Resources

In a controlled pollination experiment evaluating self-incompatibility in brassicaceous plants, an investigator examines gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI) versus sporophytic self-incompatibility (SSI). A maternal seed parent possesses the diploid genotype S1S2S_1S_2. A pollen donor parent with diploid genotype S2S3S_2S_3 sheds thousands of pollen grains onto the stigma of the maternal pistil. Assuming standard sporophytic self-incompatibility (SSI) where alleles S1S_1, S2S_2, and S3S_3 exhibit codominance in both the tapetum and stigmatic papillae: (a) state the functional phenotype conferred upon the pollen grain wall coat by the paternal donor, (b) calculate the theoretical percentage of pollen grains (0%0\%, 50%50\%, or 100%100\%) that will successfully penetrate the stigmatic surface and fertilize an ovule, and (c) state how this percentage would differ if the system instead operated under gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI) with codominance.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Dual S2S3S_2S_3 phenotype displayed on the exine pollen coat; (b) 0%0\% successful fertilization; (c) Under GSI, 50%50\% of pollen grains (specifically the S3S_3 carrying haploid grains) would successfully fertilize the ovules.

Steps

Pollen Phenotype Conferred in SSI

Understanding Sporophytic vs. Gametophytic Self-Incompatibility

Self-incompatibility (SS-locus-mediated) prevents inbreeding in flowering plants. The fundamental difference between sporophytic self-incompatibility (SSI) and gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI) lies in what determines the pollen grain's incompatibility phenotype:

  • Sporophytic Self-Incompatibility (SSI): The pollen phenotype is determined by the diploid genotype of the pollen-producing parent (the sporophyte). During microsporogenesis, the surrounding diploid tapetum secretes recognition proteins that are embedded into the outer pollen wall (exine).
  • Gametophytic Self-Incompatibility (GSI): The pollen phenotype is determined solely by the haploid genotype of the individual pollen grain itself (the gametophyte).

Step-by-Step Derivation

  1. The paternal donor plant has a diploid genotype of S2S3S_2S_3.
  2. Because the alleles S2S_2 and S3S_3 are codominant in the sporophytic tapetum, the tapetum produces both S2S_2 and S3S_3 determinant molecules (such as SCR/SP11 proteins in Brassicaceae).
  3. These molecules are deposited into the exine coat of all pollen grains, regardless of which haploid allele (S2S_2 or S3S_3) each individual pollen grain inherited.
  4. Therefore, every single pollen grain expresses a dual S2S3S_2S_3 phenotype on its outer wall.

Percentage of Successful Fertilization in SSI

  1. The maternal seed parent has the diploid genotype S1S2S_1S_2, meaning its stigmatic papillae codominantly express the receptor proteins for both S1S_1 and S2S_2 (such as SRK receptors).
  2. In SSI, an incompatibility response is triggered if either allele expressed on the pollen grain's coat matches either allele expressed by the stigma.
  3. Every pollen grain presents both S2S_2 and S3S_3 on its surface. Because S2S_2 on the pollen coat matches the S2S_2 receptor on the stigma:
    • The recognition pathway is activated, blocking pollen hydration, germination, and stigmatic penetration.
  4. Consequently, none of the pollen grains can penetrate the stigmatic surface. The theoretical percentage of successful pollen grains is 0%0\%.

Comparison with Gametophytic Self-Incompatibility (GSI)

  1. In GSI, pollen coats do not carry the diploid donor phenotype; instead, each pollen grain acts according to its own haploid genotype formed after meiosis:
    • 50%50\% of the pollen grains carry the S2S_2 allele.
    • 50%50\% of the pollen grains carry the S3S_3 allele.
  2. The maternal style expresses S1S_1 and S2S_2 proteins:
    • The 50%50\% of pollen grains carrying S2S_2 match the maternal S2S_2 allele and are inhibited inside the style.
    • The remaining 50%50\% of pollen grains carry the S3S_3 allele, which does not match either maternal allele (S1S_1 or S2S_2).
  3. As a result, under GSI, 50%50\% of the pollen grains (specifically the S3S_3 grains) successfully grow pollen tubes to fertilize the ovules.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses sporophytic self-incompatibility with gametophytic self-incompatibility, assuming the haploid genotype of individual pollen grains determines compatibility in SSI.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Pollen grains segregate into 50% S250\%\ S_2 and 50% S350\%\ S_3. Phenotypes are S2S_2 or S3S_3 individually.

    Correct

    Every pollen grain displays a dual S2S3S_2S_3 phenotype on its outer wall (exine).

