Resources

In a long-term field study of Galápagos ground finches (Geospiza fortis), researchers evaluate directional selection on beak depth following an severe drought. The initial pre-drought population had a mean beak depth of zˉ0=9.40 mm\bar{z}_0 = 9.40\text{ mm}. In the offspring generation born immediately following the drought, the mean beak depth shifted to zˉ1=9.88 mm\bar{z}_1 = 9.88\text{ mm}. If the narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2) of beak depth in this population is determined to be h2=0.64h^2 = 0.64, use the breeder's equation (R=h2SR = h^2 S) to reverse-calculate the selection differential SS (in mm\text{mm}) imposed by the drought, and determine the mean beak depth zˉ∗\bar{z}^* of the surviving parents that successfully reproduced.

Answer and steps

Final answer

S=0.75 mmS = 0.75\text{ mm}, Mean beak depth of surviving parents zˉ∗=10.15 mm\bar{z}^* = 10.15\text{ mm}

Steps

01

Calculate the Evolutionary Response (RR)

The evolutionary response to selection, RR, represents the change in the mean phenotypic trait value between the initial parental generation and the offspring generation:

R=zˉ1−zˉ0R = \bar{z}_1 - \bar{z}_0

Substitute the given values:

R=9.88 mm−9.40 mm=0.48 mmR = 9.88\text{ mm} - 9.40\text{ mm} = 0.48\text{ mm}


02

Determine the Selection Differential (SS)

The breeder's equation relates the evolutionary response (RR), narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2), and the selection differential (SS):

R=h2SR = h^2 S

Rearranging to solve for the selection differential (SS):

S=Rh2S = \frac{R}{h^2}

Substitute R=0.48 mmR = 0.48\text{ mm} and h2=0.64h^2 = 0.64:

S=0.48 mm0.64=0.75 mmS = \frac{0.48\text{ mm}}{0.64} = 0.75\text{ mm}


03

Calculate the Mean Beak Depth of the Surviving Parents (zˉ∗\bar{z}^*)

The selection differential measures the difference between the average phenotype of the surviving, reproducing individuals (zˉ∗\bar{z}^*) and the original mean of the entire population (zˉ0\bar{z}_0):

S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0

Rearranging for zˉ∗\bar{z}^*:

zˉ∗=zˉ0+S\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S

Substitute the known values:

zˉ∗=9.40 mm+0.75 mm=10.15 mm\bar{z}^* = 9.40\text{ mm} + 0.75\text{ mm} = 10.15\text{ mm}


Common Pitfall to Avoid

Do not confuse the evolutionary response (R=zˉ1−zˉ0R = \bar{z}_1 - \bar{z}_0) with the selection differential (S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0). Because heritability is less than 11 (h2<1h^2 < 1), the response in the next generation is only a fraction of the selection differential (R<SR < S). Thus, the surviving parents had to have an even larger average beak depth (10.15 mm10.15\text{ mm}) to produce an offspring generation with an average of 9.88 mm9.88\text{ mm}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student takes the square root of narrow-sense heritability h² because of the superscript 2, using h = 0.8 instead of h² = 0.64.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    R=9.88−9.40=0.48 mmR = 9.88 - 9.40 = 0.48\text{ mm}

  2. Step 2

    h2=0.64, so h=0.8  ⟹  S=Rh=0.480.8=0.60 mmh^2 = 0.64\text{, so } h = 0.8 \implies S = \frac{R}{h} = \frac{0.48}{0.8} = 0.60\text{ mm}

    Correct

    S=Rh2=0.48 mm0.64=0.75 mmS = \frac{R}{h^2} = \frac{0.48\text{ mm}}{0.64} = 0.75\text{ mm}

    In quantitative genetics, narrow-sense heritability is represented by the unified symbol h2h^2. The breeder's equation is R=h2SR = h^2 S, so you divide directly by h2=0.64h^2 = 0.64 rather than taking the square root to find hh.

