Resources

In a population of field mice (Peromyscus maniculatus), foraging behavior carries both energetic gains and predation risks. An individual mouse gathers food seeds yielding an average energetic gain of E(t)=18t−1.5t2E(t) = 18t - 1.5t^2 kJ as a function of foraging duration tt (in hours, where 0≤t≤60 \le t \le 6). However, prolonged exposure to nocturnal aerial predators imposes an energetic and survival cost quantified as C(t)=3tC(t) = 3t kJ. According to optimal foraging theory under natural selection, maximizing net energetic payoff (W(t)=E(t)−C(t)W(t) = E(t) - C(t)) confers maximum individual fitness. Calculate the optimal foraging time t∗t^* that natural selection favors, and determine the maximum net energy gain W(t∗)W(t^*) acquired during this optimal foraging bout.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Optimal foraging time t∗=5.00 hourst^* = 5.00\text{ hours}, and maximum net energy gain W(t∗)=37.5 kJW(t^*) = 37.5\text{ kJ}.

Steps

01

Formulate the Net Energetic Payoff Function

According to Optimal Foraging Theory, natural selection favors behavioral strategies that maximize the net rate of energy intake or net fitness payoff per unit time. The net energetic payoff, W(t)W(t), represents the total energy gained from foraging minus the metabolic and predation-associated costs:

W(t)=E(t)−C(t)W(t) = E(t) - C(t)

Substitute the given equations into this relationship:

W(t)=(18t−1.5t2)−3tW(t) = (18t - 1.5t^2) - 3t W(t)=15t−1.5t2W(t) = 15t - 1.5t^2

02

Determine the Optimal Foraging Time (t∗t^*)

The net payoff function W(t)=−1.5t2+15tW(t) = -1.5t^2 + 15t is a quadratic function of the form at2+bt+cat^2 + bt + c, where a=−1.5a = -1.5, b=15b = 15, and c=0c = 0. Because the leading coefficient a<0a < 0, the parabola opens downward, meaning its vertex represents the absolute maximum.

The tt-coordinate of the vertex (optimal foraging time t∗t^*) is given by:

t∗=−b2a=−152(−1.5)=153=5.00 hourst^* = -\frac{b}{2a} = -\frac{15}{2(-1.5)} = \frac{15}{3} = 5.00\text{ hours}

Alternatively, taking the first derivative with respect to time and setting it equal to zero (marginal value theorem principle where marginal gain equals marginal cost):

dWdt=15−3t=0  ⟹  3t=15  ⟹  t∗=5.00 hours\frac{\mathrm{d}W}{\mathrm{d}t} = 15 - 3t = 0 \implies 3t = 15 \implies t^* = 5.00\text{ hours}

Because the second derivative is negative (d2Wdt2=−3<0\frac{\mathrm{d}^2W}{\mathrm{d}t^2} = -3 < 0), this critical point confirms a local and global maximum.

03

Calculate the Maximum Net Energy Gain (W(t∗)W(t^*))

Substitute t∗=5.00t^* = 5.00 into the net payoff function:

W(5)=15(5)−1.5(5)2W(5) = 15(5) - 1.5(5)^2 W(5)=75−1.5(25)W(5) = 75 - 1.5(25) W(5)=75−37.5=37.5 kJW(5) = 75 - 37.5 = 37.5\text{ kJ}

04

Boundary Check and Biological Interpretation

Checking the boundaries of the interval 0≤t≤60 \le t \le 6:

  • At t=0 hourst = 0\text{ hours}: W(0)=0 kJW(0) = 0\text{ kJ}.
  • At t=6 hourst = 6\text{ hours}: W(6)=15(6)−1.5(6)2=90−54=36.0 kJW(6) = 15(6) - 1.5(6)^2 = 90 - 54 = 36.0\text{ kJ}.

Because 37.5 kJ>36.0 kJ37.5\text{ kJ} > 36.0\text{ kJ}, foraging beyond 5.00 hours5.00\text{ hours} leads to diminishing marginal food returns that are outweighed by the steady accumulation of predation risk.

