Resources

In an undergraduate genetics laboratory, students testcross female Drosophila melanogaster heterozygous for cinnabar eyes (cncn) and vestigial wings (vgvg) with homozygous cinnabar vestigial males (cn vg/cn vgcn\ vg / cn\ vg). The observed progeny counts are: 442442 wild-type (cn+ vg+cn^+\ vg^+), 458458 cinnabar vestigial (cn vgcn\ vg), 4848 cinnabar (cn vg+cn\ vg^+), and 5252 vestigial (cn+ vgcn^+\ vg). (a) Calculate the calculated chi-square test statistic (χ2\chi^2) under the null hypothesis (H0H_0) that cncn and vgvg assort independently. (b) Using a critical value of χ0.052=7.815\chi_{0.05}^2 = 7.815 for df=3\text{df} = 3, state the statistical conclusion regarding H0H_0 and calculate the observed recombination frequency.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Under H0H_0 of independent assortment, expected counts are 250250 per class: χ2=(442−250)2250+(458−250)2250+(48−250)2250+(52−250)2250=147.456+173.056+163.216+156.816=640.544≈641\chi^2 = \frac{(442-250)^2}{250} + \frac{(458-250)^2}{250} + \frac{(48-250)^2}{250} + \frac{(52-250)^2}{250} = 147.456 + 173.056 + 163.216 + 156.816 = 640.544 \approx 641; (b) Because χ2=641>7.815\chi^2 = 641 > 7.815, reject H0H_0; the loci are linked, with recombination frequency r=48+521000×100%=10.0%r = \frac{48 + 52}{1000} \times 100\% = 10.0\% (10.0 cM10.0\text{ cM}).

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Chi-Square Statistic (χ2\chi^2)

  1. Determine the total sample size (NN): Add all observed offspring counts: N=442+458+48+52=1000N = 442 + 458 + 48 + 52 = 1000
  2. State the null hypothesis (H0H_0) and expected counts (EE): Under Mendel's law of independent assortment, a dihybrid testcross produces four phenotypic classes in an equal 1:1:1:11:1:1:1 ratio. Therefore, the expected number of progeny for each phenotypic category is: E=N4=10004=250E = \frac{N}{4} = \frac{1000}{4} = 250
  3. Compute the chi-square test statistic (χ2\chi^2): Using the formula χ2=∑(O−E)2E\chi^2 = \sum \frac{(O - E)^2}{E}, where OO is the observed count and EE is the expected count:

    • Wild-type (cn+ vg+cn^+\ vg^+): (442−250)2250=(192)2250=36864250=147.456\frac{(442 - 250)^2}{250} = \frac{(192)^2}{250} = \frac{36864}{250} = 147.456
    • Cinnabar vestigial (cn vgcn\ vg): (458−250)2250=(208)2250=43264250=173.056\frac{(458 - 250)^2}{250} = \frac{(208)^2}{250} = \frac{43264}{250} = 173.056
    • Cinnabar (cn vg+cn\ vg^+): (48−250)2250=(−202)2250=40804250=163.216\frac{(48 - 250)^2}{250} = \frac{(-202)^2}{250} = \frac{40804}{250} = 163.216
    • Vestigial (cn+ vgcn^+\ vg): (52−250)2250=(−198)2250=39204250=156.816\frac{(52 - 250)^2}{250} = \frac{(-198)^2}{250} = \frac{39204}{250} = 156.816

    Summing all four terms: χ2=147.456+173.056+163.216+156.816=640.544≈641\chi^2 = 147.456 + 173.056 + 163.216 + 156.816 = 640.544 \approx 641


Part (b): Statistical Conclusion and Recombination Frequency

  1. Compare χ2\chi^2 to the critical value:

    • Degrees of freedom: df=4−1=3\text{df} = 4 - 1 = 3.
    • Critical value at α=0.05\alpha = 0.05: χ0.052=7.815\chi_{0.05}^2 = 7.815.

    Since the calculated statistic χ2=640.544≫7.815\chi^2 = 640.544 \gg 7.815, the result is statistically significant (p<0.001p < 0.001). Therefore, we reject the null hypothesis (H0H_0) of independent assortment. The genes cncn and vgvg are genetically linked on the same chromosome.

