Resources

In a quantitative study of human thermal homeostasis, the overall negative feedback loop gain GG is modeled by the ratio of corrective physiological response to open-loop perturbation: G=−ΔTresponseΔTerrorG = -\frac{\Delta T_{\text{response}}}{\Delta T_{\text{error}}}. A subject at a baseline core temperature set point of Tset=37.00∘CT_{\text{set}} = 37.00^{\circ}\text{C} enters a cold chamber, which produces an uncompensated passive open-loop drop of ΔTpassive=−2.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{passive}} = -2.40^{\circ}\text{C}. The autonomic negative feedback system responds via shivering thermogenesis and peripheral vasoconstriction, resulting in an observed steady-state regulated core temperature of Tsteady=36.60∘CT_{\text{steady}} = 36.60^{\circ}\text{C}. Calculate the dimensionless loop gain GG of this thermoregulatory system.

Answer and steps

Final answer

G=5.00G = 5.00 (dimensionless, or an open-loop feedback gain of magnitude 5.005.00)

Steps

01

Determine the Error Signal (ΔTerror\Delta T_{\text{error}})

In homeostatic negative feedback, the error signal is the difference between the actual regulated steady-state value and the set point:

ΔTerror=Tsteady−Tset\Delta T_{\text{error}} = T_{\text{steady}} - T_{\text{set}}

Substitute the given values:

ΔTerror=36.60∘C−37.00∘C=−0.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{error}} = 36.60^{\circ}\text{C} - 37.00^{\circ}\text{C} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C}


02

Determine the Corrective Physiological Response (ΔTresponse\Delta T_{\text{response}})

The net change in core temperature (ΔTnet=ΔTerror\Delta T_{\text{net}} = \Delta T_{\text{error}}) is the algebraic sum of the passive perturbation caused by the environment and the active physiological compensation (such as shivering and vasoconstriction):

ΔTnet=ΔTpassive+ΔTresponse\Delta T_{\text{net}} = \Delta T_{\text{passive}} + \Delta T_{\text{response}}

Substitute ΔTnet=−0.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{net}} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C} and ΔTpassive=−2.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{passive}} = -2.40^{\circ}\text{C}:

−0.40∘C=−2.40∘C+ΔTresponse-0.40^{\circ}\text{C} = -2.40^{\circ}\text{C} + \Delta T_{\text{response}}

ΔTresponse=−0.40∘C−(−2.40∘C)=+2.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C} - (-2.40^{\circ}\text{C}) = +2.00^{\circ}\text{C}

The physiological mechanisms actively raise the temperature by +2.00∘C+2.00^{\circ}\text{C} relative to the uncompensated state.


03

Calculate the Negative Feedback Loop Gain (GG)

Using the defined model for open-loop feedback gain:

G=−ΔTresponseΔTerrorG = -\frac{\Delta T_{\text{response}}}{\Delta T_{\text{error}}}

Substitute the calculated values:

G=−+2.00∘C−0.40∘C=5.00G = -\frac{+2.00^{\circ}\text{C}}{-0.40^{\circ}\text{C}} = 5.00


04

Verification via Closed-Loop Control Formula

In a standard linear negative feedback system, the regulated closed-loop error is attenuated by a factor of (1+G)(1 + G):

ΔTerror=ΔTpassive1+G\Delta T_{\text{error}} = \frac{\Delta T_{\text{passive}}}{1 + G}

−0.40∘C=−2.40∘C1+G-0.40^{\circ}\text{C} = \frac{-2.40^{\circ}\text{C}}{1 + G}

1+G=−2.40∘C−0.40∘C=6.00  ⟹  G=5.001 + G = \frac{-2.40^{\circ}\text{C}}{-0.40^{\circ}\text{C}} = 6.00 \implies G = 5.00

Key Pitfall: Ensure correct tracking of negative signs. Because negative feedback acts in the opposite direction of the displacement, the physiological response (ΔTresponse=+2.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = +2.00^{\circ}\text{C}) opposes the error (ΔTerror=−0.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{error}} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C}), yielding a positive, dimensionless gain GG.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies the passive perturbation itself as the corrective response instead of calculating the net physiological offset, resulting in a loop gain of -6.0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔTerror=36.60∘C−37.00∘C=−0.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{error}} = 36.60^{\circ}\text{C} - 37.00^{\circ}\text{C} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C}

  2. Step 2

    ΔTresponse=−2.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = -2.40^{\circ}\text{C}

    Correct

    ΔTresponse=ΔTerror−ΔTpassive=−0.40∘C−(−2.40∘C)=+2.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = \Delta T_{\text{error}} - \Delta T_{\text{passive}} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C} - (-2.40^{\circ}\text{C}) = +2.00^{\circ}\text{C}

    You treated the uncompensated environmental drop (−2.40∘C-2.40^{\circ}\text{C}) as the physiological response. The physiological response is the active offset produced by shivering and vasoconstriction that counters this drop: ΔTresponse=ΔTerror−ΔTpassive=+2.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = \Delta T_{\text{error}} - \Delta T_{\text{passive}} = +2.00^{\circ}\text{C}.