Therefore, natural selection favors an optimal foraging duration of 5.00 hours5.00\text{ hours}, yielding a maximum net energy payoff of 37.5 kJ37.5\text{ kJ}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student maximizes total energetic gain E(t) instead of net energy payoff W(t), ignoring the predation cost.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    E(t)=18t−1.5t2  ⟹  E′(t)=18−3t=0  ⟹  3t=18  ⟹  t∗=6 hoursE(t) = 18t - 1.5t^2 \implies E'(t) = 18 - 3t = 0 \implies 3t = 18 \implies t^* = 6\text{ hours}

    Correct

    W(t)=E(t)−C(t)=(18t−1.5t2)−3t=15t−1.5t2  ⟹  W′(t)=15−3t=0  ⟹  t∗=5.00 hoursW(t) = E(t) - C(t) = (18t - 1.5t^2) - 3t = 15t - 1.5t^2 \implies W'(t) = 15 - 3t = 0 \implies t^* = 5.00\text{ hours}

    Natural selection favors behaviors that maximize net fitness payoff (W(t)=E(t)−C(t)W(t) = E(t) - C(t)), not gross energetic intake (E(t)E(t)). You must subtract the cost function C(t)=3tC(t) = 3t before taking the derivative and finding the critical time.

  2. Step 2

    W(6)=E(6)−C(6)=(18(6)−1.5(62))−3(6)=(108−54)−18  ⟹  W(t∗)=36 kJW(6) = E(6) - C(6) = (18(6) - 1.5(6^2)) - 3(6) = (108 - 54) - 18 \implies W(t^*) = 36\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    W(5)=15(5)−1.5(52)=75−37.5=37.5 kJW(5) = 15(5) - 1.5(5^2) = 75 - 37.5 = 37.5\text{ kJ}

    Your arithmetic substitution into W(t)=E(t)−C(t)W(t) = E(t) - C(t) was executed accurately, but because it used the incorrect optimal time t∗=6 hourst^* = 6\text{ hours} from Step 1, the resulting maximum net payoff was also incorrect.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the first derivative of the quadratic function E(t)E(t).

You accurately solved for the critical point where the derivative equals zero.

You correctly remembered and applied the definition of net payoff W(t)=E(t)−C(t)W(t) = E(t) - C(t) during evaluation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Maximizing gross gain instead of net payoff

You set E′(t)=0E'(t) = 0 instead of W′(t)=0W'(t) = 0, finding when gross food collection peaks rather than when net energy profit peaks.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In optimal foraging theory, fitness is determined by net energetic payoff (benefits minus costs) rather than gross energy acquired. Because foraging carries an ongoing cost (such as predation risk or metabolic expenditure), the optimal stopping point always occurs when marginal gain equals marginal cost (E′(t)=C′(t)E'(t) = C'(t)), which is earlier than the peak of gross energy gain alone (E′(t)=0E'(t) = 0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define the Optimization Objective First
  • Optimal foraging models optimize net payoff W(t)=Benefit−CostW(t) = \text{Benefit} - \text{Cost}, never benefit alone.

  • Always write down W(t)=E(t)−C(t)W(t) = E(t) - C(t) as a single simplified expression before taking derivatives or locating the vertex.

Marginal Value Optimality Condition
  • The net payoff reaches a maximum where the marginal gain equals the marginal cost: E′(t)=C′(t)E'(t) = C'(t), which is equivalent to W′(t)=0W'(t) = 0.

  • Check whether the cost rate C′(t)>0C'(t) > 0. If costs increase with time, the optimal duration t∗t^* must be strictly less than the time that maximizes gross gain E(t)E(t).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Construct the net energetic payoff function: W(t)=E(t)−C(t)=(18t−1.5t2)−3t=15t−1.5t2W(t) = E(t) - C(t) = (18t - 1.5t^2) - 3t = 15t - 1.5t^2.

  2. Differentiate with respect to tt and set equal to 00: W′(t)=15−3t=0W'(t) = 15 - 3t = 0.

  3. Solve for the optimal foraging time: 3t=15  ⟹  t∗=5.00 hours3t = 15 \implies t^* = 5.00\text{ hours}.

  4. Calculate the maximum net energy gain by evaluating W(5)W(5): W(5)=15(5)−1.5(5)2=75−37.5=37.5 kJW(5) = 15(5) - 1.5(5)^2 = 75 - 37.5 = 37.5\text{ kJ}.

