Resources
Water movement across cellular membranes is governed by water potential: , where is solute potential and is pressure potential. An animal cell lacking a cell wall cannot sustain a positive hydrostatic turgor pressure ( permanently); if placed in pure water (), water enters until the plasma membrane lyses. Conversely, a mature plant cell with an internal solute potential is bathed in an open beaker of an aqueous sucrose solution having . Assuming equilibrium is reached without any net change in cell volume, calculate the equilibrium turgor pressure () within the plant cell. Contrast the sign and magnitude of between the fully turgid plant cell and the bathed animal cell.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Equilibrium turgor pressure of the plant cell is ; for the plant cell ( supported by the rigid cell wall), whereas for the open animal cell (animal cells cannot generate positive hydrostatic turgor pressure without lysing).
Steps
Water Potential of the Surrounding Solution
The overall water potential () of any system is the sum of its solute potential () and physical pressure potential ():
Because the surrounding sucrose solution is in an open beaker exposed to atmospheric pressure, its pressure potential is zero (). Therefore, the total water potential of the external solution is:
Calculating the Plant Cell's Equilibrium Turgor Pressure ()
At dynamic equilibrium, net water movement ceases because the water potential inside the plant cell equals that of the external solution:
Given that cell volume changes are negligible, the cell's internal solute potential remains . We solve for the internal pressure potential (turgor pressure, ):
Contrasting Plant and Animal Cell Pressure Potentials
- Plant Cell (): The pressure potential has a positive sign and a nonzero magnitude (). Water entering the hypertonic cytoplasm pushes outward against the plasma membrane, but the rigid, inelastic cellulose cell wall pushes back with an equal and opposite wall pressure. This enables the plant cell to withstand significant internal hydrostatic pressure without rupturing (lysing).
- Animal Cell (): Animal cells lack an outer rigid cell wall, possessing only a flexible plasma membrane. Consequently, they cannot generate or sustain positive hydrostatic pressure (). If placed in a hypotonic environment, osmotic influx increases volume until the membrane ruptures (lysis).
Common Pitfall: Do not confuse solute potential () with pressure potential (). Solute potential is always zero or negative because dissolved solutes decrease free water concentration. In contrast, turgor pressure () in living plant cells is typically positive, acting as an opposing force to water entry.
Typical errors
01 The student subtracts the solution solute potential from the cell solute potential instead of setting cell water potential equal to solution water potential, resulting in an erroneous negative turgor pressure.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
At equilibrium in an open beaker, . Because , rearranging gives . You inverted the subtraction, which yielded a negative turgor pressure rather than positive wall pressure.
- Step 2
The plant cell has a negative pressure potential of while the animal cell has zero pressure potential of .
CorrectThe plant cell has a positive pressure potential of supported by the rigid cell wall, whereas the animal cell has because it lacks a cell wall to resist swelling.
You correctly stated that the animal cell has a pressure potential of , but your conclusion about the plant cell having negative pressure was carried over from your arithmetic error in Step 1. Living, turgid plant cells maintain positive pressure potential.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that animal cells bathed in solution maintain a pressure potential of .
You recognized that equilibrium relates the internal cell solute potential and the surrounding beaker's solute potential.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou reversed the equilibrium equation: instead of solving for , you wrote , failing to recognize that turgor pressure in a plant cell pushing against a wall must be positive.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Equilibrium Water Potential
At dynamic equilibrium, net water movement is zero, meaning .
Set first before isolating .
- Physical Reality of Turgor Pressure
Living turgid plant cells have positive hydrostatic pressure () because the rigid cell wall pushes inward against expanding protoplast volume.
Always verify that your calculated turgor pressure in a hypotonic or equilibrium setting is positive.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEquate internal and external water potential at equilibrium: .
Calculate external water potential: in an open container, , so .
Substitute into the water potential equation for the cell: .
Solve for pressure potential: .
Equilibrium turgor pressure within the plant cell is . The plant cell exhibits a positive pressure potential () sustained by its rigid cellulose wall, whereas the animal cell cannot sustain positive turgor pressure and remains at .
02 The student confuses the solute potential formula with direct addition of magnitudes or assumes turgor pressure is the sum of both solute potentials, yielding -0.95 MPa.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You added the two solute potentials together to find pressure potential. At equilibrium, the cell's total water potential equals the solution's total water potential (). Since the open beaker has , we have , which gives .
