Resources

A student attempts to determine whether a mainland and an island bird population are undergoing divergent natural selection versus uniform stabilizing selection. In a mainland population, the frequency of an allele A1A_1 is p1=0.70p_1 = 0.70. A researcher writes down the equation for the change in island allele frequency due to migration as Δp=m(pi−pm)\Delta p = m(p_i - p_m), mistakenly reversing the subtraction convention. If the true island frequency is pi=0.20p_i = 0.20 and the migration fraction is m=0.10m = 0.10 from mainland to island: (a) Calculate the mathematically correct Δp=m(pm−pi)\Delta p = m(p_m - p_i) and explain the sign convention. (b) Calculate the erroneous Δp\Delta p produced by the student's inverted formula and state the false biological conclusion it implies.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Correct Δp=+0.050\Delta p = +0.050, indicating an influx of allele A1A_1 that increases island frequency toward the mainland value; (b) Erroneous Δp=−0.050\Delta p = -0.050, which falsely implies the island is losing allele A1A_1 despite receiving migrants from a higher-frequency source.

Steps

Part (a): Correct Calculation and Sign Convention

  1. Identify the Given Parameters:

    • Mainland allele frequency: pm=0.70p_m = 0.70
    • Initial island allele frequency: pi=0.20p_i = 0.20
    • Migration rate (fraction of island population composed of new migrants from the mainland each generation): m=0.10m = 0.10
  2. Calculate the True Change in Allele Frequency (Δp\Delta p): The standard one-way continent-to-island migration model gives the change in island allele frequency as: Δp=m(pm−pi)\Delta p = m(p_m - p_i)

    Substitute the values into the formula: Δp=0.10⋅(0.70−0.20)=0.10⋅0.50=+0.050\Delta p = 0.10 \cdot (0.70 - 0.20) = 0.10 \cdot 0.50 = +0.050

  3. Biological Meaning of the Sign Convention:

    • The sign of Δp\Delta p reflects whether the island's allele frequency increases or decreases after migration.
    • Because the mainland source has a higher frequency of allele A1A_1 (pm=0.70p_m = 0.70) than the recipient island (pi=0.20p_i = 0.20), the difference (pm−pi)(p_m - p_i) is positive.
    • A positive value (Δp=+0.050\Delta p = +0.050) correctly indicates that gene flow causes an influx of allele A1A_1, driving the island allele frequency upward toward the mainland value (from 0.200.20 to 0.20+0.050=0.250.20 + 0.050 = 0.25).

Part (b): Erroneous Calculation and False Biological Conclusion

  1. Calculate Using the Inverted Formula: Using the mistaken subtraction convention Δperr=m(pi−pm)\Delta p_{\text{err}} = m(p_i - p_m): Δperr=0.10⋅(0.20−0.70)=0.10⋅(−0.50)=−0.050\Delta p_{\text{err}} = 0.10 \cdot (0.20 - 0.70) = 0.10 \cdot (-0.50) = -0.050
  2. Identify the False Biological Conclusion:

    • The negative sign implies that the island is losing allele A1A_1, causing its frequency to drop (falsely predicting a new frequency of 0.20−0.050=0.150.20 - 0.050 = 0.15).
    • This leads to the contradictory biological conclusion that receiving immigrants from a population rich in allele A1A_1 somehow dilutes or depletes that very allele on the island, mistakenly suggesting divergence away from the mainland rather than homogenization toward it.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misplaces the decimal when multiplying the migration fraction by the allele frequency difference, resulting in an order-of-magnitude error.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δp=m(pm−pi)  ⟹  Δp=0.10(0.70−0.20)  ⟹  Δp=0.10(0.50)\Delta p = m(p_m - p_i) \implies \Delta p = 0.10(0.70 - 0.20) \implies \Delta p = 0.10(0.50)

  2. Step 2

    Δp=+0.50\Delta p = +0.50

    Correct

    Δp=+0.050\Delta p = +0.050

    Multiplying 0.10×0.500.10 \times 0.50 yields 0.0500.050, not 0.500.50. Multiplying by 0.100.10 shifts the decimal point one place to the left: 0.50×10−1=0.0500.50 \times 10^{-1} = 0.050.

  3. Step 3

    Positive sign indicates allele A1A_1 increases on the island because mainland frequency is higher.