  2. Identify parental vs. recombinant classes:

    • Parental types (most frequent): Wild-type (442442) and cinnabar vestigial (458458).
    • Recombinant types (least frequent, generated by crossing over): Cinnabar (4848) and vestigial (5252).
  3. Calculate recombination frequency (rr): r=Number of recombinant offspringTotal offspring×100%r = \frac{\text{Number of recombinant offspring}}{\text{Total offspring}} \times 100\% r=48+521000×100%=1001000×100%=10.0%r = \frac{48 + 52}{1000} \times 100\% = \frac{100}{1000} \times 100\% = 10.0\%

    A recombination frequency of 10.0%10.0\% corresponds to a genetic map distance of 10.0 cM10.0\text{ cM} (centiMorgans).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies the parental classes as the recombinants when calculating the recombination frequency, resulting in a value of 90%.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Total progeny=442+458+48+52=1000  ⟹  Expected for each class=1000/4=250\text{Total progeny} = 442 + 458 + 48 + 52 = 1000 \implies \text{Expected for each class} = 1000 / 4 = 250

  2. Step 2

    χ2=(442−250)2250+(458−250)2250+(48−250)2250+(52−250)2250=36864250+43264250+40804250+39204250=640.544\chi^2 = \frac{(442-250)^2}{250} + \frac{(458-250)^2}{250} + \frac{(48-250)^2}{250} + \frac{(52-250)^2}{250} = \frac{36864}{250} + \frac{43264}{250} + \frac{40804}{250} + \frac{39204}{250} = 640.544

  3. Step 3

    640.544>7.815, so reject H0; the genes are linked.640.544 > 7.815\text{, so reject } H_0\text{; the genes are linked.}

  4. Step 4

    Recombinant progeny=442+458=900  ⟹  Recombination frequency=900/1000=0.90\text{Recombinant progeny} = 442 + 458 = 900 \implies \text{Recombination frequency} = 900 / 1000 = 0.90

    Correct

    Recombinant progeny=48+52=100  ⟹  r=1001000×100%=10.0%\text{Recombinant progeny} = 48 + 52 = 100 \implies r = \frac{100}{1000} \times 100\% = 10.0\%

    You summed the two most frequent classes (442442 and 458458), which represent the parental non-crossover phenotypes. Recombinant phenotypes result from crossing over and correspond to the two least frequent classes (4848 and 5252).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated the total sample size and expected counts under the null hypothesis with complete accuracy.

You correctly computed each chi-square component and found the overall test statistic.

You drew the correct statistical conclusion to reject independent assortment and infer genetic linkage.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Parental vs. Recombinant Inversion

You selected the two majority classes (442442 and 458458) rather than the minority classes (4848 and 5252) when counting recombinants.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating parental (non-crossover) phenotypes with recombinant (crossover) phenotypes in a linked dihybrid testcross. In linked inheritance, parental gametes are always transmitted at frequencies well above 50%50\%, while crossover recombinants represent the minority classes (always <50%< 50\%).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identifying Recombinants vs. Parentals
  • In a dihybrid testcross involving linked genes, parental progeny are the two most abundant classes, whereas recombinant progeny are the two least abundant classes resulting from crossing over.

  • Check that your recombinant fraction is always less than or equal to 50%50\%. If you obtain a value greater than 0.500.50, you have calculated the parental frequency instead of the recombination frequency.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the recombinant offspring as the two least abundant phenotypic classes: cinnabar (4848) and vestigial (5252).

  2. Sum the recombinant progeny: 48+52=10048 + 52 = 100.

  3. Divide by the total progeny count: r=1001000=0.10r = \frac{100}{1000} = 0.10 or 10.0%10.0\% (10.0 cM10.0\text{ cM}).

Final answer

Reject H0H_0 (genes are linked); recombination frequency r=10.0%r = 10.0\% (10.0 cM10.0\text{ cM}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always verify that your calculated recombination frequency satisfies r≤50%r \le 50\%.

  • Practice writing out the original parental chromosome configurations to immediately flag which alleles traveled together without crossing over.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to divide the squared deviations by the expected count in the chi-square formula, computing the sum of squared deviations instead.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Total progeny=1000  ⟹  Expected=250 per class\text{Total progeny} = 1000 \implies \text{Expected} = 250\text{ per class}

  2. Step 2

    χ2=(442−250)2+(458−250)2+(48−250)2+(52−250)2  ⟹  χ2=36864+43264+40804+39204=160136\chi^2 = (442 - 250)^2 + (458 - 250)^2 + (48 - 250)^2 + (52 - 250)^2 \implies \chi^2 = 36864 + 43264 + 40804 + 39204 = 160136

    Correct

    χ2=∑(O−E)2E=36864+43264+40804+39204250=160136250=640.544≈641\chi^2 = \sum \frac{(O - E)^2}{E} = \frac{36864 + 43264 + 40804 + 39204}{250} = \frac{160136}{250} = 640.544 \approx 641

    You computed the squared deviations (O−E)2(O - E)^2 accurately, but you forgot to divide each squared deviation by its corresponding expected count E=250E = 250.

