Resources
A molecular phylogeneticist establishes that extant species and form an exclusive sister clade relative to an outgroup . The cladogram requires exactly evolutionary synapomorphy to unite and , while species accumulates an additional autapomorphy. Five phenotypic characters () are scored as binary states ( or ). The character matrix reveals: Outgroup , Species , and Species . However, a lab transcription error switched two character state assignments for Species and among the five characters. If the true phylogenetic tree requires that the clade is supported by exactly three synapomorphies () and Species possesses an autapomorphy at , reconstruct the correct character state vector for Species and Species .
Answer and steps
Final answer
Species and Species .
Steps
Determine the States for the Synapomorphies ()
Understanding Character States in Cladistics
In cladistic analysis, the polarity of character states is determined using an outgroup:
- Plesiomorphy (Ancestral state): The character state present in the outgroup. Since outgroup is scored as , the state represents the ancestral condition for all five characters, while state represents the derived condition (an apomorphy).
- Synapomorphy: A shared derived character state () inherited from a common ancestor that unites a monophyletic clade.
- Autapomorphy: A derived character state () unique to a single terminal taxon (lineage).
The true phylogenetic tree specifies that the clade is supported by exactly three synapomorphies: and .
Because a synapomorphy must be present in all members of the clade descended from their shared common ancestor:
- Species must possess the derived state () for and .
- Species must also possess the derived state () for and .
Thus, for the first three characters:
- :
- :
Determine the State for the Autapomorphy ()
The problem specifies that Species has an autapomorphy at character :
- Because it is an autapomorphy unique to , Species has the derived state at .
- Because Species did not evolve this autapomorphy, it retains the ancestral state at .
Thus, for character :
- :
- :
Determine the State for Character
No synapomorphic or autapomorphic changes are specified for character . Therefore, both Species and Species retain the ancestral plesiomorphic state () seen in the outgroup:
- :
- :
Assemble the Corrected Vectors
Combining the states for all five characters :
- Species :
- Species :
(Note on the transcription error: The recorded matrix erroneously omitted the derived state at for Species and misplaced the derived state at for Species . Correcting these assignments restores the true evolutionary topology).
Typical errors
01 A student confuses an autapomorphy with a synapomorphy, assigning the derived state 1 at C4 to both sister species K and L instead of uniquely to L.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Synapomorphies shared by clade : , ,
- Step 2
Autapomorphy at shared by the clade: for and
CorrectAutapomorphy at is unique to terminal taxon : ,
By definition, an autapomorphy is a derived feature unique to a single lineage or terminal taxon. Because only Species acquired the autapomorphy at , Species retains the ancestral state .
- Step 3
remains ancestral
- Step 4
Species Species
CorrectSpecies Species
Because of the mistake at in Step 2, Species has an incorrect value of instead of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that synapomorphies are shared derived states () inherited by all taxa in clade .
You correctly maintained the ancestral state () for character .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou described the autapomorphy as 'shared by the clade' and assigned to both and .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the definitions of synapomorphy (a shared derived character uniting two or more taxa) and autapomorphy (a derived character unique to only one terminal taxon).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish Synapomorphy from Autapomorphy
A synapomorphy is shared by multiple descendants of a node; an autapomorphy is restricted to a single terminal branch.
Whenever a problem specifies an autapomorphy for taxon , assign state solely to taxon and retain the ancestral state for its sister taxa.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that character is an autapomorphy unique to Species , meaning Species gets while Species keeps .
Combine the shared synapomorphic states (), the autapomorphic state ( for only), and the plesiomorphic state ().
Species and Species
02 A student misassigns the autapomorphy at C4 to Species K instead of Species L, reversing which sister taxon possesses the derived unique character state.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Clade synapomorphies: for both and
- Step 2
Autapomorphy at assigned to : for , for
CorrectSpecies has the autapomorphy at : for , for
The problem states that Species possesses the autapomorphy at . Because an autapomorphy is unique to a single terminal branch, should be for and remain ancestral () for .
- Step 3
Species , Species
CorrectSpecies , Species
Your final character state vectors swapped the values of between Species and Species due to the assignment error in Step 2.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that synapomorphies are shared derived characters present in both members of clade .
You correctly retained the ancestral state for character across both species.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally mapped the autapomorphy at onto Species instead of Species .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisMisreading or reversing the designated terminal taxon for an autapomorphy leads to swapping the unique derived state between sister lineages.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Synapomorphy vs. Autapomorphy
A synapomorphy is a shared derived state () uniting a clade; an autapomorphy is a derived state () unique to only one terminal branch.
Always double-check which specific taxon name is stated in the prompt before writing down the autapomorphic state.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationThe prompt specifies that Species possesses the autapomorphy at , so set for and for .
Combine the synapomorphies , the autapomorphy ( for , for ), and the ancestral state ().
Species and Species
Lock it in
What is the key difference between a synapomorphy and an autapomorphy in cladistics?
A synapomorphy is a derived trait shared by two or more taxa from a common ancestor; an autapomorphy is a derived trait unique to a single terminal lineage.
Similar question
An outgroup has state vector . Clade is defined relative to . The clade shares two synapomorphies (), and Taxon possesses an autapomorphy at . Write the character state vectors for Taxon and Taxon .
Answer
Taxon and Taxon . Synapomorphies and are derived in both and . Autapomorphy is derived () only in , while retains the ancestral state ().
A phylogenetic tree displays outgroup and sister taxa and . Taxon has vector and Taxon has vector . Classify characters and as synapomorphy of , autapomorphy of , autapomorphy of , or plesiomorphy.
Answer
is a synapomorphy uniting (both have ). is an autapomorphy of (only has ). is an autapomorphy of (only has ). is an uninformative plesiomorphy (both retain ).
A clade consists of three taxa: with outgroup . Two synapomorphies () unite all three ingroup taxa . One synapomorphy () unites sister pair . Species has an autapomorphy at , and remains unchanged throughout the tree. Determine the 5-character vectors for and .
Answer
, , and . All three share . Only the subclade has (so has ). Only has the autapomorphic state . All retain .