Final answer

Optimal foraging time t∗=5.00 hourst^* = 5.00\text{ hours}, and maximum net energy gain W(t∗)=37.5 kJW(t^*) = 37.5\text{ kJ}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice combining benefit and cost functions into a single net objective function before optimizing.

  • Verify your optimum by confirming that marginal benefit E′(t∗)E'(t^*) equals marginal cost C′(t∗)C'(t^*).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student adds the predation cost to energy gain instead of subtracting it when defining net payoff.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    W(t)=E(t)+C(t)=18t−1.5t2+3t=21t−1.5t2W(t) = E(t) + C(t) = 18t - 1.5t^2 + 3t = 21t - 1.5t^2

    Correct

    W(t)=E(t)−C(t)=(18t−1.5t2)−3t=15t−1.5t2W(t) = E(t) - C(t) = (18t - 1.5t^2) - 3t = 15t - 1.5t^2

    Net energy payoff represents the total energy gained minus the costs incurred. You wrote W(t)=E(t)+C(t)W(t) = E(t) + C(t) and added the cost term 3t3t, but cost must be subtracted from gain.

  2. Step 2

    W′(t)=21−3t=0  ⟹  3t=21  ⟹  t∗=7 hoursW'(t) = 21 - 3t = 0 \implies 3t = 21 \implies t^* = 7\text{ hours}

    Correct

    W′(t)=15−3t=0  ⟹  3t=15  ⟹  t∗=5.00 hoursW'(t) = 15 - 3t = 0 \implies 3t = 15 \implies t^* = 5.00\text{ hours}

    Your differentiation and algebraic steps were carried out correctly, but the result t∗=7 hourst^* = 7\text{ hours} is incorrect because it inherited the erroneous payoff equation from Step 1 (and falls outside the biological domain 0≤t≤60 \le t \le 6).

  3. Step 3

    W(7)=21(7)−1.5(72)=147−73.5  ⟹  W(t∗)=73.5 kJW(7) = 21(7) - 1.5(7^2) = 147 - 73.5 \implies W(t^*) = 73.5\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    W(5)=15(5)−1.5(52)=75−37.5  ⟹  W(t∗)=37.5 kJW(5) = 15(5) - 1.5(5^2) = 75 - 37.5 \implies W(t^*) = 37.5\text{ kJ}

    Your arithmetic was accurate based on your function and critical point, but substituting into the incorrect expression produced an incorrect net energy payoff.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that maximizing net energetic payoff requires finding where the derivative equals zero.

You differentiated the quadratic expression accurately using the power rule.

You solved the linear equation 3t=213t = 21 and evaluated the polynomial expression with sound arithmetic.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in objective function definition

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating net energetic gain with total energetic turnover or misinterpreting cost as an additive quantity rather than an expenditure that reduces fitness.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Net Benefit vs. Total Cost
  • Net Payoff W(t)=Benefit E(t)−Cost C(t)\text{Net Payoff } W(t) = \text{Benefit } E(t) - \text{Cost } C(t)

  • Always verify whether a term represents a gain (positive contribution) or a penalty/cost (subtracted contribution) before taking derivatives.

Domain Sanity Check
  • 0≤t≤6 hours0 \le t \le 6\text{ hours}

  • Check your critical point against the given domain bounds; finding t∗=7t^* = 7 should immediately alert you that something went wrong in the setup.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the correct net payoff function: W(t)=E(t)−C(t)=(18t−1.5t2)−3t=15t−1.5t2W(t) = E(t) - C(t) = (18t - 1.5t^2) - 3t = 15t - 1.5t^2.

  2. Differentiate with respect to tt and set equal to 00: W′(t)=15−3t=0W'(t) = 15 - 3t = 0.

  3. Solve for the optimal foraging time: 3t=15  ⟹  t∗=5.00 hours3t = 15 \implies t^* = 5.00\text{ hours}.

  4. Substitute t∗=5.00t^* = 5.00 into W(t)W(t): W(5)=15(5)−1.5(52)=75−37.5=37.5 kJW(5) = 15(5) - 1.5(5^2) = 75 - 37.5 = 37.5\text{ kJ}.