  3. Step 3

    G=−(−2.40∘C/−0.40∘C)=−6.0G = -(-2.40^{\circ}\text{C} / -0.40^{\circ}\text{C}) = -6.0

    Correct

    G=−ΔTresponseΔTerror=−+2.00∘C−0.40∘C=5.00G = -\frac{\Delta T_{\text{response}}}{\Delta T_{\text{error}}} = -\frac{+2.00^{\circ}\text{C}}{-0.40^{\circ}\text{C}} = 5.00

    Your gain calculation correctly applied your values into the formula, but it inherited the incorrect value for ΔTresponse\Delta T_{\text{response}} from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the steady-state error signal ΔTerror=−0.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{error}} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C}.

You correctly recalled the negative feedback loop gain formula G=−ΔTresponseΔTerrorG = -\frac{\Delta T_{\text{response}}}{\Delta T_{\text{error}}}.

You carried out the arithmetic operations and sign tracking accurately according to your written values.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Perturbation with Compensatory Response

You substituted the external perturbation ΔTpassive\Delta T_{\text{passive}} in place of the active physiological response ΔTresponse\Delta T_{\text{response}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In biological homeostatic loops, the observed net deviation ΔTerror\Delta T_{\text{error}} represents the sum of the external disturbance (ΔTpassive\Delta T_{\text{passive}}) and the corrective homeostatic response (ΔTresponse\Delta T_{\text{response}}). Confusing the disturbance with the response misses the subtractive nature of negative feedback compensation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distinguish Disturbance vs. Response
  • Net Change = Disturbance + Corrective Response: ΔTnet=ΔTpassive+ΔTresponse\Delta T_{\text{net}} = \Delta T_{\text{passive}} + \Delta T_{\text{response}}.

  • Rearrange to solve for the active response: ΔTresponse=ΔTnet−ΔTpassive\Delta T_{\text{response}} = \Delta T_{\text{net}} - \Delta T_{\text{passive}} before calculating loop gain.

Sign Check for Negative Feedback Gain
  • Negative feedback opposes perturbation, so the corrective response must have the opposite sign of the error signal, giving a positive loop gain G>0G > 0.

  • If your calculated loop gain GG turns out negative, check whether you assigned the correct opposing sign to the active physiological correction.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the active physiological correction: ΔTresponse=ΔTerror−ΔTpassive=−0.40∘C−(−2.40∘C)=+2.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = \Delta T_{\text{error}} - \Delta T_{\text{passive}} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C} - (-2.40^{\circ}\text{C}) = +2.00^{\circ}\text{C}.

  2. Substitute ΔTresponse=+2.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = +2.00^{\circ}\text{C} and ΔTerror=−0.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{error}} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C} into the gain formula: G=−+2.00∘C−0.40∘C=5.00G = -\frac{+2.00^{\circ}\text{C}}{-0.40^{\circ}\text{C}} = 5.00.

Final answer

G=5.00G = 5.00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the superposition principle in homeostatic loops where ΔObserved=ΔPerturbation+ΔCorrection\Delta \text{Observed} = \Delta \text{Perturbation} + \Delta \text{Correction}.

  • Practice isolating the effector response from given baseline, uncompensated, and regulated values.

  • Verify that negative feedback control gains are positive dimensionless values.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets the negative sign in the negative feedback loop gain formula, calculating G = -5.0 instead of +5.0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔTerror=36.60∘C−37.00∘C=−0.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{error}} = 36.60^{\circ}\text{C} - 37.00^{\circ}\text{C} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C}

  2. Step 2

    ΔTresponse=−0.40∘C−(−2.40∘C)=2.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C} - (-2.40^{\circ}\text{C}) = 2.00^{\circ}\text{C}

  3. Step 3

    G=2.00∘C−0.40∘C=−5.0G = \frac{2.00^{\circ}\text{C}}{-0.40^{\circ}\text{C}} = -5.0

    Correct

    G=−ΔTresponseΔTerror=−2.00∘C−0.40∘C=5.00G = -\frac{\Delta T_{\text{response}}}{\Delta T_{\text{error}}} = -\frac{2.00^{\circ}\text{C}}{-0.40^{\circ}\text{C}} = 5.00

    You omitted the negative sign in the formula G=−ΔTresponseΔTerrorG = -\frac{\Delta T_{\text{response}}}{\Delta T_{\text{error}}}. Because negative feedback opposes the perturbation, the loop gain GG is defined as a positive quantity.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and computed the steady-state error signal ΔTerror=−0.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{error}} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C}.

