Resources
An undergraduate genetics student standardizes a laboratory testcross to map two autosomal loci in Drosophila melanogaster: black body (, recessive to wild-type gray body ) and cinnabar eyes (, recessive to wild-type red eyes ). A dihybrid wild-type female () is testcrossed to a homozygous double-mutant male (). The progeny counts from an automated vial counter are recorded as follows:
- Wild-type gray body, red eyes ():
- Black body, cinnabar eyes ():
- Black body, red eyes ():
- Gray body, cinnabar eyes ():
(a) Identify which classes represent recombinant genotypes versus parental genotypes. (b) Calculate the map distance between the and loci in centimorgans (cM). (c) State why the observed phenotypic count differs from the classic Mendelian independent assortment ratio of .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Parental genotypes: () and (); Recombinant genotypes: () and (). (b) Total offspring . Recombination frequency , corresponding to a map distance of (or map units). (c) The observed ratio deviates from because the two loci are syntenic (located on the same chromosome) and physically linked, preventing independent assortment during meiosis.
Steps
Part (a): Identifying Parental and Recombinant Genotypes
In a testcross involving linked genes, the alleles inherited together from each parental chromosome remain together unless crossing over occurs during meiosis:
- Parental (non-crossover) classes are the original combinations inherited from the P generation and occur in the highest frequencies.
- Recombinant (crossover) classes result from homologous recombination during prophase I of meiosis and occur in lower frequencies.
Comparing the counts of each progeny class:
- ( individuals) and ( individuals) make up the vast majority of the progeny. Therefore, these two represent the parental genotypes.
- ( individuals) and ( individuals) are the least frequent classes. Therefore, these two represent the recombinant genotypes.
Part (b): Calculating the Map Distance
- Calculate the total number of progeny ():
- Sum the recombinant progeny:
- Calculate the recombination frequency ():
- Convert recombination frequency to map distance: By definition, recombination frequency equals or .
Part (c): Deviation from the Ratio
- Mendel's Law of Independent Assortment predicts a ratio in a dihybrid testcross only when the two gene loci reside on different chromosomes or are very far apart on the same chromosome.
- The significant excess of parental phenotypes () over recombinant phenotypes () occurs because the and loci are syntenic (located on the same chromosome) and genetically linked. Because they are physically linked, alleles on the same chromosome tend to segregate together into gametes unless separated by a crossover event.
Typical errors
01 The student calculates recombination frequency using only one of the two recombinant progeny classes instead of summing both.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
When determining recombination frequency, you must include all reciprocal crossover offspring. You only counted individuals from one recombinant class and omitted the individuals from the other recombinant class.
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified both parental classes and both recombinant classes based on offspring frequencies.
You accurately calculated the total number of progeny as .
You clearly stated that genetic linkage on the same chromosome prevents independent assortment.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou forgot that crossing over produces reciprocal recombinant gametes, meaning both recombinant phenotypic classes must be added together in the numerator when calculating recombination frequency.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Sum All Recombinants
Always add both reciprocal crossover classes together before dividing by the total progeny count.
- Verify Reciprocal Symmetry
In a two-point testcross without differential viability, the two recombinant classes appear in approximately equal numbers.
Check that you have identified two recombinant counts of similar magnitude and included both in your numerator.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSum both recombinant classes: .
Calculate recombination frequency: .
Convert recombination frequency directly to map units: .
(a) Parental genotypes: () and (); Recombinant genotypes: () and (). (b) Map distance . (c) The loci are linked on the same chromosome and do not assort independently.
02 The student divides the number of recombinant progeny by the number of parental progeny rather than the total progeny.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Parental classes: and Recombinant classes: and
- Step 2
= 100 \Longrightarrow = 448 + 452 = 900 \Longrightarrow = 100% = 11.1
CorrectN = 448 + 452 + 49 + 51 = 1{,}000 \Longrightarrow = 100% = 10.0% \Longrightarrow = 10.0
You divided the recombinant count by the parental count () rather than the total progeny (). Recombination frequency measures the fraction of recombinant gametes out of all gametes produced.
