Resources

In a college genetics laboratory, students use agarose gel electrophoresis to genotype an experimental population of Arabidopsis thaliana (2n=102n = 10) for a polymorphic simple sequence repeat (SSR) marker tightly linked to the flowering time gene FLC. The SSR locus on Chromosome 55 exhibits two alleles: allele 11 (180 bp180\text{ bp}) and allele 22 (240 bp240\text{ bp}). Genomic DNA is extracted from three independent plants (Plant A, Plant B, and Plant C), amplified by PCR using locus-specific primers flanking the repeat, and resolved on an ethidium bromide-stained gel alongside a DNA ladder. The experimental results show: Plant A displays a single intense band at 180 bp180\text{ bp}; Plant B displays two distinct bands of equal stoichiometric intensity at 180 bp180\text{ bp} and 240 bp240\text{ bp}; Plant C displays a single band at 240 bp240\text{ bp}. (a) Assign the specific genotype (homozygous or heterozygous with respect to alleles 11 and 22) to each plant. (b) State the exact physical location of these alleles relative to homologous chromosomes and sister chromatids in Plant B during G1\text{G}_1 phase. (c) If Plant B is allowed to self-pollinate, predict the expected genotypic ratio and the corresponding gel banding patterns among 200200 progeny plants.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Plant A: homozygous for allele 11 (1/11/1); Plant B: heterozygous (1/21/2); Plant C: homozygous for allele 22 (2/22/2); (b) In G1\text{G}_1 of Plant B, allele 11 resides at the SSR locus on one Chromosome 55 homolog, and allele 22 resides at the identical locus on the other homologous Chromosome 55; (c) 1:2:11 : 2 : 1 ratio (5050 single-band 180 bp180\text{ bp} : 100100 double-band 180 bp/240 bp180\text{ bp}/240\text{ bp} : 5050 single-band 240 bp240\text{ bp}).

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Genotype of Each Plant

In a diploid organism (2n2n), each nuclear locus is present in two copies—one on each homologous chromosome. A simple sequence repeat (SSR) is a co-dominant molecular marker, meaning that both alleles can be detected simultaneously on an agarose gel:

  • Plant A: Displays a single band at 180 bp180\text{ bp}. Because both homologous chromosomes carry allele 11, this plant is homozygous for allele 11 (genotype 1/11/1).
  • Plant B: Displays two distinct bands at 180 bp180\text{ bp} and 240 bp240\text{ bp}. Because it carries one copy of each allele, this plant is heterozygous (genotype 1/21/2).
  • Plant C: Displays a single band at 240 bp240\text{ bp}. Because both homologous chromosomes carry allele 22, this plant is homozygous for allele 22 (genotype 2/22/2).

Part (b): Physical Location of Alleles in Plant B during G1\text{G}_1 Phase

  • In the G1\text{G}_1 phase of the cell cycle, DNA replication has not yet occurred, so each chromosome consists of a single linear double-stranded DNA molecule (unreplicated chromatid).
  • Because Arabidopsis thaliana is diploid (2n=102n = 10), Plant B possesses a pair of homologous Chromosome 55s.
  • Therefore, allele 11 (180 bp180\text{ bp}) resides at the SSR locus on one of the homologous Chromosome 55s, and allele 22 (240 bp240\text{ bp}) resides at the identical homologous locus on the other Chromosome 55. Sister chromatids are not present until after the S\text{S} phase.

Part (c): Expected Progeny from Self-Pollination of Plant B

Plant B is heterozygous (1/21/2). During meiosis, alleles segregate equally into gametes:

  • Pollen produced: 12\frac{1}{2} carry allele 11, 12\frac{1}{2} carry allele 22.
  • Ovules produced: 12\frac{1}{2} carry allele 11, 12\frac{1}{2} carry allele 22.

Self-pollination (1/2×1/21/2 \times 1/2) yields a standard Mendelian monohybrid genotypic ratio of: 14 (1/1):12 (1/2):14 (2/2)\frac{1}{4}\ (1/1) : \frac{1}{2}\ (1/2) : \frac{1}{4}\ (2/2) which is a ratio of 1:2:11 : 2 : 1.

For 200200 progeny plants, the expected distribution and corresponding gel banding patterns are:

  1. 5050 plants with genotype 1/11/1: single band at 180 bp180\text{ bp} (14×200=50\frac{1}{4} \times 200 = 50).
  2. 100100 plants with genotype 1/21/2: two bands at 180 bp180\text{ bp} and 240 bp240\text{ bp} (12×200=100\frac{1}{2} \times 200 = 100).
  3. 5050 plants with genotype 2/22/2: single band at 240 bp240\text{ bp} (14×200=50\frac{1}{4} \times 200 = 50).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the cell cycle stage by assuming sister chromatids exist in G1 phase, mistakenly placing the two different alleles on sister chromatids rather than on separate homologous chromosomes.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Plant A: homozygous for allele 11 (1/11/1) Plant B: heterozygous (1/21/2) Plant C: homozygous for allele 22 (2/22/2)

  2. Step 2

    During G1\text{G}_1, allele 11 and allele 22 reside on two sister chromatids of Chromosome 55.

