Resources
An isolated population of meadow voles occupies a woodland plot, while a second population of voles occupies an identical plot with the same total resource base. Over a three-month observation period, an outbreak of a fungal pathogen causes deaths in the first plot and deaths in the second plot. During the same period, an early severe frost kills voles in the first plot and voles in the second plot. (a) Calculate the per capita mortality rate (as a percentage) attributable to the fungal infection in each plot, and classify the fungal infection as density-dependent or density-independent. (b) Calculate the per capita mortality rate attributable to the frost in each plot, and classify the frost event.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Fungal mortality: Plot 1 is , Plot 2 is ; density-dependent factor because per capita mortality increases with population density. (b) Frost mortality: Plot 1 is , Plot 2 is ; density-independent factor because per capita mortality remains constant regardless of population density.
Steps
Understanding Density-Dependent vs. Density-Independent Factors
To classify an ecological factor affecting mortality, examine its per capita mortality rate (the fraction or percentage of the population killed), rather than just the absolute number of deaths:
- Density-dependent factors: The per capita mortality rate changes as population density changes (typically increasing as density increases, due to factors like disease transmission, competition, or predation).
- Density-independent factors: The per capita mortality rate remains constant regardless of population density (typically physical or abiotic factors like severe weather, fire, or floods).
Part (a): Fungal Pathogen Mortality
-
Calculate Population Densities:
- Both plots have an area of .
- Plot 1 density:
- Plot 2 density:
- Plot 2 is three times denser than Plot 1.
-
Calculate Per Capita Fungal Mortality Rates:
- Plot 1:
- Plot 2:
-
Classification:
- As population density increases from to , the per capita mortality rate increases threefold from to .
- Therefore, the fungal pathogen is a density-dependent factor. Higher crowding facilitates closer contact and faster transmission of infectious pathogens.
Part (b): Frost Event Mortality
-
Calculate Per Capita Frost Mortality Rates:
- Plot 1:
- Plot 2:
-
Classification:
- Even though more individuals died in Plot 2 ( deaths vs. deaths), the proportion of the population killed is identical in both plots ().
- Because the per capita mortality rate is constant regardless of population density, the frost event is a density-independent factor. Abiotic weather events affect individuals independently of how crowded the population is.
Common Pitfall
A frequent mistake is comparing the raw number of deaths instead of the mortality percentage. In Plot 2, frost killed voles compared to in Plot 1; however, because the initial population was also three times larger, the risk per individual remained unchanged. Ecological classification always depends on the rate or proportion, not the raw count.
Typical errors
01 The student bases the classification on absolute death counts rather than per capita mortality rates, incorrectly concluding both factors are density-dependent because raw deaths are higher in the denser plot.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
While your final label of density-dependent is correct, your stated justification relies on the raw number of deaths () rather than the increase in the per capita mortality rate (). A factor is density-dependent only because the individual probability of dying changes with density.
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
A factor is density-independent when the per capita mortality rate remains constant regardless of population density. Because exactly of individuals died in both plots, each vole faced the same risk of death regardless of crowding.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly set up and calculated all four per capita mortality percentages.
You arrived at the correct classification for the fungal pathogen.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou checked which plot had more total dead animals instead of comparing the percentage mortality between plots.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou interpreted 'density-dependent' as meaning 'causes more total deaths in a larger population.' In a larger population, even a completely random abiotic event kills more total individuals simply because there are more individuals present. Ecological factors must be classified by how the proportion (per capita rate) changes with density.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Rate vs. Count Criterion
Classify factors by comparing per capita rates (percentages), never absolute death counts.
Always compare between low-density and high-density groups before deciding on dependence.
- Constant Proportion Meaning
If the per capita mortality percentage remains unchanged across different densities, the factor is density-independent.
When you observe equal percentages (such as vs. ), classify the factor as density-independent.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the per capita mortality rates across plots: and .
Notice that as vole density triples from to , the individual probability of dying from frost does not change.
Conclude that because the per capita mortality rate is unaffected by population density, the frost event is density-independent.
(a) Fungal mortality: Plot 1 is , Plot 2 is ; density-dependent factor. (b) Frost mortality: Plot 1 is , Plot 2 is ; density-independent factor.
02 The student divides the number of deaths by plot area (10 ha) rather than initial population size, confounding mortality rate with death density.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
To calculate per capita mortality rate, divide the number of deaths by the initial population size (), not by the plot area (). In addition, units of cannot be directly converted into percentages.
