Resources

An enclosed marine sanctuary supports a population of sea urchins (Strongylocentrotus purpuratus) that exhibits logistic growth with r=0.50 year−1r = 0.50\text{ year}^{-1} and an unharvested carrying capacity of K=5,000K = 5{,}000 individuals. A regulated commercial fishery begins removing urchins at a constant harvesting rate of H=300 individuals/yearH = 300\text{ individuals/year}, modifying the net dynamics to dNdt=rN(1−NK)−H\frac{dN}{dt} = rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) - H. Coupling logistic growth dynamics with constant-yield harvesting, calculate the new stable carrying capacity (the stable equilibrium population size N∗N^*) maintained under this ongoing harvest regime.

Answer and steps

Final answer

N∗=4,314N^* = 4{,}314 individuals (or 4,3104{,}310 to 3 significant figures)

Steps

01

Set the Equilibrium Condition

At equilibrium, the population size does not change over time, meaning the net growth rate is zero:

dNdt=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0

Substitute the governing differential equation:

rN(1−NK)−H=0rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) - H = 0

02

Formulate the Quadratic Equation

Expand the terms and express the equation in standard quadratic form:

rN−rKN2−H=0rN - \frac{r}{K}N^2 - H = 0

Multiply the entire equation by −Kr-\frac{K}{r} to simplify the coefficient of N2N^2:

N2−KN+HKr=0N^2 - KN + \frac{HK}{r} = 0

03

Solve for the Population Equilibria

Using the quadratic formula N=−b±b2−4ac2aN = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a} with a=1a = 1, b=−Kb = -K, and c=HKrc = \frac{HK}{r}:

N=K±K2−4HKr2N = \frac{K \pm \sqrt{K^2 - \frac{4HK}{r}}}{2}

Substitute the given parameters:

  • r=0.50 year−1r = 0.50\text{ year}^{-1}
  • K=5,000 individualsK = 5{,}000\text{ individuals}
  • H=300 individuals/yearH = 300\text{ individuals/year}

Calculate the terms:

4HKr=4⋅300⋅5,0000.50=12,000,000\frac{4HK}{r} = \frac{4 \cdot 300 \cdot 5{,}000}{0.50} = 12{,}000{,}000

K2=5,0002=25,000,000K^2 = 5{,}000^2 = 25{,}000{,}000

K2−4HKr=25,000,000−12,000,000=13,000,000K^2 - \frac{4HK}{r} = 25{,}000{,}000 - 12{,}000{,}000 = 13{,}000{,}000

Thus, the roots are:

N=5,000±13,000,0002N = \frac{5{,}000 \pm \sqrt{13{,}000{,}000}}{2}

04

Determine Stability

Constant-yield harvesting shifts the logistic growth parabola downward, creating two equilibria:

  • Lower equilibrium (N1N_1): An unstable threshold. If N<N1N < N_1, harvest exceeds renewal, driving the population to extinction.
  • Upper equilibrium (N∗N^*): The stable carrying capacity. For any population size above N1N_1, the net growth rate directs the population toward this upper equilibrium because ddN(dNdt)<0\frac{d}{dN}\left(\frac{dN}{dt}\right) < 0 at this point.

Therefore, the new stable carrying capacity corresponds to the positive addition root:

N∗=5,000+13,000,0002N^* = \frac{5{,}000 + \sqrt{13{,}000{,}000}}{2}

Evaluating the square root (13,000,000≈3,628\sqrt{13{,}000{,}000} \approx 3{,}628):

N∗=5,000+3,6282=8,6282=4,314 individualsN^* = \frac{5{,}000 + 3{,}628}{2} = \frac{8{,}628}{2} = 4{,}314\text{ individuals}

Rounding to three significant figures gives 4,310 individuals4{,}310\text{ individuals}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies the smaller equilibrium root as the stable carrying capacity instead of the unstable critical threshold.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    dNdt=0.50N(1−N5000)−300=0  ⟹  0.50N−0.0001N2−300=0  ⟹  N2−5000N+3000000=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0.50N\left(1 - \frac{N}{5000}\right) - 300 = 0 \implies 0.50N - 0.0001N^2 - 300 = 0 \implies N^2 - 5000N + 3000000 = 0

  2. Step 2

    N=5000±25000000−120000002=5000±130000002=5000±3605.552  ⟹  N1=697.2,N2=4302.8N = \frac{5000 \pm \sqrt{25000000 - 12000000}}{2} = \frac{5000 \pm \sqrt{13000000}}{2} = \frac{5000 \pm 3605.55}{2} \implies N_1 = 697.2, N_2 = 4302.8

  3. Step 3

    Stable equilibrium N∗=697 individuals\text{Stable equilibrium } N^* = 697\text{ individuals}