Final answer

t∗=5.00 hourst^* = 5.00\text{ hours}, W(t∗)=37.5 kJW(t^*) = 37.5\text{ kJ}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Re-read the question carefully to identify whether each variable is an inflow (gain) or outflow (cost).

  • Always subtract costs, risks, and expenditures when defining net fitness or net profit functions.

  • Verify that the calculated optimal time satisfies the stated physical or biological domain constraints.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student differentiates the quadratic term -1.5t² incorrectly as -1.5t rather than -3t.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    W(t)=15t−1.5t2W(t) = 15t - 1.5t^2

  2. Step 2

    W′(t)=15−1.5t=0  ⟹  1.5t=15  ⟹  t∗=10 hoursW'(t) = 15 - 1.5t = 0 \implies 1.5t = 15 \implies t^* = 10\text{ hours}

    Correct

    W′(t)=15−3t=0  ⟹  3t=15  ⟹  t∗=5.00 hoursW'(t) = 15 - 3t = 0 \implies 3t = 15 \implies t^* = 5.00\text{ hours}

    When applying the power rule to −1.5t2-1.5t^2, you must multiply the coefficient by the exponent: ddt(−1.5t2)=−1.5⋅2t=−3t\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}(-1.5t^2) = -1.5 \cdot 2t = -3t. Setting 15−3t=015 - 3t = 0 yields t∗=5.00 hourst^* = 5.00\text{ hours}, which also satisfies the biological domain 0≤t≤60 \le t \le 6.

  3. Step 3

    W(10)=15(10)−1.5(102)  ⟹  W(10)=150−150  ⟹  W(t∗)=0 kJW(10) = 15(10) - 1.5(10^2) \implies W(10) = 150 - 150 \implies W(t^*) = 0\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    W(5)=15(5)−1.5(5)2=75−37.5=37.5 kJW(5) = 15(5) - 1.5(5)^2 = 75 - 37.5 = 37.5\text{ kJ}

    Your evaluation method was carried out cleanly, but substituting your erroneous value t∗=10t^* = 10 yielded 0 kJ0\text{ kJ}. Substituting the correct critical value t∗=5t^* = 5 gives W(5)=37.5 kJW(5) = 37.5\text{ kJ}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly defined the net fitness payoff function as W(t)=E(t)−C(t)W(t) = E(t) - C(t).

You correctly recognized that the optimal time occurs where the first derivative equals zero.

You accurately substituted your calculated time into the objective function.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Power rule coefficient multiplication omitted

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You omitted multiplying the coefficient by the power when differentiating a quadratic term ddt(at2)=2at\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}(a t^2) = 2at. Differentiating −1.5t2-1.5t^2 yielded −1.5t-1.5t instead of −3t-3t, doubling your optimal time and exceeding the problem's specified time interval 0≤t≤60 \le t \le 6.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Power Rule with Non-Integer Coefficients
  • For any term atna t^n, the derivative is ddt(atn)=a⋅n⋅tn−1\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}(a t^n) = a \cdot n \cdot t^{n-1}.

  • Always multiply the constant coefficient by the exponent before reducing the power: −1.5×2=−3-1.5 \times 2 = -3.

Domain Boundary Verification
  • Optimization solutions must fall within the stated biological constraints (0≤t≤60 \le t \le 6).

  • Whenever your critical point exceeds the maximum allowed time (here t=10>6t = 10 > 6), immediately re-check your derivative and algebraic steps.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Differentiate W(t)=15t−1.5t2W(t) = 15t - 1.5t^2 with respect to tt: W′(t)=15−3tW'(t) = 15 - 3t.

  2. Set W′(t)=0W'(t) = 0 to find the optimal foraging duration: 15−3t=0  ⟹  3t=15  ⟹  t∗=5.00 hours15 - 3t = 0 \implies 3t = 15 \implies t^* = 5.00\text{ hours}.

  3. Verify that t∗=5.00t^* = 5.00 falls within the allowable interval 0≤t≤60 \le t \le 6.

  4. Calculate maximum net payoff: W(5)=15(5)−1.5(5)2=75−37.5=37.5 kJW(5) = 15(5) - 1.5(5)^2 = 75 - 37.5 = 37.5\text{ kJ}.

Final answer

Optimal foraging time t∗=5.00 hourst^* = 5.00\text{ hours}, and maximum net energy gain W(t∗)=37.5 kJW(t^*) = 37.5\text{ kJ}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice applying the power rule specifically on expressions with decimal coefficients like −0.5x2-0.5x^2 and −2.5x2-2.5x^2.

