Resources

In a social wasp (Polistes) colony, subordinate females assist a dominant queen in rearing offspring rather than establishing their own solitary nests. Solitary females can independently rear an average of Ns=4.0N_s = 4.0 offspring per season with relatedness rs=0.50r_s = 0.50. When serving as a helper, a subordinate enables the queen (her full sister, where rk=0.75r_k = 0.75 under haplodiploidy) to rear an additional BB reproductive offspring beyond the queen's solitary output. If the helper's inclusive fitness gain from helping must exceed her inclusive fitness from solitary nesting (rkB>rsNsr_k B > r_s N_s), calculate the minimum number of additional full-sister offspring (Bmin⁡B_{\min}) the helper must enable the queen to produce.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Bmin⁡=2.67B_{\min} = 2.67 reproductive offspring (or at least 33 whole offspring, as B>(0.50)(4.0)0.75=2.00.75≈2.67B > \frac{(0.50)(4.0)}{0.75} = \frac{2.0}{0.75} \approx 2.67).

Steps

01

Identify the Inclusive Fitness Components

According to kin selection and Hamilton's rule, an individual will favor helping relatives over solitary reproduction whenever the indirect fitness gained from helping exceeds the direct fitness lost by not reproducing independently:

  • Direct fitness from solitary nesting (Fitnesssolitary\text{Fitness}_{\text{solitary}}): Fitnesssolitary=rs⋅Ns\text{Fitness}_{\text{solitary}} = r_s \cdot N_s where:

    • rs=0.50r_s = 0.50 is the coefficient of relatedness between a female and her own offspring.
    • Ns=4.0N_s = 4.0 is the number of offspring she can rear on her own.
  • Indirect fitness gained by helping (Fitnesshelping\text{Fitness}_{\text{helping}}): Fitnesshelping=rk⋅B\text{Fitness}_{\text{helping}} = r_k \cdot B where:

    • rk=0.75r_k = 0.75 is the coefficient of relatedness to full sisters produced by the queen under haplodiploidy.
    • BB is the number of additional reproductive offspring produced because of the helper's presence.

02

Set Up and Solve the Inequality

For helping behavior to be evolutionarily favored: rk⋅B>rs⋅Nsr_k \cdot B > r_s \cdot N_s

Substitute the known values: 0.75⋅B>0.50⋅4.00.75 \cdot B > 0.50 \cdot 4.0 0.75⋅B>2.00.75 \cdot B > 2.0

Solve for BB: B>2.00.75=2.034=83≈2.67B > \frac{2.0}{0.75} = \frac{2.0}{\frac{3}{4}} = \frac{8}{3} \approx 2.67

Thus, the theoretical minimum number of additional full-sister offspring is: Bmin⁡≈2.67B_{\min} \approx 2.67

Since actual offspring are discrete individuals, the helper must enable the queen to produce at least 33 whole offspring for helping to be the more advantageous evolutionary strategy.


Key Takeaway and Pitfall

  • Genetic Asymmetry: In haplodiploid insects (like wasps, bees, and ants), full sisters share three-quarters (r=0.75r = 0.75) of their genes because they receive identical haploid genomes from their father, whereas a mother shares only half (r=0.50r = 0.50) of her genes with her offspring.
  • Common Pitfall: Do not assume a helper must produce more individuals than a solitary female (B>4.0B > 4.0). Because sister offspring carry a higher genetic relatedness (0.75>0.500.75 > 0.50), helping can yield greater inclusive fitness even with fewer total offspring reared (2.67<4.02.67 < 4.0).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the relatedness values, assigning r = 0.50 to the sister's offspring and r = 0.75 to direct offspring, resulting in an incorrect threshold of B > 6.0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    rk⋅B>rs⋅Nsr_k \cdot B > r_s \cdot N_s

  2. Step 2

    0.50⋅B>0.75⋅4.00.50 \cdot B > 0.75 \cdot 4.0

    Correct

    0.75⋅B>0.50⋅4.00.75 \cdot B > 0.50 \cdot 4.0

    You inverted the relatedness coefficients. Under haplodiploidy, a female is related to her full sisters by rk=0.75r_k = 0.75 and to her own offspring by rs=0.50r_s = 0.50, not the reverse.

  3. Step 3

    0.50⋅B>3.0  ⟹  B>3.0/0.50  ⟹  Bmin⁡>6.00.50 \cdot B > 3.0 \implies B > 3.0 / 0.50 \implies B_{\min} > 6.0

    Correct

    0.75⋅B>2.0  ⟹  B>2.00.75≈2.670.75 \cdot B > 2.0 \implies B > \frac{2.0}{0.75} \approx 2.67

    Your algebraic rearrangement and division were executed accurately, but the calculation propagated the swapped relatedness values from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified Hamilton's rule inequality (rkB>rsNsr_k B > r_s N_s) for inclusive fitness.

