Resources

A population of alpine butterflies exhibits wing pigmentation controlled by two codominant alleles, CBC^B (blue) and CYC^Y (yellow), where heterozygotes CBCYC^B C^Y display a distinct green phenotype. A researcher samples 400400 butterflies and observes 144144 blue, 192192 green, and 6464 yellow individuals. Over five generations of climate warming, predatory birds disproportionately prey on the non-camouflaged morphs, altering the allele frequencies such that the new frequency of CBC^B becomes p′=0.45p' = 0.45. Assuming the surviving population of 800800 butterflies is now in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, determine: (a) the initial allele frequency f(CB)f(C^B), (b) the net change in the frequency of the yellow allele Δq=q′−q\Delta q = q' - q, and (c) the absolute ratio of heterozygous green butterflies to homozygous yellow butterflies in the new generation.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Initial f(CB)=0.60f(C^B) = 0.60; (b) Δq=+0.15\Delta q = +0.15 (from q=0.40q = 0.40 to q′=0.55q' = 0.55); (c) The ratio of green to yellow butterflies is 1.64:11.64 : 1 (or 2p′q′(q′)2=2p′q′=1811≈1.64\frac{2p'q'}{(q')^2} = \frac{2p'}{q'} = \frac{18}{11} \approx 1.64).

Steps

Part (a): Initial Allele Frequency f(CB)f(C^B)

In a diploid organism, each individual carries two alleles for a given gene. Let p=f(CB)p = f(C^B) represent the frequency of the blue allele and q=f(CY)q = f(C^Y) represent the frequency of the yellow allele.

  1. Calculate the total gene pool size: Total number of alleles=2×N=2×400=800\text{Total number of alleles} = 2 \times N = 2 \times 400 = 800
  2. Count the copies of allele CBC^B:

    • Each of the 144144 homozygous blue butterflies (CBCBC^B C^B) contributes 22 copies: 144×2=288144 \times 2 = 288.
    • Each of the 192192 heterozygous green butterflies (CBCYC^B C^Y) contributes 11 copy: 192×1=192192 \times 1 = 192.
    • Total copies of CB=288+192=480C^B = 288 + 192 = 480.
  3. Compute the frequency pp: p=f(CB)=480800=0.60p = f(C^B) = \frac{480}{800} = 0.60

(Pitfall to avoid: Do not simply divide the number of blue individuals by the total number of individuals, as heterozygotes also carry the CBC^B allele.)


Part (b): Net Change in the Frequency of the Yellow Allele (Δq\Delta q)

  1. Determine initial frequency qq: q=1−p=1−0.60=0.40q = 1 - p = 1 - 0.60 = 0.40
  2. Determine new frequency q′q' after 5 generations: Given the new frequency of the blue allele p′=0.45p' = 0.45: q′=1−p′=1−0.45=0.55q' = 1 - p' = 1 - 0.45 = 0.55
  3. Calculate the net change Δq\Delta q: Δq=q′−q=0.55−0.40=+0.15\Delta q = q' - q = 0.55 - 0.40 = +0.15

The yellow allele increased in frequency by 0.150.15 (or 15%15\%) due to directional natural selection favoring camouflage under changing climate conditions.


Part (c): Ratio of Heterozygous Green to Homozygous Yellow Butterflies

Under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium:

  • Genotype frequency of green butterflies (CBCYC^B C^Y) is 2p′q′2p'q'.
  • Genotype frequency of yellow butterflies (CYCYC^Y C^Y) is (q′)2(q')^2.
  1. Calculate the ratio using genotype frequencies: Ratio=2p′q′(q′)2=2p′q′\text{Ratio} = \frac{2p'q'}{(q')^2} = \frac{2p'}{q'}
  2. Substitute the values p′=0.45p' = 0.45 and q′=0.55q' = 0.55: 2(0.45)0.55=0.900.55=1811≈1.64\frac{2(0.45)}{0.55} = \frac{0.90}{0.55} = \frac{18}{11} \approx 1.64

(Verification via population counts: In a population of 800800, there are 2(0.45)(0.55)×800=3962(0.45)(0.55) \times 800 = 396 green butterflies and (0.55)2×800=242(0.55)^2 \times 800 = 242 yellow butterflies. The ratio is 396:242=18:11≈1.64:1396 : 242 = 18 : 11 \approx 1.64 : 1.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the initial allele frequency by taking the square root of the homozygote frequency under an unverified assumption of initial Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, and in doing so mistakenly uses the heterozygote proportion.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    p=144400  ⟹  p=0.36=0.60p = \sqrt{\frac{144}{400}} \implies p = \sqrt{0.36} = 0.60

    Correct

    p=2(144)+1922(400)=480800=0.60p = \frac{2(144) + 192}{2(400)} = \frac{480}{800} = 0.60

    You assumed Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium for the initial generation and took the square root of the homozygous blue frequency. Because alleles are codominant and all genotype counts are given, you must use direct allele counting. While your numerical answer matches because this particular sample happens to be in equilibrium, assuming equilibrium beforehand is conceptually invalid.