  4. Step 4

    Δp=m(pi−pm)  ⟹  Δp=0.10(0.20−0.70)  ⟹  Δp=0.10(−0.50)\Delta p = m(p_i - p_m) \implies \Delta p = 0.10(0.20 - 0.70) \implies \Delta p = 0.10(-0.50)

  5. Step 5

    Δp=−0.50\Delta p = -0.50

    Correct

    Δperr=−0.050\Delta p_{\text{err}} = -0.050

    Multiplying 0.10×(−0.50)0.10 \times (-0.50) results in −0.050-0.050, not −0.50-0.50. The decimal point was misplaced by one position.

  6. Step 6

    Falsely implies allele A1A_1 frequency decreases on the island due to immigration.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You selected the correct one-way migration equation Δp=m(pm−pi)\Delta p = m(p_m - p_i) for part (a).

You correctly substituted all parameter values into both the standard and inverted equations.

You provided clear, accurate biological explanations for both sign outcomes.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Decimal multiplication slip

You dropped a zero when multiplying 0.10×0.500.10 \times 0.50, recording 0.500.50 instead of 0.0500.050.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misplacement of the decimal point during decimal multiplication, mistaking multiplication by 0.100.10 for multiplication by 11. Notice that an allele frequency change of Δp=+0.50\Delta p = +0.50 would increase the island's frequency from 0.200.20 to 0.700.70 in a single generation, which is impossible when migrants only constitute 10%10\% of the recipient population.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Decimal Place Rule
  • When multiplying decimals, the product must have as many decimal places as the sum of decimal places in the factors (0.100.10 has two places and 0.500.50 has two places, or 0.1×0.5=0.050.1 \times 0.5 = 0.05).

  • Count decimal places or convert to fractions: 110×12=120=0.050\frac{1}{10} \times \frac{1}{2} = \frac{1}{20} = 0.050.

Biological Upper Bound Check
  • In one generation of gene flow, the maximum possible change is bounded by m(1)=mm(1) = m.

  • Verify that ∣Δp∣≤m|\Delta p| \le m. Since m=0.10m = 0.10, any change ∣Δp∣=0.50|\Delta p| = 0.50 violates this biological constraint.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the product carefully: 0.10×0.50=0.0500.10 \times 0.50 = 0.050.

  2. For part (a), Δp=+0.050\Delta p = +0.050.

  3. For part (b), compute 0.10×(−0.50)=−0.0500.10 \times (-0.50) = -0.050.

Final answer

(a) Correct Δp=+0.050\Delta p = +0.050; (b) Erroneous Δp=−0.050\Delta p = -0.050.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Perform a biological reality check on Δp\Delta p: ensure ∣Δp∣≤m⋅∣pm−pi∣≤m|\Delta p| \le m \cdot |p_m - p_i| \le m.

  • Convert decimals to simple fractions (e.g., 0.10=1100.10 = \frac{1}{10}) before multiplying to prevent decimal-shift slips.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the direction of gene flow and interprets a negative value as meaning the mainland population loses genetic diversity rather than the island frequency decreasing.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δp=0.10(0.70−0.20)  ⟹  Δp=0.10(0.50)=+0.05  ⟹  The positive sign shows allele A1 increases in the island population.\Delta p = 0.10(0.70 - 0.20) \implies \Delta p = 0.10(0.50) = +0.05 \implies \text{The positive sign shows allele } A_1 \text{ increases in the island population.}

  2. Step 2

    Δp=0.10(0.20−0.70)  ⟹  Δp=0.10(−0.50)=−0.05\Delta p = 0.10(0.20 - 0.70) \implies \Delta p = 0.10(-0.50) = -0.05

  3. Step 3

    Falsely implies the mainland population is losing alleles due to emigration.\text{Falsely implies the mainland population is losing alleles due to emigration.}

    Correct

    It falsely implies that the island population's allele frequency decreases (from 0.200.20 to 0.150.15), falsely suggesting that the island loses allele A1A_1 even though it receives migrants from a higher-frequency source.

    In the continent-to-island migration model, Δp\Delta p always defines the change in the recipient island population's allele frequency, not the mainland's. The inverted equation falsely predicts that the island population loses allele A1A_1, which contradicts the biological reality of receiving migrants with a higher allele frequency.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the parameters and substituted them into the correct migration formula in part (a).

You correctly interpreted that a positive Δp\Delta p indicates an increase in island allele frequency.

