Resources
A student investigating cell membrane thermodynamics notes that moving a hydrophilic solute from the aqueous extracellular fluid () to the cytoplasm () requires free energy. The student uses the thermodynamic equation for chemical potential , where and (). However, the student incorrectly writes and concludes that passive inward transport across the lipid bilayer is spontaneous (). Calculate the correct value of in for inward transport, state whether unassisted inward transport through the bilayer can occur spontaneously, and identify the sign convention error.
Answer and steps
Final answer
. Unassisted inward transport is non-spontaneous (endergonic). The student inverted the ratio of final to initial concentrations in the logarithmic argument: for inward transport, the final state is inside and the initial state is outside, so the ratio must be , yielding a positive that necessitates active transport.
Steps
Identify the Direction of Transport and the Thermodynamic Formula
Thermodynamic free energy changes depend on the transition from an initial state to a final state:
For inward transport across a cell membrane:
- Initial state: Solute outside the cell, with concentration .
- Final state: Solute inside the cell, with concentration .
The free energy change per mole for an uncharged solute moving across a concentration gradient is given by:
Calculate the Free Energy Change ()
Substitute the given values into the equation:
Convert to kilojoules per mole:
Determine Spontaneity and Feasibility Across the Bilayer
- Because (), the inward movement of the solute is endergonic (thermodynamically unfavorable or non-spontaneous).
- The solute is moving against its concentration gradient (from a low concentration of to a high concentration of ).
- In addition, because the solute is hydrophilic, it faces a high thermodynamic barrier when attempting to traverse the hydrophobic core of the phospholipid bilayer. Therefore, unassisted passive transport cannot occur; the cell must use an energy-consuming transport protein (active transport) to accumulate the solute inside.
Identify the Student's Sign Convention Error
- The student wrote , inadvertently inverting the concentration ratio ( instead of ).
- Since , the natural logarithm yielded an erroneous negative sign ().
- This flipped sign incorrectly suggested that movement into the cell is exergonic () and spontaneous, when in reality net passive flux naturally flows down a concentration gradient (from inside to outside).
Typical errors
01 The student forgets to convert joules to kilojoules in the final calculation, reporting the energy in J/mol instead of kJ/mol.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
(or )
Because the gas constant is given in , your arithmetic product yields . To report the value in as requested, you must divide by to get .
- Step 3
No, unassisted inward transport cannot occur spontaneously because .
- Step 4
The student inverted the numerator and denominator in the log term, using instead of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou selected the correct thermodynamic chemical potential formula for uncharged solute transport.
You evaluated the arithmetic product and natural logarithm accurately.
You correctly linked the positive sign of to non-spontaneity.
You clearly identified the inverted concentration ratio as the source of the sign convention error.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou attached the unit to a numerical value calculated directly in without dividing by .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking the base energy unit of the ideal gas constant causes calculated free energies to be expressed in joules rather than kilojoules.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check the units of the gas constant $R$
The constant outputs energy in joules (), not kilojoules ().
Always append immediately after evaluating before converting units.
- Perform the metric prefix conversion
, so .
Divide by to convert your final answer into whenever requested by the problem.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the energy in base units: .
Convert from to by dividing by : (or ).
(or )
02 The student uses Celsius directly instead of absolute temperature in Kelvin, leading to an incorrect free energy value.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You substituted directly using Celsius instead of converting the temperature to Kelvin (). Because the gas constant is expressed per kelvin, the absolute temperature scale must be used, yielding .
- Step 3
No, unassisted inward transport cannot occur spontaneously because .
- Step 4
The student placed the initial concentration in the numerator instead of the final concentration, inverting the sign of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the general chemical potential equation with final and initial concentrations in their proper positions.
You evaluated the physical meaning of correctly regarding transport spontaneity.
You accurately pinpointed that inverting the concentration ratio causes an erroneous negative sign in .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou entered the Celsius temperature directly into rather than using the absolute temperature .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisIn thermodynamic relationships where appears as an absolute quantity multiplied by the ideal gas constant , temperature must always be in Kelvin to cancel the units of .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check Temperature Units in Thermodynamic Formulas
Whenever an equation contains absolute temperature (such as or ), always convert Celsius to Kelvin via .
Inspect the units of the gas constant to verify that temperature cancels out in Kelvin before performing arithmetic.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConvert the given temperature to absolute temperature: .
Substitute and into .
Calculate the product: .
Convert to kilojoules: .
; inward transport is non-spontaneous; the error was inverting the ratio of final to initial concentrations.
03 The student misinterprets a positive ΔG as indicating spontaneity by confusing Gibbs free energy criteria with positive standard cell potential.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
Yes, unassisted inward transport can occur spontaneously because is positive.
CorrectNo, unassisted inward transport cannot occur spontaneously because (endergonic), and the hydrophilic solute cannot cross the hydrophobic core of the bilayer without transport proteins.
A process is thermodynamically spontaneous at constant temperature and pressure only when (exergonic). Because , moving the solute against its gradient is non-spontaneous and requires active transport.
- Step 3
The student wrote instead of , which inverted the ratio in the natural logarithm.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou used the correct thermodynamic formula for chemical potential across a membrane.
You computed the numerical value of accurately in .
You correctly identified that the ratio in the logarithm was inverted from destination over origin.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the thermodynamic spontaneity criterion of Gibbs free energy () with other electrochemical or physical metrics where a positive sign indicates favorability (such as standard cell potential or entropy of the universe ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Gibbs Free Energy Spontaneity Rule
A process at constant temperature and pressure is spontaneous only when (exergonic). When (endergonic), the forward process is non-spontaneous.
Always verify that transport against a concentration gradient increases free energy () and therefore cannot proceed passively or spontaneously.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCheck the sign of : since , the forward inward movement is endergonic.
Recall the fundamental thermodynamic criterion: spontaneous processes require .
Conclude that unassisted transport cannot occur spontaneously into the cell; the cell must couple this inward transport to an exergonic energy source (active transport).
No, unassisted inward transport cannot occur spontaneously because (endergonic).
Lock it in
When using in thermodynamic transport equations, what is the default unit of ?
. To express in , you must divide the result by .
Similar question
Glucose is transported from an extracellular concentration of into a muscle cell where the intracellular concentration is . Using and , calculate in for inward glucose transport and state whether it is spontaneous.
Answer
. Because , inward transport is spontaneous (exergonic down its concentration gradient).
A neutral amino acid is maintained at inside an epithelial cell and in the intestinal lumen. Calculate the minimum free energy in required to transport of the amino acid into the cell at ().
Answer
. Thus, at least of free energy is required.
A researcher measures the passive efflux (exit) of a neutral metabolite from a cell (, ) at (). Calculate in for moving of metabolite out of the cell, and explain how the ratio determines the sign of .
Answer
For outward transport, initial is inside and final is outside: . Because the final concentration is lower than the initial concentration (), the natural logarithm is negative, making (favorable downhill passive efflux).