Resources

Two diverging populations of pocket gophers meet along a secondary contact boundary. Fitness assays reveal that hybrid individuals suffer from Dobzhansky-Muller incompatibilities: while parental homozygotes A1A1B1B1A_1A_1B_1B_1 and A2A2B2B2A_2A_2B_2B_2 have relative fitness w=1.00w = 1.00, the F1F_1 hybrid genotype A1A2B1B2A_1A_2B_1B_2 has relative fitness whybrid=0.65w_{\text{hybrid}} = 0.65. For reinforcement to actively drive the evolution of prezygotic assortative mating, the selection coefficient against hybridization must exceed the critical threshold defined by the migration-selection equilibrium scrit=4m1+2ms_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4m}{1 + 2m}. If the local inter-population migration rate is measured at m=0.055m = 0.055, calculate the numerical difference between the actual selection coefficient against hybrids (s=1−whybrids = 1 - w_{\text{hybrid}}) and the critical threshold scrits_{\text{crit}}. State whether reinforcement can proceed at this boundary.

Answer and steps

Final answer

s−scrit=0.152s - s_{\text{crit}} = 0.152 (s=0.350s = 0.350, scrit=0.198s_{\text{crit}} = 0.198); Reinforcement can proceed because s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}}.

Steps

01

Calculate the actual selection coefficient against hybrids (ss)

The selection coefficient against hybrids, denoted as ss, measures the proportionate reduction in fitness of the hybrid genotype relative to the optimal parental genotypes:

s=1−whybrids = 1 - w_{\text{hybrid}}

Given that the parental homozygotes have a relative fitness of w=1.00w = 1.00 and the F1F_1 hybrids have a relative fitness of whybrid=0.65w_{\text{hybrid}} = 0.65:

s=1−0.65=0.350s = 1 - 0.65 = 0.350


02

Calculate the critical threshold selection coefficient (scrits_{\text{crit}})

Reinforcement requires natural selection against postzygotic hybrids to be strong enough to overcome the homogenizing effect of gene flow (migration). The critical threshold selection coefficient under migration-selection balance is given by:

scrit=4m1+2ms_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4m}{1 + 2m}

Substitute the given inter-population migration rate m=0.055m = 0.055:

scrit=4(0.055)1+2(0.055)=0.2201+0.110=0.2201.110≈0.198s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4(0.055)}{1 + 2(0.055)} = \frac{0.220}{1 + 0.110} = \frac{0.220}{1.110} \approx 0.198


03

Find the difference and evaluate if reinforcement can proceed

Compute the numerical difference between the observed selection coefficient ss and the critical threshold scrits_{\text{crit}}:

s−scrit=0.350−0.198=0.152s - s_{\text{crit}} = 0.350 - 0.198 = 0.152

Because s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}} (the difference is positive, 0.152>00.152 > 0), selection against the unfit hybrid genotypes is sufficiently strong to overcome gene flow. Therefore, reinforcement can proceed to favor prezygotic isolation mechanisms along this secondary contact zone.

(Common Pitfall: Confusing hybrid fitness whybridw_{\text{hybrid}} with the selection coefficient ss. Remember that lower hybrid fitness means a higher selection coefficient against hybridization, since s=1−whybrids = 1 - w_{\text{hybrid}}.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies the relative fitness w_hybrid as the selection coefficient s instead of computing 1 - w_hybrid, resulting in an incorrect difference.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    s=0.65s = 0.65

    Correct

    s=1−whybrid=1−0.65=0.350s = 1 - w_{\text{hybrid}} = 1 - 0.65 = 0.350

    You set the selection coefficient ss equal to the relative fitness whybrid=0.65w_{\text{hybrid}} = 0.65. The selection coefficient measures the reduction in fitness relative to the parental baseline of 1.001.00, so it should be s=1−0.65=0.350s = 1 - 0.65 = 0.350.

  2. Step 2

    scrit=4(0.055)1+2(0.055)=0.221.11=0.1982s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4(0.055)}{1 + 2(0.055)} = \frac{0.22}{1.11} = 0.1982

  3. Step 3

    Difference=0.65−0.1982=0.4518\text{Difference} = 0.65 - 0.1982 = 0.4518

    Correct

    s−scrit=0.350−0.198=0.152s - s_{\text{crit}} = 0.350 - 0.198 = 0.152

    Your arithmetic subtraction followed the correct structure, but the resulting difference was shifted because of the incorrect value of ss from Step 1.