- Step 2Correct
Your conceptual reasoning that an increasing mortality rate indicates density dependence is correct, but your conclusion was based on death density rather than per capita mortality rate.
- Step 3Correct
You divided by the area of again instead of dividing by the population sizes and .
- Step 4Correct
Because the true per capita mortality rate is identical in both plots (), individual mortality risk does not depend on population density.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou recognized that classifying an ecological factor requires comparing mortality rates across populations of differing densities.
You correctly associated an increasing mortality rate with density-dependent regulation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou divided deaths by habitat area () instead of initial population size (), treating spatial death density () as a per capita percentage. Because Plot 2 has three times the population in the same area, dividing by area makes even density-independent mortality appear three times larger.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Per Capita Mortality Rate Definition
Always divide the number of deaths by the population count , never by habitat area or volume.
- Classifying Density Dependence
A factor is density-dependent if its per capita mortality rate changes with density, and density-independent if the per capita rate remains constant.
Compare the percentage of individuals killed, not the raw number or spatial density of deaths.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the per capita fungal mortality rate: , .
Classify the fungal pathogen: because per capita mortality increases as density increases from to , the fungal infection is density-dependent.
Calculate the per capita frost mortality rate: , .
Classify the frost event: because per capita mortality remains constant at regardless of density, the frost is density-independent.
(a) Fungal mortality: Plot 1 is , Plot 2 is ; density-dependent. (b) Frost mortality: Plot 1 is , Plot 2 is ; density-independent.
03 The student misinterprets an equal mortality rate across different densities as density-dependent regulation maintaining equal proportion.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Plot 1 fungal rate = Plot 2 fungal rate = The rate is higher in Plot 2, so fungal infection is density-dependent.
- Step 2
Plot 1 frost rate = Plot 2 frost rate =
- Step 3
The mortality rate scales proportionally to match population size, so frost is density-dependent.
CorrectBecause the per capita mortality rate is identical in both plots () despite a threefold difference in density, frost is a density-independent factor.
You noticed that the absolute death count scaled with population size, but that means the individual risk (the per capita mortality rate) remained strictly constant at . An ecological factor is density-dependent only when the rate (percentage) changes with density, not when the percentage stays fixed.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the per capita mortality percentages for both plots across both environmental events.
You properly concluded that an increase in mortality rate at higher density indicates a density-dependent factor.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the absolute number of deaths scaling with population size with density dependence. When the per capita mortality rate (percentage killed) is unaffected by density, the factor operates independently of crowding.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Evaluating Per Capita Rate vs. Density
A mortality factor is density-dependent if its per capita rate changes (usually increases) with density; it is density-independent if its per capita rate remains constant across different densities.
Always look at whether the percentage killed changes across densities, not whether the raw count of dead organisms scales with population size.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the per capita mortality rates between Plot 1 () and Plot 2 ().
Observe that density increased from to , yet the individual probability of dying from frost remained exactly .
Conclude that because the per capita mortality rate does not vary with density, frost is a density-independent factor.
(a) Fungal mortality: Plot 1 is , Plot 2 is ; density-dependent factor. (b) Frost mortality: Plot 1 is , Plot 2 is ; density-independent factor.
Lock it in
How do you determine whether an environmental factor is density-dependent or density-independent?
Compare the per capita mortality rate (percentage killed) across different population densities, not the raw number of deaths.
Similar question
A forest fire burns through two neighboring stands of pine trees. Stand A contains trees and loses . Stand B contains trees on an equal area and loses . (a) Calculate the per capita mortality rate for each stand. (b) Classify the fire as density-dependent or density-independent.
Answer
(a) Stand A: ; Stand B: . (b) Density-independent, because the per capita mortality rate () is identical regardless of tree density.
An intestinal parasite infects two fish hatcheries of identical volume. Tank 1 has fish and records deaths over a month. Tank 2 has fish and records deaths. Calculate the per capita mortality rate in each tank and classify the parasite.
Answer
Tank 1 mortality: . Tank 2 mortality: . The parasite is density-dependent because the per capita mortality rate increases significantly as population density increases.
A predatory hawk hunts ground squirrels in two pastures of identical size. In Pasture 1 (), the hawk kills squirrels. In Pasture 2 (), the hawk becomes satiated and captures a maximum of squirrels. Calculate the per capita predation rates and describe how predation risk changes with density.
Answer
Pasture 1 per capita mortality: . Pasture 2 per capita mortality: . Predation risk per individual decreases as density increases (an inversely density-dependent effect caused by predator satiation).