    Correct

    N∗=N2=5000+130000002≈4,303 individualsN^* = N_2 = \frac{5000 + \sqrt{13000000}}{2} \approx 4{,}303\text{ individuals} (or 4,3104{,}310 to three significant figures)

    In logistic growth with constant harvesting, the growth curve is a downward-opening parabola shifted down by HH. The lower intersection N1N_1 has a positive slope ddN(dNdt)>0\frac{d}{dN}\left(\frac{dN}{dt}\right) > 0, making it an unstable critical threshold below which the population crashes. The upper intersection N2N_2 has a negative slope ddN(dNdt)<0\frac{d}{dN}\left(\frac{dN}{dt}\right) < 0, making it the stable carrying capacity.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set the net growth rate to zero to represent equilibrium.

You algebraically rearranged the logistic harvesting equation into standard quadratic form without algebraic slips.

You accurately evaluated the roots using the quadratic formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Stability Identification Error

You solved for both equilibria accurately but picked the smaller root rather than testing which root is stable.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the stable carrying capacity with the unstable tipping point. Constant-yield harvesting creates two equilibria: the smaller root is an extinction threshold (unstable), while the larger root represents the harvested carrying capacity (stable, where density-dependent negative feedback restores equilibrium).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Stability Condition for 1D Differential Equations
  • An equilibrium point N∗N^* of dNdt=f(N)\frac{dN}{dt} = f(N) is locally stable if and only if f′(N∗)<0f'(N^*) < 0.

  • Differentiate f(N)=rN(1−NK)−Hf(N) = rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) - H with respect to NN: f′(N)=r−2rNKf'(N) = r - \frac{2rN}{K}. For the upper root N2>K2N_2 > \frac{K}{2}, f′(N2)<0f'(N_2) < 0, confirming stability.

Graphical Intuition for Shifted Logistic Curves
  • For a downward-opening parabola f(N)f(N), the curve crosses zero from positive to negative at the right-hand root.

  • Always identify the larger root as the stable carrying capacity, because populations just above it decrease (f(N)<0f(N) < 0) and populations just below it increase (f(N)>0f(N) > 0).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify stability using the derivative test: f′(N)=ddN[rN(1−NK)−H]=r−2rNKf'(N) = \frac{d}{dN}\left[rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) - H\right] = r - \frac{2rN}{K}.

  2. Evaluate f′(N)f'(N) at the two roots: at N1≈697.2N_1 \approx 697.2, f′(N1)=0.50−2(0.50)(697.2)5000≈+0.361>0f'(N_1) = 0.50 - \frac{2(0.50)(697.2)}{5000} \approx +0.361 > 0 (unstable).

  3. Evaluate at N2≈4302.8N_2 \approx 4302.8: f′(N2)=0.50−2(0.50)(4302.8)5000≈−0.361<0f'(N_2) = 0.50 - \frac{2(0.50)(4302.8)}{5000} \approx -0.361 < 0 (stable).

  4. Select the stable root as the new carrying capacity: N∗=N2≈4,303N^* = N_2 \approx 4{,}303 individuals (or 4,3144{,}314 using textbook rounding).

Final answer

N∗=4,310 individualsN^* = 4{,}310\text{ individuals} (to 3 significant figures, or 4,3034{,}303 individuals)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the phase line or rate-versus-population graph to visually verify the arrows of population trajectory near each root.

  • Remember that the smaller root in constant harvesting represents an Allee-like extinction threshold, never a stable carrying capacity.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student incorrectly assumes the new carrying capacity is found simply by subtracting the annual harvest rate from the unharvested carrying capacity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    N∗=K−HN^* = K - H

    Correct

    dNdt=0  ⟹  rN(1−NK)−H=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0 \implies rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) - H = 0

    Carrying capacity is a population stock (individuals), whereas harvest is a rate (individuals per year). Equilibrium occurs where the biological growth rate matches the removal rate, which requires solving the quadratic equation rN(1−NK)=HrN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) = H.

  2. Step 2

    N∗=5000−300  ⟹  N∗=4700 individualsN^* = 5000 - 300 \implies N^* = 4700\text{ individuals}

    Correct

    N∗=5,000+5,0002−4(300)(5,000)0.502≈4,314 individualsN^* = \frac{5{,}000 + \sqrt{5{,}000^2 - \frac{4(300)(5{,}000)}{0.50}}}{2} \approx 4{,}314\text{ individuals}

    This numerical subtraction follows directly from the incorrect linear formula introduced in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly extracted the numerical values for carrying capacity (K=5,000K = 5{,}000) and harvesting rate (H=300H = 300).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Dimensional Inconsistency and Neglecting Dynamic Equilibrium

You treated the harvest rate as a one-time static subtraction from population size instead of an ongoing rate balance.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating population stock (numbers of individuals) with population flow rate (individuals per year), leading to a linear subtraction instead of setting the net rate of change dNdt\frac{dN}{dt} to zero.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensional and Rate Check
  • Never subtract a rate with units individuals/time\text{individuals}/\text{time} directly from a standing stock with units individuals\text{individuals}.