    In sporophytic self-incompatibility (SSI), the pollen wall proteins are synthesized and deposited by the diploid maternal/paternal tapetum (S2S3S_2S_3). Because the alleles are codominant, all pollen grains display both S2S_2 and S3S_3 determinants regardless of which allele they inherit through meiosis.

  2. Step 2

    Maternal stigma is S1S2S_1S_2. S2S_2 pollen is rejected because S2S_2 matches maternal allele. S3S_3 pollen does not match S1S_1 or S2S_2, so it penetrates. 50%50\% of pollen grains will successfully fertilize.

    Correct

    0%0\% of pollen grains will successfully penetrate and fertilize an ovule.

    Because every pollen grain carries the dual S2S3S_2S_3 phenotype on its surface, and the maternal stigma (S1S2S_1S_2) expresses S2S_2 receptors, all pollen grains trigger the self-incompatibility block at the stigmatic surface. None can penetrate.

  3. Step 3

    Under GSI, pollen is also determined gametophytically (50% S250\%\ S_2, 50% S350\%\ S_3). Therefore, the percentage would not differ and remains 50%50\%.

    Correct

    Under GSI, the percentage would increase from 0%0\% to 50%50\% because only the S3S_3 haploid grains are compatible with an S1S2S_1S_2 style.

    While your calculation of 50%50\% for GSI is mechanistically correct, your statement that the percentage 'would not differ' is incorrect because the true percentage under SSI is 0%0\%, not 50%50\%.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the maternal diploid genotype as S1S2S_1S_2.

You correctly deduced that an individual pollen grain carrying S3S_3 can successfully fertilize an S1S2S_1S_2 pistil in a gametophytic system.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
SSI vs GSI Genetic Determinant Misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You applied the rules of gametophytic self-incompatibility (where individual haploid pollen genotypes determine the surface phenotype) to a sporophytic system, overlooking that SSI pollen coat phenotypes are determined by the diploid sporophyte via the tapetum.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Sporophytic Self-Incompatibility (SSI)
  • In SSI, the pollen phenotype is determined by the diploid genotype of the pollen donor (2n2n), so every grain displays all codominant paternal SS-alleles.

  • Check the donor plant's diploid genotype first. If it is SaSbS_a S_b, treat all pollen coats as carrying both SaS_a and SbS_b.

Gametophytic Self-Incompatibility (GSI)
  • In GSI, the pollen phenotype is determined by its own haploid genotype (1n1n) after meiosis.

  • Segregate pollen into haploid genotypes (e.g., 50% Sa50\%\ S_a, 50% Sb50\%\ S_b) and test each grain independently against the diploid maternal style.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the donor sporophyte genotype: S2S3S_2S_3. Since S2S_2 and S3S_3 are codominant in the tapetum, every pollen grain receives both S2S_2 and S3S_3 coat proteins, displaying an S2S3S_2S_3 phenotype.

  2. Compare the pollen coat phenotype (S2S3S_2S_3) to the maternal stigma phenotype (S1S2S_1S_2). Because the S2S_2 determinant on the pollen matches the S2S_2 receptor on the stigma, an incompatibility response blocks all pollen at the surface (0%0\% penetration).

  3. Under GSI, pollen phenotype matches the haploid grain (50% S250\%\ S_2 and 50% S350\%\ S_3). The S2S_2 grains match the maternal S2S_2 allele and are arrested, while the S3S_3 grains do not match and successfully fertilize (50%50\%).

Final answer

(a) Dual S2S3S_2S_3 phenotype; (b) 0%0\%; (c) Under GSI, 50%50\% of pollen grains would successfully fertilize, whereas 0%0\% fertilize under SSI.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how tapetal cell secretions coat the pollen exine during microsporogenesis in sporophytic systems.

  • Practice cross-matching diploid parental genotypes against maternal stigmas for both SSI and GSI systems.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes that pollen is only rejected if both paternal alleles match the maternal genotype, incorrectly concluding that all pollen grains are compatible under SSI.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Paternal diploid genotype is S2S3S_2S_3. ⟹ Tapetum deposits both S2S_2 and S3S_3 determinants onto the pollen wall. ⟹ Pollen coat phenotype is S2S3S_2S_3.

  2. Step 2

    Pistil genotype is S1S2S_1S_2. ⟹ Pollen is S2S3S_2S_3, which is not completely identical to S1S2S_1S_2. ⟹ Because the pollen possesses an S3S_3 allele not present in the pistil, it avoids full rejection. ⟹ 100%100\% of pollen grains will successfully fertilize.