  3. Step 3

    zˉ∗=zˉ0+S  ⟹  zˉ∗=9.40+0.60=10.00 mm\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S \implies \bar{z}^* = 9.40 + 0.60 = 10.00\text{ mm}

    Correct

    zˉ∗=zˉ0+S=9.40 mm+0.75 mm=10.15 mm\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S = 9.40\text{ mm} + 0.75\text{ mm} = 10.15\text{ mm}

    Your formula zˉ∗=zˉ0+S\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S is completely correct, but the calculated value was affected by your previous error in SS.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the evolutionary response R=0.48 mmR = 0.48\text{ mm} from the generation means.

You correctly applied the definition of the selection differential to relate surviving parents to the initial population via zˉ∗=zˉ0+S\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Parameter Notation Misinterpretation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You interpreted the superscript in narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2) as an algebraic power operation requiring a square root (h=0.64=0.8h = \sqrt{0.64} = 0.8), rather than recognizing h2h^2 as a standard single-variable symbol representing the proportion of additive genetic variance (VA/VPV_A / V_P).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Breeder's Equation Parameterization
  • The breeder's equation is R=h2SR = h^2 S, where h2h^2 is narrow-sense heritability entered directly as a single value.

  • Whenever a problem specifies narrow-sense heritability (h2=ch^2 = c), substitute cc directly into the breeder's equation without taking its square root.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute R=0.48 mmR = 0.48\text{ mm} and h2=0.64h^2 = 0.64 directly into S=Rh2S = \frac{R}{h^2}.

  2. S=0.48 mm0.64=0.75 mmS = \frac{0.48\text{ mm}}{0.64} = 0.75\text{ mm}.

  3. Add SS to the initial mean to find the surviving parents: zˉ∗=9.40 mm+0.75 mm=10.15 mm\bar{z}^* = 9.40\text{ mm} + 0.75\text{ mm} = 10.15\text{ mm}.

Final answer

S=0.75 mmS = 0.75\text{ mm}, zˉ∗=10.15 mm\bar{z}^* = 10.15\text{ mm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review quantitative genetics notation to remember that h2h^2 denotes the ratio VA/VPV_A / V_P and functions as an indivisible symbol in the breeder's equation.

  • Practice identifying the difference between the evolutionary response (R=zˉ1−zˉ0R = \bar{z}_1 - \bar{z}_0) and the selection differential (S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student multiplies R by h² instead of dividing by h² when rearranging the breeder's equation R = h²S.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    R=9.88−9.40=0.48 mmR = 9.88 - 9.40 = 0.48\text{ mm}

  2. Step 2

    S=R⋅h2=0.48⋅0.64=0.3072 mmS = R \cdot h^2 = 0.48 \cdot 0.64 = 0.3072\text{ mm}

    Correct

    S=Rh2=0.48 mm0.64=0.75 mmS = \frac{R}{h^2} = \frac{0.48\text{ mm}}{0.64} = 0.75\text{ mm}

    From the breeder's equation R=h2SR = h^2 S, isolating SS requires dividing both sides by h2h^2, which gives S=Rh2S = \frac{R}{h^2}. Because h2<1h^2 < 1, the selection differential SS must be greater than the evolutionary response RR.

  3. Step 3

    zˉ∗=zˉ0+S  ⟹  zˉ∗=9.40+0.3072=9.7072 mm\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S \implies \bar{z}^* = 9.40 + 0.3072 = 9.7072\text{ mm}

    Correct

    zˉ∗=zˉ0+S=9.40 mm+0.75 mm=10.15 mm\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S = 9.40\text{ mm} + 0.75\text{ mm} = 10.15\text{ mm}

    Your formula zˉ∗=zˉ0+S\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S is correct, but your final numerical value was affected by substituting the incorrect selection differential from step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the evolutionary response R=0.48 mmR = 0.48\text{ mm} from the generational means.