You executed the multi-step algebraic inequality correctly based on your substituted numbers.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Relatedness Coefficients

You swapped rk=0.75r_k = 0.75 and rs=0.50r_s = 0.50 when substituting into the inequality.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the asymmetry of haplodiploid relatedness by assigning the standard diploid offspring relatedness (r=0.50r = 0.50) to indirect sister rearing rather than to direct mother-offspring reproduction.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Haplodiploid Relatedness Asymmetry
  • In haplodiploid Hymenoptera, full sisters share r=0.75r = 0.75 of their genes (100% of the father's haploid genome + 50% of the mother's diploid genome), whereas a mother shares r=0.50r = 0.50 with her own offspring.

  • Always verify whether the coefficient applies to full sisters (r=0.75r = 0.75) or direct offspring (r=0.50r = 0.50) before substituting into Hamilton's rule.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute rk=0.75r_k = 0.75, rs=0.50r_s = 0.50, and Ns=4.0N_s = 4.0 into rkB>rsNsr_k B > r_s N_s: 0.75⋅B>0.50⋅4.00.75 \cdot B > 0.50 \cdot 4.0

  2. Simplify the right-hand side: 0.75⋅B>2.00.75 \cdot B > 2.0

  3. Divide both sides by 0.750.75: B>2.00.75=83≈2.67B > \frac{2.0}{0.75} = \frac{8}{3} \approx 2.67

Final answer

Bmin⁡≈2.67B_{\min} \approx 2.67 (or at least 33 whole offspring)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the genetic basis of the 3/43/4 relatedness among haplodiploid full sisters.

  • Label each variable explicitly with its biological meaning (rsister=0.75r_\text{sister} = 0.75, roffspring=0.50r_\text{offspring} = 0.50) before substituting values into evolutionary inequalities.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly multiplies by 0.75 instead of dividing when isolating B, obtaining B > 1.5.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    0.75⋅B>0.50⋅4.0  ⟹  0.75⋅B>2.00.75 \cdot B > 0.50 \cdot 4.0 \implies 0.75 \cdot B > 2.0

  2. Step 2

    B>2.0⋅0.75B > 2.0 \cdot 0.75

    Correct

    B>2.00.75B > \frac{2.0}{0.75}

    Because BB is multiplied by 0.750.75, you must divide both sides by 0.750.75 rather than multiply to isolate BB.

  3. Step 3

    Bmin⁡>1.5B_{\min} > 1.5

    Correct

    Bmin⁡≈2.67 (or at least 3 whole offspring)B_{\min} \approx 2.67 \text{ (or at least } 3 \text{ whole offspring)}

    This numerical result follows directly from multiplying rather than dividing in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the relatedness values and set up Hamilton's inequality rkB>rsNsr_k B > r_s N_s.

You correctly evaluated the product 0.50⋅4.0=2.00.50 \cdot 4.0 = 2.0 for direct fitness.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic isolation error

You performed multiplication instead of division when moving the coefficient across the inequality sign.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Inverting a multiplication operation with another multiplication rather than applying the inverse operation (division) when isolating a variable.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolating a variable with a coefficient
  • For an inequality a⋅x>ca \cdot x > c where a>0a > 0, divide both sides by aa to get x>cax > \frac{c}{a}.

  • Divide 2.02.0 by 0.750.75 (or multiply by the reciprocal 43\frac{4}{3}) instead of multiplying by 0.750.75.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Start from the correct inequality: 0.75⋅B>2.00.75 \cdot B > 2.0.

  2. Divide both sides by 0.750.75: B>2.00.75=2.034=2.0⋅43=83B > \frac{2.0}{0.75} = \frac{2.0}{\frac{3}{4}} = 2.0 \cdot \frac{4}{3} = \frac{8}{3}.

  3. Convert to a decimal or whole offspring: B>2.67B > 2.67, meaning the helper must enable at least 33 additional sisters.

Final answer

Bmin⁡≈2.67B_{\min} \approx 2.67 (or at least 33 whole offspring)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check algebraic inverse operations: whenever a variable is multiplied by a coefficient aa, isolate it by dividing by aa.

  • Perform a sanity check: since 0.75<10.75 < 1, dividing 2.02.0 by 0.750.75 must yield a number larger than 2.02.0.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student ignores the relatedness coefficients r_k and r_s, assuming equal genetic weighting and concluding B_min > 4.0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    B>Ns  ⟹  B>4.0B > N_s \implies B > 4.0

    Correct

    rkB>rsNs  ⟹  0.75B>(0.50)(4.0)r_k B > r_s N_s \implies 0.75 B > (0.50)(4.0)

    You omitted the relatedness coefficients rkr_k and rsr_s when setting up the inequality. Hamilton's rule evaluates inclusive fitness by weighting the benefit and cost by genetic relatedness.