  2. Step 2

    q=1−0.60=0.40  ⟹  q′=1−0.45=0.55  ⟹  Δq=0.55−0.40=+0.15q = 1 - 0.60 = 0.40 \implies q' = 1 - 0.45 = 0.55 \implies \Delta q = 0.55 - 0.40 = +0.15

  3. Step 3

    Green=2p′q′=2(0.45)(0.55)=0.495  ⟹  Yellow=q′2=(0.55)2=0.3025  ⟹  Ratio=0.4950.3025=1811≈1.64\text{Green} = 2p'q' = 2(0.45)(0.55) = 0.495 \implies \text{Yellow} = q'^2 = (0.55)^2 = 0.3025 \implies \text{Ratio} = \frac{0.495}{0.3025} = \frac{18}{11} \approx 1.64

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the complement rule p+q=1p + q = 1 to find allele frequencies.

You accurately calculated the net shift in allele frequency Δq=+0.15\Delta q = +0.15.

You applied the Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium formulas correctly to the surviving generation to find the phenotypic ratio.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unjustified Hardy-Weinberg assumption

You took the square root of the homozygote frequency under an unverified assumption of equilibrium instead of counting alleles directly.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating situations where Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium must be assumed (complete dominance with hidden heterozygotes) with situations where all genotypes are directly observable (codominance or incomplete dominance).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direct Allele Counting vs. Square Root Method
  • When every genotype is phenotypically distinct (codominance/incomplete dominance), calculate allele frequency using direct allele counting: p=2Nhomo+Nhet2Ntotalp = \frac{2N_{homo} + N_{het}}{2N_{total}}.

  • Check whether heterozygotes are identifiable before assuming Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium. Never take frequency\sqrt{\text{frequency}} unless equilibrium is explicitly stated or unavoidable due to complete dominance.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Count the total copies of allele CBC^B: homozygous blue butterflies carry 22 copies (144×2=288144 \times 2 = 288), and heterozygous green butterflies carry 11 copy (192×1=192192 \times 1 = 192), giving 288+192=480288 + 192 = 480 copies.

  2. Calculate the total number of alleles in the diploid gene pool: 2×400=8002 \times 400 = 800.

  3. Divide the copies of CBC^B by the total pool size: p=480800=0.60p = \frac{480}{800} = 0.60.

Final answer

(a) f(CB)=0.60f(C^B) = 0.60; (b) Δq=+0.15\Delta q = +0.15; (c) 1811≈1.64:1\frac{18}{11} \approx 1.64 : 1

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always check whether phenotype allows direct identification of heterozygotes before applying equilibrium formulas.

  • Practice identifying when a population is merely an observed sample versus when it is explicitly given as being in Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student subtracts the new frequency from the initial frequency instead of subtracting initial from final, resulting in an inverted sign for the net change.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Total alleles=2×400=800  ⟹  f(CB)=2×144+192800=480800=0.60\text{Total alleles} = 2 \times 400 = 800 \implies f(C^B) = \frac{2 \times 144 + 192}{800} = \frac{480}{800} = 0.60

  2. Step 2

    q=1−0.60=0.40  ⟹  q′=1−0.45=0.55q = 1 - 0.60 = 0.40 \implies q' = 1 - 0.45 = 0.55

  3. Step 3

    Δq=q−q′=0.40−0.55=−0.15\Delta q = q - q' = 0.40 - 0.55 = -0.15

    Correct

    Δq=q′−q=0.55−0.40=+0.15\Delta q = q' - q = 0.55 - 0.40 = +0.15

    You calculated initial minus final (q−q′q - q') instead of final minus initial (q′−qq' - q). Net change is defined as Δq=qfinal−qinitial\Delta q = q_{\text{final}} - q_{\text{initial}}, which means the yellow allele increased in frequency by +0.15+0.15.

  4. Step 4

    Green butterflies=2p′q′×800=2(0.45)(0.55)×800=396  ⟹  Yellow butterflies=(q′)2×800=(0.55)2×800=242  ⟹  Ratio=396242=1811≈1.64\text{Green butterflies} = 2p'q' \times 800 = 2(0.45)(0.55) \times 800 = 396 \implies \text{Yellow butterflies} = (q')^2 \times 800 = (0.55)^2 \times 800 = 242 \implies \text{Ratio} = \frac{396}{242} = \frac{18}{11} \approx 1.64

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You counted alleles accurately using diploid gene pool principles.