  4. Step 4

    Reinforcement can proceed because s exceeds scrit.\text{Reinforcement can proceed because } s \text{ exceeds } s_{\text{crit}}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the critical threshold selection coefficient scrits_{\text{crit}} using the migration rate.

You correctly applied the conceptual criterion that reinforcement proceeds when s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflation of relative fitness and selection coefficient

You substituted relative fitness ww in place of the selection coefficient ss.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked the complementary relationship between fitness and selection (s=1−ws = 1 - w), treating survival/reproductive success (ww) as the penalty against hybridization (ss).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Fitness vs. Selection Coefficient
  • Relative fitness ww and selection coefficient ss are complementary: s=1−ws = 1 - w.

  • Always subtract the genotype's relative fitness from the optimal standard (1.001.00) before comparing against critical thresholds.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the selection coefficient against hybrids: s=1−whybrid=1−0.65=0.350s = 1 - w_{\text{hybrid}} = 1 - 0.65 = 0.350.

  2. Compute the difference between actual selection and the critical threshold: s−scrit=0.350−0.198=0.152s - s_{\text{crit}} = 0.350 - 0.198 = 0.152.

  3. Compare ss and scrits_{\text{crit}}: since 0.350>0.1980.350 > 0.198, the selection coefficient exceeds the threshold.

Final answer

s−scrit=0.152s - s_{\text{crit}} = 0.152; Reinforcement can proceed because s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice distinguishing genotype fitness values (ww) from selection coefficients (ss) across population genetics formulas.

  • Recalculate differences using the complementary value s=1−ws = 1 - w to ensure arithmetic precision.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student omits the factor of 2 in the denominator when calculating the critical threshold, using 1 + m instead of 1 + 2m.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    s=1−0.65=0.35s = 1 - 0.65 = 0.35

  2. Step 2

    scrit=4(0.055)1+0.055=0.221.055=0.2085s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4(0.055)}{1 + 0.055} = \frac{0.22}{1.055} = 0.2085

    Correct

    scrit=4m1+2m=4(0.055)1+2(0.055)=0.2201.110≈0.198s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4m}{1 + 2m} = \frac{4(0.055)}{1 + 2(0.055)} = \frac{0.220}{1.110} \approx 0.198

    You omitted the factor of 22 multiplying mm in the denominator, substituting 1+m1 + m instead of 1+2m1 + 2m.

  3. Step 3

    Difference=0.35−0.2085=0.1415\text{Difference} = 0.35 - 0.2085 = 0.1415

    Correct

    s−scrit=0.350−0.198=0.152s - s_{\text{crit}} = 0.350 - 0.198 = 0.152

    Your subtraction followed directly from your calculated value of scrits_{\text{crit}}, but the result was shifted by the earlier formula substitution error.

  4. Step 4

    Reinforcement can proceed because s exceeds scrit.\text{Reinforcement can proceed because } s \text{ exceeds } s_{\text{crit}}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the selection coefficient against hybrids using s=1−whybrids = 1 - w_{\text{hybrid}}.

You correctly understood that reinforcement can proceed when s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula Substitution Slip

You wrote the denominator as 1+m1 + m rather than 1+2m1 + 2m, dropping the coefficient 22.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the multiplier of migration rate mm in the denominator of the migration-selection equilibrium formula leads to an overestimated threshold scrits_{\text{crit}}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Verify Formula Structure
  • The critical threshold under migration-selection balance is scrit=4m1+2ms_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4m}{1 + 2m}.

  • Double-check that all coefficients in the formula, especially the 22 multiplying mm in the denominator, are included before calculating.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute m=0.055m = 0.055 into the full formula: scrit=4(0.055)1+2(0.055)=0.2201.110≈0.198s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4(0.055)}{1 + 2(0.055)} = \frac{0.220}{1.110} \approx 0.198.

  2. Subtract the corrected threshold from ss: s−scrit=0.350−0.198=0.152s - s_{\text{crit}} = 0.350 - 0.198 = 0.152.

Final answer

s−scrit=0.152s - s_{\text{crit}} = 0.152; Reinforcement can proceed because s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Carefully re-copy the denominator 1+2m1 + 2m with parentheses around 2m2m when plugging in values.

  • Practice computing migration-selection thresholds with various migration rates to solidify formula familiarity.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student reverses the condition for reinforcement, believing reinforcement requires gene flow to overcome selection (s < s_crit) rather than selection overcoming gene flow.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    s=1−0.65=0.35s = 1 - 0.65 = 0.35

  2. Step 2

    scrit=4(0.055)1+2(0.055)=0.221.11=0.1982s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4(0.055)}{1 + 2(0.055)} = \frac{0.22}{1.11} = 0.1982

  3. Step 3

    Difference=0.35−0.1982=0.1518\text{Difference} = 0.35 - 0.1982 = 0.1518

  4. Step 4

    Reinforcement cannot proceed because ss exceeds scrits_{\text{crit}} instead of being smaller.

