Resources
A classical dihybrid cross between two heterozygous self-incompatible plants () yields the standard Mendelian phenotypic ratio among viable offspring when both loci assort independently. A student assumes that whenever two heterozygous parents are crossed, the probability of obtaining an offspring showing both dominant phenotypes must always remain . However, suppose the recessive allele in homozygous state () is embryonic lethal (recessive lethal), causing complete failure of seed development prior to germination, while allele has no effect on viability. Calculate the expected phenotypic ratio and the exact percentage of viable surviving seedlings that will exhibit the dominant phenotype.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Phenotypic distribution among viable seedlings: dominant- : recessive-; Expected percentage of viable seedlings showing dominant phenotype: (or )
Steps
Analyze Each Gene Locus Independently
According to the law of independent assortment, the alleles at locus and locus segregate independently during gamete formation. We can therefore analyze the inheritance of each gene separately using standard monohybrid cross probabilities.
For the cross :
- Locus :
- Locus :
Determine the Genotypes and Viability at Locus
The homozygous recessive genotype is embryonic lethal, meaning embryos with this genotype fail to develop seeds and do not germinate:
- Inviable zygotes: ( of total conceptions)
- Viable surviving seedlings: () and ()
Because individuals do not survive to become seedlings, the pool of viable seedlings consists only of and :
Both and carry at least one dominant allele . Consequently, () of all viable seedlings express the dominant phenotype.
Determine the Distribution of the Phenotype Among Survivors
Allele has no effect on viability, and the two loci assort independently. Thus, the condition of survival (carrying at least one allele) does not alter the probability distribution of alleles at locus :
- Dominant phenotype (): () + () =
- Recessive phenotype (): =
Among all viable seedlings:
- Dominant individuals:
- Recessive individuals:
This establishes the phenotypic distribution among viable seedlings as:
Combined with the locus (where all survivors are dominant for ), the full phenotypic ratio of viable seedlings is:
Calculate the Exact Percentage
The fraction of viable seedlings showing the dominant phenotype is:
Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is calculating the probability relative to all original Mendelian outcomes without adjusting the denominator. While dominant- individuals originally make up of total fertilized zygotes, only of all zygotes are viable. Normalizing to the surviving population yields (or ).
Typical errors
01 The student calculates the proportions using the total zygotic population of 16 rather than renormalizing to the 12 viable surviving offspring.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You divided by the total original zygotes () instead of renormalizing to the total surviving seedlings (). Because only seedlings germinate and survive, the fraction exhibiting the dominant phenotype is .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that homozygous recessive individuals do not survive.
You accurately determined the distribution of surviving genotypes as and .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the surviving phenotypes as part of the original 16-part zygotic Punnett square denominator rather than redefining the sample space (denominator) to include only viable, surviving seedlings.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Renormalizing Sample Space in Lethal Alleles
When a lethal allele eliminates a class of offspring before germination or birth, probabilities among survivors must use the surviving total as the denominator: .
Always sum the surviving categories first to establish your new denominator before computing percentages or probabilities.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationNumber of viable seedlings showing dominant phenotype
Fraction among surviving seedlings
Percentage
Phenotypic ratio: (or ); Percentage:
02 The student assumes embryonic lethality reduces both homozygous recessive genotypes (aa and bb), altering the viable ratio to 2:1 and reducing the dominant B frequency.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Viable A genotypes :
- Step 2
Both homozygous recessive genotypes are assumed lethal ⟹ Viable B genotypes :
CorrectAllele has no effect on viability, so viable genotypes remain .
The problem states that allele has no effect on viability. Therefore, individuals survive normally, so the distribution at locus remains standard Mendelian inheritance rather than a lethal-allele distribution.
- Step 3
Dominant B frequency ⟹ Phenotypic ratio ⟹ Viable seedlings with dominant B ⟹ Percentage
CorrectPhenotypic ratio: dominant- : recessive-; Percentage showing dominant :
Because locus is unaffected by lethality, the proportion of dominant seedlings is ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that recessive embryonic lethality eliminates the homozygous recessive class at locus .
You correctly adjusted the surviving genotype distribution for a lethal locus to a ratio.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that the lethal condition applied symmetrically to both gene loci, overlooking the specific problem condition stating that allele has no effect on viability.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Evaluate each gene locus independently
By Mendel's Law of Independent Assortment, lethality or selection acting at one locus does not alter the genotypic distribution produced at an independent locus unless explicitly linked or epistatic.
Always list each gene separately and check whether specific lethality conditions apply to locus , locus , or both before calculating phenotypic ratios.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the genotypes at locus : since allele is viable, offspring follow standard monohybrid probabilities: , , and .
Calculate the frequency of the dominant phenotype () among viable seeds: .
Express the phenotypic distribution at locus as a ratio: dominant- : recessive-.
Convert the proportion of dominant seedlings into a percentage: .
Phenotypic distribution among viable seedlings: dominant- : recessive-; Expected percentage:
03 The student mistakenly retains the 4 lethal aa classes as a distinct non-germinating phenotype in the phenotypic ratio, giving 9:3:4.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Because embryonic lethal seeds fail to germinate, they cannot be observed or counted among living seedlings. The phenotypic ratio must be normalized exclusively to surviving plants (, which reduces to ).
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly broke down the standard Mendelian dihybrid classes.
You correctly identified that the combinations containing are embryonic lethal.
You successfully renormalized the denominator to when computing the percentage of viable seedlings showing the dominant trait.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou listed the non-surviving embryonic lethal embryos as an observed phenotypic category in the ratio.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated lethal non-development as an observable phenotype alongside living seedling phenotypes, rather than removing inviable individuals entirely from the reference population when establishing phenotypic ratios among survivors.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define the Reference Population
When a prompt asks for ratios among viable offspring or seedlings, the sample space consists exclusively of surviving individuals.
Remove lethal genotypes completely from both the denominator and the ratio terms before writing the final phenotypic ratio.
- Simplify Phenotypic Ratios
Phenotypic ratios should be reduced to their simplest integer form.
Reduce to to represent the dominant- to recessive- phenotypes among survivors.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationExclude all lethal zygotes because they do not germinate into seedlings.
Compare the surviving phenotypes: 9\text{ dominant-}B\text{ (}A\_B\_\) : 3\text{ recessive-}b\text{ (}A\_bb\).
Divide by the greatest common divisor () to get the simplified phenotypic ratio of .
Phenotypic ratio of viable seedlings is (or );
Lock it in
How does an embryonic lethal genotype alter standard Mendelian probability denominators?
It eliminates that genotype before birth or germination, so you must remove those outcomes from the denominator and renormalize probabilities over only the surviving classes.
Similar question
In Manx cats, the allele for taillessness () is dominant over normal tail (), but homozygous embryos die early in development. If two tailless Manx cats () mate, what phenotypic ratio and percentage of living kittens will be tailless?
Answer
(); (or ). Living offspring consist of and , so tailless kittens represent of survivors.
In a plant species, two gene loci assort independently: . Homozygous recessive causes seed abortion before germination, while locus does not affect viability. What fraction of viable seedlings will exhibit the recessive phenotype?
Answer
(or ). Survival depends solely on carrying at least one allele (), which represents of total zygotes. Because loci and assort independently, locus retains its standard distribution among survivors, yielding with phenotype .
In mice, yellow coat color () is dominant to agouti (), but is embryonic lethal. Separately, albino () is recessive to colored coat (), with no effect on viability. In a cross between two dihybrid yellow, colored mice (), what proportion of viable offspring will be yellow and colored ()?
Answer
(or ). At locus , survivors are , so . At locus , . By independent assortment, .