You correctly isolated and calculated the compensatory response ΔTresponse=+2.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = +2.00^{\circ}\text{C} from the net temperature change.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula sign omission

You left out the leading negative sign in the negative feedback gain formula when substituting your values.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the definition of negative feedback loop gain, where the explicit negative sign ensures that an opposing corrective response yields a positive dimensionless gain GG.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Feedback Gain Sign Convention
  • In homeostatic control systems, open-loop gain is defined as G=−ΔResponseΔErrorG = -\frac{\Delta \text{Response}}{\Delta \text{Error}}, ensuring G>0G > 0 for stable negative feedback.

  • Always verify that your calculated loop gain GG is positive for an intact negative feedback loop.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the negative feedback gain formula: G=−ΔTresponseΔTerrorG = -\frac{\Delta T_{\text{response}}}{\Delta T_{\text{error}}}.

  2. Substitute ΔTresponse=+2.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = +2.00^{\circ}\text{C} and ΔTerror=−0.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{error}} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C}: G=−+2.00∘C−0.40∘C=−(−5.00)=5.00G = -\frac{+2.00^{\circ}\text{C}}{-0.40^{\circ}\text{C}} = -(-5.00) = 5.00.

Final answer

G=5.00G = 5.00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that the definition of negative feedback gain includes the leading negative sign: G=−ResponseErrorG = -\frac{\text{Response}}{\text{Error}}.

  • Perform a physical sanity check: stable negative feedback systems always have a positive loop gain (G>0G > 0).

  • Practice checking your results with the closed-loop attenuation relation ΔTerror=ΔTpassive1+G\Delta T_{\text{error}} = \frac{\Delta T_{\text{passive}}}{1 + G}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student computes the response as the difference between the passive perturbation and the steady-state drop rather than the baseline, inverting the numerator to -2.00°C and obtaining G = -5.0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔTerror=36.60∘C−37.00∘C=−0.40∘C\Delta T_{\text{error}} = 36.60^{\circ}\text{C} - 37.00^{\circ}\text{C} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C}

  2. Step 2

    ΔTresponse=−2.40∘C−(−0.40∘C)=−2.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = -2.40^{\circ}\text{C} - (-0.40^{\circ}\text{C}) = -2.00^{\circ}\text{C}

    Correct

    ΔTresponse=ΔTerror−ΔTpassive=−0.40∘C−(−2.40∘C)=+2.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = \Delta T_{\text{error}} - \Delta T_{\text{passive}} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C} - (-2.40^{\circ}\text{C}) = +2.00^{\circ}\text{C}

    You subtracted the final error from the passive perturbation rather than subtracting the perturbation from the observed net change. Since the net change is ΔTnet=ΔTpassive+ΔTresponse\Delta T_{\text{net}} = \Delta T_{\text{passive}} + \Delta T_{\text{response}}, the physiological warming response must be positive (+2.00∘C+2.00^{\circ}\text{C}) to counteract the environmental cooling.

  3. Step 3

    G=−(−2.00∘C−0.40∘C)=−5.0G = -\left(\frac{-2.00^{\circ}\text{C}}{-0.40^{\circ}\text{C}}\right) = -5.0

    Correct

    G=−ΔTresponseΔTerror=−+2.00∘C−0.40∘C=5.00G = -\frac{\Delta T_{\text{response}}}{\Delta T_{\text{error}}} = -\frac{+2.00^{\circ}\text{C}}{-0.40^{\circ}\text{C}} = 5.00

    You substituted your negative response value correctly into the given formula, but the sign error from Step 2 carried over to produce a negative gain instead of the expected positive dimensionless gain.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the error signal ΔTerror\Delta T_{\text{error}} as the deviation from the set point.

You used the correct mathematical relationship for the negative feedback gain formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed Subtraction in Physiological Response

You set up ΔTpassive−ΔTerror\Delta T_{\text{passive}} - \Delta T_{\text{error}} instead of ΔTerror−ΔTpassive\Delta T_{\text{error}} - \Delta T_{\text{passive}}, flipping the physical direction of the warming response.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the algebraic components of the net perturbation equation ΔTnet=ΔTpassive+ΔTresponse\Delta T_{\text{net}} = \Delta T_{\text{passive}} + \Delta T_{\text{response}}. Because shivering and vasoconstriction act against cooling, the active response must oppose the disturbance with a positive temperature contribution.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Biological Directionality Check
  • In negative feedback, the effector response must actively counteract the disturbance.

  • Always verify that your computed ΔTresponse\Delta T_{\text{response}} has the opposite sign of the environmental challenge (e.g., cold exposure requires a positive ΔTresponse\Delta T_{\text{response}}).