    Correct

    Reinforcement can proceed because s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}}.

    Reinforcement requires selection against hybrids to be stronger than the homogenizing force of gene flow (s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}}). Because s=0.35>0.198s = 0.35 > 0.198, reinforcement can proceed.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the hybrid selection coefficient s=0.35s = 0.35.

You evaluated the critical migration-selection threshold scrit≈0.198s_{\text{crit}} \approx 0.198 accurately.

You correctly computed the difference between the selection coefficient and the threshold.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed Evolutionary Condition

You stated that reinforcement requires s<scrits < s_{\text{crit}} rather than s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the biological role of natural selection versus migration in reinforcement. Gene flow (migration) acts to homogenize populations and breaks down linkage disequilibrium, whereas selection against unfit hybrids favors individuals that mate assortatively. Therefore, selection against hybrids must overpower gene flow (s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}}), not yield to it.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Selection Versus Gene Flow in Reinforcement
  • For reinforcement to evolve prezygotic isolation, disruptive selection against unfit hybrids must be strong enough to overcome the homogenizing effect of gene flow (s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}}).

  • Check whether selection against hybrids exceeds the threshold dictated by gene flow (s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}}) before concluding whether reinforcement can proceed.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the observed selection coefficient s=0.350s = 0.350 with the threshold scrit≈0.198s_{\text{crit}} \approx 0.198.

  2. Because s=0.350>0.198=scrits = 0.350 > 0.198 = s_{\text{crit}}, natural selection against hybrids outweighs the gene flow introduced by migration.

Final answer

s−scrit≈0.152s - s_{\text{crit}} \approx 0.152; Reinforcement can proceed because s>scrits > s_{\text{crit}}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how migration-selection balance governs the reinforcement of reproductive isolation at hybrid zones.

  • Practice writing down the ecological and genetic conditions under which prezygotic isolation evolves before plugging in numerical values.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two plant species meet in a hybrid zone with gene flow rate m=0.04m = 0.04. Hybrids display reduced seed set with relative fitness whybrid=0.78w_{\text{hybrid}} = 0.78. Using the critical threshold scrit=4m1+2ms_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4m}{1 + 2m}, determine ss, scrits_{\text{crit}}, and state whether reinforcement can occur.

Answer

s=1−0.78=0.220s = 1 - 0.78 = 0.220. scrit=4(0.04)1+2(0.04)=0.161.08≈0.148s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4(0.04)}{1 + 2(0.04)} = \frac{0.16}{1.08} \approx 0.148. Because s=0.220>scrit=0.148s = 0.220 > s_{\text{crit}} = 0.148, reinforcement can occur.

02

In a hybrid zone of spadefoot toads, m=0.08m = 0.08. Laboratory crosses reveal hybrid relative fitness whybrid=0.75w_{\text{hybrid}} = 0.75. Calculate the difference s−scrits - s_{\text{crit}} and evaluate if prezygotic isolation will be reinforced by natural selection.

Answer

s=1−0.75=0.250s = 1 - 0.75 = 0.250. scrit=4(0.08)1+2(0.08)=0.321.16≈0.276s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4(0.08)}{1 + 2(0.08)} = \frac{0.32}{1.16} \approx 0.276. Difference: s−scrit=0.250−0.276=−0.026s - s_{\text{crit}} = 0.250 - 0.276 = -0.026. Because s<scrits < s_{\text{crit}}, gene flow overwhelms selection against hybrids, so reinforcement cannot proceed.

03

Two warbler populations hybridize along a river basin. Inter-population migration is m=0.06m = 0.06. What is the minimum relative fitness reduction (selection coefficient ss) required for reinforcement to proceed, and what is the maximum hybrid relative fitness (whybridw_{\text{hybrid}}) that allows reinforcement?

Answer

scrit=4(0.06)1+2(0.06)=0.241.12≈0.214s_{\text{crit}} = \frac{4(0.06)}{1 + 2(0.06)} = \frac{0.24}{1.12} \approx 0.214. Thus, reinforcement requires s>0.214s > 0.214. Since whybrid=1−sw_{\text{hybrid}} = 1 - s, the maximum hybrid fitness is whybrid<1−0.214=0.786w_{\text{hybrid}} < 1 - 0.214 = 0.786.

Loading workspace…