- Step 3
The genes are linked on the same chromosome, so parental gametes are produced more frequently than recombinant gametes.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified the progeny into parental and recombinant categories based on their frequencies.
You accurately summed the recombinant progeny to obtain .
You clearly explained that physical linkage on the same chromosome accounts for the deviation from Mendel's testcross ratio.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou summed the parental progeny () and used that subtotal in the denominator of your recombination frequency fraction instead of the sum of all offspring.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the parental subtotal with the total population size when calculating recombination frequency. Recombination frequency represents the proportion of recombinant gametes relative to all gametes produced, so the denominator must always be the total number of progeny (parental plus recombinant).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Denominator in Recombination Frequency
Always sum all phenotypic classes (parentals + recombinants) to establish the total sample size before computing the fraction.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFind the total number of progeny: .
Compute the recombination frequency: .
Convert the percentage directly to map units: .
(a) Parental: and ; Recombinant: and . (b) . (c) The loci are linked on the same chromosome, so parental alleles stay together more often than they recombine.
03 The student misinterprets recombinant versus parental classes by confusing the largest counts for recombinants.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Parental: and Recombinant: and
CorrectParental: and ; Recombinant: and
Parental gametes reflect non-crossover chromatids and therefore always appear in the highest frequencies among testcross progeny, whereas recombinant classes result from crossing over and appear in the lowest frequencies.
- Step 2
Total progeny Total recombinants Map distance
CorrectTotal recombinants
Because you swapped the recombinant and parental classes in part (a), you summed the parental counts () instead of the recombinant counts (). Notice that genetic map distance from a two-point testcross cannot exceed .
- Step 3
The loci are linked on the same chromosome and do not assort independently.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the two loci are linked on the same chromosome and do not assort independently.
You summed the individual phenotypic counts accurately to obtain the total progeny of .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou associated the recombinant designation with the most abundant progeny classes rather than recognizing that crossover events are less frequent than non-crossover events during meiosis.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Abundance Rule for Linked Genes
In any testcross involving linked genes, parental (non-crossover) combinations are always the two largest phenotypic classes, while recombinant (crossover) combinations are the least frequent classes.
Sort the progeny counts from largest to smallest: designate the two largest classes as parental and the smaller classes as recombinant.
- Two-Point Map Distance Upper Limit
A two-point testcross recombination frequency cannot exceed , which corresponds to a maximum measurable distance of .
If your calculated map distance is greater than , check immediately whether you summed the parental classes instead of the recombinants.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the recombinant classes as the less frequent progeny: and .
Sum the recombinant offspring: .
Calculate recombination frequency: .
Convert recombination frequency directly to map distance: .
(a) Parental: and ; Recombinant: and . (b) . (c) The loci are linked on the same chromosome and do not assort independently.
Lock it in
In a two-point testcross involving linked genes, how many recombinant phenotypic classes are expected, and how are they used to calculate map distance?
Two reciprocal recombinant classes are expected. You must sum the counts of both recombinant classes and divide by the total number of progeny.
Similar question
A dihybrid female Drosophila () is testcrossed to a homozygous double-recessive male (). The offspring counts are: , , , and . Calculate the map distance between gene and gene .
Answer
. Total progeny . Sum of recombinants . .
In tomato plants, tall height () is dominant to dwarf (), and smooth skin () is dominant to peach skin (). A testcross of a dihybrid plant yields: tall smooth, dwarf peach, tall peach, and dwarf smooth. (a) Identify the recombinant phenotypes. (b) What percentage of gametes produced by the dihybrid parent underwent recombination between these two loci?
Answer
(a) Recombinant phenotypes are tall peach () and dwarf smooth (). (b) . Total progeny . Total recombinants . Percentage of recombinant gametes .
Two autosomal linked loci in corn, and , are separated by a map distance of . A plant heterozygous in coupling () is testcrossed to an individual. In a field trial producing total seeds, what is the expected count of the progeny class alone?
Answer
seeds. An distance corresponds to an total recombination frequency. Because recombination yields two reciprocal classes ( and ) in equal proportions, each recombinant class represents of the total progeny. Expected count .