  3. Step 3

    160136>7.815, so reject H0; cn and vg are linked.160136 > 7.815\text{, so reject } H_0\text{; } cn \text{ and } vg \text{ are linked.}

    Correct

    640.544>7.815, so reject H0; cn and vg are linked.640.544 > 7.815\text{, so reject } H_0\text{; } cn \text{ and } vg \text{ are linked.}

    Your qualitative conclusion to reject the null hypothesis and conclude linkage is biologically correct, but your comparison relied on the unstandardized test value 160136160136 instead of χ2≈641\chi^2 \approx 641.

  4. Step 4

    Recombinants=48+52=100  ⟹  Recombination frequency=1001000=0.10\text{Recombinants} = 48 + 52 = 100 \implies \text{Recombination frequency} = \frac{100}{1000} = 0.10

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total number of offspring and the expected progeny per class under independent assortment.

You accurately calculated each of the squared deviations (O−E)2(O - E)^2.

You correctly identified the recombinant classes and computed the recombination frequency.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula omission: missing expected count denominator in chi-square statistic

You summed the squared deviations (O−E)2(O - E)^2 without dividing each term by EE.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the chi-square statistic as a sum of squared errors ∑(O−E)2\sum (O - E)^2 rather than standardizing each deviation relative to its expected frequency ∑(O−E)2E\sum \frac{(O - E)^2}{E}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Standardizing Deviations
  • Every term in Pearson's chi-square formula must be divided by its expected value: χ2=∑(O−E)2E\chi^2 = \sum \frac{(O - E)^2}{E}.

  • Check that each category's squared deviation is scaled by EE before summing, or factor out 1E\frac{1}{E} when all expected values are equal.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Divide the total sum of squared deviations by the expected count per category: χ2=160136250=640.544\chi^2 = \frac{160136}{250} = 640.544.

  2. Compare the standardized value to the critical value: 640.544>7.815640.544 > 7.815, which confirms rejection of H0H_0.

Final answer

(a) χ2=640.544≈641\chi^2 = 640.544 \approx 641; (b) Reject H0H_0; cncn and vgvg are linked, with recombination frequency r=10.0%r = 10.0\% (10.0 cM10.0\text{ cM}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the full formula χ2=∑(O−E)2E\chi^2 = \sum \frac{(O - E)^2}{E} at the start of your work as a visual reminder.

  • When all expected counts are equal, remember that you can divide the sum of squared deviations by EE in one final step.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student divides the number of recombinant offspring by the number of parental offspring rather than by total offspring when calculating recombination frequency.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Total=442+458+48+52=1000  ⟹  Expected count=10004=250\text{Total} = 442 + 458 + 48 + 52 = 1000 \implies \text{Expected count} = \frac{1000}{4} = 250

  2. Step 2

    χ2=(192)2250+(208)2250+(−202)2250+(−198)2250=36864+43264+40804+39204250=640.544\chi^2 = \frac{(192)^2}{250} + \frac{(208)^2}{250} + \frac{(-202)^2}{250} + \frac{(-198)^2}{250} = \frac{36864 + 43264 + 40804 + 39204}{250} = 640.544

  3. Step 3

    Because 640.544>7.815, reject H0; genes are linked.\text{Because } 640.544 > 7.815\text{, reject } H_0\text{; genes are linked.}

  4. Step 4

    Recombinants=48+52=100  ⟹  Parentals=442+458=900  ⟹  Recombination frequency=100900=0.111\text{Recombinants} = 48 + 52 = 100 \implies \text{Parentals} = 442 + 458 = 900 \implies \text{Recombination frequency} = \frac{100}{900} = 0.111

    Correct

    r=Recombinant progenyTotal progeny=48+521000=1001000=0.100 (or 10.0%)r = \frac{\text{Recombinant progeny}}{\text{Total progeny}} = \frac{48 + 52}{1000} = \frac{100}{1000} = 0.100 \text{ (or } 10.0\%\text{)}

    You correctly identified the recombinant and parental counts, but you divided recombinant progeny by parental progeny instead of total progeny. Recombination frequency represents the proportion of all gametes/offspring that underwent crossing over.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total number of offspring as 10001000.