You used the correct relationship zˉ∗=zˉ0+S\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S connecting the selection differential to the surviving parental mean.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic rearrangement error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the breeder's equation as S=R⋅h2S = R \cdot h^2 rather than dividing RR by h2h^2. Conceptually, when heritability is incomplete (h2<1h^2 < 1), only a fraction of the parental selection differential is transmitted to offspring, meaning selection on parents (SS) must be stronger than the observed response in offspring (RR).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Rearranging the Breeder's Equation
  • The breeder's equation is R=h2SR = h^2 S. To isolate the selection differential, divide by heritability: S=Rh2S = \frac{R}{h^2}.

  • Always check whether you are predicting offspring response (R=h2SR = h^2 S) or back-calculating parental selection (S=Rh2S = \frac{R}{h^2}).

Biological Magnitude Check
  • Since 0≤h2≤10 \le h^2 \le 1, the evolutionary response cannot exceed the selection differential (R≤SR \le S).

  • Verify that your calculated selection differential SS is larger than the observed response RR whenever h2<1h^2 < 1.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Rearrange R=h2SR = h^2 S to isolate SS: S=Rh2=0.48 mm0.64=0.75 mmS = \frac{R}{h^2} = \frac{0.48\text{ mm}}{0.64} = 0.75\text{ mm}.

  2. Substitute S=0.75 mmS = 0.75\text{ mm} into zˉ∗=zˉ0+S\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S: zˉ∗=9.40 mm+0.75 mm=10.15 mm\bar{z}^* = 9.40\text{ mm} + 0.75\text{ mm} = 10.15\text{ mm}.

Final answer

S=0.75 mmS = 0.75\text{ mm}, zˉ∗=10.15 mm\bar{z}^* = 10.15\text{ mm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to isolate each variable in R=h2SR = h^2 S (R=h2SR = h^2 S, h2=RSh^2 = \frac{R}{S}, and S=Rh2S = \frac{R}{h^2}).

  • Perform a biological reality check: because offspring inherit only part of parental phenotypic advantage, surviving parents must deviate further from the original mean than the offspring do.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student adds the selection differential S to the offspring mean z̄₁ instead of the initial parental generation mean z̄₀ to find z̄*.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    R=9.88−9.40=0.48 mmR = 9.88 - 9.40 = 0.48\text{ mm}

  2. Step 2

    S=Rh2=0.480.64=0.75 mmS = \frac{R}{h^2} = \frac{0.48}{0.64} = 0.75\text{ mm}

  3. Step 3

    zˉ∗=zˉ1+S  ⟹  zˉ∗=9.88+0.75=10.63 mm\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_1 + S \implies \bar{z}^* = 9.88 + 0.75 = 10.63\text{ mm}

    Correct

    zˉ∗=zˉ0+S  ⟹  zˉ∗=9.40+0.75=10.15 mm\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S \implies \bar{z}^* = 9.40 + 0.75 = 10.15\text{ mm}

    The selection differential SS measures the shift within the parental generation from the pre-selection mean zˉ0\bar{z}_0 to the surviving breeder mean zˉ∗\bar{z}^*, so S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0. Adding SS to the offspring mean zˉ1\bar{z}_1 double-counts the selection process.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the phenotypic shift across generations as the evolutionary response RR.

You correctly applied the breeder's equation to deduce the selection differential SS from RR and h2h^2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Baseline reference confusion for selection differential

You substituted the offspring generation mean zˉ1\bar{z}_1 instead of the original parental population mean zˉ0\bar{z}_0 when solving for zˉ∗\bar{z}^*.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating within-generation selection (S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0) with between-generation response (R=zˉ1−zˉ0R = \bar{z}_1 - \bar{z}_0), leading to treating SS as an offset from the offspring generation instead of the parental baseline.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Baseline for Selection Differential
  • SS is defined exclusively within the parental generation: S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0.

  • Always anchor SS to the original parental mean zˉ0\bar{z}_0, never to the offspring mean zˉ1\bar{z}_1.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall the definition of the selection differential within the parental cohort: S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0.

