mutant alleles in homozygotes is 2q22q=q=0.005\frac{2q^2}{2q} = q = 0.005 (or 0.5%0.5\% eliminated). Case B (dominant): Every carrier expresses the lethal phenotype and dies, so 100%100\% of mutant copies are eliminated in one generation.

03

Suppose a deleterious allele has frequency 0.0400.040 and selection coefficient s=0.80s = 0.80. What is the expected ratio of the rate of elimination if the allele is dominant versus if it is recessive, ∣Δpdom∣∣Δqrec∣\frac{|\Delta p_{\text{dom}}|}{|\Delta q_{\text{rec}}|}?

Answer

Ratio ≈s⋅f⋅(1−f)s⋅f2⋅(1−f)=1f=10.040=25\approx \frac{s \cdot f \cdot (1 - f)}{s \cdot f^2 \cdot (1 - f)} = \frac{1}{f} = \frac{1}{0.040} = 25. The dominant allele is eliminated approximately 2525 times faster.

Loading workspace…