Resources
A genetics laboratory analyzes whether a dihybrid cross of fruit flies (Drosophila melanogaster) involving body color (, ) and wing morphology (, ) conforms to Mendel's Law of Independent Assortment. Heterozygous females () are test-crossed to homozygous recessive males (). A total of offspring are scored:
- Gray body, normal wings ():
- Black body, vestigial wings ():
- Gray body, vestigial wings ():
- Black body, normal wings ():
Perform a chi-square () goodness-of-fit test against the null hypothesis () of independent assortment:
- State the expected offspring counts for each phenotypic class under and calculate the degrees of freedom ().
- Calculate the sample statistic to three significant figures.
- Given the critical boundary values for significance level ( for ; for ), state the statistical conclusion (using correct formal phrasing regarding ).
- Formulate the definitive biological explanation supported by this threshold evidence, calculating the map distance between the loci in centimorgans ().
Answer and steps
Final answer
- Under of independent assortment ( ratio), expected count for each class is ; . 2. . 3. Because (), we reject the null hypothesis (). 4. The biological explanation is that the genes for body color and wing shape are linked on the same autosome (Chromosome 2). Recombinant offspring total . The recombination frequency is , establishing an empirical map distance of .
Steps
Part 1: Expected Offspring Counts and Degrees of Freedom
Under Mendel's Law of Independent Assortment, the null hypothesis () states that the two gene loci assort independently into gametes. In a two-point testcross between a heterozygous female () and a homozygous recessive male (), the male provides only recessive alleles (). Therefore, the phenotypes of the offspring directly reflect the maternal gametes produced.
Under independent assortment, the female produces four gametic combinations in an equal ratio:
With a total of offspring across phenotypic classes:
- Expected count per phenotypic class ():
- Degrees of freedom ():
Part 2: Chi-Square () Test Statistic Calculation
The chi-square statistic is given by:
Substitute the observed () and expected () values for all four phenotypic classes:
Compute the squared deviations:
- Gray, normal:
- Black, vestigial:
- Gray, vestigial:
- Black, normal:
Sum the squared deviations and divide by :
Rounded to three significant figures:
Part 3: Statistical Evaluation and Conclusion
- Calculated statistic:
- Critical value at for :
Because the calculated test statistic far exceeds the critical threshold (, corresponding to ), we reject the null hypothesis (). The deviation from the expected ratio is statistically significant and cannot be attributed to random chance.
Part 4: Biological Explanation and Genetic Map Distance
Biological Explanation
Because the null hypothesis of independent assortment is rejected, the genes for body color () and wing morphology () do not assort independently; they are genetically linked on the same chromosome (specifically, autosome 2 in Drosophila melanogaster).
The two most abundant phenotypic classes represent the parental (non-recombinant) phenotypes (), inherited directly without crossing over. The two rare phenotypic classes represent the recombinant phenotypes (), resulting from homologous crossing over between the two gene loci during prophase I of female meiosis.
Map Distance Calculation
The recombination frequency () provides an empirical estimate of the physical proximity between the two gene loci:
By definition, recombination frequency equals (or map unit):
Typical errors
01 A student incorrectly assumes degrees of freedom equals the number of phenotypic classes (df = 4) instead of k - 1, leading to comparing against the wrong critical value.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Expected ratio under is Expected counts: per class
CorrectExpected counts: per class;
You correctly determined that each of the four phenotypic classes has an expected count of . However, degrees of freedom for a goodness-of-fit test is calculated as , where is the number of phenotypic categories, so rather than .
- Step 2
- Step 3
for Reject
CorrectBecause (for at ), reject .
Your final decision to reject is correct, but you evaluated it using the critical value for () because of your earlier slip. With the correct , you should compare against .
- Step 4
The genes are linked on the same chromosome. Recombinant offspring Map distance
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the expected ratio and computed the expected count of per class.
You accurately calculated each squared deviation and summed them to find .
You correctly identified the recombinant offspring classes and converted the recombination frequency into centimorgans.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou equated the degrees of freedom directly to the total number of categories () instead of subtracting one for the fixed sample size constraint ().
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the number of phenotypic classes () with the number of independent values that are free to vary (). Because the total count across all categories must sum to , once three category counts are known, the fourth is completely determined.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Degrees of freedom rule for goodness-of-fit
For a standard single-variable goodness-of-fit test with mutually exclusive phenotypic categories, .
Count your categories () and always subtract because the fixed total sample size imposes one mathematical constraint.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate degrees of freedom: .
Select the critical threshold corresponding to at , which is .
Compare the test statistic: because , reject the null hypothesis of independent assortment.
- Expected count per class; . 2. . 3. Reject because . 4. The genes are linked on the same chromosome; map distance is .
