Resources
In an undergraduate genetics laboratory investigation of microevolution, students maintain a population cage of polymorphic for alcohol dehydrogenase alleles: (fast) and (slow). At generation , the cage is seeded with flies showing an initial allele frequency of . The medium is supplemented with ethanol to exert strong selection. At generation , the class samples adult progeny and records the following genotype counts via gel electrophoresis: homozygous , heterozygous , and homozygous . (a) Calculate the observed allele frequencies and in the sampled generation 1 progeny. (b) Perform a Pearson's chi-square test for goodness-of-fit to determine whether the generation 1 progeny adhere to Hardy-Weinberg proportions: calculate the expected counts for each genotype, the test statistic , and evaluate significance at (critical value ). (c) State the formal statistical conclusion and the biological implication for gene frequency evolution in the ethanol environment.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) , ; (b) Expected counts: , , ; ; (c) Because (), we fail to reject the null hypothesis (); the progeny conform to Hardy-Weinberg genotype proportions despite the substantial allele frequency change from to , demonstrating that random mating within a single generation establishes genotype frequencies at reflecting the shifted allele pool.
Steps
Part (a): Calculating Observed Allele Frequencies
In a diploid population of size , each individual carries two alleles, giving a total gene pool of:
Count the occurrences of the fast allele :
- Homozygotes () carry two copies: alleles
- Heterozygotes () carry one copy: alleles
Total count of :
Therefore, the allele frequencies are:
(Alternatively, verifying directly: .)
Part (b): Chi-Square () Goodness-of-Fit Test
Under the Hardy-Weinberg null hypothesis (), genotype frequencies are predicted by the binomial expansion .
-
Calculate the expected numbers () for each genotype:
- Compute the chi-square statistic:
-
Statistical evaluation: For a single gene with two alleles tested for Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, the degrees of freedom are: where genotype classes and estimated independent parameter ().
Comparing the test statistic with the critical value at :
Part (c): Statistical Conclusion and Biological Implication
- Statistical Conclusion: Because the test statistic is strictly less than the critical value , we fail to reject the null hypothesis (). The generation 1 progeny genotype frequencies fit Hardy-Weinberg proportions.
- Biological Implication:
- Microevolution occurred: The frequency of the allele rose significantly from to due to natural selection favoring flies with higher alcohol dehydrogenase activity in an ethanol medium.
- Equilibrium restored in a single generation: Although selection altered the gene pool of the surviving parents, random union of their gametes immediately established Hardy-Weinberg genotype proportions () in the resulting generation 1 offspring. This demonstrates that a population can undergo rapid adaptive evolution while maintaining Hardy-Weinberg proportions among progeny.
Typical errors
01 The student calculates the expected genotype counts using the initial generation 0 allele frequency p₀ = 0.200 instead of the generation 1 allele frequencies p₁ = 0.300.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
When testing whether a cohort conforms to Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, you must calculate expected genotype counts using that specific cohort's own allele frequencies (). Using the ancestral tests whether allele frequencies remained constant over time, rather than testing whether the current generation's genotypes are in binomial proportions ().
- Step 3Correct
Your arithmetic was internally consistent with your values, but the test statistic was artificially inflated due to using incorrect expected counts.
- Step 4Correct
Because the true test statistic is , we fail to reject the null hypothesis. A single generation of random mating establishes Hardy-Weinberg proportions among progeny according to the newly shifted gene pool.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted the total allele pool as .
You successfully computed the observed allele frequencies and .
You accurately applied the Pearson chi-square formula to the expected counts you generated.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted the initial parental generation allele frequency into the expected genotype formula instead of using the generation 1 frequency .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated two distinct biological concepts: (1) whether allele frequencies changed across generations due to natural selection, and (2) whether genotypes in the offspring generation conform to Hardy-Weinberg proportions given the parental gamete frequencies. A Hardy-Weinberg goodness-of-fit test evaluates binomial pairing of alleles within a specific generation, requiring that generation's estimated allele frequencies ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify the Target Generation for HWE
Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium tests if genotypes equal within a given cohort.
