Resources

A population geneticist evaluates reproductive character displacement in a contact zone of two cricket sister species, Gryllus lineatus and Gryllus maculatus. In allopatry, male pulse rate in G. lineatus has a mean of μA=48.0 s−1\mu_{\text{A}} = 48.0\text{ s}^{-1} with variance σA2=4.0 s−2\sigma_{\text{A}}^2 = 4.0\text{ s}^{-2}, and female acoustic preference matches this distribution. In sympatric populations, intense female preference against heterospecific calls shifts the male pulse rate distribution to avoid hybrid breakdown. If the threshold for female acceptance in sympatry shifts such that only males with pulse rates exceeding μcrit=51.5 s−1\mu_{\text{crit}} = 51.5\text{ s}^{-1} obtain matings, calculate the standardized selection differential S∗=μcrit−μAσAS^* = \frac{\mu_{\text{crit}} - \mu_{\text{A}}}{\sigma_{\text{A}}} acting on the target acoustic phenotype in standard deviation units. Identify whether this reproductive barrier represents a prezygotic or postzygotic isolation mechanism.

Answer and steps

Final answer

S∗=1.75S^* = 1.75 standard deviations; Prezygotic isolation mechanism (specifically behavioral/acoustic isolation).

Steps

01

Calculate the standard deviation of the allopatric population

The population variance for the male calling song pulse rate is given as: σA2=4.0 s−2\sigma_{\text{A}}^2 = 4.0\text{ s}^{-2}

Take the square root to find the standard deviation (σA\sigma_{\text{A}}): σA=4.0 s−2=2.0 s−1\sigma_{\text{A}} = \sqrt{4.0\text{ s}^{-2}} = 2.0\text{ s}^{-1}


02

Compute the standardized selection differential (S∗S^*)

The standardized selection differential measures the difference between the minimum phenotypic threshold required for mating (μcrit\mu_{\text{crit}}) and the baseline mean (μA\mu_{\text{A}}) in units of standard deviations: S∗=μcrit−μAσAS^* = \frac{\mu_{\text{crit}} - \mu_{\text{A}}}{\sigma_{\text{A}}}

Substitute the values: S∗=51.5 s−1−48.0 s−12.0 s−1=3.5 s−12.0 s−1=1.75S^* = \frac{51.5\text{ s}^{-1} - 48.0\text{ s}^{-1}}{2.0\text{ s}^{-1}} = \frac{3.5\text{ s}^{-1}}{2.0\text{ s}^{-1}} = 1.75

The standardized selection differential is 1.751.75 standard deviations.


03

Classify the reproductive isolation mechanism

Reproductive isolation mechanisms are categorized based on when they act relative to fertilization:

  • Prezygotic barriers prevent mating or fertilization from occurring between species (e.g., behavioral, temporal, ecological, or mechanical isolation).
  • Postzygotic barriers operate after fertilization, resulting in hybrid inviability, sterility, or breakdown.

Here, mate choice is governed by female discrimination between male acoustic calling signals (pulse rate) before mating can take place. Therefore, this represents a prezygotic isolation mechanism (specifically, behavioral or acoustic isolation).

Common Pitfall: Even though the selective pressure driving the shift is the avoidance of "hybrid breakdown" (which is a postzygotic cost), the actual isolating barrier being evaluated is the acoustic mating preference, which operates before fertilization and is strictly prezygotic.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student mistakenly uses the variance in the denominator instead of taking the square root to find the standard deviation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    σ=4.0  ⟹  S∗=(51.5−48.0)/4.0\sigma = 4.0 \implies S^* = (51.5 - 48.0) / 4.0

    Correct

    σA=σA2=4.0 s−2=2.0 s−1  ⟹  S∗=51.5−48.02.0\sigma_{\text{A}} = \sqrt{\sigma_{\text{A}}^2} = \sqrt{4.0\text{ s}^{-2}} = 2.0\text{ s}^{-1} \implies S^* = \frac{51.5 - 48.0}{2.0}

    You used the variance value of 4.0 s−24.0\text{ s}^{-2} directly as σ\sigma. Because the problem provides variance σA2=4.0 s−2\sigma_{\text{A}}^2 = 4.0\text{ s}^{-2}, you must take the square root to find the standard deviation σA=2.0 s−1\sigma_{\text{A}} = 2.0\text{ s}^{-1} before dividing.