- Step 2
The plant cell has a negative pressure potential of magnitude , whereas the animal cell has a pressure potential of .
CorrectThe fully turgid plant cell has a positive pressure potential of supported by its rigid cell wall, whereas the animal cell cannot sustain positive hydrostatic pressure () without lysing.
You correctly stated that the animal cell has , but your conclusion about the plant cell having a negative pressure potential stemmed directly from the calculation error in Step 1. Turgor pressure inside a turgid plant cell is positive because the rigid wall resists water influx.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recalled that an animal cell lacking a cell wall cannot maintain positive turgor pressure ().
You correctly identified the two solute potential values given in the problem statement.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated pressure potential as the sum of internal and external solute potentials rather than applying the dynamic equilibrium condition where total water potentials are equal ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Equilibrium Water Potential Condition
At osmotic equilibrium between a cell and an external solution, , where .
Always set first before rearranging for the unknown variable.
- Physical Sign of Turgor Pressure
Turgor pressure () in a living, intact plant cell in a hypotonic medium is always positive () because water pushing against the rigid cell wall creates outward hydrostatic pressure.
Check the sign of : a negative value would mean physical tension or suction (such as in xylem transpiration), which does not occur in a turgid living cell.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine the external water potential of the open beaker: .
Set the plant cell's water potential equal to the surrounding solution at equilibrium: .
Use to isolate turgor pressure: .
Equilibrium turgor pressure is . The plant cell maintains a positive pressure potential () due to its rigid cell wall, whereas the animal cell cannot sustain positive turgor pressure () and would lyse in a hypotonic environment.
03 The student mistakenly treats the surrounding solution as pure water with Ψ = 0 MPa, ignoring the solute potential of the sucrose solution.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
At dynamic equilibrium, the cell's water potential equals the water potential of the surrounding solution. Because the open beaker has and , the external water potential is , not .
- Step 2Correct
You substituted and solved the linear equation correctly, but using instead of caused an incorrect turgor pressure of instead of .
- Step 3
The plant cell has a positive pressure potential of , while the animal cell has no cell wall and a pressure potential of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou remembered and correctly used the core equation .
You correctly recognized that animal cells maintain because they lack a rigid cell wall to exert counter-pressure.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou equated the equilibrium state to instead of calculating the actual water potential of the surrounding sucrose solution.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated dynamic equilibrium (where ) with the reference state of pure water at atmospheric pressure (where ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Calculate External Solution Potential First
For an open container at atmospheric pressure, , so .
Always find for the surrounding bath before setting up the equilibrium equation.
- Apply Dynamic Equilibrium Condition
Net water movement stops when , not when (unless the bath is pure water).
Set and solve for the unknown.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate external water potential: .
Equate cell potential to external potential at equilibrium: .
Solve for cell turgor pressure: .
; the plant cell has a positive turgor pressure of supported by its cell wall, whereas the bathed animal cell has .
Lock it in
What is the pressure potential () of a solution in an open beaker exposed to atmospheric pressure?
. Open containers have no external hydrostatic pressure beyond atmospheric pressure.
Similar question
A plant cell with an internal solute potential is placed into an open beaker of pure water (). Assuming negligible volume change, calculate the cell's equilibrium pressure potential .
Answer
. At equilibrium, . Therefore, .
A plant cell with and is dropped into an open sucrose solution with . Determine whether water moves into or out of the cell initially, and find the new equilibrium assuming no change in internal .
Answer
Water moves into the cell; new equilibrium . Initial cell potential is , while solution ... wait: , so water flows OUT of the cell down the water potential gradient until . At equilibrium, .
A red blood cell and a flaccid plant cell (both having internal and initial ) are simultaneously transferred into an open tank of distilled water (). Describe the ultimate structural fate and equilibrium of both cells.
Answer
Animal cell: water flows inward down the potential gradient, causing swelling until lysis occurs; it never establishes a positive stable equilibrium pressure (remains until rupture). Plant cell: water flows inward until the rigid cell wall exerts an equal opposing wall pressure, reaching stable equilibrium at without lysing.