Always estimate and directly from the genotype counts of the specific generation or sample being tested.
- Distinguish Microevolution from HWE Proportions
Selection changes allele frequencies between generations (), but one generation of random mating immediately restores genotype proportions () in the progeny.
Do not use ancestral or pre-selection allele frequencies when calculating expected progeny genotype counts.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the expected counts for generation 1 using and : , , .
Evaluate the test statistic: .
Compare with the critical threshold : because , fail to reject .
Conclude that the progeny conform to Hardy-Weinberg genotype proportions reflecting the shifted allele frequencies.
(a) , ; (b) Expected counts are , , , yielding ; (c) Fail to reject ; the progeny fit Hardy-Weinberg proportions because random mating in generation 1 distributed genotypes in binomial proportions based on the new allele pool.
02 The student miscalculates allele frequency p₁ by dividing the count of homozygous Adh^F/Adh^F individuals plus heterozygotes directly by the total number of individuals instead of counting individual alleles.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Total flies = 200 ⟹ p_1 = = = 0.51 ⟹ q_1 = 1 - 0.51 = 0.49
Correctp_1 = = = 0.300 ⟹ q_1 = 1 - 0.300 = 0.700
You calculated the proportion of individuals carrying at least one allele rather than the frequency of the allele itself. Because each diploid fly carries two alleles, the total gene pool contains alleles, and homozygotes contribute two copies each.
- Step 2
p^2 = (0.51)^2 = 0.2601, 2pq = 2(0.51)(0.49) = 0.4998, q^2 = (0.49)^2 = 0.2401 ⟹ E(FF) = 200 0.2601 = 52.02, E(FS) = 200 0.4998 = 99.96, E(SS) = 200 0.2401 = 48.02
CorrectE(FF) = 200(0.300)^2 = 18.0 ⟹ E(FS) = 200(2)(0.300)(0.700) = 84.0 ⟹ E(SS) = 200(0.700)^2 = 98.0
You applied the Hardy-Weinberg expected frequency formulas , , and correctly, but your expected counts were shifted because they relied on the miscalculated allele frequencies.
- Step 3
^2 = + + = 76.82 ⟹ ^2 = 76.82 > 3.841,
Correct^2 = + + = 0.000 < 3.841
Your chi-square summation formula and comparison against the critical value were mathematically accurate, but the large test statistic was an artifact of the incorrect expected values.
- Step 4
Reject Hardy-Weinberg proportions because ^2 = 76.82 exceeds 3.841. Selection by ethanol has caused a significant departure from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium in generation 1.
CorrectFail to reject H_0 because ^2 = 0.000 < 3.841. Generation 1 conforms to Hardy-Weinberg genotype proportions despite the allele frequency shift from p_0 = 0.200 to p_1 = 0.300, because random mating among surviving parents restores binomial genotype proportions in a single generation.
Your conclusion logically followed your computed test statistic, but with the correct expected counts, the observed counts match Hardy-Weinberg proportions exactly.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the complement relationship to find the alternative allele frequency.
You correctly set up the binomial genotype expansion , , and and multiplied by the sample size to obtain expected counts.
You accurately structured and calculated the chi-square goodness-of-fit formula and compared it against the critical threshold .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated diploid individuals as single-allele units by dividing genotype counts by instead of counting copies across the gene pool of alleles.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Allele Counting in Diploids
For a diploid population of individuals, the total number of alleles is . Each homozygote carries copies and each heterozygote carries copy.
Always set the denominator to and double the homozygous count when calculating allele frequencies: .
- Selection vs. Equilibrium
Natural selection during a parental generation changes allele frequencies (), but one generation of subsequent random mating immediately generates offspring genotype frequencies in Hardy-Weinberg proportions ().
Distinguish between allele frequency change across generations (microevolution) and deviation from Hardy-Weinberg proportions among progeny within a generation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCount alleles in the gene pool: total alleles.
