Resources
A student preparing a cell fractionation laboratory confuses the sedimented organelle identity due to centrifugation speed conventions. The protocol specifies differential centrifugation at for (Pellet 1), for (Pellet 2), and for (Pellet 3). The student mistakenly predicts that ribosomes and small microsomal vesicles sediment in Pellet 1, while nuclei sediment in Pellet 3. Provide the correct assignment of primary organelles to Pellets 1, 2, and 3, and state the governing physical principle relating sedimentation velocity to organelle radius and centrifugal acceleration.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Pellet 1 (): (and intact cells/heavy debris); Pellet 2 (): , , and ; Pellet 3 (): (fragments of ER) and large multi-protein complexes/free ribosomes. Physical principle: According to Svedberg/Stokes sedimentation, velocity scales with the square of the organelle's effective radius (), causing the largest and densest structures (nuclei) to pellet at the lowest centrifugal forces.
Steps
The Physical Principle of Differential Centrifugation
Differential centrifugation separates cellular components based on their sedimentation velocity (). For a spherical organelle of radius moving through a viscous medium, balancing the centrifugal force against buoyant and drag forces (Stokes' Law) gives:
where:
- is the effective radius of the organelle,
- is the particle (organelle) density,
- is the medium density,
- is the fluid viscosity,
- is the centrifugal acceleration (, often expressed in multiples of gravitational acceleration, ).
Key Insight: Sedimentation velocity is directly proportional to the square of the organelle's radius () and the applied acceleration (). Because velocity depends quadratically on size, the largest and heaviest organelles sediment first at low centrifugal speeds, while progressively smaller organelles require exponentially higher speeds and longer durations to form a pellet.
Correct Assignment of Pellets
Following standard differential centrifugation protocols from lowest to highest speed:
-
Pellet 1 ( for — Low Speed):
- Primary Contents: Nuclei, intact unbroken cells, and large cytoskeletal fragments.
- Reasoning: Nuclei are the largest organelles in eukaryotic cells (typically in diameter). Their massive radius gives them the highest sedimentation velocity, causing them to sediment under modest centrifugal force.
-
Pellet 2 ( for — Medium Speed):
- Primary Contents: Mitochondria, chloroplasts (in plant tissues), and lysosomes/peroxisomes.
- Reasoning: These are intermediate-sized organelles (roughly ). With the nuclei removed in the supernatant, these medium-sized components pellet out at moderate speeds.
-
Pellet 3 ( for — High Speed / Ultracentrifugation):
- Primary Contents: Microsomes (small vesicles formed from fragmented endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi membranes) and large multi-protein complexes/free ribosomes.
- Reasoning: Microsomes and ribosomal complexes have very small radii (). Because is extremely small, high centrifugal accelerations () applied for an extended period are required to overcome thermal diffusion and force them into a pellet. The remaining liquid is the soluble cytosolic fraction.
Common Pitfall
- Inverting the size-speed relationship: A frequent misconception is assuming that high speeds are needed to pull down large objects. In reality, large particles sediment quickly and easily under low force; smaller particles require intense gravitational fields because their small cross-sectional area produces a tiny net centrifugal force relative to the viscous drag of the buffer.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the sedimentation order by assuming smaller particles sediment first at low speeds because they encounter less resistance, reversing the relationship between size and centrifugal force.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Pellet 1: microsomes and ribosomes
CorrectPellet 1 (): Nuclei, intact unbroken cells, and large cytoskeletal debris
Low centrifugal speed () is sufficient to pellet only the largest and heaviest cellular components, such as nuclei. Microsomes and ribosomes are far too small to sediment at this low speed.
- Step 2
Pellet 2: mitochondria and lysosomes
- Step 3
Pellet 3: nuclei and whole cells
CorrectPellet 3 (): Microsomes (ER fragments) and small vesicles / ribosomes
High centrifugal acceleration () is required to overcome viscous drag and thermal diffusion for tiny structures such as microsomes and ribosomes, not large structures like nuclei.
- Step 4
Sedimentation velocity is inversely proportional to radius squared, so smaller particles sediment at lower g-force.