  2. Step 2

    Bmin⁡>4.0B_{\min} > 4.0

    Correct

    B>2.00.75=83≈2.67B > \frac{2.0}{0.75} = \frac{8}{3} \approx 2.67 (or at least 33 whole offspring)

    Carrying the unweighted condition forward led you to conclude that the helper must rear more than 4.04.0 offspring, whereas the higher relatedness to sisters (0.75>0.500.75 > 0.50) lowers the required threshold to approximately 2.672.67.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the helper's output must exceed the solitary output baseline to be evolutionarily favored.

You correctly substituted the solitary fecundity value Ns=4.0N_s = 4.0 into your inequality.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Relatedness Coefficients in Inclusive Fitness

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating raw reproductive count with inclusive fitness by treating all offspring as genetically equivalent (r=1r = 1), rather than applying Hamilton's rule where each offspring's evolutionary value is scaled by the coefficient of relatedness (rr).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Weighting by Relatedness
  • Inclusive fitness calculations require multiplying offspring counts by their coefficient of relatedness (r⋅Nr \cdot N).

  • Always write the full inequality rkB>rsNsr_k B > r_s N_s before substituting numerical values.

Haplodiploid Asymmetry
  • In haplodiploid systems, full sisters share r=0.75r = 0.75 of their genes, whereas mother-offspring relatedness is only r=0.50r = 0.50.

  • Check whether relatedness to collateral kin exceeds relatedness to direct descendants before comparing reproductive outputs.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up Hamilton's rule inequality with relatedness: rkB>rsNsr_k B > r_s N_s

  2. Substitute rk=0.75r_k = 0.75, rs=0.50r_s = 0.50, and Ns=4.0N_s = 4.0: 0.75B>(0.50)(4.0)0.75 B > (0.50)(4.0)

  3. Simplify the right-hand side: 0.75B>2.00.75 B > 2.0

  4. Solve for BB: B>2.00.75=83≈2.67B > \frac{2.0}{0.75} = \frac{8}{3} \approx 2.67

Final answer

Bmin⁡≈2.67B_{\min} \approx 2.67 reproductive offspring (or at least 33 whole offspring)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Hamilton's rule (rB>CrB > C) and define how inclusive fitness weights individual offspring by relatedness rr.

  • Practice setting up fitness inequalities for haplodiploid vs. diploid social systems.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A solitary female bee can independently produce Ns=5.0N_s = 5.0 daughters (rs=0.50r_s = 0.50). If she instead acts as a helper for her mother (the queen), enabling her to produce additional full sisters (rk=0.75r_k = 0.75), calculate the minimum number of additional sisters Bmin⁡B_{\min} required for helping to be evolutionarily favored.

Answer

Bmin⁡≈3.33B_{\min} \approx 3.33 sisters (or at least 44 whole sisters). Key steps:

  1. Apply Hamilton's rule: rkB>rsNsr_k B > r_s N_s.
  2. Substitute values: 0.75B>0.50×5.0=2.500.75 B > 0.50 \times 5.0 = 2.50.
  3. Solve: B>2.500.75=103≈3.33B > \frac{2.50}{0.75} = \frac{10}{3} \approx 3.33.
02

In a diploid mammal species, a subordinate female can either reproduce alone to yield Ns=3.0N_s = 3.0 offspring (rs=0.50r_s = 0.50) or assist her mother in rearing additional full siblings (rk=0.50r_k = 0.50). Calculate the minimum number of additional siblings (Bmin⁡B_{\min}) she must help her mother rear to favor helping over solitary nesting.

Answer

Bmin⁡=3.0B_{\min} = 3.0 siblings (she must enable more than 33 offspring, so at least 44 whole siblings). Key steps:

  1. In diploid species, full siblings share rk=0.50r_k = 0.50, and parent-offspring relatedness is rs=0.50r_s = 0.50.
  2. Hamilton's rule: 0.50B>0.50×3.0  ⟹  B>3.00.50 B > 0.50 \times 3.0 \implies B > 3.0.
03

In a primitively eusocial wasp colony, a helper is related to the queen's male offspring (brothers) by rm=0.25r_m = 0.25 and to the queen's female offspring (sisters) by rf=0.75r_f = 0.75. If the queen produces a 1:11:1 sex ratio of reproductive offspring (average relatedness rˉ=0.50\bar{r} = 0.50), and a solitary female can rear Ns=4.0N_s = 4.0 daughters (rs=0.50r_s = 0.50), determine the minimum total number of additional mixed-sex reproductives (Bmin⁡B_{\min}) the helper must enable the colony to produce.

Answer

Bmin⁡=4.0B_{\min} = 4.0 offspring (she must help rear more than 4.04.0, so at least 55 whole offspring). Key steps:

  1. Calculate average relatedness: rˉ=0.75+0.252=0.50\bar{r} = \frac{0.75 + 0.25}{2} = 0.50.
  2. Set up the inequality: rˉ⋅B>rs⋅Ns  ⟹  0.50⋅B>0.50×4.0\bar{r} \cdot B > r_s \cdot N_s \implies 0.50 \cdot B > 0.50 \times 4.0.
  3. Solve: B>4.0B > 4.0.
Loading workspace…