  • Check units on both sides of any formula before performing arithmetic.

Equilibrium Condition
  • A population reaches a stable equilibrium N∗N^* when net growth ceases: dNdt=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0.

  • Set the governing differential equation rN(1−N/K)−H=0rN(1 - N/K) - H = 0 and solve for NN using the quadratic formula.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the net rate of change to zero: rN(1−NK)−H=0rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) - H = 0.

  2. Rearrange into standard quadratic form: N2−KN+HKr=0N^2 - KN + \frac{HK}{r} = 0.

  3. Substitute r=0.50r = 0.50, K=5,000K = 5{,}000, and H=300H = 300: N2−5,000N+3,000,000=0N^2 - 5{,}000N + 3{,}000{,}000 = 0.

  4. Apply the quadratic formula and choose the stable upper root: N∗=5,000+25,000,000−12,000,0002=5,000+13,000,0002N^* = \frac{5{,}000 + \sqrt{25{,}000{,}000 - 12{,}000{,}000}}{2} = \frac{5{,}000 + \sqrt{13{,}000{,}000}}{2}.

Final answer

N∗≈4,314 individualsN^* \approx 4{,}314\text{ individuals} (or 4,3104{,}310 to 3 significant figures)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how constant harvesting shifts the logistic growth curve downward and alters equilibria.

  • Practice solving for equilibria by setting differential equations equal to zero rather than modifying parameters linearly.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to divide the linear coefficient by K when expanding the growth term, miscalculating the quadratic equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    rN(1−NK)−H=0rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) - H = 0

  2. Step 2

    0.50N−0.50N2−300=00.50N - 0.50N^2 - 300 = 0

    Correct

    0.50N−0.505,000N2−300=0  ⟹  0.50N−0.0001N2−300=00.50N - \frac{0.50}{5{,}000}N^2 - 300 = 0 \implies 0.50N - 0.0001N^2 - 300 = 0

    When expanding rN(1−NK)rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right), the second term is −rKN2-\frac{r}{K}N^2. You forgot to divide by K=5,000K = 5{,}000, writing −0.50N2-0.50N^2 instead of −0.505,000N2=−0.0001N2-\frac{0.50}{5{,}000}N^2 = -0.0001N^2.

  3. Step 3

    0.50N2−0.50N+300=0  ⟹  N2−N+600=00.50N^2 - 0.50N + 300 = 0 \implies N^2 - N + 600 = 0

    Correct

    N2−5,000N+3,000,000=0N^2 - 5{,}000N + 3{,}000{,}000 = 0

    This simplification follows algebraically from your previous line, but it carries forward the missing carrying capacity factor KK.

  4. Step 4

    Discriminant=(−1)2−4(1)(600)=1−2400=−2399  ⟹  No real equilibrium population size exists\text{Discriminant} = (-1)^2 - 4(1)(600) = 1 - 2400 = -2399 \implies \text{No real equilibrium population size exists}

    Correct

    N∗=5,000+5,0002−4(1)(3,000,000)2≈4,314 individualsN^* = \frac{5{,}000 + \sqrt{5{,}000^2 - 4(1)(3{,}000{,}000)}}{2} \approx 4{,}314\text{ individuals}

    Because of the missing KK in the quadratic coefficient, your discriminant became negative, which led you to conclude that no equilibrium exists.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly established the equilibrium condition by setting the net rate of change dNdt=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0.

You correctly identified the parameters r=0.50r = 0.50 and H=300H = 300 in the governing equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of carrying capacity K in expansion

You expanded rN(1−NK)rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) as rN−rN2rN - rN^2, inadvertently leaving out the denominator KK.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Distributing across the parentheses without carrying through the fractional denominator 1K\frac{1}{K} alters the scale of density dependence by a factor of 5,0005{,}000, which drastically overstates self-limitation and artificially prevents any real roots.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the expanded terms of the logistic growth model
  • Distributing rNrN into (1−NK)\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) yields rN−rKN2rN - \frac{r}{K}N^2.

  • Always verify that the non-linear density-dependent term carries the units of rate divided by individuals: −rKN2-\frac{r}{K}N^2.