  2. Rearrange for the surviving parents' mean: zˉ∗=zˉ0+S\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S.

  3. Substitute zˉ0=9.40 mm\bar{z}_0 = 9.40\text{ mm} and S=0.75 mmS = 0.75\text{ mm}: zˉ∗=9.40+0.75=10.15 mm\bar{z}^* = 9.40 + 0.75 = 10.15\text{ mm}.

Final answer

S=0.75 mmS = 0.75\text{ mm}, zˉ∗=10.15 mm\bar{z}^* = 10.15\text{ mm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinct definitions of SS (within parents: zˉ∗−zˉ0\bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0) and RR (across generations: zˉ1−zˉ0\bar{z}_1 - \bar{z}_0).

  • Practice drawing a quick timeline or three-distribution sketch showing parents, survivors, and offspring before calculating.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a population of butterflies, the mean thorax length is zˉ0=12.0 mm\bar{z}_0 = 12.0\text{ mm}. Breeders select individuals with a mean thorax length of zˉ∗=15.0 mm\bar{z}^* = 15.0\text{ mm} to reproduce. If the narrow-sense heritability is h2=0.40h^2 = 0.40, calculate the selection differential SS and the predicted mean thorax length of the offspring generation zˉ1\bar{z}_1.

Answer

S=3.0 mmS = 3.0\text{ mm}, zˉ1=13.2 mm\bar{z}_1 = 13.2\text{ mm}. Key steps: S=zˉ∗−zˉ0=15.0−12.0=3.0 mmS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0 = 15.0 - 12.0 = 3.0\text{ mm}. Response R=h2S=0.40×3.0=1.2 mmR = h^2 S = 0.40 \times 3.0 = 1.2\text{ mm}. Offspring mean zˉ1=zˉ0+R=12.0+1.2=13.2 mm\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R = 12.0 + 1.2 = 13.2\text{ mm}.

02

A corn variety has an average kernel mass of zˉ0=250 mg\bar{z}_0 = 250\text{ mg}. After one generation of artificial selection, the offspring crop has an average mass of zˉ1=280 mg\bar{z}_1 = 280\text{ mg}. Given that the narrow-sense heritability for kernel mass is h2=0.25h^2 = 0.25, determine the selection differential SS and the average kernel mass zˉ∗\bar{z}^* of the selected parent plants.

Answer

S=120 mgS = 120\text{ mg}, zˉ∗=370 mg\bar{z}^* = 370\text{ mg}. Key steps: R=zˉ1−zˉ0=280−250=30 mgR = \bar{z}_1 - \bar{z}_0 = 280 - 250 = 30\text{ mg}. Using R=h2SR = h^2 S, S=Rh2=300.25=120 mgS = \frac{R}{h^2} = \frac{30}{0.25} = 120\text{ mg}. Selected parent mean zˉ∗=zˉ0+S=250+120=370 mg\bar{z}^* = \bar{z}_0 + S = 250 + 120 = 370\text{ mg}.

03

In an experiment on sheep body mass, the total phenotypic variance is VP=50 kg2V_P = 50\text{ kg}^2, and the additive genetic variance is VA=18 kg2V_A = 18\text{ kg}^2. The original flock mean was 60 kg60\text{ kg}, and the selected breeding flock had a mean of 68 kg68\text{ kg}. Find the narrow-sense heritability h2h^2, the selection differential SS, and the expected offspring flock mean zˉ1\bar{z}_1.

Answer

h2=0.36h^2 = 0.36, S=8.0 kgS = 8.0\text{ kg}, zˉ1=62.88 kg\bar{z}_1 = 62.88\text{ kg}. Key steps: h2=VAVP=1850=0.36h^2 = \frac{V_A}{V_P} = \frac{18}{50} = 0.36. Selection differential S=zˉ∗−zˉ0=68−60=8.0 kgS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0 = 68 - 60 = 8.0\text{ kg}. Response R=h2S=0.36×8.0=2.88 kgR = h^2 S = 0.36 \times 8.0 = 2.88\text{ kg}. Offspring mean zˉ1=zˉ0+R=60+2.88=62.88 kg\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R = 60 + 2.88 = 62.88\text{ kg}.

Loading workspace…