Resources
An introductory biology student hypothesizes that natural selection should always favor organisms that produce the maximum possible number of offspring per clutch to maximize individual fitness. To test this intuition, an investigator monitors nesting blue tits (Cyanistes caeruleus) over three seasons. As clutch size increases, parent birds must make more frequent feeding trips, increasing parental exhaustion and chick competition. The survival probability of an individual chick to independence follows the empirical relationship for clutches between and eggs. Consequently, the total number of surviving offspring produced per clutch is . Contrary to the intuition that maximizing clutch size maximizes reproductive success, calculate the biologically realistic integer clutch size that maximizes the number of surviving fledglings , and calculate the expected surviving fledglings compared to the largest possible clutch of .
Answer and steps
Final answer
Optimal integer clutch size (yielding ); by comparison, the maximal clutch of yields only .
Steps
Understand the Life-History Trade-Off
In evolutionary biology, fitness is measured not by the sheer number of eggs laid, but by the number of offspring that survive to reproductive age or independence (known as Lack's principle).
Here, two opposing factors govern reproductive success:
- Clutch size (): Laying more eggs increases potential offspring count.
- Offspring survival probability (): As clutch size increases, parental feeding effort is divided among more chicks, and nestling competition intensifies, lowering each chick's individual survival probability:
The total reproductive success, or number of surviving fledglings , is:
Determine the Theoretical Maximum of
The function is a downward-opening parabola ().
To find the continuous value of that maximizes , find the vertex using the derivative:
Setting the derivative equal to zero:
Evaluate Adjacent Integer Clutch Sizes
Because birds cannot lay a fractional egg, evaluate the integers nearest to :
- For eggs:
- For eggs:
Comparing the two, produces a higher expected number of surviving fledglings than . Therefore, the optimal integer clutch size is:
Compare with the Maximal Clutch Size ()
For a bird that lays the maximum clutch size of eggs:
Biological Conclusion
Producing the maximal clutch () results in severe chick mortality due to starvation and exhaustion, yielding only surviving fledglings. By contrast, a bird that limits its clutch to the optimal size of rears more than twice as many surviving fledglings (), demonstrating why natural selection favors intermediate clutch sizes over maximal egg production.
Typical errors
01 The student rounds 6.25 up to 7 or assumes clutch size should be rounded to the nearest integer above 6.25, concluding k* = 7 without comparing values of F(k).
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
Round up to nearest biologically realistic integer:
CorrectCompare integer clutch sizes adjacent to : and , so .
You rounded up to without checking . Because is a symmetric parabola centered at , the integer closest to the vertex (, distance ) yields a higher value () than (distance , ).
- Step 3
, ⟹ yields fledglings compared to fledglings at
Correctfledglings compared to fledglings
Your arithmetic for and is accurate, but your comparison evaluated the suboptimal clutch rather than the optimal clutch .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou accurately defined the total fledgling function .
You took the first derivative correctly and set it to zero to find the unconstrained continuous peak at .
You accurately calculated survival probabilities and fledglings for your chosen test values.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed that biologically realistic clutch sizes must round upward from a non-integer peak instead of evaluating the nearest integers on both sides.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisTreating a continuous optimization problem with discrete constraints by applying an arbitrary ceiling function (rounding up) rather than comparing objective values at the candidate integers or using the symmetry of the parabola.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Integer Optimization on Quadratic Curves
For a downward-opening quadratic function , the curve is symmetric about the vertex . The integer that maximizes is always the integer nearest to .
Find the distance from to the adjacent integers, or explicitly calculate for both integers floor and ceiling of the vertex.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate : .
Evaluate : .
Identify as the optimal integer clutch size because .
Optimal integer clutch size with , compared to for the maximal clutch size.
02 The student attempts to maximize individual survival probability S(k) rather than total surviving fledglings F(k), leading to the smallest boundary clutch size.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
To maximize reproductive success, maximize chick survival probability decreases linearly with , so maximum survival occurs at minimum clutch size
CorrectMaximize total surviving offspring . Taking gives , so the optimal integer clutch is .