You performed the algebraic evaluation for the inverted formula correctly in part (b).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misidentifying the Target Population in Gene Flow Models

You initially wrote that the island was losing the allele, but crossed it out to interpret the negative sign as emigration loss from the mainland.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing which population's allele frequency is tracked by Δp\Delta p in continent-to-island gene flow models, leading you to interpret a negative value as an effect on the source population rather than a contradictory reduction in the recipient population.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define the Reference Population
  • In one-way continent-to-island migration models, Δp\Delta p is defined strictly for the recipient population: Δp=pisland′−pisland\Delta p = p_{\text{island}}' - p_{\text{island}}.

  • Always interpret the sign of Δp\Delta p as a change occurring within the recipient population, never the donor population.

Direction of Homogenization
  • Gene flow acts as a homogenizing evolutionary force: when psource>precipientp_{\text{source}} > p_{\text{recipient}}, the recipient's allele frequency must increase toward the source value.

  • Check whether the sign of Δp\Delta p moves the recipient frequency toward or away from the source frequency to evaluate biological plausibility.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall that Δp\Delta p represents the change in allele frequency of the recipient island population: Δp=pi′−pi\Delta p = p_i' - p_i.

  2. A value of Δp=−0.05\Delta p = -0.05 predicts that the new island frequency becomes pi′=0.20+(−0.05)=0.15p_i' = 0.20 + (-0.05) = 0.15.

  3. State the false biological conclusion: receiving migrants from a mainland with a higher allele frequency (0.700.70) would somehow dilute or deplete allele A1A_1 on the island, suggesting divergence instead of genetic homogenization.

Final answer

The erroneous result Δp=−0.050\Delta p = -0.050 falsely implies that the island population is losing allele A1A_1, causing its frequency to decrease from 0.200.20 to 0.150.15 despite receiving immigrants from a mainland population with a higher allele frequency (0.700.70).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how one-way migration equations are derived from weighted averages of resident and immigrant frequencies.

  • Practice identifying the recipient versus source population in population genetics word problems.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A mainland bird population has frequency pm=0.60p_m = 0.60 for allele BB. An isolated coastal island has pi=0.10p_i = 0.10. Each breeding season, migrants from the mainland comprise m=0.05m = 0.05 of the island's breeding adults. Calculate the change in island allele frequency (Δp\Delta p) after one generation of gene flow and state the island's new allele frequency pi′p_i'.

Answer

Δp=+0.025\Delta p = +0.025, and pi′=0.125p_i' = 0.125. Key steps: Δp=m(pm−pi)=0.05(0.60−0.10)=0.05(0.50)=0.025\Delta p = m(p_m - p_i) = 0.05(0.60 - 0.10) = 0.05(0.50) = 0.025. The new frequency is pi′=pi+Δp=0.10+0.025=0.125p_i' = p_i + \Delta p = 0.10 + 0.025 = 0.125.

02

An island butterfly population has an initial dark-wing allele frequency of pi=0.85p_i = 0.85. Gene flow occurs from a mainland population where pm=0.25p_m = 0.25, with a migration rate of m=0.12m = 0.12. (a) Calculate Δp\Delta p on the island. (b) Explain why Δp\Delta p is negative and what this means for the evolutionary trajectory of the island population.

Answer

(a) Δp=−0.072\Delta p = -0.072. (b) Δp\Delta p is negative because pm<pip_m < p_i (0.25−0.85=−0.600.25 - 0.85 = -0.60), meaning incoming migrants dilute the high frequency of the dark-wing allele on the island, moving the island toward homogenization with the mainland source. Key steps: Δp=0.12(0.25−0.85)=0.12(−0.60)=−0.072\Delta p = 0.12(0.25 - 0.85) = 0.12(-0.60) = -0.072.

03

An agricultural weed on an island has a pesticide resistance allele at frequency pi=0.90p_i = 0.90. Wild, non-resistant mainland plants (pm=0.00p_m = 0.00) migrate to the island at a rate of m=0.20m = 0.20 each generation. Assuming no natural selection, how many generations of gene flow are required for the island resistance allele frequency to drop below 0.500.50?

Answer

t=3t = 3 generations. Key steps: The island frequency after tt generations satisfies (pt−pm)=(p0−pm)(1−m)t(p_t - p_m) = (p_0 - p_m)(1 - m)^t. With pm=0p_m = 0, pt=0.90(0.80)tp_t = 0.90(0.80)^t. For t=1t = 1, p1=0.720p_1 = 0.720; for t=2t = 2, p2=0.576p_2 = 0.576; for t=3t = 3, p3≈0.461<0.50p_3 \approx 0.461 < 0.50.

Loading workspace…