Calculate : , and .
Calculate expected numbers: , , .
Calculate chi-square: .
Evaluate at : , so fail to reject .
(a) , ; (b) , , , ; (c) Fail to reject ; the offspring conform to Hardy-Weinberg proportions, showing that random mating establishes equilibrium proportions in one generation even when selection shifts allele frequencies from to .
03 The student wrongly concludes that microevolution has not occurred because the observed genotype counts adhere to Hardy-Weinberg proportions.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
Microevolution did occur because the allele frequency changed from to due to selection; random mating among survivors restores Hardy-Weinberg genotype proportions () in a single generation.
You equated fitting Hardy-Weinberg genotype proportions in offspring with an absence of evolution, missing that microevolution is defined by changes in allele frequencies across generations.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted alleles from genotype counts and determined the generation 1 allele frequencies.
You accurately calculated expected Hardy-Weinberg counts and the chi-square statistic.
You drew the correct statistical conclusion by failing to reject the null hypothesis at .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo computational slip occurred; your quantitative work is entirely correct.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that because the offspring cohort's genotypes match the binomial proportions , the population must be in static evolutionary equilibrium. In reality, microevolution is defined as any change in allele frequencies over time (). When surviving adults mate randomly, one generation of random union of gametes immediately re-establishes Hardy-Weinberg genotype proportions relative to the new, shifted allele frequencies.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Definition of Microevolution
Microevolution is defined as a change in allele frequencies in a population's gene pool over successive generations ().
Compare allele frequencies between consecutive generations ( vs. ) rather than relying solely on genotype ratios within a single generation.
- Single-Generation Return to Hardy-Weinberg Proportions
Under random mating, any diploid gene pool forms zygotes in the proportions after just one generation, regardless of prior selection on the parental generation.
Recognize that conformity to in progeny only demonstrates random mating of the parents, not the absence of past natural selection.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationNote the shift in the allele frequency from generation 0 () to generation 1 ().
Recognize that this directional increase demonstrates microevolution via natural selection favoring in ethanol.
Explain that random mating among the selected parents produces offspring genotypes conforming to within a single generation.
(c) We fail to reject because (); the progeny adhere to Hardy-Weinberg proportions. Biologically, microevolution did occur because the allele frequency rose substantially from to due to natural selection in the ethanol medium, while random mating in generation 0 established Hardy-Weinberg genotype proportions in generation 1 reflecting the newly shifted allele pool.
Lock it in
When performing a chi-square goodness-of-fit test for Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium on a specific sample, which allele frequencies must you use to compute expected genotype counts?
Use the allele frequencies calculated directly from that sample (), never frequencies from an ancestral generation.
Similar question
A population of beetles has initial allele frequencies . After a pesticide application, surviving parents produce offspring with genotype counts: , , and . Calculate the observed allele frequency in the offspring and state the expected count for heterozygotes () under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium.
Answer
and .
Key steps:
- Total alleles .
- , .
- Expected heterozygotes .
In a population of plants, an herbivore outbreak shifts allele frequencies. A sample of seedlings is genotyped: , , and . Test whether this seedling cohort is in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium at (critical value ) by calculating , expected genotype counts, and the test statistic .
Answer
, conforming to Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium.
Key steps:
- , .
- Expected counts: , , .
- . Fail to reject .
An initial population of moths has . Following industrial soot deposition, selection shifts the allele frequency in breeding adults to . They mate randomly to produce progeny. (i) Calculate the expected progeny genotype counts under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium. (ii) Explain why comparing observed progeny to expectations based on tests directional evolution rather than Hardy-Weinberg genotype assembly.
Answer
(i) , , . (ii) Using tests the null hypothesis that allele frequencies did not change between generations (testing for evolutionary change). In contrast, an HWE goodness-of-fit test evaluates whether random mating combined alleles in binomial proportions () within the current gene pool, which strictly requires using .
Key steps:
- .
- .
- .