  • Always compare your final time value against the boundary conditions given in the problem prompt.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A desert rodent forages with an energetic intake of E(t)=24t−2t2E(t) = 24t - 2t^2 kJ over duration tt (in hours). Thermal and predatory costs are given by C(t)=4tC(t) = 4t kJ. According to optimal foraging theory, determine the optimal foraging time t∗t^* and the maximum net energy payoff W(t∗)W(t^*).

Answer

t∗=5.00 hourst^* = 5.00\text{ hours}, W(t∗)=50.0 kJW(t^*) = 50.0\text{ kJ}. Set up W(t)=E(t)−C(t)=20t−2t2W(t) = E(t) - C(t) = 20t - 2t^2. Differentiating yields W′(t)=20−4t=0  ⟹  t∗=5W'(t) = 20 - 4t = 0 \implies t^* = 5. Then W(5)=20(5)−2(25)=100−50=50 kJW(5) = 20(5) - 2(25) = 100 - 50 = 50\text{ kJ}.

02

A predatory bird hunts over an open marsh where energetic gain is E(t)=32t−2t2E(t) = 32t - 2t^2 kJ, but defensive mobbing by prey inflicts a non-linear energetic stress cost of C(t)=2t2C(t) = 2t^2 kJ (for 0≤t≤80 \le t \le 8). Calculate the optimal hunting duration t∗t^* and compare the net payoff at t∗t^* to the net payoff if the bird had maximized gross intake E(t)E(t).

Answer

Optimal t∗=4.00 hourst^* = 4.00\text{ hours} with W(4)=64 kJW(4) = 64\text{ kJ}; maximizing gross gain gives t=8 hourst = 8\text{ hours} with W(8)=0 kJW(8) = 0\text{ kJ} (a net loss of 64 kJ64\text{ kJ}). Net payoff is W(t)=32t−4t2W(t) = 32t - 4t^2. Setting W′(t)=32−8t=0W'(t) = 32 - 8t = 0 gives t∗=4t^* = 4, so W(4)=32(4)−4(16)=64 kJW(4) = 32(4) - 4(16) = 64\text{ kJ}. Maximizing E(t)E(t) alone gives E′(t)=32−4t=0  ⟹  t=8E'(t) = 32 - 4t = 0 \implies t = 8, where W(8)=32(8)−4(64)=0 kJW(8) = 32(8) - 4(64) = 0\text{ kJ}.

03

An omnivorous mammal forages in a patch where food gain satisfies E(t)=40tE(t) = 40\sqrt{t} kJ (for t≥0t \ge 0 hours). Exposure to diurnal predators imposes a linear cost of C(t)=5tC(t) = 5t kJ. Find the optimal foraging duration t∗t^* that maximizes net energetic gain W(t)W(t), and state the marginal gain and marginal cost at this optimum.

Answer

t∗=16.00 hourst^* = 16.00\text{ hours}, where marginal gain E′(16)=5 kJ/hE'(16) = 5\text{ kJ/h} equals marginal cost C′(16)=5 kJ/hC'(16) = 5\text{ kJ/h}, yielding W(16)=80 kJW(16) = 80\text{ kJ}. Net payoff is W(t)=40t1/2−5tW(t) = 40t^{1/2} - 5t. Setting W′(t)=20t−1/2−5=0W'(t) = 20t^{-1/2} - 5 = 0 gives t−1/2=1/4  ⟹  t=4  ⟹  t∗=16 hourst^{-1/2} = 1/4 \implies \sqrt{t} = 4 \implies t^* = 16\text{ hours}. At t∗=16t^* = 16, E′(16)=C′(16)=5 kJ/hE'(16) = C'(16) = 5\text{ kJ/h}, and W(16)=40(4)−5(16)=160−80=80 kJW(16) = 40(4) - 5(16) = 160 - 80 = 80\text{ kJ}.

Loading workspace…