You set up and evaluated the chi-square statistic accurately across all four phenotypic classes.

You made the correct statistical decision to reject H0H_0 based on the given critical value.

You accurately identified the two recombinant classes (cn vg+cn\ vg^+ and cn+ vgcn^+\ vg).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ratio denominator confusion

Dividing recombinant offspring by parental offspring (100/900100 / 900) rather than by total offspring (100/1000100 / 1000).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing an odds-like ratio (recombinant-to-parental) with a frequency or proportion (recombinant-to-total). A frequency must always be evaluated relative to the entire population of testcross offspring.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define Recombination Frequency
  • r=Number of recombinantsTotal number of progenyr = \frac{\text{Number of recombinants}}{\text{Total number of progeny}}

  • Always verify that the denominator is the sum of all observed progeny (parentals plus recombinants), never parentals alone.

Unit and Range Sanity Check
  • 0≤r≤0.500 \le r \le 0.50 (0% to 50%0\% \text{ to } 50\%)

  • Express the frequency as a fraction or percentage out of 100%100\% of the offspring to ensure you are reporting a true proportion.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Sum the recombinant offspring: 48+52=10048 + 52 = 100.

  2. Identify the total number of offspring: N=442+458+48+52=1000N = 442 + 458 + 48 + 52 = 1000.

  3. Divide recombinant offspring by total offspring: r=1001000=0.100r = \frac{100}{1000} = 0.100.

  4. Convert to percentage/map units: r=10.0%r = 10.0\% (10.0 cM10.0\text{ cM}).

Final answer

10.0% (or 0.100, 10.0 cM)10.0\%\text{ (or } 0.100\text{, } 10.0\text{ cM)}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of recombination frequency (rr) as a part-to-whole ratio (extrecombinants/exttotal ext{recombinants} / ext{total}).

  • Practice converting recombination frequencies directly into map units (centiMorgans, cM\text{cM}).

  • Work through the follow-up exercises below to build automaticity with testcross data.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A testcross of a dihybrid female tomato plant heterozygous for tall/dwarf (D/dD/d) and smooth/peach fruit (P/pP/p) produces the following progeny: 285285 tall smooth, 275275 dwarf peach, 2222 tall peach, and 1818 dwarf smooth. Calculate the recombination frequency between DD and PP.

Answer

Recombinants are the minority classes: 22+18=4022 + 18 = 40. Total progeny =285+275+22+18=600= 285 + 275 + 22 + 18 = 600. Recombination frequency r=40600×100%≈6.67%r = \frac{40}{600} \times 100\% \approx 6.67\% (6.7 cM6.7\text{ cM}).

02

In maize, colored aleurone (CC) is dominant to colorless (cc), and full endosperm (ShSh) is dominant to shrunken (shsh). A testcross of a C Sh/c shC\ Sh / c\ sh plant produces 40004000 total kernels, of which 148148 are colored shrunken and 152152 are colorless full. What are the expected counts for the other two classes, and what is the map distance between CC and shsh?

Answer

Total recombinants =148+152=300= 148 + 152 = 300. Total parentals =4000−300=3700= 4000 - 300 = 3700, divided equally into 18501850 colored full (C ShC\ Sh) and 18501850 colorless shrunken (c shc\ sh). Map distance =3004000×100%=7.5 cM= \frac{300}{4000} \times 100\% = 7.5\text{ cM}.

03

A genetics student testcrosses a female Drosophila heterozygous for black body (bb) and purple eyes (prpr). The cross yields 420420 wild-type, 430430 black purple, 7878 black, and 7272 purple. The student claims the recombination frequency is 85%85\%. Identify the error, compute the correct value, and explain whether crossing over occurred between non-sister chromatids or homologous chromosomes as a whole.

Answer

The student summed parental classes ((420+430)/1000=85%(420+430)/1000 = 85\%) instead of recombinants. Recombinants are 78+72=15078 + 72 = 150, giving r=1501000×100%=15.0%r = \frac{150}{1000} \times 100\% = 15.0\%. Crossing over occurs physically between non-sister chromatids of homologous chromosomes during prophase I of meiosis.

Loading workspace…