CorrectSedimentation velocity is directly proportional to the square of the organelle's radius (), not inversely proportional. Because buoyant force and mass scale with volume () while drag scales with radius (), net sedimentation velocity increases dramatically as particle radius increases.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified mitochondria and lysosomes as intermediate-speed sedimenting organelles.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that smaller organelles encounter less resistance and therefore sediment at lower speeds, leading you to formulate an inverse relationship () instead of a direct quadratic dependence ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Stokes' Drag and Buoyancy Scaling
Centrifugal driving force scales with volume (), whereas Stokes viscous drag scales linearly with radius ().
Equate the centrifugal force and drag force to see that sedimentation velocity scales with , meaning larger particles always sediment faster under lower centrifugal acceleration.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply the sedimentation velocity formula .
Rank cellular components by effective size: Nuclei () > Mitochondria/Lysosomes () > Microsomes/Ribosomes ().
Assign the largest structures (nuclei and whole cells) to the lowest speed, Pellet 1 ().
Assign the smallest structures (microsomes and ribosomes) to the highest speed, Pellet 3 ().
Pellet 1 (): Nuclei and intact cells; Pellet 2 (): Mitochondria and lysosomes; Pellet 3 (): Microsomes and ribosomes. Physical principle: (sedimentation velocity is directly proportional to the square of the particle radius and the centrifugal acceleration).
02 The student correctly understands that larger particles sediment first, but mistakenly assumes sedimentation velocity depends linearly on radius rather than radius squared.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Pellet 1: nuclei and whole cells Pellet 2: mitochondria and chloroplasts Pellet 3: microsomes and ribosomes
- Step 2
⟹ Sedimentation velocity is directly proportional to centrifugal acceleration and particle radius .
CorrectCentrifugal force is proportional to particle mass/volume (which scales with ), while viscous drag opposes motion linearly with radius (). Equating the two forces yields , meaning sedimentation velocity depends on the square of the radius rather than just .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly ordered the organelles by size and paired them with the corresponding centrifugation speeds.
You correctly identified that sedimentation velocity is directly proportional to centrifugal acceleration .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou likely balanced the drag force without accounting for the organelle's volume dependence on , resulting in an incorrect linear relationship rather than the quadratic relationship .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Derivation of Stokes Sedimentation Velocity
Net centrifugal force scales with particle volume (), while Stokes drag scales with particle radius ().
Equate : , then divide both sides by to solve for velocity: .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet the net centrifugal force equal to the viscous drag: .
Solve for the sedimentation velocity: .
Conclude the governing scaling relationship: .
Pellet 1: nuclei; Pellet 2: mitochondria and chloroplasts; Pellet 3: microsomes and ribosomes. Governing principle: (sedimentation velocity is proportional to centrifugal acceleration and the square of particle radius).
Lock it in
How does organelle radius affect sedimentation velocity during differential centrifugation?
Sedimentation velocity is directly proportional to the square of the radius (). Larger organelles sediment much faster.
Similar question
A cell homogenate containing chloroplasts () and peroxisomes () of similar densities is subjected to differential centrifugation. Which organelle will pellet at a lower speed and shorter duration, and by approximately what factor does its initial sedimentation velocity exceed the other?
Answer
Chloroplasts pellet first. Because , the ratio of velocities is . Chloroplasts sediment roughly times faster.
After spinning a liver homogenate at for , the supernatant is transferred and spun at for . Identify the primary organelles found in the first pellet, the second pellet, and the remaining supernatant.
Answer
First pellet (): Nuclei and intact hepatocytes. Second pellet (): Mitochondria, lysosomes, and peroxisomes. Remaining supernatant: Microsomes (ER fragments), free ribosomes, and soluble cytosolic proteins.
A researcher isolates endosomes () and transport vesicles () of identical buoyant density. If endosomes achieve sedimentation under an acceleration of in a given time, what centrifugal acceleration is required to sediment the transport vesicles in the exact same duration through the same medium?
Answer
. Sedimentation velocity is . For equal travel time, , so . Substituting values: .