Loop Gain Sign Convention
  • A stable negative feedback control system exhibits a positive open-loop gain G>0G > 0 when defined with a leading negative sign: G=−ResponseErrorG = -\frac{\text{Response}}{\text{Error}}.

  • Check that the final gain GG is a positive dimensionless value.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Re-evaluate the net temperature balance: ΔTnet=ΔTpassive+ΔTresponse\Delta T_{\text{net}} = \Delta T_{\text{passive}} + \Delta T_{\text{response}}.

  2. Solve for the response: ΔTresponse=−0.40∘C−(−2.40∘C)=+2.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = -0.40^{\circ}\text{C} - (-2.40^{\circ}\text{C}) = +2.00^{\circ}\text{C}.

  3. Substitute into the gain formula: G=−+2.00∘C−0.40∘C=5.00G = -\frac{+2.00^{\circ}\text{C}}{-0.40^{\circ}\text{C}} = 5.00.

Final answer

G=5.00G = 5.00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how net homeostatic changes are partitioned into passive perturbations and active physiological responses.

  • Practice checking signs by considering whether the physiological effector heats or cools the body.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A subject's baseline mean arterial blood pressure set point is 100 mmHg100\text{ mmHg}. An infusion of a vasodilator would passively drop pressure by −30 mmHg-30\text{ mmHg} in the absence of feedback. Due to baroreceptor reflex activation, the regulated steady-state blood pressure drops to 94 mmHg94\text{ mmHg}. Calculate the dimensionless open-loop gain GG of the baroreflex.

Answer

ΔPerror=94−100=−6 mmHg\Delta P_{\text{error}} = 94 - 100 = -6\text{ mmHg}. The active baroreceptor response is ΔPresponse=ΔPerror−ΔPpassive=−6−(−30)=+24 mmHg\Delta P_{\text{response}} = \Delta P_{\text{error}} - \Delta P_{\text{passive}} = -6 - (-30) = +24\text{ mmHg}. Thus, G=−ΔPresponseΔPerror=−+24−6=4.00G = -\frac{\Delta P_{\text{response}}}{\Delta P_{\text{error}}} = -\frac{+24}{-6} = 4.00.

02

In a glucose regulation study, an intravenous glucose infusion exerts an uncompensated passive perturbation of +180 mg/dL+180\text{ mg/dL}. Pancreatic insulin release compensates with a negative feedback loop gain of G=8.0G = 8.0. What is the resulting steady-state error Δ[Glu]error\Delta [\text{Glu}]_{\text{error}} relative to the fasting set point?

Answer

In a linear negative feedback loop, Δ[Glu]error=Δ[Glu]passive1+G=+180 mg/dL1+8.0=1809=+20 mg/dL\Delta [\text{Glu}]_{\text{error}} = \frac{\Delta [\text{Glu}]_{\text{passive}}}{1 + G} = \frac{+180\text{ mg/dL}}{1 + 8.0} = \frac{180}{9} = +20\text{ mg/dL}.

03

During strenuous exercise in hot weather, metabolic heat generation causes an uncompensated thermal perturbation of ΔTpassive=+4.50∘C\Delta T_{\text{passive}} = +4.50^{\circ}\text{C}. The thermoregulatory loop operates with a feedback gain of G=8.00G = 8.00. If the baseline set point is Tset=37.00∘CT_{\text{set}} = 37.00^{\circ}\text{C}, determine: (a) the active cooling response ΔTresponse\Delta T_{\text{response}}, and (b) the final regulated core temperature TsteadyT_{\text{steady}}.

Answer

(a) The regulated error is ΔTerror=ΔTpassive1+G=+4.50∘C1+8.00=+0.50∘C\Delta T_{\text{error}} = \frac{\Delta T_{\text{passive}}}{1 + G} = \frac{+4.50^{\circ}\text{C}}{1 + 8.00} = +0.50^{\circ}\text{C}. The active response is ΔTresponse=ΔTerror−ΔTpassive=+0.50∘C−(+4.50∘C)=−4.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = \Delta T_{\text{error}} - \Delta T_{\text{passive}} = +0.50^{\circ}\text{C} - (+4.50^{\circ}\text{C}) = -4.00^{\circ}\text{C} (or via GG: ΔTresponse=−G⋅ΔTerror=−8.00×0.50∘C=−4.00∘C\Delta T_{\text{response}} = -G \cdot \Delta T_{\text{error}} = -8.00 \times 0.50^{\circ}\text{C} = -4.00^{\circ}\text{C}). (b) The steady-state temperature is Tsteady=Tset+ΔTerror=37.00∘C+0.50∘C=37.50∘CT_{\text{steady}} = T_{\text{set}} + \Delta T_{\text{error}} = 37.00^{\circ}\text{C} + 0.50^{\circ}\text{C} = 37.50^{\circ}\text{C}.

Loading workspace…