    Correct

    In G1\text{G}_1 of Plant B, allele 11 resides at the SSR locus on one Chromosome 55 homolog, and allele 22 resides at the identical locus on the other homologous Chromosome 55.

    In G1\text{G}_1 phase, DNA replication has not yet occurred, so each chromosome consists of a single chromatid (sister chromatids do not exist). Furthermore, in a diploid organism, contrasting alleles of a heterozygous gene reside on separate homologous chromosomes, whereas sister chromatids (formed after S\text{S} phase) carry identical copies of the same allele.

  3. Step 3

    Plant B selfing gives 1 (1/1):2 (1/2):1 (2/2)1\,(1/1) : 2\,(1/2) : 1\,(2/2) 5050 progeny with 180 bp180\text{ bp} band, 100100 with both 180 bp180\text{ bp} and 240 bp240\text{ bp} bands, and 5050 with 240 bp240\text{ bp} band

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly deduced the diploid genotypes of all three plants from the gel electrophoresis band counts.

You correctly predicted the Mendelian segregation ratio and progeny counts for the self-pollination of Plant B.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Cell Cycle & Chromosome Anatomy Misconception

You assumed sister chromatids are present in G1\text{G}_1 and can carry different alleles of a gene.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused homologous chromosomes with sister chromatids and overlooked the timing of DNA replication during the cell cycle. Sister chromatids are identical products of replication formed during S\text{S} phase; in an unreplicated G1\text{G}_1 diploid cell, the two alleles at any autosomal locus reside on the two homologous chromosomes.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Timing of Sister Chromatids
  • Chromosomes in G1\text{G}_1 phase are unreplicated single DNA molecules; sister chromatids exist only after S\text{S} phase (in G2\text{G}_2 and MM phases).

  • Check the cell cycle stage specified in the prompt before mentioning sister chromatids.

Homologous Chromosomes vs. Sister Chromatids
  • In a diploid organism, different alleles of a heterozygous locus reside on corresponding loci of maternal and paternal homologous chromosomes, never on sister chromatids.

  • Assign contrasting alleles (11 and 22, or AA and aa) to homologous chromosomes, and reserve sister chromatids for identical duplicated copies.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall that during G1\text{G}_1 phase, DNA replication has not taken place, so sister chromatids have not been formed.

  2. Identify that Arabidopsis thaliana is diploid (2n=102n = 10), meaning it possesses pairs of homologous chromosomes.

  3. Conclude that allele 11 is located at the SSR locus on one Chromosome 55 homolog, and allele 22 is located at the equivalent locus on the other Chromosome 55 homolog.

Final answer

(a) Plant A: homozygous for allele 11 (1/11/1); Plant B: heterozygous (1/21/2); Plant C: homozygous for allele 22 (2/22/2); (b) Allele 11 and allele 22 reside at the same SSR locus on opposite homologous Chromosome 55s (sister chromatids do not exist in G1\text{G}_1); (c) 1:2:11:2:1 ratio (5050 with 180 bp180\text{ bp}, 100100 with 180/240 bp180/240\text{ bp}, 5050 with 240 bp240\text{ bp}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the stages of the eukaryotic cell cycle (G1\text{G}_1, S\text{S}, G2\text{G}_2, MM) with a focus on when DNA content doubles from 2C2C to 4C4C.

  • Practice drawing a pair of homologous chromosomes before and after replication, labeling alleles at a heterozygous locus to reinforce that sister chromatids are genetically identical.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student treats the codominant molecular marker as following a dominant/recessive phenotype ratio of 3:1 rather than a 1:2:1 ratio for both genotypes and distinct gel banding patterns.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Plant A: homozygous 1/1 ⟹ Plant B: heterozygous 1/2 ⟹ Plant C: homozygous 2/2

  2. Step 2

    During G1 phase, allele 1 is on one homologous Chromosome 5 and allele 2 is on the other homologous Chromosome 5, with no sister chromatids present.

  3. Step 3

    Self-pollination of Plant B yields a 3:1 ratio of dominant to recessive phenotypes. ⟹ 150 progeny show two bands at 180 bp and 240 bp, and 50 progeny show a single 240 bp band.

    Correct

    1:2:11:2:1 genotypic and phenotypic ratio: 5050 progeny with a single 180 bp180\text{ bp} band (1/11/1), 100100 progeny with two bands at 180 bp180\text{ bp} and 240 bp240\text{ bp} (1/21/2), and 5050 progeny with a single 240 bp240\text{ bp} band (2/22/2).