Clear denominators by multiplying the entire equation
  • Multiplying −rKN2+rN−H=0-\frac{r}{K}N^2 + rN - H = 0 by −Kr-\frac{K}{r} gives N2−KN+HKr=0N^2 - KN + \frac{HK}{r} = 0.

  • Convert the differential equation to monic standard form before calculating the discriminant to avoid arithmetic slips with small decimals.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute all parameters into the equilibrium equation: 0.50N−0.505,000N2−300=00.50N - \frac{0.50}{5{,}000}N^2 - 300 = 0.

  2. Multiply the entire equation by −5,0000.50=−10,000-\frac{5{,}000}{0.50} = -10{,}000: N2−5,000N+3,000,000=0N^2 - 5{,}000N + 3{,}000{,}000 = 0.

  3. Apply the quadratic formula: N=5,000±(−5,000)2−4(1)(3,000,000)2=5,000±13,000,0002N = \frac{5{,}000 \pm \sqrt{(-5{,}000)^2 - 4(1)(3{,}000{,}000)}}{2} = \frac{5{,}000 \pm \sqrt{13{,}000{,}000}}{2}.

  4. Evaluate the stable upper equilibrium: N∗=5,000+3,605.552≈4,314 individualsN^* = \frac{5{,}000 + 3{,}605.55}{2} \approx 4{,}314\text{ individuals}.

Final answer

N∗=4,314 individualsN^* = 4{,}314\text{ individuals} (or 4,3104{,}310 to three significant figures)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the expansion of rN(1−NK)rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) in symbolic form first, making sure the denominator KK remains under N2N^2.

  • Practice converting harvested logistic equations to standard quadratic form N2−KN+HKr=0N^2 - KN + \frac{HK}{r} = 0 before substituting numbers.

  • Check that the harvest rate HH does not exceed maximum sustainable yield (HMSY=rK4=625H_{\text{MSY}} = \frac{rK}{4} = 625), which ensures real equilibria must exist.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A fish stock exhibits logistic growth with r=0.40 year−1r = 0.40\text{ year}^{-1} and K=2,000K = 2{,}000 metric tons. A harvest of H=150 tons/yearH = 150\text{ tons/year} is removed constantly. Formulate the quadratic equation and state which of the two roots represents the new stable carrying capacity.

Answer

At equilibrium, 0.40N(1−N/2000)−150=00.40N(1 - N/2000) - 150 = 0, which simplifies to N2−2000N+750000=0N^2 - 2000N + 750000 = 0. Using the quadratic formula, N=2000±4000000−30000002=2000±10002N = \frac{2000 \pm \sqrt{4000000 - 3000000}}{2} = \frac{2000 \pm 1000}{2}. The roots are N1=500N_1 = 500 and N2=1,500N_2 = 1{,}500. The larger root represents the stable carrying capacity, so N∗=1,500 metric tonsN^* = 1{,}500\text{ metric tons} (while 500 tons500\text{ tons} is the unstable threshold).

02

A deer herd with K=1,200K = 1{,}200 and r=0.30 year−1r = 0.30\text{ year}^{-1} is harvested at H=80 individuals/yearH = 80\text{ individuals/year}. Calculate the unstable critical threshold below which the population will collapse to extinction.

Answer

Set dNdt=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0: 0.30N−0.301200N2−80=0  ⟹  N2−1200N+320000=00.30N - \frac{0.30}{1200}N^2 - 80 = 0 \implies N^2 - 1200N + 320000 = 0. Roots: N=1200±1440000−12800002=1200±1600002=1200±4002N = \frac{1200 \pm \sqrt{1440000 - 1280000}}{2} = \frac{1200 \pm \sqrt{160000}}{2} = \frac{1200 \pm 400}{2}. The roots are N1=400N_1 = 400 and N2=800N_2 = 800. The unstable threshold is the lower root: Ncrit=400 individualsN_{\text{crit}} = 400\text{ individuals}.

03

For the general constant-harvest model dNdt=rN(1−N/K)−H\frac{dN}{dt} = rN(1 - N/K) - H, derive the mathematical condition under which harvesting causes the stable carrying capacity and unstable threshold to collide into a single point, and state the maximum sustainable yield (HMSYH_{\text{MSY}}).

Answer

The equilibria satisfy N2−KN+HKr=0N^2 - KN + \frac{HK}{r} = 0. The roots coincide when the discriminant is zero: Δ=K2−4HKr=0\Delta = K^2 - \frac{4HK}{r} = 0. Solving for HH yields HMSY=rK4H_{\text{MSY}} = \frac{rK}{4}. At this harvest level, the single semi-stable equilibrium occurs at N=K2N = \frac{K}{2}. Any harvest H>rK4H > \frac{rK}{4} yields no real equilibria and drives the population to extinction.

Loading workspace…