You used the complement identity p+q=1p + q = 1 to find both the initial and new yellow allele frequencies.

You correctly predicted Hardy-Weinberg genotype numbers and determined the phenotypic ratio.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Order in Net Change Formula

You set up Δq=q−q′\Delta q = q - q' instead of Δq=q′−q\Delta q = q' - q, inverting the sign of the evolutionary change.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the algebraic definition of change (final minus initial) with a difference between values, causing an allele that increased in frequency to appear as if it decreased.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direction of Net Change (Delta)
  • For any quantity XX, the net change is always defined as ΔX=Xfinal−Xinitial\Delta X = X_{\text{final}} - X_{\text{initial}}.

  • Check whether the frequency grew or shrank over time: an increase from 0.400.40 to 0.550.55 must have a positive sign (+0.15+0.15).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the final frequency q′=0.55q' = 0.55 and initial frequency q=0.40q = 0.40.

  2. Apply the standard formula for net change: Δq=q′−q=0.55−0.40=+0.15\Delta q = q' - q = 0.55 - 0.40 = +0.15.

Final answer

(a) f(CB)=0.60f(C^B) = 0.60; (b) Δq=+0.15\Delta q = +0.15; (c) Ratio=1811≈1.64:1\text{Ratio} = \frac{18}{11} \approx 1.64 : 1

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the formal definition of delta as Δ=final−initial\Delta = \text{final} - \text{initial} across population genetics problems.

  • Perform a sanity check on the sign: if an allele becomes more common in the population, its Δ\Delta must be positive.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student omits the factor of 2 in the Hardy-Weinberg formula for heterozygote frequency, calculating the ratio of p'q' to q'² instead of 2p'q' to q'².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Total alleles=800  ⟹  f(CB)=288+192800=0.60\text{Total alleles} = 800 \implies f(C^B) = \frac{288 + 192}{800} = 0.60

  2. Step 2

    q=1−0.60=0.40  ⟹  q′=1−0.45=0.55  ⟹  Δq=0.55−0.40=+0.15q = 1 - 0.60 = 0.40 \implies q' = 1 - 0.45 = 0.55 \implies \Delta q = 0.55 - 0.40 = +0.15

  3. Step 3

    f(Green)=p′q′=0.45×0.55=0.2475  ⟹  f(Yellow)=(q′)2=(0.55)2=0.3025  ⟹  Ratio=0.24750.3025=911≈0.82f(\text{Green}) = p'q' = 0.45 \times 0.55 = 0.2475 \implies f(\text{Yellow}) = (q')^2 = (0.55)^2 = 0.3025 \implies \text{Ratio} = \frac{0.2475}{0.3025} = \frac{9}{11} \approx 0.82

    Correct

    f(Green)=2p′q′=2(0.45)(0.55)=0.4950  ⟹  f(Yellow)=(q′)2=0.3025  ⟹  Ratio=2p′q′(q′)2=2p′q′=1811≈1.64f(\text{Green}) = 2p'q' = 2(0.45)(0.55) = 0.4950 \implies f(\text{Yellow}) = (q')^2 = 0.3025 \implies \text{Ratio} = \frac{2p'q'}{(q')^2} = \frac{2p'}{q'} = \frac{18}{11} \approx 1.64

    You used p′q′p'q' instead of 2p′q′2p'q' for the heterozygous green genotype frequency. Under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, heterozygotes can be formed in two distinct ways (CBC^B from egg and CYC^Y from sperm, or vice versa), requiring a coefficient of 22.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the gene-counting method to find the initial allele frequency p=0.60p = 0.60.

You used the complement rule p+q=1p + q = 1 accurately to find qq, q′q', and Δq\Delta q.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Heterozygote Multiplicity Factor (2pq)

You wrote f(Green)=p′q′f(\text{Green}) = p'q' instead of 2p′q′2p'q', forgetting to multiply the product of the two allele frequencies by 22.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the probability of drawing one specific ordered pair of gametes (p×qp \times q) with the total genotype frequency of heterozygotes in a diploid population, which includes two reciprocal combinations (p×q+q×p=2pqp \times q + q \times p = 2pq).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Hardy-Weinberg Expansion Rule
  • The sum of genotype frequencies equals the binomial expansion (p+q)2=p2+2pq+q2=1(p + q)^2 = p^2 + 2pq + q^2 = 1.