  2. Step 2

    S∗=3.5/4.0=0.875S^* = 3.5 / 4.0 = 0.875

    Correct

    S∗=3.5 s−12.0 s−1=1.75S^* = \frac{3.5\text{ s}^{-1}}{2.0\text{ s}^{-1}} = 1.75

    Your arithmetic division was carried out correctly for your written expression, but the final numerical value was altered because of the variance substituted in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Prezygotic isolation mechanism\text{Prezygotic isolation mechanism}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the phenotypic shift in the numerator as 51.5−48.0=3.551.5 - 48.0 = 3.5.

You correctly identified acoustic mate choice as a prezygotic reproductive isolation mechanism.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
variance-instead-of-standard-deviation

You briefly considered dividing by 2.02.0 (as seen in your crossed-out work) but second-guessed yourself and reverted to using the given variance 4.04.0.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing variance (σ2\sigma^2) with standard deviation (σ\sigma) when standardizing selection differentials or test statistics.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Variance vs. Standard Deviation Units
  • Variance has squared units (s−2\text{s}^{-2}), whereas standard deviation has linear units (s−1\text{s}^{-1}).

  • Check that the denominator shares the exact same physical units as the numerator so that the standardized differential S∗S^* becomes dimensionless.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. σA=4.0 s−2=2.0 s−1\sigma_{\text{A}} = \sqrt{4.0\text{ s}^{-2}} = 2.0\text{ s}^{-1}

  2. S∗=51.5 s−1−48.0 s−12.0 s−1=3.5 s−12.0 s−1S^* = \frac{51.5\text{ s}^{-1} - 48.0\text{ s}^{-1}}{2.0\text{ s}^{-1}} = \frac{3.5\text{ s}^{-1}}{2.0\text{ s}^{-1}}

  3. S∗=1.75S^* = 1.75 standard deviations

Final answer

S∗=1.75S^* = 1.75 standard deviations; Prezygotic isolation mechanism

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always inspect the exponents and units in the problem text: if you see σ2\sigma^2 or squared units, take the square root before calculating standardized metrics.

  • Trust your initial intuition when checking units; dimensional consistency is a reliable way to verify your denominator.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies the barrier as postzygotic because the problem text mentions avoiding hybrid breakdown.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    σ=4.0=2.0  ⟹  S∗=51.5−48.02.0=3.52.0=1.75\sigma = \sqrt{4.0} = 2.0 \implies S^* = \frac{51.5 - 48.0}{2.0} = \frac{3.5}{2.0} = 1.75

  2. Step 2

    Postzygotic isolation mechanism

    Correct

    Prezygotic isolation mechanism (specifically behavioral/acoustic isolation)

    The barrier evaluated here is female discrimination of male acoustic signals, which acts before mating and fertilization take place.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the standard deviation from the population variance.

You set up and evaluated the standardized selection differential formula accurately to obtain S∗=1.75S^* = 1.75.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating selective pressure with barrier timing
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You likely focused on the phrase 'hybrid breakdown' mentioned in the prompt, which is indeed a postzygotic cost. However, reproductive isolating barriers are classified strictly by when the physical or behavioral block occurs relative to fertilization. Because mate choice based on acoustic calls acts prior to mating, the barrier itself is prezygotic (behavioral isolation).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Timing Relative to Fertilization
  • Reproductive isolating mechanisms are classified as prezygotic if they prevent mating or gamete fusion, and postzygotic if they reduce the viability or fertility of the hybrid offspring after zygote formation.