    Correct

    0%0\% successful fertilization.

    In sporophytic self-incompatibility (SSI), pollen germination is inhibited if either allele presented on the pollen coat matches either allele expressed by the stigma. Because both the pollen coat and the pistil display S2S_2, an incompatibility reaction is triggered on the stigmatic surface for all pollen grains, resulting in 0%0\% penetration.

  3. Step 3

    Under GSI, compatibility is determined by each haploid grain (S2S_2 or S3S_3). ⟹ S2S_2 pollen is rejected while S3S_3 pollen penetrates. ⟹ The percentage would decrease from 100%100\% to 50%50\%.

    Correct

    50%50\% of pollen grains (specifically the S3S_3-bearing grains) successfully fertilize, which is an increase from 0%0\% under SSI.

    Your genetic explanation for GSI is completely correct, but your statement that success decreases from 100%100\% to 50%50\% was affected by the incorrect value calculated in part (b).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the diploid donor tapetum determines the outer pollen coat phenotype in SSI.

You accurately identified that gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI) evaluates the individual haploid genotype of each pollen grain.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
SSI rejection rule misconception

You assumed that pollen in an SSI system is only rejected if its coat alleles completely match the maternal genotype.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating complete genotype identity with partial allelic match in sporophytic self-incompatibility. In codominant SSI, a match between any single pollen coat determinant and any single stigmatic receptor activates the arrest pathway, blocking pollen hydration and germination.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
SSI Recognition Rule
  • In codominant SSI, pollen is rejected if pollen alleles∩stigma alleles≠∅\text{pollen alleles} \cap \text{stigma alleles} \neq \emptyset.

  • Check whether the pollen coat and stigma share at least one common SS-allele; if they do, 0%0\% of pollen grains can germinate.

SSI vs. GSI Locus of Action
  • SSI acts on the stigmatic surface before hydration; GSI acts inside the style during pollen tube elongation.

  • Confirm where arrest occurs and whether the pollen unit evaluated is diploid-derived (coat) or haploid (pollen genome).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the alleles present on the maternal stigma: S1S_1 and S2S_2.

  2. Compare each allele on the pollen coat (S2S_2 and S3S_3) to the maternal alleles.

  3. Observe that S2S_2 on the pollen coat binds the maternal S2S_2 receptor (SRK) on the stigmatic papillae.

  4. Conclude that all pollen grains are recognized as self and blocked, yielding 0%0\% fertilization.

Final answer

(a) Dual S2S3S_2S_3 phenotype on the exine coat; (b) 0%0\% fertilization; (c) Under GSI, 50%50\% of grains (S3S_3) successfully fertilize, which is an increase compared to 0%0\% under SSI.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the SSI rejection condition: any shared allele between pollen coat and stigma causes complete (0%0\%) rejection.

  • Practice cross-pollination crosses with varying diploid genotypes to distinguish between partial compatibility (50%50\%) in GSI and all-or-nothing (0%0\% or 100%100\%) outcomes in codominant SSI.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A diploid maternal plant has genotype S1S3S_1S_3, and a pollen donor has genotype S3S4S_3S_4. Assuming sporophytic self-incompatibility (SSI) with codominant alleles, what percentage of pollen grains can successfully penetrate the stigma?

Answer

0%0\%. Under SSI, all pollen grains carry the dual S3S4S_3S_4 phenotype from the donor tapetum. Because S3S_3 matches the maternal S3S_3 allele on the stigma, germination/penetration is completely blocked.

02

Consider the same cross (maternal S1S3×S_1S_3 \times paternal S3S4S_3S_4), but assume the species uses gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI). What percentage of pollen grains will successfully fertilize the ovules, and which allele do they carry?

Answer

50%50\%, carried by the S4S_4 pollen grains. In GSI, pollen grains act haploidly: 50%50\% are S3S_3 (blocked by maternal S3S_3) and 50%50\% are S4S_4 (compatible with S1S3S_1S_3).

03

In an SSI species, allele S1S_1 is strictly dominant over S2S_2 in pollen, while both are codominant in the stigma. If a pollen donor is S1S2S_1S_2 and the maternal plant is S2S3S_2S_3, what percentage of pollen grains will successfully fertilize?

Answer

100%100\%. Because S1S_1 is dominant over S2S_2 in pollen, all pollen grains exhibit only the S1S_1 phenotype. The maternal stigma expresses S2S_2 and S3S_3. Since S1S_1 does not match S2S_2 or S3S_3, all pollen grains are fully compatible.

Loading workspace…