  • Always verify that the heterozygote frequency includes the factor of 22, representing both maternal and paternal allele combinations.

Ratio Simplification Check
  • The ratio of heterozygotes to homozygotes simplifies algebraically: 2pqq2=2pq\frac{2pq}{q^2} = \frac{2p}{q}.

  • Simplify algebraic ratios of genotype frequencies before multiplying decimals to reduce arithmetic steps and prevent missing terms.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. f(Green)=2p′q′=2(0.45)(0.55)=0.4950f(\text{Green}) = 2p'q' = 2(0.45)(0.55) = 0.4950

  2. f(Yellow)=(q′)2=(0.55)2=0.3025f(\text{Yellow}) = (q')^2 = (0.55)^2 = 0.3025

  3. Ratio=f(Green)f(Yellow)=2p′q′(q′)2=2p′q′=2(0.45)0.55=0.900.55=1811≈1.64\text{Ratio} = \frac{f(\text{Green})}{f(\text{Yellow})} = \frac{2p'q'}{(q')^2} = \frac{2p'}{q'} = \frac{2(0.45)}{0.55} = \frac{0.90}{0.55} = \frac{18}{11} \approx 1.64

Final answer

(a) f(CB)=0.60f(C^B) = 0.60; (b) Δq=+0.15\Delta q = +0.15; (c) Ratio ≈1.64:1\approx 1.64 : 1 (or 1811\frac{18}{11})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the Punnett square origin of the Hardy-Weinberg binomial expansion (p+q)2=p2+2pq+q2(p+q)^2 = p^2 + 2pq + q^2.

  • Practice writing genotype frequency ratios symbolically before plugging in numerical values to catch missing coefficients early.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A population of 500500 wildflowers has incomplete dominance for petal color: 180180 red (CRCRC^R C^R), 240240 pink (CRCWC^R C^W), and 8080 white (CWCWC^W C^W). Calculate the true allele frequency f(CR)f(C^R) using direct gene counting, and state whether the population is currently in Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium.

Answer

Total alleles =2×500=1000= 2 \times 500 = 1000. Copies of CR=2(180)+240=600C^R = 2(180) + 240 = 600. Thus, p=f(CR)=6001000=0.60p = f(C^R) = \frac{600}{1000} = 0.60 and q=0.40q = 0.40. Expected Hardy–Weinberg counts are p2N=0.36(500)=180p^2 N = 0.36(500) = 180 red, 2pqN=0.48(500)=2402pq N = 0.48(500) = 240 pink, and q2N=0.16(500)=80q^2 N = 0.16(500) = 80 white. Because observed counts match expected counts exactly, the population is in Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium.

02

In a herd of 200200 cattle with codominant coat color, there are 108108 red (RRRR), 2424 roan (RrRr), and 6868 white (rrrr). (a) Find the frequency of allele RR. (b) What would you have incorrectly estimated f(R)f(R) to be if you had assumed Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium and taken f(RR)\sqrt{f(RR)}?

Answer

(a) Total alleles =400= 400. Copies of R=2(108)+24=240R = 2(108) + 24 = 240. True frequency p=240400=0.60p = \frac{240}{400} = 0.60. (b) If assuming equilibrium: pest=108200=0.54≈0.735p_{\text{est}} = \sqrt{\frac{108}{200}} = \sqrt{0.54} \approx 0.735. This demonstrates why taking the square root without guaranteed equilibrium yields a severe error.

03

A population of 10001000 moths with two codominant alleles A1A_1 and A2A_2 starts with f(A1)=0.70f(A_1) = 0.70 and f(A2)=0.30f(A_2) = 0.30. Severe predation reduces the population to 400400 individuals, altering the gene pool such that f(A1)′=0.50f(A_1)' = 0.50. Assuming the surviving group mates randomly to form the next generation in Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium: (a) calculate the net change Δf(A2)\Delta f(A_2), and (b) find the expected number of heterozygotes in the next generation of 12001200 individuals.

Answer

(a) Initial q=0.30q = 0.30. New p′=0.50  ⟹  q′=1−0.50=0.50p' = 0.50 \implies q' = 1 - 0.50 = 0.50. Net change Δq=q′−q=0.50−0.30=+0.20\Delta q = q' - q = 0.50 - 0.30 = +0.20. (b) Under Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium in the next generation, expected heterozygote frequency is 2p′q′=2(0.50)(0.50)=0.502p'q' = 2(0.50)(0.50) = 0.50. Expected number of heterozygotes =0.50×1200=600= 0.50 \times 1200 = 600.

Loading workspace…