Resources
A behavioral biologist studies alarm calling in Belding's ground squirrels (Urocitellus beldringi). A sentinel squirrel incurs a personal fitness cost of when producing a predator alarm trill. The warning call provides a reproductive survival benefit of to a group of surrounding kin that share an identical average coefficient of relatedness to the caller. Applying Hamilton's rule (), calculate the minimum threshold value of the coefficient of relatedness () required for this cooperative behavior to evolve via kin selection, and identify the closest genealogical relationship corresponding to this threshold.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(or ); since for first cousins is insufficient (), kin must be related at or above the half-sibling or aunt/uncle/nephew level ().
Steps
Understanding Hamilton's Rule
Kin selection explains how altruistic or cooperative behaviors can evolve even when an individual incurs a personal fitness cost. According to Hamilton's rule, an altruistic allele will increase in frequency if:
where:
- is the coefficient of relatedness between the altruist (the alarm caller) and the recipient(s),
- is the sum of reproductive benefits gained by the recipients,
- is the reproductive fitness cost incurred by the altruist.
Calculating the Minimum Coefficient of Relatedness ()
For the alarm-calling behavior to be favored by natural selection, the product of relatedness and benefit must strictly exceed the cost:
Substitute the given parameters: and :
Divide both sides by :
Thus, the minimum theoretical threshold required is:
Comparing with Standard Genealogical Relationships
In diploid organisms, common genealogical relationships have standard coefficients of relatedness ():
- Full siblings or Parent-offspring:
- Half-siblings, Aunt/Uncle-Niece/Nephew, or Grandparent-Grandchild:
- First cousins:
Evaluating these against the threshold :
- For first cousins, , which is less than (). Therefore, first cousins do not provide a high enough degree of relatedness for kin selection to favor the alarm call under these specific fitness values.
- For half-siblings or an aunt/uncle-niece/nephew relationship, , which satisfies the condition ().
Consequently, the closest biological relationship that meets or exceeds this threshold is at the level of half-siblings or aunt/uncle/niece/nephew ().
Typical errors
01 The student inverts the cost-benefit ratio in Hamilton's rule, calculating b / c instead of c / b.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
To isolate in the inequality , you must divide both sides by the benefit , yielding . You divided by instead, which inverted the ratio to .
- Step 2
A coefficient of relatedness cannot exceed 1, so no biological genealogical relationship exists.
Correct; since first cousins have , the closest qualifying genealogical relationship is half-siblings or aunt/uncle/niece/nephew ().
Your biological reasoning that is completely sound, but your conclusion was affected by the incorrect value from Step 1. Using the correct threshold , relationships with satisfy the condition.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly wrote down the formula for Hamilton's rule, .
You correctly noted that a biological coefficient of relatedness cannot exceed .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou divided by cost instead of benefit when rearranging .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou inverted the numerator and denominator during algebraic isolation, calculating instead of to find the threshold coefficient of relatedness.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Isolating Variables in Product Inequalities
For positive terms, .
Divide both sides by the factor attached to the target variable, keeping the target variable alone on one side.
- Biological Plausibility Check
The coefficient of relatedness between outbred diploid relatives ranges from to ().
If a calculated threshold exceeds , check whether you inverted the cost and benefit terms.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up Hamilton's rule: with and .
Divide both sides by : .
Compare with standard diploid coefficients: first cousins () fall below the threshold, whereas half-siblings and aunt/uncle/niece/nephew () satisfy .
; the closest biological relationship meeting this threshold is half-siblings or aunt/uncle/niece/nephew ().
02 The student rounds 1/6 ≈ 0.167 down to the nearest lower standard coefficient (first cousins, r = 0.125) which fails the minimum threshold requirement r b > c.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
Comparing to standard relationships: for first cousins is the closest number to .
CorrectCompare standard relationships while enforcing : for first cousins, (fails); for half-siblings or aunt/nephew, (satisfies threshold).
A threshold condition requires to meet or exceed . Because , first cousins do not provide sufficient relatedness to favor alarm calling.
- Step 3
Closest genealogical relationship: first cousins.
CorrectClosest genealogical relationship satisfying the threshold: half-siblings or aunt/uncle/niece/nephew ().
This conclusion follows from selecting a relationship below the required evolutionary threshold.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recalled and algebraically rearranged Hamilton's rule.
You accurately calculated the minimum threshold value as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated 'closest genealogical relationship' as the nearest absolute numerical distance to rather than the nearest discrete relationship category that satisfies the strict evolutionary threshold .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Minimum Threshold Meaning
A minimum threshold requires (or ); values below the threshold do not allow the altruistic trait to evolve.
Always verify that your chosen biological category satisfies by plugging the coefficient back into the inequality.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCheck whether first cousins () satisfy Hamilton's rule: , so alarm calling is selected against.
Test the next standard biological relationship level: half-siblings or aunt/uncle/niece/nephew ().
Verify: , which satisfies Hamilton's rule.
; the closest genealogical relationship satisfying the threshold is half-siblings or aunt/uncle/niece/nephew ().
03 The student incorrectly subtracts cost from benefit rather than taking the ratio when rearranging Hamilton's rule.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Hamilton's rule is a multiplicative relationship (), not an additive one. To isolate the coefficient of relatedness , you must divide both sides by the benefit , yielding .
- Step 2
Comparing to standard coefficients: (half-siblings) is the closest genealogical relationship.
CorrectCompare to standard genealogical values: first cousins () fall below the threshold, so half-siblings or aunt/uncle-niece/nephew () is the closest relationship satisfying .
Your genealogical conclusion was affected by the initial calculation error. In addition, note that if your threshold had truly been , a coefficient of would not have satisfied the inequality.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recalled that half-siblings share an average coefficient of relatedness of .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the product in Hamilton's rule () as a sum ( or ), subtracting rather than dividing to isolate .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Hamilton's Rule Formulation
Hamilton's rule states that altruism is favored when , where scales the reproductive benefit relative to cost .
Always solve for by dividing by : .
- Evaluating Inequality Thresholds
The chosen genealogical coefficient must be strictly greater than or equal to the minimum threshold ().
Check that the selected coefficient exceeds your calculated threshold rather than picking a value below it.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRearrange Hamilton's rule by dividing both sides by benefit : .
Substitute the given values and : .
Compare standard relatedness coefficients to : first cousins have (), while half-siblings have ().
; the closest biological relationship meeting this threshold is half-siblings (or aunt/uncle/nephew/niece) with .
Lock it in
How do you algebraically isolate from Hamilton's rule, ?
Divide both sides by : . The minimum threshold is always cost divided by benefit ().
Similar question
A bird gives an alarm call warning flockmates of an approaching hawk. The call carries a personal survival cost of and confers a total survival benefit of to the nearby flock. Calculate the minimum coefficient of relatedness () needed for this behavior to be favored by kin selection.
Answer
Apply Hamilton's rule: . Thus, .
In a mammal species, a cooperative territory defender pays a fitness cost of . The defense yields a total reproductive benefit of distributed among recipients. Will kin selection favor this cooperative behavior if the recipients are full siblings ()? What if they are half-siblings ()?
Answer
Threshold: . For full siblings, , so the behavior is favored. For half-siblings, , so kin selection will not favor the behavior.
A sterile worker bee forfeits direct reproduction () to raise female brood produced by the queen. In a haplodiploid system, full sisters share . What is the minimum benefit (number of additional full sisters reared) required for this altruistic worker behavior to evolve via Hamilton's rule?
Answer
Hamilton's rule: . Substituting and : . The queen must produce more than additional reproductive sisters for the behavior to evolve.