Resources
A behavioral ecologist studies cooperative nest defense in a diploid passerine bird species to determine whether natural selection favors alarm calling via kin selection. An individual bird emitting an alarm call incurs an absolute direct fitness cost of units of reproductive success due to increased detection by hawks. A recipient sibling of the caller () gains a fitness benefit . Rather than evaluating whether altruism occurs, determine the minimum fitness benefit (in units of reproductive success) that must be conferred to the sibling for natural selection to favor the evolution of this altruistic alarm call under Hamilton's rule (), and calculate the benefit-to-cost ratio .
Answer and steps
Final answer
Minimum fitness benefit , and the critical benefit-to-cost ratio .
Steps
State Hamilton's Rule
Under kin selection theory, natural selection favors an altruistic trait if the indirect fitness gained by relatives exceeds the direct fitness cost to the actor. This condition is formalized by Hamilton's rule:
Where:
- is the coefficient of relatedness between the actor and the recipient (the probability that two individuals share a given gene identical by descent).
- is the reproductive fitness benefit gained by the recipient.
- is the direct reproductive fitness cost incurred by the actor.
Determine the Minimum Fitness Benefit ()
To find the minimum benefit required for natural selection to favor the behavior, set the net inclusive fitness effect equal to the threshold of selection ():
Given:
- Direct fitness cost:
- Coefficient of relatedness for full siblings in a diploid species:
Substitute these values:
Thus, an alarm call must provide a reproductive benefit strictly greater than units of reproductive success to the sibling for natural selection to favor the gene.
Calculate the Critical Benefit-to-Cost Ratio ()
Rearranging Hamilton's threshold gives the critical benefit-to-cost ratio:
Substitute :
(Alternatively, evaluating .)
Key Pitfall to Avoid
- Inverting the Ratio or Misinterpreting : The rule rearranges to , not . Because full siblings share only half their genes (), saving a sibling requires at least twice the benefit to offset the personal reproductive loss of the caller.
Typical errors
01 A student inverts the coefficient of relatedness by multiplying the cost by r instead of dividing by r, resulting in an underestimated minimum benefit of 0.09 and an incorrect ratio of 0.5.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
When isolating in the inequality , you need to divide both sides by rather than multiplying.
- Step 2Correct
Because you multiplied by instead of dividing, your calculated threshold was four times smaller than the correct value of .
- Step 3Correct
Carrying forward your calculation gave a ratio equal to instead of the true critical ratio .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recalled Hamilton's rule () as the condition for kin-selected altruism.
You correctly set up the benefit-to-cost ratio formula using your calculated values.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou multiplied the direct cost by instead of dividing by when isolating the benefit .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating the discounted indirect benefit () with a discounted cost (). Because a relative shares only a fraction of genes identical by descent, the reproductive benefit to that relative must be scaled up by to compensate for the actor's direct loss, requiring .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Isolate Factors by Inversion
If and , divide both sides by : .
Check that solving for a multiplied variable uses division, not multiplication.
- Biological Sense Check
When relatedness is less than (), the recipient shares only a fraction of genes, so the benefit must be larger than the cost ().
Ensure that for , the required benefit is at least double the cost (), which means .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRewrite Hamilton's rule: .
Divide both sides by : .
Substitute and : .
Calculate the critical ratio: .
Minimum fitness benefit , and the critical benefit-to-cost ratio .
02 A student attaches the coefficient of relatedness r to the actor's direct cost c rather than the recipient's benefit b, arriving at a minimum benefit of 0.09 and a ratio of 0.5.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Hamilton's rule weights the benefit to the recipient by the relatedness coefficient (), not the cost to the actor (). Because the actor pays the direct cost personally, that cost is unweighted (), giving the condition .
- Step 2Correct
Because your starting inequality was inverted, you multiplied and instead of dividing by .
- Step 3Correct
Carrying forward gave rather than the required critical threshold .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the relevant variables ( and ) from the problem text.
You carried out your algebraic substitutions and arithmetic operations consistently based on your initial setup.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou associated the relatedness coefficient with the actor's direct cost rather than the recipient's benefit. In inclusive fitness theory, the actor bears 100% of its own direct fitness cost, while the indirect fitness benefit is discounted by because the recipient only shares a fraction of the actor's genes identical by descent.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Inclusive Fitness Weighting
The indirect benefit is discounted by relatedness (), while direct personal cost is not ().
Always attach to the recipient's benefit so that .
- Critical Ratio Check
Because , the recipient must receive a greater benefit than the actor loses (i.e., whenever ).
Verify that whenever dealing with diploid relatives.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState Hamilton's rule correctly: , which gives .
Solve for the minimum benefit : .
Evaluate the benefit-to-cost ratio: .
Minimum fitness benefit units of reproductive success, and the critical ratio .
03 A student inverts the benefit-to-cost ratio and computes the cost-to-benefit ratio c / b_min, obtaining 0.5 instead of 2.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You calculated the cost-to-benefit ratio rather than the requested benefit-to-cost ratio .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified and applied Hamilton's rule .
You accurately substituted and to calculate the minimum benefit .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou set up the ratio as instead of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the phrasing 'benefit-to-cost ratio' (which places benefit in the numerator and cost in the denominator) with the fraction . From , dividing both sides by gives , meaning the benefit-to-cost ratio must exceed , not .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Translating Ratios to Fractions
The phrasing 'X-to-Y ratio' always represents the fraction .
Always write out explicitly before inserting numbers to confirm that benefit is in the numerator.
- Biological Intuition for Hamilton's Rule
Under kin selection, because full siblings share only half their genes (), the recipient's benefit must be greater than the actor's cost.
Check whether the benefit-to-cost ratio is greater than ; since saving a relative with requires more benefit than personal cost, must be greater than .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the numerator and denominator from the name 'benefit-to-cost ratio': .
Substitute and : (or equivalently ).
,
Lock it in
How do you algebraically isolate from Hamilton's rule, ?
Divide both sides by to get . Since multiplies , isolating requires division, not multiplication.
Similar question
A mammal emits a warning cry to protect a half-sibling (). If the direct fitness cost to the caller is , what is the minimum fitness benefit that the half-sibling must receive for Hamilton's rule to favor this behavior?
Answer
. By Hamilton's rule, . Substituting gives .
In a social wasp colony, a female helper aids her full sister ( in haplodiploids). If providing help increases the sister's reproductive output by offspring, what is the maximum direct fitness cost the helper can incur and still have the helping behavior favored by natural selection?
Answer
. Hamilton's rule states . Substituting gives .
An animal can perform an altruistic act that costs units of fitness. It simultaneously saves two nephews, each with a coefficient of relatedness of . What is the minimum benefit each nephew must gain (assuming both gain equally) for natural selection to favor the action?
Answer
units of fitness per nephew. With multiple beneficiaries, Hamilton's rule is . Here, .