02 A student misidentifies the parental classes as recombinants when calculating map distance, resulting in a complementary map distance of 76.7 cM.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Expected ratio under Expected count for each class
- Step 2
- Step 3
- Step 4
The genes are linked on the same chromosome.
- Step 5Correct
You summed the two highest frequency classes ( and ), which represent the non-crossover parental types, rather than the low-frequency crossover recombinant classes ( and ). A two-point recombination frequency cannot exceed .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou calculated the expected offspring numbers and degrees of freedom accurately.
You performed the chi-square summation correctly to arrive at .
You stated the correct formal conclusion rejecting the null hypothesis of independent assortment.
You recognized that significant deviation from independent assortment implies autosomal gene linkage.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused parental (non-recombinant) phenotypic classes with recombinant classes. In a linkage testcross, the parental classes are always the most frequent because crossing over occurs in only a subset of meiotic events, meaning recombinants are always the minority classes and recombination frequency cannot exceed .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify Majority vs. Minority Classes
In any two-point testcross involving linked genes, parental gametes do not require crossing over and therefore always constitute of offspring, while recombinant gametes arise from crossing over and constitute .
Sort phenotypic counts in descending order: the two largest classes are parental, and the two smallest classes are recombinant.
- 50% Boundary Check for Map Distance
A standard two-point recombination frequency cannot exceed ().
If your calculated map distance is greater than , check whether you accidentally calculated the non-recombinant (parental) frequency instead.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify recombinant phenotypes by finding the two minority classes: gray body, vestigial wings () and black body, normal wings ().
Sum the recombinant offspring: .
Compute the recombination frequency: .
Convert recombination frequency directly to map units: .
The genes are linked on the same chromosome with an empirical map distance of .
03 A student applies the 9:3:3:1 F2 dihybrid phenotypic ratio instead of the 1:1:1:1 test-cross ratio to determine expected counts under the null hypothesis.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Under , expected ratio is ⟹ Expected counts: ⟹
CorrectExpected ratio under is ⟹ Expected counts: ⟹
You correctly found , but this cross is a testcross (), not an self-cross. The homozygous recessive tester parent produces only recessive gametes, so under independent assortment, the expected phenotypic ratio is , giving expected individuals per class.
- Step 2Correct
You carried out the summation arithmetic correctly according to your numbers, but your calculation inherited the incorrect expected values from Step 1.
- Step 3
⟹ Reject
- Step 4
The genes are linked on the same chromosome. ⟹ Recombinant offspring ⟹ Map distance
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the degrees of freedom as .
You accurately identified recombinant progeny and calculated the map distance in centimorgans.
You stated the correct biological interpretation that the two gene loci are linked on the same chromosome.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the expected phenotypic ratio of a two-point testcross () with the phenotypic ratio of a dihybrid cross (). Because the homozygous recessive parent contributes only recessive alleles, offspring phenotypes directly display maternal gamete frequencies, which assort in an equal ratio under Mendel's second law.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Cross Type Identification
An organism crossed with a homozygous double recessive individual () is a testcross, yielding a baseline ratio under independent assortment.
Check the genotype of the second parent: if it is homozygous recessive (), set expected proportions to each, not .
- Calculating Expected Counts in Goodness-of-Fit
For equally likely testcross classes, .
Divide the total sample size by 4 to get equal expected values across all phenotypic classes before computing .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the cross as a testcross: .
Under (independent assortment), the four maternal gametes (, , , ) occur with equal frequency ( each).
Compute expected count for each class: .
Recalculate .
Expected counts are per class (); ; reject ; genes are linked with a map distance of .
Lock it in
How do you calculate degrees of freedom () for a standard chi-square () goodness-of-fit test with phenotypic classes?
. One degree of freedom is lost because the category counts must sum to the fixed total sample size .
Similar question
A trihybrid testcross () results in distinct phenotypic classes of offspring. State the degrees of freedom () that should be used for a chi-square goodness-of-fit test of independent assortment.
Answer
. In a chi-square goodness-of-fit test, , where is the number of phenotypic classes. Here, , so .
A geneticist performs a monohybrid cross yielding total offspring in phenotypic classes (ratio ). If the calculated statistic is , and critical values for are () and (), state the degrees of freedom and whether the null hypothesis should be rejected.
Answer
; Reject . With classes, . Comparing the calculated to the critical value for (), since , we reject the null hypothesis.
In a dihybrid testcross of tomato plants involving fruit shape and color, progeny are scored across phenotypic classes: parental type 1, parental type 2, recombinant type 1, and recombinant type 2. Calculate the recombination frequency and map distance between the two gene loci.
Answer
Recombination frequency is and map distance is . Total recombinants . Recombination frequency . Since recombination corresponds to , the map distance is .