You maximized the per-chick survival rate rather than total reproductive output . Because decreases with every additional egg, alone is highest at , but laying fewer eggs reduces the total count of potential fledglings.
- Step 2
and yields fledglings compared to at
CorrectEvaluate fledglings and compare with fledglings.
Your arithmetic evaluation of was completely correct for and , but because the optimal clutch size was identified incorrectly in the previous step, your final comparison missed the true peak fitness at ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly substituted clutch values into the fitness function .
You accurately computed the fledgling success for the maximum clutch size of as fledglings.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated per-offspring quality (survival probability ) with parental fitness (total surviving offspring ), leading you to minimize clutch size rather than finding the trade-off optimum.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define Parental Fitness in Life-History Evolution
Natural selection maximizes total surviving descendants (), not the survival percentage of an individual offspring alone.
Always optimize the product of quantity and quality: .
- Optimize Quadratic Life-History Trade-Offs
When with , the optimum occurs at the vertex , followed by testing adjacent integers.
Differentiate with respect to , set the derivative to zero to find the critical value, and test integer values on either side.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the total reproductive success function: .
Differentiate with respect to : .
Evaluate the neighboring integers: and .
Identify the optimal integer clutch size as , which gives surviving fledglings.
Optimal integer clutch size eggs (yielding surviving fledglings); by comparison, the maximal clutch of eggs yields only surviving fledglings.
03 The student forgets to differentiate the quadratic term properly by omitting the factor of 2, solving 1.00 - 0.080k = 0 to get k = 12.5, which falls outside the domain.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
When differentiating with respect to , you forgot to multiply by the exponent . Applying the power rule yields , which sets the critical point at rather than .
- Step 3Correct
Because of the erroneous critical point of , you concluded the function was monotonically increasing across the entire domain and picked the boundary .
- Step 4Correct
Your arithmetic for is accurate, but because was misidentified as , you missed the comparison showing that the intermediate clutch of yields more than double the surviving fledglings ( vs. ).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly formulated the total fledgling success function by multiplying clutch size by survival probability.
You recognized that finding the maximum involves setting the derivative equal to zero.
You correctly evaluated the boundary value using the given survival formula.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou wrote instead of , dropping the factor of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou rushed through the power rule on a decimal coefficient, treating the quadratic term as linear during differentiation. Consequently, the vertex of the downward-opening parabola appeared outside the domain, masking the central biological prediction of Lack's principle that intermediate clutch sizes maximize reproductive success.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Power Rule for Quadratic Terms
Always bring the exponent down as a multiplier before simplifying decimal coefficients.
- Vertex Formula Verification
For , the vertex is located at .
Double-check your derivative critical point against the standard parabola vertex formula to catch missing factors of .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSolve for the continuous critical point: .
Test adjacent integer clutch sizes: and .
Identify the maximum integer clutch: , so .
Calculate the maximal clutch success: .
Optimal integer clutch size with ; by comparison, the maximal clutch yields only .
Lock it in
When continuous calculus gives a non-integer optimum for a discrete biological quantity (such as clutch size), how do you find the true optimum?
Evaluate both adjacent integers ( and ) in the fitness function, or pick the integer closest to the peak if the curve is symmetric.
Similar question
A songbird species has per-offspring survival given by for clutch sizes between and . Determine the optimal integer clutch size that maximizes total surviving offspring .
Answer
. The continuous peak is at . Since is already an integer, .
A rodent species produces litters where per-pup survival is . Find the unconstrained continuous peak litter size, test the two surrounding integers, and state the integer litter size that maximizes surviving offspring .
Answer
Continuous peak: . Evaluating integers: and . Thus, .
In a parasitoid wasp, female fitness depends on host clutch size as . A researcher predicts by rounding up to allow extra eggs as a buffer. Evaluate whether or gives higher fitness, and compute the fitness cost of laying eggs instead of the optimum.
Answer
Continuous peak: . Evaluating fitness: and . The true optimum is , and laying eggs incurs a fitness loss of offspring.