    Because SSR markers are codominant, heterozygotes do not show dominance over either homozygote. Each distinct genotype yields a unique electrophoretic banding pattern, so the phenotypic ratio directly mirrors the 1:2:11:2:1 Mendelian genotypic ratio.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly deduced the diploid genotypes of Plants A, B, and C from the electrophoresis banding patterns.

You accurately explained that homologous chromosomes each carry one allele at the locus and that sister chromatids are not yet formed in G1\text{G}_1 phase.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing codominant molecular markers with complete dominance

Applying a classical 3:13:1 monohybrid phenotypic ratio to a molecular marker where both alleles are directly and independently visualized.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating organismal trait dominance with molecular marker expression. In gel electrophoresis, both alleles produce amplified DNA fragments of different sizes, meaning heterozygotes display both bands simultaneously (codominance) rather than masking one allele.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify marker inheritance type
  • DNA markers such as SSRs, RFLPs, and SNPs that produce distinct bands or signals for each allele are codominant.

  • Check whether heterozygotes display both bands; if so, treat the phenotypic banding ratio as identical to the genotypic ratio (1:2:11:2:1).

Calculate progeny distributions for codominant markers
  • In a monohybrid cross of heterozygotes (A1A2×A1A2A_1A_2 \times A_1A_2), the progeny ratio is 14A1A1:12A1A2:14A2A2\frac{1}{4} A_1A_1 : \frac{1}{2} A_1A_2 : \frac{1}{4} A_2A_2.

  • Multiply the total progeny count by 14\frac{1}{4}, 12\frac{1}{2}, and 14\frac{1}{4} to find the expected count for each unique gel profile.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that Plant B is heterozygous (1/21/2), and self-pollination (1/2×1/21/2 \times 1/2) produces a standard monohybrid genotypic ratio of 14 (1/1):12 (1/2):14 (2/2)\frac{1}{4}\ (1/1) : \frac{1}{2}\ (1/2) : \frac{1}{4}\ (2/2), which simplifies to 1:2:11 : 2 : 1.

  2. Because SSR alleles are codominant, each genotype displays a unique electrophoretic profile: 1/11/1 yields a single 180 bp180\text{ bp} band, 1/21/2 yields two bands (180 bp180\text{ bp} and 240 bp240\text{ bp}), and 2/22/2 yields a single 240 bp240\text{ bp} band.

  3. Calculate the counts among 200200 progeny: 14×200=50\frac{1}{4} \times 200 = 50 for genotype 1/11/1, 12×200=100\frac{1}{2} \times 200 = 100 for genotype 1/21/2, and 14×200=50\frac{1}{4} \times 200 = 50 for genotype 2/22/2.

Final answer

Genotypic ratio is 1:2:11 : 2 : 1; among 200200 progeny: 5050 show a single 180 bp180\text{ bp} band, 100100 show two bands (180 bp180\text{ bp} and 240 bp240\text{ bp}), and 5050 show a single 240 bp240\text{ bp} band.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition and gel appearance of codominant vs. dominant molecular markers.

  • Practice predicting progeny banding patterns from monohybrid and dihybrid crosses involving codominant markers.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A diploid plant with genotype B/bB/b enters G2\text{G}_2 phase after completing S\text{S} phase. Describe the total number of chromatids for this chromosome pair and state where allele BB and allele bb are physically located.

Answer

In G2\text{G}_2, the chromosome pair consists of two duplicated homologous chromosomes (four sister chromatids total). One homolog consists of two identical sister chromatids each bearing allele BB; the other homologous chromosome consists of two identical sister chromatids each bearing allele bb.

02

In tomato (2n=242n = 24), a seedling is heterozygous for two unlinked genes on different chromosomes: R/rR/r on Chromosome 22 and Y/yY/y on Chromosome 77. Specify the physical distribution of all four alleles in a root apical meristem cell during G1\text{G}_1 phase.

Answer

In G1\text{G}_1, there are no sister chromatids. Allele RR is on one Chromosome 22 homolog and allele rr is on the other Chromosome 22 homolog; allele YY is on one Chromosome 77 homolog and allele yy is on the other Chromosome 77 homolog.

03

An animal cell of genotype D/dD/d undergoes normal meiosis. At Metaphase I, how many total DNA molecules make up this homologous pair, and how are alleles DD and dd arranged relative to the metaphase plate?

Answer

The bivalent consists of 44 DNA molecules (chromatids). One duplicated homolog carries allele DD on both of its sister chromatids, and the other duplicated homolog carries allele dd on both of its sister chromatids. The two homologs align on opposite sides of the metaphase plate.

Loading workspace…