  • Ask whether the specific trait (here, acoustic pulse rate preference) acts before or after a zygote is formed.

Driver vs. Mechanism in Reinforcement
  • In reproductive character displacement (reinforcement), postzygotic fitness reductions (e.g., hybrid breakdown) often act as the selective pressure that favors the evolution of prezygotic barriers (e.g., mate choice).

  • Distinguish the selective agent (hybrid inviability/breakdown) from the evolving barrier trait (calling song discrimination).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the timing of the barrier: female acoustic preference filters potential mates before copulation or gamete transfer occurs.

  2. Conclude that any barrier preventing mating or fertilization is classified as prezygotic (behavioral isolation).

Final answer

S∗=1.75S^* = 1.75 standard deviations; Prezygotic isolation mechanism (behavioral/acoustic isolation)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between prezygotic barriers (behavioral, temporal, ecological, mechanical, gametic) and postzygotic barriers (hybrid inviability, sterility, breakdown).

  • Practice identifying whether a question is asking for the evolutionary driver (the cost of hybridization) or the actual mechanism of isolation.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a population of spadefoot toads, the mean mating call frequency is μ0=120 Hz\mu_0 = 120\text{ Hz} with a variance of σ2=16 Hz2\sigma^2 = 16\text{ Hz}^2. In sympatry with a congener, character displacement shifts the mean mating call to μ1=126 Hz\mu_1 = 126\text{ Hz}. Calculate the standardized selection differential S∗S^* and state whether this displacement reinforces prezygotic or postzygotic isolation.

Answer

S∗=1.5S^* = 1.5 standard deviations; Prezygotic isolation (behavioral/acoustic isolation). Key steps: σ=16 Hz2=4 Hz\sigma = \sqrt{16\text{ Hz}^2} = 4\text{ Hz}; S∗=126−1204=64=1.5S^* = \frac{126 - 120}{4} = \frac{6}{4} = 1.5.

02

Two sympatric plant species avoid hybrid seed abortiveness because flowering time diverged. The ancestral population had a mean flowering day of μ=40\mu = 40 with variance σ2=25 days2\sigma^2 = 25\text{ days}^2. The new sympatric threshold requires flowering after day μcrit=52.5\mu_{\text{crit}} = 52.5. Compute S∗S^* and determine whether flowering time divergence constitutes prezygotic or postzygotic isolation.

Answer

S∗=2.5S^* = 2.5 standard deviations; Prezygotic isolation (temporal isolation). Key steps: σ=25=5 days\sigma = \sqrt{25} = 5\text{ days}; S∗=52.5−405=12.55=2.5S^* = \frac{52.5 - 40}{5} = \frac{12.5}{5} = 2.5 standard deviations. Even though it prevents hybrid seed abortion (a postzygotic penalty), temporal divergence prevents mating itself, which is prezygotic.

03

In a hybrid zone of stickleback fish, female armor preference enforces prezygotic isolation. An ancestral benthic population has lateral plate count mean μ=14.0\mu = 14.0 with standard deviation σ=1.2\sigma = 1.2, while a limnetic population requires plate counts ≤11.0\le 11.0. However, another researcher reports the variance in a nearby stream as Var(X)=2.25\text{Var}(X) = 2.25 with a shift of Δμ=−3.0\Delta \mu = -3.0. Calculate S∗S^* for both scenarios and identify which population experienced stronger directional selection per standard deviation.

Answer

Benthic scenario: ∣S∗∣=∣11.0−14.0∣1.2=2.50|S^*| = \frac{|11.0 - 14.0|}{1.2} = 2.50 standard deviations. Stream scenario: σ=2.25=1.5\sigma = \sqrt{2.25} = 1.5; ∣S∗∣=∣−3.0∣1.5=2.00|S^*| = \frac{|-3.0|}{1.5} = 2.00 standard deviations. The benthic population experienced stronger directional selection (2.50>2.002.50 > 2.00 standard deviations). Both represent prezygotic behavioral/morphological barriers.

Loading workspace…